The Judge (2014)

1. You can't get away with that! Palmer, you stupid asshole

2. - Whoah. - Stop!

3. - Darn it. - You did it on purpose.

4. So I don't think so.

5. The search took place according to the book. Carter never dismisses the case.

6. It's just an investigative interview.

7. You are screwing me and implying that my witness is free imagination.

8. The cynical lawyer with no respect for the law.

9. Is it me? I just don't fall head over heels for it.

10. If the prosecutor cannot meet the burden of proof -

11. - and he goes free, it's your fault. So mind your work, Kattan.

12. Did you finish that cliché you stalked me out here with?

13. Can I look myself in the eye? Can I sleep at night?

14. I sleep in a Tempur bed in a home with a Ferrari in the driveway -

15. - next to my gorgeous wife.

16. How does it feel, Hank?

17. All your clients are guilty.

18. It is fine enough. The innocent can't afford me.

19. Lift the burden of proof, Kattan.

20. Now wait a bit. You promised the case wouldn't go to court.

21. - You had to make the case go away. - No.

22. You hired me because we both know you'll never survive in prison.

23. Let me mind my own business. I'm not telling you either -

24. - how to fool the sick and put 140 million in your pocket.

25. I don't do that kind of thing, because you can do that best yourself.

26. - It is received. - Fine.

27. All rise. Court set.

28. The court is set by Judge Stanley Carter.

29. Any additions before I give my ruling?

30. Yes. We would like to remove any doubt about the validity of the search.

31. May I May I step forward?

32. - I request an adjournment. - Totally out of the question!

33. - My mother passed away this morning. - Fuck you.

34. I am playing the message again.

35. Is this the first time or does she always die when you lose?

36. - My condolences. - Thanks. It's the first time.

37. You're a fool.

38. So he peed on me.

39. - It happened just a little while ago. - That's good, Mr. Cat.

40. - Dad, are you sad? - Yes. Only you had met my mother.

41. - Why can't I come along? - It is far too sad for you.

42. Is grandpa dead too?

43. He is as good as dead to me. It's a figure of speech.

44. - You just heard wrong. - I'd better go with you.

45. No one voluntarily goes to Carlinville, Indiana. Everyone flees from there.

46. Looking for something?

47. - Stick me with a caramel, you old man. - Find it yourself.

48. I love you, baby. You can eat it after breakfast.

49. It's a deal.

50. Do you need any help? After all, they are my parents-in-law

51. Lou Shrubner. Is it your divorce attorney?

52. He is good-

53. She's going to live with me.

54. Handle. Handle!

55. When does it ring? What is her teacher's name?

56. What is her favorite color? Who is her friend?

57. What is her doctor's name? Do you have his number?

58. Don't let it get to her.

59. She understands that it is wrong that her father is never at home.

60. Her mother doesn't always have to be sad.

61. - Are you sad? - Yes!

62. You were so sad you went on Facebook and found your old flame Josh -

63. - and fucked him. He is so sexy. So clever.

64. Why aren't you climbing together right now?

65. If you want to help, water those damn hydrangeas.

66. Thanks.

67. Then it's off.

68. Altar by the old.

69. MARY PALMER BELOVED WIFE, MOTHER AND GRANDMOTHER

70. Hey, Hank.

71. Hi Dale.

72. I've missed you.

73. Her heart just stopped.

74. - I found her by the hydrangeas. - It was good.

75. It is Saint Francis. She loved him.

76. He was the saint of birds.

77. I have to remember to put food out for them for the winter.

78. He is caring, just like mother was.

79. - He drove the snakes out of Indiana. - Ireland. Out of Ireland?

80. It was Saint Patrick, and it was Ireland, not Indiana.

81. Nobody hunts reptiles in Indiana.

82. - Were you there? - No, I wasn't.

83. - Maybe you are right. - Hank Palmer in Carlinville.

84. - There we have him. - The red cardinal is their mascot.

85. - Hey, Glenn. - I just greeted you.

86. Where do you stay?

87. - Out on the street. - I'm staying up there.

88. The parking lot was full.

89. - But I found a place. - Here you go.

90. - Where is the family? - They have to look after the school.

91. Do the kids in Chicago go to school in the summer?

92. No, but I am here alone.

93. - What caused it? - Nothing.

94. COURT BUILDING

95. Do you have anything to add, Mr. Williams?

96. Anything that can shed light on the matter?

97. What should I say? There are no jobs here.

98. You can't cut someone bald. I cannot pay child support.

99. Can you not? Is that your new pickup out there?

100. What kind of one?

101. - Yep. - "Yeps is not a word

102. Jeps is not a word you use in court.

103. - Yes, Your Highness. - The keys.

104. Throw them over here.

105. Increase

106. - Augustus. - Of course. Gus.

107. Will you give the keys to mr. Williams' ex-wife?

108. Follow Mr. Williams out to the car, which he then hands to her.

109. They drive down to Devaney Motors -

110. - and asking for Mike DeVaney, not his chubby son -

111. - and sells the car back to him for the amount the fool paid.

112. - It's ridiculous. - Then it's good!

113. They stand in one of the country's last cathedrals -

114. - which is based on the basic idea that you yourself are responsible -

115. - for his actions.

116. If you want a laugh, you can go to Indianapolis.

117. Tractor pull, candyfloss -

118. - popcorn and the world's largest bull calf. First week in August.

119. Wait, I almost forgot.

120. They don't have a car anymore.

121. Thank you.

122. Do you know how you can avoid this kind of thing?

123. Thank you for coming. Who watches over the bakery?

124. She was a good person, Joseph.

125. - Grace and I are here for you. - Thank you very much.

126. - We all loved Mary. - Thanks. It means a lot to me.

127. Thank you for coming.

128. - Henry. - Sir. judging.

129. - Johnny boy. - I am so sorry.

130. - Joseph. - Thank you, Rose.

131. I go to bed. Keep an eye on your boys tomorrow.

132. - We don't want any noise. - It's alright.

133. It's been a long time, Hank -

134. - but backing into the driveway will never be my cup of tea.

135. - Thanks. Understood. - You are welcome here.

136. How are you? Can you handle the funeral tomorrow?

137. If I see that camera, you know where it ends.

138. - In my ass. - Exactly.

139. - Rough day. - Yep.

140. He shook my hand while everyone else got a hug.

141. Our family is a fucking Picasso painting.

142. Your room is full of dad's important things.

143. It is unbelievable.

144. - My magic fortune teller. - Definitely.

145. - Hey, Hank. Breakfast? - Then you must hurry.

146. "Hank, shall we have breakfast together? In a little while."

147. "Can I just get dressed?"Of course." Is that completely unreasonable?

148. We come here every Saturday, but everything is about you.

149. Coffee?

150. Come on.

151. - See you over there, Hank. - I'll be there in a moment.

152. Are you still letting him get on your nerves?

153. Sam.

154. Henry.

155. Think you still work here.

156. It is meant positively. You might be surprised-

157. - when someone has had the same job for twenty years. Stop it.

158. You still have your hair.

159. Then you just took the sorrows in advance. Did you have any other concerns?

160. Yes. This situation.

161. Meeting old friends.

162. Stop glaring. I know I'm beautiful.

163. I'm sorry about your mother.

164. We were still close. I saw her on Tuesday.

165. You never know.

166. - Can you find the cemetery? - Well, you're invited too.

167. - Hurry up. - Think I'm invited.

168. You have always been my love and you always will be.

169. This you should know.

170. I will come again tomorrow.

171. I come every single day. Goodbye.

172. Give your brother a chance.

173. - Hank has his feet on the couch. - Exactly.

174. Do my nephews still play baseball? Can they measure up to you?

175. Yes, Joe is the best hitter on the first team.

176. Eric wouldn't recognize a baseball if it hit him in the neck.

177. For the rest, I don't care.

178. Keep an eye on the referee. I think he drinks.

179. - Father has been sober for 28 years. - He forgot Gus's name in court.

180. Gus? Coroner Gus.

181. - Stop it. - I am just saying.

182. Piss with you. What time do you fly tomorrow?

183. At 8.15. I look forward to. It's the first departure.

184. Now you just have to make yourself at home, Henry.

185. - I buy in. - Will Glen drive you?

186. Is a widower automatically a lousy driver?

187. Hank, if we don't see each other before you leave, then

188. Thank you for coming. Your mother would appreciate that.

189. - Honey, we're having a drink at Firefly. - No. I go to bed.

190. - No, we have to drink. - Dale, are you coming?

191. He was just throwing things at us to get our attention.

192. No, then he blurted out dog commands.

193. You always made trouble so you got off cheap.

194. - Thanks for stopping by, Carla. - Yes, I'll be late.

195. He was strict, but he wasn't that bad either.

196. - Do you remember the fishing trips? - I remember the cabin.

197. - He asked us to be quiet. - "You scare the fish."

198. He still plays chess up there every Wednesday with Dr. Morris.

199. I don't know you? Don't have a workshop?

200. - Yeah. - Palm trees?

201. And you're the lazy one who's always running around filming.

202. - Quiet now. - Is Judge Palmer your father?

203. He thinks he owns the city, doesn't he?

204. - Your father is an asshole! - Now wait a bit.

205. - I told you to relax! - Try me!

206. Who here is on parole? I don't like Judge Palmer.

207. When your supervisors ask me, I am very helpful.

208. Let me guess. Who has drunk driving?

209. You blinked. Possession of drugs? Domestic violence?

210. It is you. Can you handle it, honey?

211. What violations see the light of day while you are inside?

212. Illegal absence? Come on.

213. As the only one with a valid driver's license, I drive the girls home.

214. Who lives closest? The bubbly pimple chump or you with sperm breath?

215. Just hit. Are you hungry for prison food?

216. Maybe I just held out my fist.

217. Perhaps I would ask you to blow on the dice.

218. I understood that metaphor well. Very funny.

219. - We're making progress. - Seek help.

220. Dershowitz? Come here.

221. Yes?

222. Can you read me too? Then I'll give you a drink.

223. Doesn't fit the time. High self-confidence. Strong teeth. No inbreeding.

224. The wetter you are, the better you look.

225. What are you drinking?

226. Last round, boys.

227. I guess you've had enough.

228. - Do you care? - What do you think?

229. - Straight. - You smell like her.

230. - She's a toy. Are you paying attention? - Straight.

231. More, more. It is fine.

232. Stop.

233. - You did that on purpose. - I do not think.

234. You have to arrange that yourself. Dale, come on.

235. - What the hell is wrong with that? - I'm guessing a six pack.

236. What the hell? Which one of you wrecked my car?

237. - Answer me. Who was it? - Who do you think you are?

238. We saw you drive to the grocery store.

239. - Glenn? where are your boys - They wouldn't touch your car.

240. No, he shouldn't complicate it. There is no doubt here.

241. His wife is dead, and he washes away the grief. Life is shit.

242. - Like your marriage. - What do you know about it?

243. - You don't know shit. - Yeah.

244. She was first and foremost my wife. We had no secrets.

245. Have you told your brothers that you are getting a divorce? Come on.

246. Lisa did sheet gymnastics with someone else.

247. - I'm not coming back. - Good trip.

248. - I will not set foot here again. - Well!

249. We must ask passengers to turn off all electronic equipment.

250. - Yep. - Hurry back. Sheep

251. - I do not care. - Now shut up.

252. - I turn off the phone. - Please just shut up!

253. Now just listen!

254. What's up, Glen?

255. The chief of police has called father down to the station.

256. They ask questions about the dents in the car.

257. I don't care unless he killed someone.

258. They found a body, Hank.

259. "I can milk, butcher and eat her, but is that illegal?"

260. It's a true story.

261. - Mr. Palmer - Judge Palmer.

262. - Have others had access to the car? - No.

263. Damn, is this an interrogation?

264. A witness saw his car on highway 30 at the time of the accident.

265. It does not place the car at the crime scene.

266. It's baby food for a lawyer. The car was stolen.

267. - He must be placed behind the wheel. - Come on, Hank.

268. "Bisexual Bobby". I remember the closing party.

269. You and Kevin lay naked in the car and sniffed.

270. - Shall I elaborate? - It's just a rumor.

271. Where did we come from?

272. He must have forgotten that if you keep quiet, you go free.

273. We don't hide behind the law here. I drove to the grocery store yesterday.

274. Every word makes it harder for him.

275. Imagine a place far away where people are listening to you. Go there.

276. What about booze? 80 percent of all getaway drivers have been drinking.

277. The wife was dead. Maybe he took a drink.

278. But it requires a confession.

279. Or better yet, a urine test. Here you go. Fill the cup.

280. You fill him with coffee and when he has to pee anyway

281. - Maybe he'll jump on it. - We just need a hair sample.

282. Exactly. Good work.

283. You can be proud of yourselves. He is soon convicted of murder.

284. Judge Palmer. We will have to impound your car.

285. - What happened? - I can not remember.

286. - Because you were drunk? - No, I just don't remember!

287. I don't think I hit anything.

288. What does an alcoholic in treatment do with a full bar cupboard?

289. I am well again. It reminds me that I myself have the power.

290. Right now officer Hansen is on his way to the grocery store -

291. - to ask a nervous clerk with a joint in his pocket -

292. - if you smelled of alcohol.

293. - Did you do it? Slurred speech? - No. No!

294. They probably shouldn't be driving together.

295. I'm on your side. If it ends wrong-

296. - you must be able to say that you have not had a drink for 28 years.

297. If you hit someone, he swerved in front of you.

298. - Practice that explanation. - Practice this one!

299. We are just asking for postponement again.

300. I'll be back soon. It's just something private.

301. Yes, I wish I could just slide.

302. Hold on, Karen.

303. What the hell are you calling for, Lisa?

304. Lauren?

305. What do you do with mom's phone?

306. No, it doesn't matter. So what?

307. I miss you too. See you soon.

308. Maybe you can come visit?

309. We'll figure out something. Do not worry.

310. Can we go shopping? Do you want your own phone?

311. I'm buying a Father has to work now. Yes?

312. The technicians have found blood on your father's car.

313. - And? - Far inside the radiator grille.

314. It is the blood of the victim. Sorry.

315. - It's negligent homicide. - Manslaughter? Are you psychic?

316. - There is still more. - How amateurish it is.

317. The victim is Mark Blackwell.

318. It's a bit of a coincidence, isn't it? Blackwell.

319. You killed him!

320. - It's mrs. Blackwell. - You killed my son!

321. Go straight to the car. Such.

322. When my lawyers are done with you, I'm moving into your house!

323. - We are sorry for your loss. - Sad?

324. - It will be you! - Hank, come on!

325. - And don't play fair. - Mother.

326. - I know you. You are no angel. - Mom, come on.

327. Drive.

328. Why were they angry?

329. She spat on the window.

330. A judge sometimes has to make difficult decisions.

331. - There was a girl. - What was her name?

332. Hope Stevens.

333. Mark Blackwell attended last year as did Glen.

334. Hope was his girlfriend. She had just turned 16.

335. - He trooped up with a gun. - Can we change the subject?

336. - I do not understand it. - He shot at her windows.

337. He was angry, as young people can become after six months.

338. He stood in court and cried like a whip.

339. He said he was drunk. He didn't want to hurt her.

340. I believed him! I believed him.

341. I gave him 30 days. I remember the release.

342. Glen and I were in the garden practicing screw balls.

343. Talent scouts had started showing up for the games.

344. But while we were doing it

345. Blackwell pulled her down to a pool of rainwater.

346. It was 50 meters behind her house.

347. He dragged her out to a depth of half a meter and drowned her.

348. Father gave him twenty years. He was released in April.

349. - Stop the car. - Dad, stop now.

350. Hello, do I speak Korean? Stop!

351. - I go for a walk. - Escape, blood trail, motive.

352. You made the wrong move of your career, and then you hit him completely by accident?

353. But now finally take your turn.

354. If the blood matches, I must have hit him.

355. - But I don't remember it. - Bad excuse in a murder case.

356. We must build a solid defense.

357. We have to get the charges dropped before the case goes to court.

358. There is no "we". It was an accident.

359. A good lawyer can easily determine that. In other words, an honest lawyer from here.

360. Someone with integrity that a judge from here respects.

361. I already found one.

362. I wish I liked you.

363. Oh boy.

364. - He didn't mean that. - Only he was dead.

365. - Stop it! - Turn around, you coward.

366. - You lust after him blindly. "Stop the car." - Shut up!

367. You are Miss Daisy's chauffeur, you bloody coward.

368. Maybe we should follow him.

369. Were you at the back of the queue for nuts? I'm leaving.

370. Well. Well!

371. Where are you going? The prison is in the other direction.

372. Fuck me.

373. Were we at the back when the prizes were handed out?

374. You know I'm going back home.

375. Just listen, don't talk.

376. The best thing about laminated glass is that it is double-walled.

377. At the bottom it says New England Glass. It's a good find.

378. Shall we go up to my office?

379. - Do you know Judge Warren? - Yes.

380. He is strict and fair and arrogant.

381. They have appointed a prosecutor from Gary. It's far away.

382. The inquest hearing is on Friday.

383. Hang on, we're on the bucket list.

384. - It's straightforward, C.P. It was dark. - Wait a minute.

385. - Is your strength furniture or law? Jurisprudence

386. - Law school? - Yes?

387. Do you know the term, or have you read the subject?

388. You cannot practice law without having studied. Valpo.

389. Valpo? Valparaíso? It's Mom!

390. The examination certificate must be presented. I'm tired of her books.

391. It is located here in Indiana. Where did you study?

392. - Northwestern. - Well, it's a good school.

393. - Have you had a jury trial? - Yes.

394. - What was the charge? - Simple violence.

395. Coach Blakely hit his quarterback in the head with his papers.

396. In his defense, John Jr. his helmet on.

397. - The sales pitch continues - Sit down.

398. Every summer I was an intern with an appointed defender.

399. And I have been an assistant to Supreme Court Justice Roberts.

400. It was a cool experience.

401. - "Enough" is not well received in court. - Thanks. It is noted.

402. If he makes a fool of himself, you face a murder case.

403. I'll get a cup of coffee. Enough!

404. It looks dangerous. Be careful not to smoke in court.

405. Don't take care of him. You are the right man.

406. I will fight tooth and nail for you.

407. Good morning.

408. All rise. Court set.

409. The court is set by Judge Sanford Warren.

410. Sit down.

411. I can understand that you have a request.

412. The deadline for changing the district has already expired.

413. So unless the circumstances make the request current -

414. - such as if the county has suddenly moved -

415. - then the trial must be conducted here in Carlinville.

416. This is just an investigative interview.

417. Why do you want to change district, mr. Dickham?

418. What would you say if we asked to change districts?

419. The deadline has passed, but I would consider it.

420. - And then I would reject it. - Then we have no request.

421. We must determine whether charges should be brought in the case.

422. We will wait with the evidence until we have heard the witnesses.

423. Let's get down to business, gentlemen.

424. - What happened? - The victim did not react.

425. - Did you help? - He was dead, son.

426. - So no. - It is correct.

427. - What did Mr. Palm trees? - That he was driving his car

428. - His Cadillac DeVille? - Yes, on the night of the accident.

429. Okay.

430. The case must be dismissed as an accident.

431. Sorry? Sorry!

432. Are you sidekicks?

433. - No he is not. - So sit down and clap!

434. What was the cause of death?

435. Internal injuries consistent with a road traffic accident.

436. Thank you, Dr. Putney. That was all.

437. - Do you wish to cross-examine? - No, I have no questions.

438. They were at work in the store and saw Judge Palmer and Mr. Blackwell.

439. They were standing in front of the refrigerator.

440. - Did they make eye contact? - Yes.

441. Mr. Blackwell and Judge Palmer made eye contact.

442. - What did Judge Palmer do? - He dropped his eggs.

443. - Then it's good. Get him out of here. - Read it.

444. It's not my first time.

445. PROTEST! EYE CONTACT CANNOT BE PROVEN!

446. Did they leave the store together? Did he follow?

447. All rise. We begin again.

448. The court is set by Judge Sanford Warren.

449. Sit down.

450. Based on the testimony and mr. Dickham's Material -

451. - is there a basis for scheduling a trial.

452. Jury selection will begin in a week. See you later.

453. JUDGE PALMER ACCUSED OF MURDER

454. "Agreement from Gipper's coach"?

455. What have?

456. "Agreement from Gipper's coach"? Nine letters.

457. "Eye of Knut."

458. The great Knute Rockne came from Indiana.

459. He knows the answer, but asks anyway.

460. Sit down. Let's talk a little.

461. Sit down.

462. Quietly

463. Why do you think the deadline expired for Dickham?

464. Neither did it. Everyone knows everyone in town.

465. Half hate you.

466. He never planned to move the trial.

467. C. P. resigned this morning.

468. - Why? - He prefers to be a bystander.

469. His lack of experience did not have to cost him the victory.

470. What were you doing on Shelby Road? It's not on the way home.

471. Now wait a bit. Are you asking if you can represent me?

472. Okay. I remember driving to the grocery store for eggs.

473. The way home was under water near the old mill.

474. I turned around and stopped for red on State.

475. After that I can't remember any more.

476. - Can I borrow your pen? - Yes.

477. And no, I'm not asking if I can represent you.

478. You can't afford it, so I had to work for free.

479. Fortunately, I haven't done that much free legal aid this year.

480. Here is my standard contract. Tick, sign and date.

481. YES - NO HOLE IN THE MEMORY

482. - The offer expires today. - I have to think about it.

483. YES HOLE IN THE MEMORY

484. - The artist works. - I cut film.

485. - You are welcome to help. - I'm just watching.

486. Who did you say dad played chess with?

487. - Dr. Morris. - So he doesn't play chess.

488. The only thing he hates more than board games is doctors.

489. So he plays chess. Now I'm going to show you.

490. It's not finished yet

491. It's a black grackle. They are annoying. Here is the lake.

492. Here is the porch.

493. See. He plays chess.

494. Stop.

495. It's beautifully filmed. What else do you have?

496. I have also filmed a family of muskrats.

497. The body was found there. The collision happened here.

498. - According to the police, he was on a bicycle. - I can't see any brake marks.

499. Now I ask as a lawyer. Did you recognize Blackwell?

500. - I can't remember that Impossible. - Impossible. Exactly.

501. They'll claim you hit him on purpose.

502. A cocktail of whiskey and thirst for revenge

503. I thought so too.

504. - But you hadn't been drinking, had you? - No.

505. Are you sick, dad?

506. You can say that. Yes.

507. Cancer. In the abdominal region. Bowel cancer.

508. After a few chemo treatments I should be on the mend.1

509. I'll probably manage that.

510. Nobody knows anything. Only your mother knew.

511. We build the defense on weakened mental abilities as a result of the chemo.

512. - Then we win the jurors' sympathy. - Now wait a bit.

513. - Faithful civil servant for 40 years - Wait a minute!

514. Think what that means for the cases I've handled this year.

515. - All convicts will protest. - So what? You will die in prison!

516. It's better than getting a bad reputation.

517. A demented man behind the witness stand.

518. Shame you won't be allowed to testify.

519. Ulysses S. Grant stayed together in the countryside.

520. But he is remembered as a drunkard.

521. Ronald Reagan ended the Cold War.

522. But the discussion of his legacy is about jellybeans and Alzheimer's.

523. Reagan? Oh boy. With all due respect

524. Now I will formulate it as nicely as I can.

525. You are a civil servant far out in the countryside.

526. No one gives a damn about your legacy!

527. But I do. I have sat in court for 42 years.

528. People out here trust both me and the law.

529. It's a sure thing, Henry.

530. You can't drop it. Then do not.

531. Only guilty people refuse to testify. Are you following?

532. I can't help if I'm not allowed to look after my job.

533. Unlock the door. I want to go home.

534. Goddamn!

535. Like in the old days.

536. No! Damn it!

537. So I only have one mourning dress.

538. Hank, this is my daughter, Carla.

539. It didn't matter as hell! Is that your Hank?

540. Now don't embarrass me.

541. - Have you met? - Yes. On th ebar.

542. - Does not? - What are you doing? Turn around.

543. Do you still have that T-shirt?

544. - Hank disappeared that night. - When did you have a daughter?

545. - February 1990. - She is on summer holiday at home.

546. - Have you been married? - No.

547. No, I am the unforeseen result of a wild boat trip.

548. Lots of Kool-Aid and Everclear.

549. - Now Carla goes to Georgetown. - In D.C.? Oh boy.

550. Are you ever in Washington, mr. Palm trees?

551. Never. What are you reading?

552. Jurisprudence.

553. Always on the grass to avoid splashes on the shoes.

554. - I don't know what's wrong. - You are emotionally involved.

555. - It will probably pass. Believe me. - I hope not.

556. Are you not influenced at all by the fact that you know the defendant?

557. Which jurors are we looking for?

558. Intelligent people who listen to the evidence.

559. Crazy heads. People that I can picture everything in.

560. The types who have seen Bigfoot and reject the moon landing.

561. - Mr. Palm trees. - Put on the velvet gloves.

562. Who has stickers on the back? Raise your hand.

563. What is written on them? Exactly.

564. It says "tolerance" with religious symbols.

565. - "Willie Nelson as President." - Is it realistic?

566. He has never been convicted of anything.

567. "Certified breast inspector. Find them."

568. "Gun control means using both hands."

569. "Model student in the car."

570. "Wife and dog missing. Bounty offered for dog."

571. Thanks.

572. I've missed you. It's going to be a fun weekend.

573. Unless I drop you on the escalator!

574. Lauren I'd better get you ready for the meeting with your grandfather.

575. He's not like your grandfather who is nice and nice.

576. He gives ice cream and reads aloud.

577. If you ask Grandpa to read aloud, he might throw the book at you.

578. He is not malicious.

579. He's just an old mummy who can do you no harm.

580. Now he comes.

581. He usually limps off wrapped in bandages.

582. He's probably out looking for food.

583. - Who are you? - Lauren.

584. - Do you know who I am? - Grandfather.

585. Are you my grandson? Just come along.

586. Such.

587. Are you happy to be here? Okay.

588. I have waited a long time for this moment.

589. You are my little darling. Now I'll show you around.

590. You are my first granddaughter.

591. You are actually the first girl in the family for a long time.

592. - Grandpa is cute. - No, but you're welcome to think so.

593. Now you lie super well. Would you like another pillow?

594. Then lie down. Such.

595. Whoa. Maybe I'll strangle her!

596. Everything is alright? There are ghosts here, so I'll slip away now.

597. - Whose room is this? - It was Uncle Glen's.

598. - Why are there so many trophies? - He was good at baseball.

599. - Really good. - Did he appear on television?

600. He could have played for a big team.

601. But in high school we had a bad car accident.

602. He destroyed his hand.

603. It was a shame.

604. Why hasn't he brought his trophies?

605. They meant more to his father.

606. It is a sensitive subject. Now you must sleep.

607. - Goodnight honey. - Goodnight Dad.

608. Let's practice. Blackwell was in court with you before he killed Miss Stevens.

609. Yes. Many people have been in court with me

610. But there were special circumstances in the case.

611. Most believe that their cases are quite special.

612. So there are no snacks in the witness stand.

613. - They distract. - I don't need preparation.

614. You've never been on the witness stand.

615. Dickham can never prove that I had intent.

616. Dickham makes the jurors dance to his pipe.

617. Then you can wave goodbye to the dream of flags at half-mast upon your death.

618. It's called "on half a pole". No one says "at half mast".

619. Well, then we don't prepare.

620. Fine. You don't have to be so grumpy, Henry.

621. Sam. Can you hear me? I have my head in the oven.

622. The choice was between that and a convention with you.

623. Okay. Over there? Fine.

624. It seems higher. Have they raised it?

625. Now show me what you can do.

626. I'm just stretching a little. Give me a push.

627. It was easy enough.

628. We are inside.

629. It's midnight. I'm droning home.

630. - The Chevette with fake wood panels. - No, Father Maverick.

631. What were you thinking?

632. I sense something in the corner of my eye.

633. The world's biggest buck. 12-14 thanks.

634. 100 kilos. It storms down the road towards me.

635. We step out. I have one hand on the wheel and one on Carla.

636. The deer jumps. It smokes over the radiator hood, and the hooves cut the window.

637. Had we driven a little faster, we would have been killed.

638. I make a decision on the spot.

639. Regardless of what had happened in the past -

640. - I wanted to be the hero of my own adventure.

641. - Does that sound cracker? - It sounds fantastic.

642. I had 4,000 in the bank and borrowed 12,000 from grandpa.

643. Then I made Dan an offer for dinner that he couldn't refuse.

644. Do you own the place? Why would I break in?

645. For fun. It was worth the broken window.

646. I bought the bar three years later.

647. I have money. I am ashamed of money.

648. You are a true entrepreneur. I am impressed.

649. We've known each other since third grade. Are you impressed now?

650. You've always been nice, but now you've also accomplished something.

651. There we have you.

652. But it was now second class. Second class.

653. In miss Jenkins hour in the corner of the ball field.

654. I tried to kiss you but you made the fish hook.

655. You taste of cinnamon. Such.

656. Did you break the kiss to think back?

657. It was just a side jump.

658. Come on.

659. What now?

660. I'm going home after the case. Are you sure about this?

661. - Am I sure? - He's safe, but are you?

662. What are we doing here?

663. It's good to see you, but I'm not naive. I know you.

664. What do you think you know? Frankly.

665. That I'm a nice man? Faithful?

666. That I'm a formidable lawyer with an excellent work ethic?

667. Say it. I'm used to being put to the test.

668. I know I will never leave Carlinville.

669. You're just a kid from Indiana who thinks it doesn't fit.

670. Lock the door behind you. I want to play with myself while thinking about you.

671. And I've been with your daughter. Piss.

672. He says he has gaps in his memory.

673. It's called the chemo brain. There is also fatigue and cracked skin.

674. You can get memory loss, dementia and delusions.

675. He may have been mentally impaired when he hit Blackwell.

676. If you can confirm it, you may have to testify.

677. He receives chemotherapy in a fisherman's cabin. He seems to be trying to keep a low profile.

678. - As his doctor, I am bound. - Of his vanity?

679. - When is the treatment finished? - It's up to him.

680. For him? But how would he know that?

681. - What did he actually say? - That he is recovering.

682. Spit it out. I am not his son. I'm his lawyer.

683. - You're not a nice guy. - Right now I'm gentle as a lamb.

684. When I subpoena you and pull the truth out of your ass -

685. - then you realize I'm not a nice guy.

686. We discovered it too late to remove it.

687. If he had been screened regularly

688. But he's not the type to let a camera in.

689. Your mother insisted on treatment.

690. So he probably does it for her sake.

691. I have been treating him for a year.

692. The disease is advanced. Fourth stage.

693. The pain increases, so we use morphine.

694. "Café du Monde."

695. "The clouds billowed in the sky above the sunset."

696. - What is a hushpuppy? - Healthy.

697. Out from here. Out!

698. Why am I not wearing shoes?

699. Quiet now. Stand still.

700. - Let me go... No, no'-

701. Let's get it over with.

702. Okay? Carefully.

703. Can you lift your leg over? Such.

704. - Is it fine? - Yes, come on.

705. - What about the temperature? - Too hot.

706. - Sorry. Such. - It is better.

707. It is fine.

708. - What is it? - May I enter?

709. Just a moment. Eat your housepuppies.

710. - I'm full. - Hold on, Lauren!

711. - Come on. - What are you doing?

712. - What are we doing? - I do not know. Tidy up the laundry.

713. We do the laundry. It is leaking.

714. - May I help? - No, there is water all over.

715. Now find something else to do. We'll be right back.

716. - Knock Knock. - Lauren

717. I'm not talking to you.

718. - Who's there? - Shame.

719. - Skavi who? - Shall we still have ice cream?

720. Okay.

721. What does Lauren like? What are the future plans?

722. What do you want to be? Teacher? Doctor? Being a lawyer is popular.

723. Racing driver. I like to drive fast.

724. - What are you thinking? - I've got a stupid idea.

725. But it's fun.

726. Looking at the road? You're doing great. Look in the mirrors.

727. You are a natural talent. I remove my hands from the steering wheel.

728. You don't have to do it either.

729. Okay?

730. This is how you stay informed.

731. - When are you and mother going to separate? - What? The hands of ten and two.

732. - Where did you hear that? - It's pretty obvious.

733. This kind of thing takes a long time.

734. There are different steps.

735. - Your things are in boxes. - This is the first step.

736. You don't wear your rings.

737. And you probably ask me who I want to live with.

738. - What stage are we at? - What you said.

739. - You know too much. - Mother gets lonely.

740. What about me? So will I.

741. Fathers don't get lonely. They marry younger mothers.

742. We'll have to find out.

743. It happened to Megan. Then it happened to Katlin.

744. I didn't think it would happen to me.

745. I didn't either. Do you want to turn left?

746. I can let you drive home. You're doing great. Clever girl.

747. - What are you going to say to mother? - The world's best holiday.

748. Excellent, but don't overdo it.

749. Hello. Thanks.

750. Can you handle it?

751. It will be OK. You are something special.

752. Sheep? The best vacation in the world.

753. It was a coincidence. Nothing else.

754. APRIL 9, 1989 SAMANTHA AND HANK HAVE FUN

755. June, July, August, September, October, November, December

756. June, July, August, September, October, November Fandens.

757. Then it's off.

758. Thanks for the introduction to DNA evidence analysis.

759. But can the numbers and percentages tell if it is Blackwell's blood on the car?

760. That's the victim's blood on the car.

761. - Did he strike out after mr. Blackwell? - No.

762. Did he yell at him or show signs of hostility?

763. No not at all.

764. Dr. Brannamon, you found something else in his body.

765. Blackwell had oxycodone-paracetamol in his blood. Strong pain reliever.

766. - And his blood alcohol level was 2.3? - Yes.

767. Could he even ride in that condition?

768. If he could ride a bike, he would swing.

769. What did you feel after the many years of heartbreak when he was released?

770. I finally got my Mark back. I had waited so long.

771. No woman should bury her child. Thanks.

772. How often did you visit Mark in prison?

773. I can not remember. Way too many times.

774. Maybe the visitation list will help. How many times?

775. Twice. Twice!

776. So not "too many times". Twice in twenty years. Thaw.

777. One visit for each hand.

778. The turn is at most twenty degrees.

779. There is no indication that Judge Palmer attempted to slow down.

780. - No. - There are no brake tracks at all.

781. - No. - That was all.

782. Mr. Palm trees.

783. You have been a policeman in Detroit.

784. Protest. His background is irrelevant.

785. I just wanted to say "welcome to Carlinville".

786. Aha.

787. The pictures were taken the following morning.

788. What is it? Can you help?

789. - Right there. - I do not know.

790. - Does it help? - Maybe a traffic-killed raccoon.

791. - Is it relevant? - What do you want to achieve?

792. - It's a snapping turtle. - And?

793. "Detroit" probably doesn't know what it feels like to hit a snapping turtle.

794. No one hits it on purpose.

795. If you hit a rabbit or a raccoon, it says bump.

796. A snapping turtle is the equivalent of hitting a concrete block.

797. It says bang! Boom!

798. Mr. Palmer, what's the point?

799. The prosecution alleges -

800. - that the missing brake marks prove that Mr. Blackwell was hit on purpose.

801. That Judge Palmer could not have hit anything significant in the dark-

802. - without realizing it was a person.

803. That has already been established. Is this the shadow of a question?

804. The question is:

805. Are there brake tracks in front of the turtle?

806. - Yes or no? - No, it's not there.

807. Thanks. That was all.

808. You move everything around!

809. Good, Mary. What what?

810. God damn! Don't act like that!

811. Memory plays tricks. It teases.

812. You left too soon, Mary.

813. I could hear you had nightmares.

814. What happened to your hands?

815. Here. Then the skin becomes soft.

816. Who really is the best lawyer you know?

817. I say Robert Graham. I work for him.

818. He never loses.

819. Then it's your turn.

820. Mr. Shaw. My first position after studying.

821. A vagabond killed a farmer and raped his wife.

822. He was a despicable human being. Mr. Shaw was appointed.

823. Every evening Mr. Shaw with him in prison.

824. He prepared him and defended him. Exactly by the book.

825. Did he win?

826. He was executed.

827. He was dead, but mr. Shaw was to live on here.

828. He was threatened and spat on. People kept him at a distance in the church.

829. He could have declined the case, but he believed in the legal system.

830. I don't know if he was the best.

831. But Henry Shaw

832. He is the most decent man I have ever met. Ever.

833. - Yes. - Henry?

834. Decent man. Big man.

835. Henry Shaw.

836. - Hank Palmer. - It's Chief White.

837. Do you have time to stop by? You have to see something.

838. We've already seen the surveillance footage.

839. The judge leaves the shop and they go their separate ways.

840. Patience.

841. - What does the time say? - 4 minutes and 45.

842. - He didn't make it to the mill. - So what?

843. Palmer said the road at the mill was flooded and he turned around.

844. He is lying. It takes nine minutes to drive there and back.

845. Your father made it in five.

846. He turned because he wanted to pursue Blackwell.

847. He can easily assess when the road is under water.

848. - That's not the main thing. - May we borrow your office?

849. - Thanks. - You know how to empty a room.

850. - Ten years. He is serving seven. - Lack of evidence.

851. - Pack up. - You're on your toes.

852. - You bore me. - He had intentions.

853. I portray your father as a saved fool on a crusade for justice.

854. He's a saved fool on a crusade, so it's over quickly.

855. Funny.

856. I understand you don't remember me. I was only a bystander.

857. You defended the beer baron's kid touring Gary's slums.

858. 40 million in the bank. A dead prostitute.

859. You are razor sharp. A better judgment cannot be bought with money.

860. Everyone wants Atticus Finch until they end up with a dead whore.

861. That's right for the backseat.

862. Have you followed me for revenge?

863. No, for the hell of it.

864. I followed you to prevent anyone from getting away with murder.

865. - My father is not a murderer. - But he's a liar. We know that now.

866. He believes he is above the law just like his son.

867. You are a polished wooden pole. A bully with dirty tricks.

868. Unlike you, I believe in one thing:

869. That the legal system is the only thing that can make people equal.

870. You probably think Mark Blackwell was a social outcast -

871. - but in the eyes of the authorities, his life also has value.

872. I'm charging your client with premeditated murder.

873. And you get first floor.

874. What are we doing down here? It's never a tornado.

875. You're lucky your grandfather has a basement.

876. - Oh no. - Do not worry. I'll fix it.

877. - Turn it on, Uncle Dale. - Yeah, let's see what you've been up to.

878. Let's see.

879. Okay. Charles Francis Jenkins invented the movie projector -

880. - June 6, 1894 in Indiana.

881. Dale, can we see your movie? Thanks.

882. Here it comes.

883. - Such! - Well done, Dale.

884. - It looks like Christmas. Cozy.

885. A real family Christmas. You are adorable in nightwear.

886. - It's us. It's the family. - Exactly.

887. - Grandmother. - It is me.

888. - Sweet. - Dad, you were dear then.

889. - There we have Hank and father. - Did you have hair?

890. - There we have you. - Now see how it should be done.

891. Oh boy. So what do you say?

892. What a throw.

893. Victory is at home.

894. It was a good day.

895. - The proud mother. - Sheep.

896. - Goddamn. - Clap in, Joe.

897. - Power off. - Fast forward.

898. - You can not do that. It's a movie. - Continue! Continue!

899. - Then you have to fast forward manually. - Give him a chance.

900. - Turn it off! - Relax now!

901. Dale, we'll fix it.

902. - Not in this house! - Sheep!

903. - Oh no. - I'm sick of you.

904. I'm tired of everything being about you.

905. You demand that everyone dance to your tune.

906. Here I decide. You can decide for yourself.

907. I have a client who is fighting to be found guilty.

908. You never made it to the mill, did you?

909. You left me in the lurch at Dickham's because you were hiding something.

910. - I have told you everything! - Well, you haven't!

911. - Stay away! - Let it go!

912. Where are you going, dad? You must not go outside!

913. What are you doing?

914. - Remove that paw! - Damn it, Hank!

915. - Why wasn't I allowed to be a scout? - You blew up a mailbox.

916. - I was 13. - You should have known better.

917. - You didn't come to my graduation. - Dry your eyes.

918. Youth detention and truancy. It should not be rewarded.

919. I completed law school.

920. - Great that you didn't drop out. - Run me!

921. Now I have to tell you something.

922. I have given you a roof over your head, money in your pocket and food on the table.

923. Who paid for your education? Your mother? She was a homemaker.

924. Couldn't you forget your pride and come home to her?

925. You invited ex-convicts back.

926. You paid tribute to those who had accomplished something.

927. You had everyone in the courtroom clapping.

928. You shared how proud you were of a bunch of strangers.

929. Did you just miss some nice words? A bravo?

930. Then you might as well have just come home!

931. We were waiting for you. But you never came.

932. And she blamed me because you didn't come. Me.

933. Was I a strict father? Yes.

934. But what did you become, Henry? Serving? Tramp?

935. You sent me to juvenile detention. Damn Vanderburgh!

936. It was your own fault.

937. The prosecutor recommended community service.

938. - I needed you. - You drove wrong with your brother.

939. He had a great career in mind and now he owns a workshop.

940. You ruined his future and now you're screwing me!

941. - I was 17 years old. - "I was 13. I was 17."

942. You were out on an incline. I did the right thing.

943. I didn't just graduate. I was the best on the team.

944. - I did well, father. - You're welcome.

945. I could level the damn house.

946. What a storm.

947. I'm glad you and mom became friends. Why, Sam?

948. - Who is Carla's father? - Find her birth certificate.

949. I have done that. Her father's name is not mentioned.

950. He would never be a father to her, so he doesn't know anything.

951. There was no wild boat ride with Everclear and Kool-Aid.

952. It was a white lie so we could move on.

953. I also want to move on.

954. What lies are you telling me?

955. That it was okay that you went to a concert and never called.

956. To...

957. I'm fine with carla not knowing her father.

958. That you're the only one who gets hurt when you run away.

959. - I know that look. - Fuck you.

960. Yeah, that's my shit. So move.

961. See you in twenty years. I look forward to.

962. Then you finally opened it.

963. It was 23 years old when I bought it in Kentucky in 1979.

964. I often wanted to open it.

965. It was good you didn't.

966. - Will you talk me out of drinking? - You decide.

967. As long as you are ready for tomorrow. Dickham turns up the heat.

968. I'm ready.

969. - I visited mother today. - It was good.

970. Where is she now?

971. Where is Mary? Is there life after death?

972. Are you asking if I believe in God?

973. Do you?

974. I am 72 and affected by cancer. Do I have a choice?

975. I wanted to say one thing

976. I wanted to apologize for belittling your marriage.

977. Maintaining a good marriage is not easy.

978. What would you do with Lisa and all?

979. I really don't know, Henry. Can you be happy again?

980. Pour up. I will raise a toast.

981. - Let's toast something. - What a good day in court.

982. The judge's Cadillac reappears five minutes later.

983. - The exact time? - 4 minutes and 45 seconds.

984. Okay, again. Here he is driving.

985. It was too long. Such.

986. Judge Palmer?

987. Sheep? Call for an ambulance.

988. Dad, say something. Sheep?

989. I don't know what prayer card he likes.

990. - Saint Joseph is the guardian angel - Okay, Dale!

991. Turn down the madness!

992. Can't find anything in the machine? Here you go.

993. - Buy what you want. - You have a naked lady.

994. - Yes, it's a funny purse. - Film the machines, Dale.

995. - Forget it. - It shouldn't happen to him.

996. Not now. You know nothing about my life.

997. Mother is gone. Are you following?

998. And dangers

999. What do we do with Dale? Are you going to help?

1000. I understand why you are going crazy here.

1001. - I never asked you for anything. - Now I am here.

1002. He's your father, so of course you're here.

1003. I never asked you for anything.

1004. Now I'm begging you.

1005. You must not lose that case. Father must not end up in prison.

1006. Don't pat me on the back. I'm your big brother.

1007. Dad wants to talk to you, Hank. Not you, Glen.

1008. Come here.

1009. I killed the pig.

1010. Very funny. But you mustn't say that again.

1011. I know myself. I ran him down.

1012. Pure speculation. I know you too.

1013. You cannot set aside a lifetime of high ethics.

1014. - I don't have the strength to argue. - So man up.

1015. - Do you remember hitting him? - It is a matter of time.

1016. Time is up. You don't have to be on the witness stand.

1017. Then I fire you and get C.P. to do it.

1018. You are the most stubborn client I have ever had.

1019. There are no witnesses. Neither of you can prove you hit him.

1020. I have cast doubt on the whole matter. Can't you just

1021. Let me mind my own business. Shut up. You win.

1022. Yes. But I have to live here too.

1023. You are impossible to defend!

1024. What became of Reagan? All your piss about the legacy.

1025. Are you going to swear you remember hitting him?

1026. I'm not confessing to something I can't remember, okay?

1027. - Do you promise? - Yes. See you in court, Henry.

1028. See you in court.

1029. Judge Palmer.

1030. Do you swear to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

1031. Yes.

1032. - How long have you been a judge? - For 42 years.

1033. How many cases of violence have you had?

1034. Protest. The defendant's past as a judge is irrelevant.

1035. The prosecutor believes that the motive is connected with the judge's act.

1036. I have the right to refute that ridiculous presumption.

1037. It's not something I can count on.

1038. Does it occur to you that you have convicted 17 murder cases?

1039. 434 assault? 12,942 civil cases?

1040. No it does not.

1041. - Did you run any of them down? - Protest.

1042. Get to the point, mr. Palm trees.

1043. You just lost your wife.

1044. - How long were you married? - 50 years.

1045. How did she die?

1046. She spent the morning in the garden. She went up to her hydrangeas.

1047. A blood clot formed in the leg, which continued to the heart.

1048. What were you doing on the day of the accident?

1049. I buried your mother my wife.

1050. - Rough day. How were you? - I was tired.

1051. Tired. It was dark and rainy.

1052. - Do you remember hitting the victim? - No.

1053. Thanks.

1054. That was all.

1055. - Did you hate Mark Blackwell? - Yes.

1056. - Did you wish him misfortune? - Yes.

1057. - Did you want him dead? - Yes.

1058. You have told the police that it was only you who drove the car.

1059. - Not even your wife. - It is my car.

1060. The blood of a man you hate -

1061. - was found on a car that only you drive.

1062. - But you don't know why? - No.

1063. He was 185 centimeters tall and weighed 100 kilos.

1064. A big loaf of bread on a steel bike.

1065. - But you don't remember anything? - Protest. Leading question.

1066. - Rejected. - It is correct.

1067. So on one of the worst days of your life -

1068. - you go into a shop and see a man you hate

1069. - Protest. Provocative. - Let him talk.

1070. You see a man you hate, and shortly afterwards you take a detour.

1071. They and the man are on the same road at the same time.

1072. Their car is smeared in his blood -

1073. - and he lies in the ditch with crushed kidneys and a broken back.

1074. But you don't remember hitting him?

1075. No I can not.

1076. They are under oath, which you know all about.

1077. We have a man who committed murder.

1078. A man you had released -

1079. - who drowned a 16-year-old girl.

1080. A man whom you sincerely hate. It is the worst day of your life.

1081. They have an obvious chance to balance the accounts.

1082. But your explanation is that you didn't take the chance and kill him.

1083. No.

1084. That was all.

1085. That is not my explanation.

1086. Have I misunderstood your explanation?

1087. Protest. He said he was done. Sorry?

1088. My explanation is that I don't remember hitting him.

1089. - May I ask for a short break? - Rejected.

1090. Mr. Palmer Judge Palmer.

1091. Do you think you killed him on purpose?

1092. Protest. Speculation. The question should be deleted.

1093. Yes.

1094. Calm in the hall. Peace in the hall!

1095. Thank you, Your Highness. That was all.

1096. Re-interrogation?

1097. Okay. So you think you did it?

1098. - Correct. - You think so.

1099. - But you can't remember it. - It is true.

1100. Your position is that you hit him deliberately.

1101. - Correct? - I said yes.

1102. - Why can't you remember the accident? - My wife had just passed away.

1103. - Are you undergoing treatment? - Protest. Irrelevant.

1104. Clarification of state of mind.

1105. - The two of us are finished. - Well, we're not.

1106. C.P., your turn.

1107. Sit down, mr. Kennedy. You are done when you have answered.

1108. - You are not my lawyer! - Answer the question!

1109. I'm at my full five. It is none of your business

1110. - Sit down! I'm not done. - No one cares!

1111. Gentlemen! Judge Palmer.

1112. They are welcome to choose a new defender.

1113. But you must wait until after the testimony.

1114. It's alright.

1115. I repeat: Are you undergoing treatment? Yes or no?

1116. Chemotherapy.

1117. - How long has it been going on? - In six months.

1118. Chemo, so that means cancer. What is the prognosis?

1119. The cancer is advanced.

1120. Has your doctor told you about possible side effects?

1121. - Yes he has. - What are they?

1122. - Fatigue, lack of appetite - Depression, memory loss?

1123. - Yes, but I am not affected by that. - So?

1124. What would it mean to your affairs if your mental faculties were impaired?

1125. Protest. The defense is trying to mislead the jurors.

1126. A lot of cases had to go around, right?

1127. - Possibly. - A stain on your reputation.

1128. - You will do everything to avoid that. - No no no!

1129. Why don't you remember seeing Blackwell that night?

1130. I remember him well. I just can't remember

1131. that I hit the pig.

1132. So what do you remember?

1133. I remember him opening his filthy mouth.

1134. What could he have said?

1135. Hey, judge!

1136. It was a shame about the wife.

1137. You know what?

1138. She is buried 15 meters from Hope.

1139. So I don't have to go far to piss on both graves.

1140. He has them.

1141. No.

1142. That does not make sense.

1143. It can't possibly be the first time someone has insulted you.

1144. Why did you give him a lenient sentence the first time?

1145. They were the strictest judge in Indiana.

1146. They gave him 30 days.

1147. He threatened her and fired shots.

1148. He stood for six months or a year. Least.

1149. What was your thinking?

1150. 180 days might have taught him a lesson.

1151. Then he might not have killed Hope.

1152. For many years, they handed down severe sentences.

1153. But the understanding suddenly falls to Mark Blackwell?

1154. How do you explain that misjudgment?

1155. I looked at him and saw you.

1156. The same stubbornness and disobedience. Same arrogance.

1157. I looked at him and saw my middle son.

1158. My little boy.

1159. My little boy.

1160. I wanted to hug him and comfort him.

1161. I wanted someone to help him -

1162. - like someone should help my son

1163. if he went astray.

1164. It was my chance to be

1165. that person. Is that too much to ask for? Maybe.

1166. I have memories.

1167. About us. You and me-

1168. But then they stop.

1169. How can it be?

1170. Why?

1171. Why? Why?

1172. I looked at you and saw him.

1173. Can we get the bailiff to come forward?

1174. This man has been your bailiff for 22 years. What's his name?

1175. Gus

1176. Don't you know?

1177. I want to go home now.

1178. That was all.

1179. Reach

1180. - Are you okay? - I do not know.

1181. It depends on the ruling.

1182. - I'm Carla's father, right? - Are you starting again now?

1183. Why can't you forget it? She's fine.

1184. She was born after I slipped. Maybe you cheated.

1185. Neither part is okay. The second is just worse.

1186. The matter is that

1187. Now it gets ugly.

1188. I met Carla at the bar. I was with Dale and Glen.

1189. He is her father.

1190. - Who is? - Glen doesn't know.

1191. - Well, not my brother? - It only happened once.

1192. - What? Glenn? - You slipped!

1193. - I went to a concert. - And you never came back!

1194. He was down-to-earth and sweet. I missed something normal.

1195. - What does that make me? - The worst bastard!

1196. Damn it, Hank. I loved you and I still do.

1197. I like that you at the same time -

1198. - is the most selfish and most generous person.

1199. I love that you hate tyrants even though you are one yourself.

1200. But your constant hindsight?

1201. When you let your verbose flow out

1202. I disappeared with you, Hank.

1203. Say it again.

1204. All?

1205. Yep.

1206. Stand up for the jurors.

1207. Sit down.

1208. - Have you reached a decision? - Yes, high judge.

1209. What is your ruling on the charge of premeditated manslaughter?

1210. We find the defendant not guilty.

1211. And the subsidiary allegation of negligent manslaughter?

1212. Here we find the defendant guilty.

1213. - Calm in the room. - Request sentencing.

1214. It has been a tragic case -

1215. - and it is incumbent upon me to impose an appropriate punishment.

1216. But you know that's my job.

1217. I sentence you to four years in prison to be served immediately.

1218. Will the bailiff take Judge Palmer into custody?

1219. Calm in the hall.

1220. Sheep.

1221. - Yes. - Sheep.

1222. I will always be proud of you.

1223. I always will be.

1224. You are a strong man, not a boy.

1225. Now take good care of your brother. Will you do it?

1226. - Okay, Dad. - And the camera here.

1227. I know it helps you. Just use it.

1228. - But you can also manage without it. - Okay, Dad.

1229. Thanks to the jurors.

1230. You are now exempt. The court is adjourned.

1231. - Should we expect an appeal? - Nah.

1232. 90 percent believe in ghosts. A third believe in evolution.

1233. 35 percent know Homer Simpson and his fictional hometown.

1234. Less than one percent know the name Thurgood Marshall.

1235. But when you assemble twelve jurors and ask for justice -

1236. - a miracle happens.

1237. Most often they hit the spot.

1238. Burke's mistress was highly prepared for Hank Palmer's infamous cross-examination.

1239. But you let her off easy.

1240. I did?

1241. It could cost you your job.

1242. Well, you can't win every time.

1243. And when it's running, you just have to scratch.

1244. INDIANA STATE PRISON 7 MONTHS LATER

1245. REQUEST FOR HUMANITARIAN RELEASE

1246. Sign here and here.

1247. - Can you keep warm? - Yes.

1248. - Is it too hot? - Stop it.

1249. Glen and Dale fetch more bait.

1250. - You always bought them. - Yes. Give me some pieces.

1251. Give me some to take home. You were some bandits.

1252. You quickly put them to death. Do you remember that?

1253. Until Dale dropped a seal and ruined it for everyone.

1254. Your mother blamed me. Ghostly Dale.

1255. He is glorious.

1256. - Do you want water? - No.

1257. Do you remember what you said if I wore one?

1258. "Stick me a caramel, you old man."

1259. - It worked every time. - Yes.

1260. - It is you. - Is it? What?

1261. You asked me who was the best lawyer.

1262. You chose who you work with.

1263. I choose you-

1264. Glen could have really driven it to something.

1265. Undoubtedly.

1266. Yep.

1267. High five that I catch something first.

1268. I believe in luck.

1269. Come on. Nothing.

1270. Sheep?

1271. Sheep?

1272. Close your eyes. Green, orange.

1273. One two Three. Then we close.

1274. You didn't make it.

1275. Thank you for the reception.

1276. I close early tonight.

1277. You could possibly drop by at nine o'clock

1278. Then I save a piece of cake.

1279. - Where are you going? - Out to draw air.

1280. Wait.

1281. I just want to lend you a little before you run off.

1282. - I just need some air. - And then you disappear

1283. I just want to

1284. Palmer, you asshole!

1285. I'm right here! I'm from here!