| Movie | Role |
|---|---|
| Something Wild (1986) | Ray Sinclair |
| The Details (2012) | Peter Mazzoni |
| Observe and Report (2009) | Detective Harrison |
| Suddenly (2013) | Todd |
| Field of Dreams (1989) | "Shoeless" Joe Jackson |
| Kill the Messenger (2014) | John Cullen |
| Campus Code (2015) | Bartender |
| Turbulence (1997) | Ryan Weaver |
| Blow (2001) | Fred Jung |
| 1992 (2024) | Lowell |
| Marriage Story (2019) | Jay Marotta |
| The Many Saints of Newark (2021) | "Hollywood Dick" Moltisanti / Salvatore “Sally” Moltisanti |
| Fool's Paradise (2023) | The Producer |
| Killing Them Softly (2012) | Markie Trattman |
| GoodFellas (1990) | Henry Hill |
| Cocaine Bear (2023) | Syd |
| The Place Beyond the Pines (2013) | Peter Deluca |
| Hannibal (2001) | Paul Krendler |