1. Emily!Copy !req
2. You're the medical examiner?Copy !req
3. Mr. Rose?Copy !req
4. I'm sorry, Mr. Rose...Copy !req
5. but I cannot state conclusively...Copy !req
6. that the cause of death
was natural.Copy !req
7. Your daughter, she...Copy !req
8. Excuse me, Father?Copy !req
9. Father Moore.Copy !req
10. You'll have to come with me.Copy !req
11. - Father Moore!
- Will you plead guilty?Copy !req
12. - Tell us about the exorcism!
- Over here, Father Moore!Copy !req
13. We're at Crescent County Courthouse.
We show you Father Richard Moore...Copy !req
14. - What about the parents?
- They're not talking to the police.Copy !req
15. Do we charge them?Copy !req
16. No. Even the priest admits
he ran the show.Copy !req
17. We need a Christian on this.Copy !req
18. Preferably a Catholic.Copy !req
19. Somebody that knows this shit
inside out...Copy !req
20. and who the public will see
as unbiased.Copy !req
21. We're going after a holy man here.Copy !req
22. Ethan Thomas.Copy !req
23. He's not Catholic, though.
Methodist, I think.Copy !req
24. But the guy practically lives at church.
Choir, teaches Sunday school.Copy !req
25. He's no choirboy in the courtroom.
I've seen him tear people up.Copy !req
26. He's a shrewd son of a bitch.Copy !req
27. All right, pull him off whatever
he's doing. He's lead prosecutor.Copy !req
28. There's ambition. She never stops.
She even works while she drinks.Copy !req
29. - Gentlemen, you know Erin Bruner.
- Of course.Copy !req
30. - Hello.
- I was so sure Van Hopper would fry...Copy !req
31. but you proved me wrong, lady.Copy !req
32. The system worked, that's all.Copy !req
33. Gentlemen, you'll excuse us,
will you?Copy !req
34. Have you seen the news
about this priest?Copy !req
35. I heard something about an exorcism
gone bad, but I don't know the details.Copy !req
36. The DA charged him
with negligent homicide.Copy !req
37. They offered a very reasonable plea
bargain, but the priest turned it down.Copy !req
38. Do not ask me to take this—Copy !req
39. The archdiocese
specifically requested you.Copy !req
40. - Why me?
- They followed the Van Hopper trial.Copy !req
41. They think you're smart...Copy !req
42. and convincing.Copy !req
43. They want you to ask the priest
to reconsider.Copy !req
44. Well, what if he won't?Copy !req
45. This sounds like a quagmire.
If I'm smart, I'll leave it alone.Copy !req
46. Erin, the Van Hopper case
got you back on the fast track.Copy !req
47. Once again, you're a rising star.Copy !req
48. - Chivas, neat, please.
- Tanqueray martini, dry.Copy !req
49. - What are you saying?
- I'm saying, you do this for me...Copy !req
50. and the rising star keeps rising.Copy !req
51. The case is yours.Copy !req
52. And just how high
do I get to rise this time?Copy !req
53. I've been junior partner
for too long now, Karl.Copy !req
54. - It's not like other firms haven't called.
- Erin—Copy !req
55. I want my name on the door,
right next to yours.Copy !req
56. Okay.Copy !req
57. Try to get the deal.Copy !req
58. If the priest won't
and this goes to trial...Copy !req
59. the archdiocese feels he could
be an embarrassment.Copy !req
60. So under no circumstances
is he to testify.Copy !req
61. No, of course.
If I'd put Van Hopper on the stand...Copy !req
62. he'd be marking time on death row
instead of sunbathing in Miami.Copy !req
63. His tab.Copy !req
64. Good morning, I'm Erin Bruner.Copy !req
65. May I sit down?Copy !req
66. They brought the chair
for my public defender.Copy !req
67. I guess they left it when they decided
I wasn't going to kill myself with it.Copy !req
68. My firm represents the archdiocese.Copy !req
69. Yes.Copy !req
70. Yes, I was expecting them
to send someone.Copy !req
71. - Why did they choose you?
- I wanted this case.Copy !req
72. - So you like the spotlight?
- I'm used to it.Copy !req
73. I defended James Van Hopper.Copy !req
74. And now you've come
to further your celebrity.Copy !req
75. No.Copy !req
76. I'm here to make senior partner
at my firm.Copy !req
77. - Are you a Catholic?
- No.Copy !req
78. I'm an agnostic, I guess.
I'm not really sure.Copy !req
79. If you're not sure, then you are one.Copy !req
80. I don't think you're the right attorney.
I'll stick with my public defender.Copy !req
81. He can't get the DA
to get you a better deal. I can.Copy !req
82. I won't be making
any plea agreement.Copy !req
83. If you don't, the archdiocese
won't post your bail.Copy !req
84. You'll be stuck in here for the trial.Copy !req
85. Do you understand how long
they can put you away?Copy !req
86. It's been explained to me.Copy !req
87. The DA's office doesn't like it when
religion holds itself above the law.Copy !req
88. And this prosecutor,
Ethan Thomas?Copy !req
89. You're gonna need somebody
hungry and smart...Copy !req
90. and aggressive
to even have a chance.Copy !req
91. What would your strategy be to defend
me against such a formidable man?Copy !req
92. - That depends.
- On what?Copy !req
93. On how you wanna be defended.Copy !req
94. What's your main concern,
other than staying out of jail?Copy !req
95. - Is it how you're being portrayed?
- I don't care about my reputation.Copy !req
96. I'm not afraid of jail.Copy !req
97. What I care about
is telling Emily Rose's story.Copy !req
98. I want people to hear
what only I can tell.Copy !req
99. And what is that?Copy !req
100. What really happened to Emily...Copy !req
101. and why.Copy !req
102. If I let you defend me...Copy !req
103. will you promise to let me testify and
tell the truth about what happened?Copy !req
104. And what is the truth you would tell?
That the ritual killed her?Copy !req
105. - Was it your fault she died?
- No.Copy !req
106. All right.
Then I'll let you tell her story.Copy !req
107. But only if you agree to let me do
whatever else it takes to win.Copy !req
108. You're not used to
this kind of place.Copy !req
109. I'm sure our life is very strange
to you.Copy !req
110. Not so strange.Copy !req
111. I grew up in a little town.Copy !req
112. But our house wasn't as nice
or as big as this.Copy !req
113. My mother, she raised me alone.Copy !req
114. She was a schoolteacher,
so we had very little money.Copy !req
115. What a wonderful thing to be.Copy !req
116. That was Emily's dream,
to be a teacher.Copy !req
117. That's why she went away
to the university.Copy !req
118. A lot of cats live here.Copy !req
119. There are...Copy !req
120. 11 now, I think.Copy !req
121. Emily always brought them home.Copy !req
122. Ever since she was a little girl,
she couldn't leave a stray abandoned.Copy !req
123. Before these troubles began...Copy !req
124. was Emily a happy girl?Copy !req
125. Oh, yes.Copy !req
126. Before she went away
to university...Copy !req
127. my Emily was so very happy.Copy !req
128. What is going on—? Girls!Copy !req
129. Mama.Copy !req
130. Is it—?Copy !req
131. It's a scholarship, Mama.Copy !req
132. They pay for it.
They pay for everything.Copy !req
133. This is your dream, Emily.Copy !req
134. You'll be leaving us.Copy !req
135. It's okay.Copy !req
136. I'll be okay.Copy !req
137. I'm gonna show this to your father.Copy !req
138. - Counselor. Thanks for meeting me.
- Sure.Copy !req
139. Can I buy you a drink, Mr. Thomas?
He makes an excellent martini.Copy !req
140. Just water for me, please.Copy !req
141. So...Copy !req
142. the judge thinks we should offer
a new plea agreement.Copy !req
143. She feels the community might be
better served without this trial.Copy !req
144. How do you feel about it?Copy !req
145. Personally.Copy !req
146. My job is to represent
the interests of the people...Copy !req
147. and make an effort to be objective.Copy !req
148. I ask because I know
you're a churchgoer.Copy !req
149. Now you're set to prosecute
a man of God.Copy !req
150. Your priest broke the law...Copy !req
151. and a young girl is dead.Copy !req
152. If he's a man of God, then, personally,
I think he's even more subject...Copy !req
153. to the laws of moral behavior.
If it were up to me, he'd get no deal.Copy !req
154. And forgiveness and compassion?
Isn't that part of your creed?Copy !req
155. Or does that just get in the way
of your work?Copy !req
156. If you have compassion
for your client...Copy !req
157. you'll persuade him to accept this:Copy !req
158. Charges reduced
to reckless endangerment.Copy !req
159. Twelve months in a county jail.Copy !req
160. Reducible to six, plus probation,
if he stays out of trouble.Copy !req
161. Somehow I expect
he can manage that.Copy !req
162. But please understand me.
If he refuses, I will seek the maximum.Copy !req
163. Father Moore has made it clear
there will be no plea agreement.Copy !req
164. He will not lie or admit to something
he is not guilty of.Copy !req
165. - And he was never neglectful of Emily.
- "Never neglectful"?Copy !req
166. Have you seen
the postmortem photographs?Copy !req
167. We'll go to trial. My client wants
the public to know the truth.Copy !req
168. Good.Copy !req
169. So do I.Copy !req
170. Have a good night, counselor.Copy !req
171. Let the record show that the defendant
and his counsel are present...Copy !req
172. and that the jury is seated.Copy !req
173. - Mr. Thomas, you may begin.
- Thank you, Your Honor.Copy !req
174. Good morning, ladies and gentlemen.
My name is Ethan Thomas.Copy !req
175. I'm the assistant district attorney,
and I represent the people.Copy !req
176. In the case before you,
the evidence will show...Copy !req
177. that the victim had a serious medical
condition that demanded treatment.Copy !req
178. We will prove that the victim's
condition rendered her physically...Copy !req
179. and psychologically incapable
of caring for herself.Copy !req
180. Her care...Copy !req
181. was then wholly entrusted...Copy !req
182. to that man, the defendant,
Father Richard Moore.Copy !req
183. She became his responsibility...Copy !req
184. and he betrayed
that responsibility...Copy !req
185. by persuading her to abandon
her medical treatment...Copy !req
186. in favor of religious treatment:Copy !req
187. A ritual exorcism,
performed by the defendant...Copy !req
188. allegedly to cure the victim
by ridding her of demonic forces.Copy !req
189. We will demonstrate
that this course of action...Copy !req
190. directly resulted
in the victim's death.Copy !req
191. I said a moment ago
that I represent the people.Copy !req
192. We all know what that means,
but it's a little abstract, isn't it?Copy !req
193. Miss Bruner,
the attorney for the defense...Copy !req
194. is seated right next
to the man she represents.Copy !req
195. And I stand here
to represent the people.Copy !req
196. That's not really why
I stand here today.Copy !req
197. I'm here on behalf of someone
who can't sit at a table...Copy !req
198. and look at you every day
and gain your sympathy...Copy !req
199. someone who can't take the stand
to testify...Copy !req
200. and tell you what happened
in her own words.Copy !req
201. A young girl...Copy !req
202. that could've been your daughter.Copy !req
203. Could've been mine.Copy !req
204. A girl who trusted
Father Richard Moore with her life.Copy !req
205. This is what she looked like...Copy !req
206. before the defendant began
his religious treatment.Copy !req
207. This is a photograph taken of her
on the day that she died.Copy !req
208. I stand here for Emily Rose...Copy !req
209. who died horribly...Copy !req
210. at age 19.Copy !req
211. You won't be able to see Emily sitting
here day after day during this trial.Copy !req
212. But I hope you'll remember her
as she was when she was alive...Copy !req
213. and full of...Copy !req
214. hopes and dreams.Copy !req
215. And as she was when Father
Richard Moore was finished with her...Copy !req
216. and left her to die.Copy !req
217. Thank you.Copy !req
218. Is the defense prepared
to make its opening statement?Copy !req
219. I'd like to reserve
my opening statement...Copy !req
220. until the presentation
of the defense's case.Copy !req
221. As is your privilege.Copy !req
222. Prosecution may begin.Copy !req
223. That was already my plan.Copy !req
224. Thank you, Your Honor.
The people call Dr. Edith Vogel.Copy !req
225. I've known Emily her entire life.
I took care of all of the Rose girls.Copy !req
226. Can you describe Emily
as you knew her growing up?Copy !req
227. She was a bit sickly
in her early years.Copy !req
228. She stayed inside a lot,
reading, learning music.Copy !req
229. How did she feel about
going to school?Copy !req
230. Objection.
The witness is not a psychiatrist.Copy !req
231. I'll rephrase. Did you talk to Emily
about going off to college?Copy !req
232. Yes. She told me she was excited...Copy !req
233. but nervous that she would be away
from her family in the big city.Copy !req
234. This was an overwhelming change
for her.Copy !req
235. Did you stay in touch
after she went away?Copy !req
236. Yes. She wrote me a letter
saying that she'd been to a dance...Copy !req
237. and she'd met a boy
named Jason.Copy !req
238. She didn't want her mother
to know this...Copy !req
239. because her mother did not
approve of dancing...Copy !req
240. and had warned her
about the boys at school.Copy !req
241. Did Emily communicate with you again
last fall after you received the letter?Copy !req
242. Actually, it was her mother.Copy !req
243. She telephoned me...Copy !req
244. waking me out of a deep sleep
at 4 in the morning.Copy !req
245. She asked me to call Emily at
a payphone on the university campus.Copy !req
246. When Emily answered,
she was quite hysterical.Copy !req
247. At first, she just
sobbed uncontrollably.Copy !req
248. But eventually she calmed down
enough to tell me what happened.Copy !req
249. She said that she was alone
that weekend.Copy !req
250. Her roommate had gone home.Copy !req
251. She had awakened...Copy !req
252. and thought she smelled
something burning.Copy !req
253. There was no alarm,
but she got up...Copy !req
254. afraid there was a fire.Copy !req
255. Dr. Mueller, what's your position
at the university hospital?Copy !req
256. I am chairman of
the Department of Neurology.Copy !req
257. And after you heard
about the dorm-room incident...Copy !req
258. what were your initial thoughts?Copy !req
259. At first, I thought perhaps
Emily had taken illegal drugs.Copy !req
260. Some type of hallucinogen.Copy !req
261. But we ran tests and found no trace
of drugs in her system.Copy !req
262. And the more she explained
the incident to me...Copy !req
263. the more I began to suspect
something else.Copy !req
264. Epilepsy results from uncontrolled
electrical activity in the brain.Copy !req
265. In a severe, or grand mal, seizure...Copy !req
266. a person may lose consciousness
for several minutes...Copy !req
267. and suffer involuntary contractions
of all the muscles of the body.Copy !req
268. Is it possible for a person
suffering such a seizure...Copy !req
269. to have hallucinations or perceive
the things that Emily described?Copy !req
270. The muscle contractions could feel
like an extreme pressure on the body.Copy !req
271. And it is certainly possible,
with all that brain activity...Copy !req
272. for a person to perceive all sorts
of strange and violent things.Copy !req
273. So suspecting that Emily was
epileptic, how did you proceed?Copy !req
274. I administered
an electroencephalograph.Copy !req
275. What did the EEG reveal?Copy !req
276. It showed a possible epileptic focus
in the patient's left temporal lobe.Copy !req
277. Did this require a specific treatment?Copy !req
278. Yes, I began a medication schedule
for Emily with the drug Gambutrol.Copy !req
279. I also advised regular follow-up
examinations and further tests.Copy !req
280. But Emily failed to keep
her follow-up appointments with me.Copy !req
281. She give any reason for discontinuing
these appointments?Copy !req
282. Yes, she told me she was convinced
that her condition was a spiritual one.Copy !req
283. It was the conviction of her priest,
she said, and she shared his beliefs.Copy !req
284. Was it your impression
that Emily had placed her care...Copy !req
285. - ... entirely—?
- Leading the witness.Copy !req
286. Sustained.Copy !req
287. After the end of October...Copy !req
288. did you ask Emily
why she had stopped...Copy !req
289. filling her Gambutrol
prescriptions?Copy !req
290. Yes. She said that Father Moore had
suggested she stop taking the drug.Copy !req
291. And what, in your medical opinion...Copy !req
292. was the result
of Father Moore's suggestion?Copy !req
293. I believe Father Moore's suggestion
killed her.Copy !req
294. Objection, Your Honor!Copy !req
295. The witness is asserting outrageous
conclusions based on pure hearsay.Copy !req
296. Technically correct, but I'll allow it
as part of his expert opinion testimony.Copy !req
297. Thank you, Dr. Mueller.Copy !req
298. Your witness.Copy !req
299. You said you observed a possible
epileptic focus in the temporal lobe.Copy !req
300. Doesn't this imply what you observed
may not have been an epileptic focus?Copy !req
301. Yes, that's also possible.Copy !req
302. Would Father Moore's advice to stop
taking Gambutrol be good advice...Copy !req
303. if Emily were, in fact,
not epileptic?Copy !req
304. Of course. But that's not
the case here. She was epileptic.Copy !req
305. Really.Copy !req
306. When Emily saw objects move
on their own...Copy !req
307. and felt an invisible presence
on top of her...Copy !req
308. was she experiencing symptoms
typical of epilepsy?Copy !req
309. Not typical, no.Copy !req
310. Are they typical indications
of any other conditions?Copy !req
311. - Say, for example, psychosis?
- Yes, I would say that's correct.Copy !req
312. But isn't psychosis an entirely different
medical condition from epilepsy?Copy !req
313. - Yes, in my—
- So aren't you selectively choosing...Copy !req
314. what parts of Emily's experiences
fit your epilepsy diagnosis...Copy !req
315. while ignoring those which
indicate something else?Copy !req
316. - Objection. Argumentative.
- Withdrawn.Copy !req
317. No further questions.Copy !req
318. We have to work fast.Copy !req
319. They're only giving me an hour
with you tonight.Copy !req
320. Listen.Copy !req
321. Before we get started,
there's something I have to tell you...Copy !req
322. something I should've said to you
before I let you take the case.Copy !req
323. Okay.Copy !req
324. There are forces
surrounding this trial.Copy !req
325. Dark, powerful forces.Copy !req
326. Just be careful, Erin.
Watch your step.Copy !req
327. I see.Copy !req
328. Look—Copy !req
329. Father, you don't have to worry
about me.Copy !req
330. I'm an agnostic, remember?Copy !req
331. Demons exist,
whether you believe in them or not.Copy !req
332. Your involvement in this trial might
just open you up to their attacks.Copy !req
333. Look, Father,
I appreciate your concern...Copy !req
334. but you need to be worried
about yourself.Copy !req
335. Ethan Thomas is using the medical
aspects of this case as ammunition...Copy !req
336. and I have to be prepared
for his attacks, so...Copy !req
337. with what little time we have, I think
we need to focus on your defense.Copy !req
338. Now, what I need from you is more
information about Emily's condition.Copy !req
339. Specific details of how it progressed
after the dorm-room episode.Copy !req
340. Well, after the first incident...Copy !req
341. she was sent to the university
hospital for testing and observation.Copy !req
342. Emily once told me that in her
dorm room, she resisted the demons...Copy !req
343. but at the hospital
they overcame her.Copy !req
344. So she believed...Copy !req
345. that her possession
began at the hospital?Copy !req
346. Yeah, I think she did.Copy !req
347. And after that, things just went
from bad to worse.Copy !req
348. Emily!Copy !req
349. Emily?Copy !req
350. Oh, my God. Emily?Copy !req
351. Don't touch me.Copy !req
352. Jason, please...Copy !req
353. don't leave me.Copy !req
354. And I never did leave her.Copy !req
355. I stayed until the end.Copy !req
356. So much of what we shared
was like a nightmare...Copy !req
357. but I wouldn't give up
a single minute I spent with her.Copy !req
358. She woke me up, you know?Copy !req
359. To things I never felt before,
things I never knew I could feel.Copy !req
360. I never knew how dead I was
until I met her.Copy !req
361. —Residential north metro district
where James Van Hopper...Copy !req
362. acquitted after
a controversial trial...Copy !req
363. - Can you turn that up, please?
- ... has apparently struck again.Copy !req
364. It was inside
this quiet suburban home...Copy !req
365. that police say James Van Hopper
murdered a young couple today.Copy !req
366. Sources close to the investigation
say that Van Hopper...Copy !req
367. who was acquitted
of murder charges in April...Copy !req
368. may have known
both of the victims.Copy !req
369. Their names are being withheld
pending family notification.Copy !req
370. Most glorious prince
of the heavenly army...Copy !req
371. holy Michael, the archangel...Copy !req
372. defend us in battle
against the princes...Copy !req
373. powers and rulers of darkness.Copy !req
374. Counsel Bruner, my courtroom day
begins at 9:30 a.m.Copy !req
375. - I'm sorry, Your Honor, I—
- Which was 17 minutes ago.Copy !req
376. Ready to proceed?Copy !req
377. Yes, Your Honor.Copy !req
378. Dr. Briggs, please state
your qualifications for the court.Copy !req
379. I have advanced degrees
in medicine...Copy !req
380. psychiatry and neurology
from Johns Hopkins...Copy !req
381. and I have had three books
and several dozen papers published...Copy !req
382. in the fields of neurology
and neuropsychiatry.Copy !req
383. What was the cause of death,
as determined by the autopsy?Copy !req
384. The decedent expired due to a gradual
shutdown of the bodily functions.Copy !req
385. Why did her body shut down?Copy !req
386. The autopsy found
that it was a cumulative effect...Copy !req
387. from numerous physical traumas
exacerbated by malnutrition...Copy !req
388. which severely inhibited her ability
to recuperate from those traumas.Copy !req
389. In other words, her starving body
had little or no means to recover...Copy !req
390. from the injuries it was sustaining,
and so it eventually just gave out.Copy !req
391. How did Emily get these injuries?Copy !req
392. Some were the result
of violent epileptic seizures...Copy !req
393. and some were self-inflicted.Copy !req
394. And why, in your opinion,
did Emily injure herself...Copy !req
395. and why did she stop eating?Copy !req
396. Upon review
of her complete medical file...Copy !req
397. I concluded that Emily's epilepsy
had evolved...Copy !req
398. into a condition known as
psychotic epileptic disorder.Copy !req
399. This is a rare development,
to be sure...Copy !req
400. but one that I have witnessed
numerous times.Copy !req
401. - Emily was epileptic and psychotic?
- Yes.Copy !req
402. Explain how this psychotic epileptic
disorder would manifest itself.Copy !req
403. The seizures would have
the symptoms of schizophrenia...Copy !req
404. such as auditory
and visual hallucinations...Copy !req
405. and sometimes extreme paranoia.Copy !req
406. The seizures may lock up the joints
and slightly contort the body.Copy !req
407. The pupils will dilate,
making the eyes appear black.Copy !req
408. So you believe
that Emily had epilepsy...Copy !req
409. which developed into
a form of violent psychosis...Copy !req
410. a condition that can be controlled
with Gambutrol?Copy !req
411. Yes. And it would've been,
if she'd continued her treatment.Copy !req
412. In your opinion, if Emily
had continued with her medication...Copy !req
413. - ... would she be alive today?
- Absolutely.Copy !req
414. If treated early, psychotic epileptic
disorder is rarely fatal.Copy !req
415. I mean, this—Copy !req
416. This was a very sick girl.Copy !req
417. The defendant should've realized
that Emily was in need...Copy !req
418. of continued medical treatment.Copy !req
419. Thank you, doctor. Your witness.Copy !req
420. Doctor, you testified that Gambutrol
could've controlled Emily's condition.Copy !req
421. How do you know that?Copy !req
422. It's the inevitable result
of taking the drug.Copy !req
423. It would've controlled
her seizures...Copy !req
424. which were the root cause
of her psychosis.Copy !req
425. But wasn't Emily still experiencing
psychotic symptoms...Copy !req
426. even after she started
taking the medication?Copy !req
427. Yes. Because Gambutrol
has a cumulative effect.Copy !req
428. It takes time to build up
in the system.Copy !req
429. You assume that Gambutrol would've
helped her, but you don't know.Copy !req
430. It's a reasonable assumption, but...Copy !req
431. No, of course, I can't be certain.Copy !req
432. Doctor, is "psychotic epileptic
disorder" a common medical term...Copy !req
433. or did you just make it up?Copy !req
434. Well, I distinguished
and named the—Copy !req
435. So psychotic epileptic disorder
is really your own pet theory?Copy !req
436. - Objection. Argumentative.
- Sustained.Copy !req
437. When Emily chose
to stop her medical treatment...Copy !req
438. what do you think
should've been done?Copy !req
439. Upon recognizing her condition...Copy !req
440. I would have tranquilized her
and force-fed her.Copy !req
441. And then, if necessary...Copy !req
442. I would've treated her
with electroconvulsive therapy.Copy !req
443. Electroshock treatment. You would've
done this against her will?Copy !req
444. To save her life?Copy !req
445. Absolutely.Copy !req
446. Nothing further.Copy !req
447. The witness may step down.Copy !req
448. Your Honor, I offer into evidence this
photograph as People's Exhibit 3-A.Copy !req
449. And having done so, the people rest.Copy !req
450. The photograph is entered
into evidence.Copy !req
451. We are recessed until
tomorrow morning, 9:30 sharp...Copy !req
452. at which time the defense
will give its opening statement...Copy !req
453. and call its first witness.Copy !req
454. I'm sorry I was late.Copy !req
455. I didn't get a lot of sleep. Big power
outage knocked out my alarm clock.Copy !req
456. - It won't happen again.
- No, I didn't sleep either.Copy !req
457. What kept you awake?Copy !req
458. Doesn't matter.Copy !req
459. You're under attack.Copy !req
460. What are you talking about?Copy !req
461. You're in a spiritual battle, Erin.Copy !req
462. The forces of darkness are trying
to keep you away from the light.Copy !req
463. Don't let them.Copy !req
464. Don't worry about today.
We're doing fine.Copy !req
465. We're getting creamed.
I can't believe I walked right into that.Copy !req
466. Look, if we don't find a doctor
to testify that Emily...Copy !req
467. wasn't epileptic or schizophrenic
or schizo-epileptic, we're gonna lose.Copy !req
468. Care of the city's main branch
and the university library...Copy !req
469. I bring you another dozen
fun-filled books...Copy !req
470. about the demonic
and the mentally deranged.Copy !req
471. They burned women at the stake...Copy !req
472. during witch hunts
for being possessed.Copy !req
473. Glad you don't have to defend
those guys.Copy !req
474. - How are we on our medical experts?
- Not good.Copy !req
475. The psychiatrist you wanted
is tied up in another trial.Copy !req
476. And the neurologist is sailing
to Costa Rica.Copy !req
477. This book I'm reading,
it's by an anthropologist.Copy !req
478. It's about contemporary cases of
possession, mostly in the Third World.Copy !req
479. People there are still
primitive and superstitious.Copy !req
480. Maybe.Copy !req
481. Maybe they see possession
for what it really is.Copy !req
482. Maybe we've taught ourselves
not to see it.Copy !req
483. - You saying you believe in this stuff?
- No.Copy !req
484. Maybe we shouldn't just try
to invalidate the prosecution's case...Copy !req
485. by punching holes
in the medical approach.Copy !req
486. Maybe we should also try
to validate the alternative.Copy !req
487. - Validate possession in a court of law?
- Yes.Copy !req
488. Okay. I guess we could bring in
some priests to talk about exorcisms—Copy !req
489. No, the archdiocese
won't let us do that.Copy !req
490. They wanna limit the Church's
exposure to Father Moore.Copy !req
491. I've got three articles by the
anthropologist who wrote this book.Copy !req
492. She approaches
the subject of possession...Copy !req
493. from a scientific perspective
and doesn't try to debunk it.Copy !req
494. - You want me to track her down?
- Yeah.Copy !req
495. Keep looking for a medical expert
to refute Dr. Briggs.Copy !req
496. But send the case file
to this Dr. Sadira Adani.Copy !req
497. Ladies and gentlemen of the jury...Copy !req
498. as you know by now,
my name is Erin Bruner...Copy !req
499. and I represent the defendant,
Richard Moore.Copy !req
500. Mr. Thomas has contended
that Emily Rose suffered...Copy !req
501. from a serious medical condition...Copy !req
502. that required medical treatment,
nothing more.Copy !req
503. He has asserted that any attempt
by my client...Copy !req
504. to help Emily by anything
other than medical means...Copy !req
505. was not only inappropriate,
but criminally negligent.Copy !req
506. I'm now gonna ask
that you keep an open mind...Copy !req
507. to what our evidence
and testimony will show.Copy !req
508. Medical treatment was not
the answer for Emily...Copy !req
509. because she simply did not suffer
from a medical condition.Copy !req
510. She was neither epileptic
nor psychotic.Copy !req
511. Emily Rose's condition, in fact,
was demonic possession.Copy !req
512. An exorcism was her only hope
for a cure.Copy !req
513. Some of you may find yourself unable
to reconcile Emily's beliefs...Copy !req
514. or those of the defendant
with your own.Copy !req
515. You may not believe demons exist.
You won't have to.Copy !req
516. Because you will see that after the
utter failure of doctors to help Emily...Copy !req
517. Father Moore simply tried
to help Emily in a different way...Copy !req
518. using an approach that he,
Emily and her family firmly believed...Copy !req
519. was her only chance for relief.Copy !req
520. And we will show that
despite his greatest efforts...Copy !req
521. and his sincere love for Emily...Copy !req
522. there was nothing he could've done
to prevent the death of Emily Rose.Copy !req
523. Are you okay?Copy !req
524. Aren't you gonna eat anything?Copy !req
525. She said it was terrible to hear
the clinking of spoons and forks.Copy !req
526. She was always hungry,
but she said they wouldn't let her eat.Copy !req
527. Who did she mean by "they"?Copy !req
528. The forces that were
in control of her.Copy !req
529. That were inside her.Copy !req
530. You know, the demons.Copy !req
531. Tell us what else happened
that night.Copy !req
532. I walked her back to her dorm...Copy !req
533. and she seemed really nervous
and scared.Copy !req
534. So I held her for a while,
trying to calm her down.Copy !req
535. I fell asleep, but when I woke up,
she wasn't beside me.Copy !req
536. Emily?Copy !req
537. Hey.Copy !req
538. Can you hear me?Copy !req
539. I called her father, and he told me
to bring Emily home.Copy !req
540. Jason and I put Emily to bed...Copy !req
541. hoping she would sleep.Copy !req
542. And when did Father Moore
become involved?Copy !req
543. Emily stayed home after that.Copy !req
544. She didn't return to school,
and she kept getting worse.Copy !req
545. Eventually, when she didn't get better,
we called our priest, Father Moore.Copy !req
546. When he arrived,
I sent my daughter Alice upstairs...Copy !req
547. to see if Emily was awake.Copy !req
548. Emily?Copy !req
549. Can I come in?Copy !req
550. - Our Father, who art in heaven—
- Emily?Copy !req
551. Father Moore is here.
Can you come downstairs?Copy !req
552. —As it is in heaven.Copy !req
553. Give us this day our daily bread...Copy !req
554. Emily, can you hear me?Copy !req
555. Let's get her off the floor.Copy !req
556. Alice, no!Copy !req
557. I am the one who dwells within.Copy !req
558. And I am the one who comes
in His name.Copy !req
559. Think you can force me out, priest?Copy !req
560. Try.Copy !req
561. I dare you.Copy !req
562. You've suffered a terrible loss,
Mr. Rose. I know this is difficult.Copy !req
563. So thank you for being here today.Copy !req
564. Sir, do you often read the Bible?Copy !req
565. - Yes, I do.
- So do I.Copy !req
566. What about the DSM?Copy !req
567. The Diagnostic and Statistical
Manual of Mental Disorders...Copy !req
568. commonly referred to
as the bible of abnormal psychiatry.Copy !req
569. - Have you read that?
- No.Copy !req
570. So you're not aware
that according to the DSM...Copy !req
571. a person's refusal to eat is
a common indication of anorexia?Copy !req
572. Objection. The witness just said
he hasn't read the DSM, Your Honor.Copy !req
573. - Sustained.
- Mr. Rose...Copy !req
574. are you aware
that catatonic rigidity...Copy !req
575. specifically a locking up
of the body's joints...Copy !req
576. is a known symptom of psychosis?Copy !req
577. No. I haven't studied these things.Copy !req
578. Have you ever visited
an insane asylum...Copy !req
579. or a hospital for the mentally ill?Copy !req
580. Once. My aunt was in one
before she died.Copy !req
581. Really? So there's a history
of mental illness in your family?Copy !req
582. I suppose.Copy !req
583. Sir, if you saw someone
eating insects...Copy !req
584. on a street corner, would you say
that that person is mentally ill?Copy !req
585. - Probably, yes.
- So can you say with confidence...Copy !req
586. that the behavior you saw
in your daughter's bedroom...Copy !req
587. could not be the behavior of
someone suffering from psychosis?Copy !req
588. I don't know. She never had
any problems like that before.Copy !req
589. It just didn't feel that way to me
or to Father Moore.Copy !req
590. - And you trusted him, right?
- Yes.Copy !req
591. He is our parish priest.Copy !req
592. Fair enough. And after that night,
would you say that you...Copy !req
593. put your daughter entirely
in Father Moore's care?Copy !req
594. Yes. We had done all we could.Copy !req
595. We said she was in his hands now...Copy !req
596. body and soul.Copy !req
597. Thank you. No further questions,
Your Honor.Copy !req
598. Thank you, Mr. Rose.
You may step down.Copy !req
599. The defense calls Dr. Sadira Adani.Copy !req
600. I am currently a professor
of anthropology and psychiatry...Copy !req
601. at Northwestern University.Copy !req
602. Where did you receive
your education?Copy !req
603. At Yale, and then at Cambridge.Copy !req
604. And what is your specific area
of expertise?Copy !req
605. I study the spiritual experiences
of people in various cultures...Copy !req
606. and the physiological
and psychological changes...Copy !req
607. they undergo
during these experiences.Copy !req
608. Would it be accurate to say that you
specialize in the study of possession?Copy !req
609. Yes. "Possession" is one term
for a basic human experience...Copy !req
610. reported by a great number
of people all around the world.Copy !req
611. In my fieldwork, I've seen
many people who experienced...Copy !req
612. a sense of being invaded by
an entity from the supernatural realm.Copy !req
613. Why do you think
Emily was invaded?Copy !req
614. Why did this possession
happen to her?Copy !req
615. Based on my study of the case file...Copy !req
616. I believe that Emily Rose
was a hypersensitive.Copy !req
617. A person with
an unusual connection...Copy !req
618. to what Carlos Castaneda called
"the separate reality."Copy !req
619. Hypersensitives are born
different from everyone else.Copy !req
620. They can have visions of the future,
or see the dead...Copy !req
621. and sometimes be
uniquely susceptible...Copy !req
622. to invasion by an entity
that is alien to them.Copy !req
623. Objection.Copy !req
624. On what grounds?Copy !req
625. How about silliness, Your Honor?Copy !req
626. A young girl
suffered terribly and died.Copy !req
627. Do we have to subject her illness
to this pseudoscientific analysis?Copy !req
628. Both counselors,
please approach the bench.Copy !req
629. Your Honor, this testimony
is beyond ridiculous. Visions—Copy !req
630. Supernatural belief systems
are shared by millions of people.Copy !req
631. We're in The Twilight Zone here.Copy !req
632. Her expertise is relevant
to the issues in this case.Copy !req
633. Let's have a witch doctor
sift through bones—Copy !req
634. Stop.Copy !req
635. We've heard a great deal
of testimony...Copy !req
636. in support of a medical explanation
for Emily's condition.Copy !req
637. Now we have a witness
who has spent her career...Copy !req
638. studying the defense's
alternative explanation.Copy !req
639. An exorcism expert, if you will.Copy !req
640. I think we'll hear
what she has to say.Copy !req
641. Thank you, Your Honor.Copy !req
642. Dr. Adani, why do you think
Emily's exorcism failed?Copy !req
643. The medical treatment.
Specifically, the drug Gambutrol.Copy !req
644. Please explain.Copy !req
645. The exorcism ritual results
in a specific brain activity...Copy !req
646. that cuts the person off from
the possession experience.Copy !req
647. But Emily's exorcism
could not have achieved this...Copy !req
648. because the doctor
gave her Gambutrol...Copy !req
649. which has an intoxicating effect
on the brain.Copy !req
650. The drug made her immune
to the psycho-spiritual shock...Copy !req
651. that exorcism
is intended to provide.Copy !req
652. What do you believe was the result of
treatment with this intoxicating drug?Copy !req
653. Gambutrol locked Emily
in the possessed state.Copy !req
654. This left her unable to respond
to the exorcism...Copy !req
655. and therefore, it directly
contributed to her death.Copy !req
656. Thank you, doctor.Copy !req
657. No further questions.Copy !req
658. I'm looking at a list of
your published articles, doctor.Copy !req
659. You've been quite busy and prolific.Copy !req
660. So based on your time spent
with Holy Roller snake-handlers...Copy !req
661. voodoo priestesses
and Indians tripping on peyote buds...Copy !req
662. based on observing
these bizarre individuals...Copy !req
663. you've concluded
that possession is...Copy !req
664. a basic, typical
human experience?Copy !req
665. I must say, counselor...Copy !req
666. that's quite a laundry list
of disdain...Copy !req
667. and one that thoroughly
mischaracterizes my research.Copy !req
668. No, I don't think possession
is a typical experience.Copy !req
669. But I am convinced that it is
a scientifically verified...Copy !req
670. culturally universal one.Copy !req
671. Have you ever used Gambutrol
in your studies...Copy !req
672. to test your theory about its effect
on the possession experience?Copy !req
673. Absolutely not. That would be
dangerous to the patient.Copy !req
674. So this notion of Gambutrol locking
someone in a possessed state...Copy !req
675. the key to your assertion that
her medical treatment harmed Emily...Copy !req
676. this would be your own
pet theory, correct?Copy !req
677. - You're just making this one up?
- Objection. Argumentative.Copy !req
678. Sustained.Copy !req
679. Although I think he's just taking
a page from your book, counselor.Copy !req
680. No further questions.Copy !req
681. Erin!Copy !req
682. I've got a doctor
who wants to testify.Copy !req
683. He's an eyewitness, Erin.Copy !req
684. He was there.
He was at the exorcism.Copy !req
685. - What?
- He called us.Copy !req
686. Dr. Graham Cartwright,
Department of Abnormal Psychiatry...Copy !req
687. at St. Mary's Hospital.Copy !req
688. Dr. Cartwright. Ring a bell?Copy !req
689. Yes.Copy !req
690. He was there?Copy !req
691. - Yes.
- Father...Copy !req
692. if you want me to defend you,
you've got to give me...Copy !req
693. all the information I need.Copy !req
694. With all of this medical testimony
helping the prosecution...Copy !req
695. how could you not tell me
that a doctor attended the exorcism?Copy !req
696. He asked that I keep
his involvement confidential...Copy !req
697. and I said I would.Copy !req
698. Dr. Cartwright?Copy !req
699. I recognize you from those
courtroom drawings on the news.Copy !req
700. You're much prettier in real life.Copy !req
701. - May I sit?
- Yes, please.Copy !req
702. You're losing.Copy !req
703. I had hoped Father Moore
wouldn't need me...Copy !req
704. but I don't wanna see him
put away.Copy !req
705. How do you know him?Copy !req
706. Well, I was his parishioner
at St. Vincent's Church...Copy !req
707. about 15 years ago.Copy !req
708. I hadn't seen or heard of him for years
when he called me last fall.Copy !req
709. But he needed help, so...Copy !req
710. What kind of help, doctor?Copy !req
711. He wanted a medical perspective
from a psychiatrist...Copy !req
712. you know, one that he knew,
trusted...Copy !req
713. to observe Emily's physical
and mental state during this...Copy !req
714. During the exorcism.Copy !req
715. Yeah.Copy !req
716. Doctor.Copy !req
717. Can you help our case?Copy !req
718. That girl was not schizophrenic...Copy !req
719. and she was not epileptic,
or any combination of the two.Copy !req
720. I've seen hundreds of people
with those problems.Copy !req
721. They can be terrible afflictions,
of course, but they don't scare me.Copy !req
722. But what you saw that night in Emily,
that did scare you.Copy !req
723. God, if I'd known,
I never would've been there.Copy !req
724. I started praying again
since then, you know.Copy !req
725. I examined that girl before I drove
back to the city that night.Copy !req
726. She was lucid...Copy !req
727. and she was completely aware
of this separate entity inside her.Copy !req
728. When she wasn't in his grip, she was
totally herself, completely normal.Copy !req
729. The awareness of her alternate mental
state is counterindicative of psychosis.Copy !req
730. Crazy people
don't know they're crazy.Copy !req
731. That's right.Copy !req
732. You'll testify to all of this, in detail?Copy !req
733. Everything you saw?Copy !req
734. Send me the case files
and tell me when to be in court.Copy !req
735. Thank you, doctor.Copy !req
736. We need this.Copy !req
737. Before he was arrested,
Father Moore sent this to me.Copy !req
738. He asked me to take care of it.Copy !req
739. It's your burden now.Copy !req
740. One more thing.
When you saw Emily...Copy !req
741. did Father Moore ask you
to give her any medical help?Copy !req
742. He was already trying to stop her from
injuring herself and urging her to eat.Copy !req
743. And I told him, as a doctor,
I couldn't help her.Copy !req
744. Dr. Cartwright's going to testify.Copy !req
745. Don't you get it?Copy !req
746. He's not just an eyewitness
to the exorcism.Copy !req
747. He can also refute the prosecution's
medical case. This is huge for us.Copy !req
748. When do I get to testify?Copy !req
749. I don't know. Let's take this
one step at a time.Copy !req
750. No.Copy !req
751. What matters most is Emily's story,
which only I can tell.Copy !req
752. I understand.Copy !req
753. Have you thought about
what I said before?Copy !req
754. About dark forces
and demonic attacks?Copy !req
755. Yes, I have.Copy !req
756. That day, after Briggs testified...Copy !req
757. I was feeling awful.Copy !req
758. And I went out for a walk
just to clear my head...Copy !req
759. and I was thinking about
what you said to me.Copy !req
760. "What if demons really do exist?"Copy !req
761. And wondering what that
would mean if I believed that.Copy !req
762. Because God knows,
I have my own demons.Copy !req
763. And I saw something
lying on the sidewalk.Copy !req
764. It was a gold locket...Copy !req
765. with the initials E.C.B.
engraved on it.Copy !req
766. My middle name is Christine.Copy !req
767. Erin Christine Bruner.Copy !req
768. And of all the people walking by
that day, I found that locket.Copy !req
769. What are the chances of that?Copy !req
770. I don't know, maybe it was a sign.Copy !req
771. Or maybe it was just some
incredible coincidence.Copy !req
772. But it made me feel...Copy !req
773. like no matter what mistakes
I've made in the past...Copy !req
774. at that moment, I was exactly
where I was meant to be.Copy !req
775. Like I was on the right path.Copy !req
776. You sound more like a mystic
than an agnostic.Copy !req
777. Are you wearing the locket now?Copy !req
778. No.Copy !req
779. You should.Copy !req
780. The archdiocese
doesn't want you to testify.Copy !req
781. They're just afraid
that I'll embarrass them.Copy !req
782. Testify to some medieval-sounding
supernatural nonsense.Copy !req
783. They're expecting me
to talk you out of it.Copy !req
784. I've just decided
I'm not even gonna try.Copy !req
785. Why not?Copy !req
786. If the archdiocese
wants to avoid embarrassment...Copy !req
787. they need you to walk out of here
a free man.Copy !req
788. I believe a jury will find you
sincere and credible...Copy !req
789. and when Dr. Cartwright
corroborates your testimony...Copy !req
790. and refutes the prosecution's
medical arguments...Copy !req
791. we'll get an acquittal.Copy !req
792. And everyone will thank me for it.Copy !req
793. Emily!Copy !req
794. God help me.Copy !req
795. Do you swear to tell the truth,
the whole truth, so help you God?Copy !req
796. I do.Copy !req
797. Father Moore, before you could
perform the exorcism...Copy !req
798. you had to get the sanction
of the Church, correct?Copy !req
799. Yes, on October the 27th
of last year...Copy !req
800. I presented my assessment and
recommendation to the archbishop...Copy !req
801. and he authorized the exorcism
that day before I left the office.Copy !req
802. Tell us what happened that night.Copy !req
803. I drove home.Copy !req
804. I sat up till after midnight
studying The Roman Ritual...Copy !req
805. thinking about what lay ahead.Copy !req
806. You mean The Roman Ritual
of Exorcism.Copy !req
807. A text used by Catholic priests...Copy !req
808. as a guide to performing
the exorcism rite.Copy !req
809. Yes, I think I actually fell asleep
with the book in my hand.Copy !req
810. What happened next?Copy !req
811. I woke up, freezing.Copy !req
812. It was exactly 3 a.m.Copy !req
813. Three a.m. is the demonic
witching hour.Copy !req
814. It's a way for demons
to mock the Holy Trinity.Copy !req
815. It's an inversion of 3 p.m.,
the miracle hour...Copy !req
816. which is traditionally accepted
as the hour of Christ's death.Copy !req
817. I thought I smelled
something burning.Copy !req
818. Only later did I connect it...Copy !req
819. and I remembered that that same
smell of something burning...Copy !req
820. had been perceived by Emily.Copy !req
821. Holy Mary, mother of God,
pray for us sinners, now and—Copy !req
822. Pray for us sinners,
now and at the hour of our—Copy !req
823. At the hour of—Copy !req
824. What do you make of this gesture,
this nod in your direction?Copy !req
825. I don't know. Some kind
of acknowledgment, I guess.Copy !req
826. That the game is on.Copy !req
827. You're really God's gunslinger,
aren't you, Father?Copy !req
828. Standing tall and facing the devil
with your prayer book at your side.Copy !req
829. Objection, Your Honor.
Counsel's harassing my witness.Copy !req
830. Sustained. Mr. Thomas, you know
I won't allow that in my courtroom.Copy !req
831. Forgive me, Your Honor.Copy !req
832. Father, did you understand this
black-robed figure to be the devil?Copy !req
833. I believe it was
a demonic manifestation.Copy !req
834. Like the demonic force
you believe possessed Emily?Copy !req
835. - Yes.
- Why do you think it appeared to you?Copy !req
836. I believe the demonic
can appear as an apparition...Copy !req
837. much like a ghost,
in an attempt to excite our fear.Copy !req
838. - Did it excite your fear, Father?
- It scared the hell out of me.Copy !req
839. So this night, when you began to
prepare Emily's exorcism...Copy !req
840. was it your first encounter
with this demon ghost?Copy !req
841. - Yes.
- Have you seen it again?Copy !req
842. I've seen it ever since.Copy !req
843. No further questions at this time.Copy !req
844. Redirect, Your Honor.Copy !req
845. Father Moore, after you received
the bishop's authorization...Copy !req
846. when did you proceed
with an exorcism?Copy !req
847. October 31 st.Copy !req
848. On Halloween.
Isn't that a bit dramatic?Copy !req
849. Halloween tradition is based on
legends throughout history...Copy !req
850. that indicate a real increase
in spiritual activity on that night...Copy !req
851. and I thought we could use the
occasion to draw them into the open.Copy !req
852. - The demons, you mean?
- Yes.Copy !req
853. Father Moore...Copy !req
854. can you identify this?Copy !req
855. It's my tape recorder.
I used it to record the exorcism.Copy !req
856. Inside is the tape I made that night.Copy !req
857. Why would you make such a tape?Copy !req
858. Ever since the technology
has been available...Copy !req
859. exorcists have used tape recorders
to authenticate the ritual...Copy !req
860. and provide a record for review.Copy !req
861. I offer into evidence this
cassette recorder and audiotape...Copy !req
862. Objection. The people were not aware
of the existence of this tape...Copy !req
863. - ... until last night.
- Neither were we.Copy !req
864. This tape is new evidence that came
into our possession yesterday.Copy !req
865. We provided counsel for the people
with a transcript of its contents.Copy !req
866. You mean this tape was not
given to you by your client?Copy !req
867. No, Your Honor. We received it
from a reluctant witness...Copy !req
868. Dr. Graham Cartwright, who will also
be called to testify to its authenticity.Copy !req
869. The people will find his name
on the updated witness list...Copy !req
870. we provided to them this morning.Copy !req
871. Very well. I'll allow it into evidence.Copy !req
872. Father Moore.Copy !req
873. Will you play the tape for us now?Copy !req
874. This is the exorcism of Emily Rose.Copy !req
875. Those present are myself,
Father Richard Moore...Copy !req
876. Nathaniel, Emily's father...Copy !req
877. Jason, her friend...Copy !req
878. a doctor who is here
to monitor Emily during the ritual...Copy !req
879. and Emily herself...Copy !req
880. who has given her permission
for the ritual to be performed.Copy !req
881. All right, now listen.Copy !req
882. You may say the rosary or any
private prayer for her deliverance...Copy !req
883. when you're not responding
to my words.Copy !req
884. Above all...Copy !req
885. do whatever I ask,
without question.Copy !req
886. Don't ask it any questions...Copy !req
887. or pay any attention
to what it says.Copy !req
888. "It"?Copy !req
889. We won't be dealing
with Emily tonight.Copy !req
890. Restrain her.Copy !req
891. Lord Jesus Christ,
have mercy on us.Copy !req
892. It has begun.Copy !req
893. Let us pray.Copy !req
894. "Because she hopes
in you, my God."Copy !req
895. "Send her help from
the holy place, Lord."Copy !req
896. "And give her heavenly protection."Copy !req
897. "May the Lord be with you."Copy !req
898. "And with your spirit."Copy !req
899. Our Father, who art in heaven,
hallowed be thy name.Copy !req
900. My God. Are you all right?Copy !req
901. Dolls and kisses
and crosses and wishes...Copy !req
902. you think that can save
your little girl?Copy !req
903. Thy kingdom come, thy will be done,
on earth as it is in heaven.Copy !req
904. I'm fine.Copy !req
905. Give us this day our daily bread.Copy !req
906. And forgive us our trespasses as we
forgive those that trespass against us.Copy !req
907. And lead us not into temptation—Copy !req
908. But deliver us from evil!Copy !req
909. Who are you, demon?
Tell me your name.Copy !req
910. I am the one who dwells within...Copy !req
911. In the Name of Christ...Copy !req
912. identify yourself!Copy !req
913. One, two, three, four, five, six.
One, two, three, four, five, six.Copy !req
914. Trick or treat.
I give you treats and tricks.Copy !req
915. One, two, three, four, five, six.Copy !req
916. Father Moore!Copy !req
917. Papa!Copy !req
918. Emily!Copy !req
919. She feels so hot, Father!
She's burning up!Copy !req
920. Hold her down there on the straw!
Hold her!Copy !req
921. Emily!Copy !req
922. Doctor! I need you here now.Copy !req
923. Watch her vital signs.Copy !req
924. In the beginning was the word.Copy !req
925. And the word was with God.Copy !req
926. And the word was the word,
and what a wonderful word it was.Copy !req
927. Through him all things remain.Copy !req
928. Without him, nothing was made
that has been made.Copy !req
929. And the 70 disciples
returned again with joy, saying:Copy !req
930. "Lord, even the devils are subject
unto us through thy name."Copy !req
931. Her heart is racing.
It's almost 180 beats a minute.Copy !req
932. I beheld Satan as lightning
fall from heaven.Copy !req
933. Behold. I give you power to tread on
serpents and scorpions...Copy !req
934. and over all the power
of the enemy.Copy !req
935. And nothing shall,
by any means, hurt you.Copy !req
936. Nothing...?Copy !req
937. Get it off! Get it off! Get it off!Copy !req
938. Release him, demon. I command you
in the name of our Lord, Jesus Christ.Copy !req
939. Tell me your name, wicked one.Copy !req
940. One, two, three, four, five, six!Copy !req
941. He who commands you is he
who ordered you thrown down...Copy !req
942. from the highest heaven
into the depths of hell.Copy !req
943. In the name of our Lord, Jesus Christ,
I now command you:Copy !req
944. Tell me your name!Copy !req
945. One, two, three, four, five, six!Copy !req
946. Hear, therefore, and fear,
Satan, enemy of the faith.Copy !req
947. Give me your name, demon!Copy !req
948. Names!Copy !req
949. One, two, three, four, five, six!Copy !req
950. Ancient serpents...Copy !req
951. depart from this servant of God!Copy !req
952. Tell me your six names!Copy !req
953. We are the ones who dwell within!Copy !req
954. I am the one who dwelt within Cain!Copy !req
955. I am the one who dwelt within Nero!Copy !req
956. I once dwelt within Judas!Copy !req
957. And I was with Legion!Copy !req
958. I am Belial!Copy !req
959. And I am Lucifer...Copy !req
960. the devil in the flesh.Copy !req
961. Mr. Rose.Copy !req
962. Doctor, help him!Copy !req
963. After a few moments,
Mr. Rose revived...Copy !req
964. but the exorcism
had to be abandoned.Copy !req
965. Emily was taken to her room
and soon fell into a deep sleep.Copy !req
966. The whole thing
was a complete failure.Copy !req
967. Describe her behavior from the night
of the failed exorcism...Copy !req
968. until the time of her death.Copy !req
969. Violence towards others and herself.Copy !req
970. Sometimes she screamed
for hours on end.Copy !req
971. She drove her head through windows,
tried to bite...Copy !req
972. Tried to bite holes in the walls,
breaking several more of her teeth...Copy !req
973. as you saw in
the postmortem photograph.Copy !req
974. - You witnessed this?
- Some of it, yes.Copy !req
975. I tried to visit every day...Copy !req
976. and the family told me the rest.Copy !req
977. Did you attempt another exorcism?Copy !req
978. I wanted to, but Emily refused.Copy !req
979. And without the consent
of the possessed...Copy !req
980. the exorcism ritual
can't be performed.Copy !req
981. Did you encourage her to eat?Copy !req
982. Yes, every time I saw her...Copy !req
983. but the few times she tried,
it seemed like...Copy !req
984. Seemed like she couldn't swallow,
or she couldn't keep it down.Copy !req
985. What about medical care?Copy !req
986. I wanted her to continue. I never said
she should quit seeing her doctors.Copy !req
987. That would be wrong.
Medical care is not my field.Copy !req
988. But you did suggest she stop
taking the drug Gambutrol.Copy !req
989. Yes.Copy !req
990. After the exorcism,
she asked for my counsel.Copy !req
991. She told me that the drugs
had never helped her.Copy !req
992. After all, she was on Gambutrol
during the exorcism...Copy !req
993. when her so-called symptoms
were at their peak.Copy !req
994. Ultimately, we both felt that
she was beyond medical care...Copy !req
995. and that she had to see this
through to the end...Copy !req
996. by faith alone.Copy !req
997. The dual voices we just heard
on this tape...Copy !req
998. you're certain that they were both
coming from Emily at the same time?Copy !req
999. Yes. Yes, I heard them.Copy !req
1000. Have you tampered
with this tape in any way?Copy !req
1001. No. No, I have not.Copy !req
1002. No further questions at this time.Copy !req
1003. Mr. Thomas.Copy !req
1004. Father Moore, you consider this tape
to be proof of the supernatural?Copy !req
1005. I think it's a record
of certain indications...Copy !req
1006. that Emily was possessed.Copy !req
1007. Signs of possession,
you may call them.Copy !req
1008. By "signs of possession," would you
mean her speaking in languages...Copy !req
1009. we might assume
she couldn't possibly know?Copy !req
1010. And the vocalization of two
distinct voices simultaneously?Copy !req
1011. Yes. Among other signs that I
observed and described to the court...Copy !req
1012. while the tape was playing.
Things I saw.Copy !req
1013. Things you can't hear
on the tape.Copy !req
1014. We'll just have to take
your word, won't we?Copy !req
1015. - Your Honor.
- Mr. Thomas.Copy !req
1016. I apologize.
Father, as Emily's parish priest...Copy !req
1017. are you aware that she underwent
advanced catechism training?Copy !req
1018. Yes. Yes. Her family is very devout.Copy !req
1019. And in that training, did she study
Ancient Greek, Hebrew and Latin?Copy !req
1020. Yes, I think that's right.Copy !req
1021. Might have even studied Aramaic,
Christ and his disciples' language...Copy !req
1022. which, according to the transcripts,
we also heard on the tape, correct?Copy !req
1023. She spoke Aramaic on the tape.
It wasn't part of her training.Copy !req
1024. But it was offered as an elective
at her catechism school.Copy !req
1025. I have the school's curriculum
here if you'd like to see it.Copy !req
1026. No. I'll accept that she might have
been exposed to that language.Copy !req
1027. And according to
her high school records...Copy !req
1028. German was the foreign language
she studied there, yes?Copy !req
1029. I don't know. If you say so.Copy !req
1030. So that covers the strange languages
we heard on the tape, correct?Copy !req
1031. Did I miss any?Copy !req
1032. - No.
- Good.Copy !req
1033. We've already established
you're no medical expert.Copy !req
1034. You said it's not your field.Copy !req
1035. But are you aware of the dual sets of
vocal cords every human possesses?Copy !req
1036. - No.
- Have you heard of...Copy !req
1037. the superior vocal cords, which are
higher than the ones we use to speak?Copy !req
1038. No. So you didn't know that
Tibetan monks, for example...Copy !req
1039. as part of their religious training,
teach themselves...Copy !req
1040. to activate both sets
of vocal cords at once?Copy !req
1041. No, I didn't know that.Copy !req
1042. Well, now that you do know,
would you think it's possible...Copy !req
1043. that Emily, in her psychotic state...Copy !req
1044. might have activated both sets
of vocal cords...Copy !req
1045. so as to achieve the amazing effect
we heard captured on your audiotape?Copy !req
1046. Her state was not psychotic.Copy !req
1047. Father Moore, you told us
that in the exorcism we heard...Copy !req
1048. you actually saw, once again,
this black-robed figure...Copy !req
1049. - ... or demonic apparition, am I right?
- Yes.Copy !req
1050. But we couldn't see him
when you played the tape, correct?Copy !req
1051. - No, of course not.
- Of course not.Copy !req
1052. So that would be another
supernatural aspect of the exorcism...Copy !req
1053. - ... your tape doesn't prove, correct?
- Yes.Copy !req
1054. Where is your dark figure, Father?Copy !req
1055. Is he here now?
Do I look like your demon ghost?Copy !req
1056. - Your Honor.
- Counselor.Copy !req
1057. I have nothing further.Copy !req
1058. Does the defense wish to redirect?Copy !req
1059. No, Your Honor, but we reserve
the right to recall the witness later.Copy !req
1060. Very well.
The witness may step down.Copy !req
1061. Your Honor, my next witness
must have been detained.Copy !req
1062. If we could take a short recess
so I could—Copy !req
1063. You've made this court wait before,
counselor. I'm inclined to—Copy !req
1064. Your Honor, please.Copy !req
1065. Dr. Cartwright came to us
in good conscience...Copy !req
1066. as an eyewitness to the exorcism
on Father Moore's tape.Copy !req
1067. He can substantiate
all of my client's testimony—Copy !req
1068. Your Honor, the defense has already
presented its exorcism testimony...Copy !req
1069. in dramatic fashion.
Do we really have to—?Copy !req
1070. We have absorbed some
extraordinary testimony today.Copy !req
1071. I think we'll take some time
to consider it.Copy !req
1072. Court is adjourned
until 9:30 tomorrow morning.Copy !req
1073. - You can't find him?
- I went to meet him, he didn't show.Copy !req
1074. I called his office, I called his house.Copy !req
1075. Okay. Go to the hospital, ask around.
Somebody's gotta know where he is.Copy !req
1076. What the hell happened?Copy !req
1077. Tell Father Moore I'm sorry.Copy !req
1078. Tell him I know the demons are real
and I admire his courage...Copy !req
1079. for standing and speaking
against them.Copy !req
1080. Tell him I know what they can do.Copy !req
1081. - Cartwright's dead.
- I heard.Copy !req
1082. Are you drunk?Copy !req
1083. - Not yet, but I'm working on it.
- Have you seen this?Copy !req
1084. - What the hell were you thinking?
- Karl...Copy !req
1085. You told me you'd talk him out
of testifying.Copy !req
1086. Instead, you put on a freak show
with taped demons...Copy !req
1087. and a dead girl
speaking in tongues...Copy !req
1088. and your client testifies that the
archbishop sanctioned the exorcism.Copy !req
1089. We'll be lucky if
the archdiocese isn't named—Copy !req
1090. I had a doctor
who was gonna corroborate.Copy !req
1091. Besides that, Father Moore's
testimony's crucial to his defense.Copy !req
1092. Did you forget the archdiocese
is paying for this defense?Copy !req
1093. The archdiocese isn't on trial.Copy !req
1094. I swore an oath to do
what's best for my client.Copy !req
1095. Spare me the law school pieties,
Bruner.Copy !req
1096. You cashed in your conscience
at the door.Copy !req
1097. - People can change.
- Like James Van Hopper?Copy !req
1098. It's not over.Copy !req
1099. I can put Mr. Rose on the stand...Copy !req
1100. to corroborate Father Moore
about the exorcism.Copy !req
1101. And there are the girls.
Her sister Alice, she saw part of it.Copy !req
1102. They all look like superstitious rubes.
They've got no credibility.Copy !req
1103. Thomas will rip them to pieces.Copy !req
1104. You'll be worse off than you are now,
if that's possible.Copy !req
1105. You're gonna replace me
on this case.Copy !req
1106. You've screwed it up
beyond all repair.Copy !req
1107. But the archdiocese feels
that replacing you now...Copy !req
1108. would only draw more
unnecessary attention to the trial.Copy !req
1109. But just so we're clear, Bruner...Copy !req
1110. if you put that priest
on the stand again, I will fire you.Copy !req
1111. You've been crying.Copy !req
1112. - Dr. Cartwright is dead.
- What?Copy !req
1113. He was killed.
There was an accident. I'm sorry.Copy !req
1114. I know he was your friend.Copy !req
1115. We've lost.Copy !req
1116. Without his testimony, it's over.Copy !req
1117. No.Copy !req
1118. No, no, no, it isn't over. We're telling
Emily's story. That's what matters.Copy !req
1119. - It can't be worth all this.
- Yes, it is worth it.Copy !req
1120. Just let me go back on the stand
and tell the rest of the story.Copy !req
1121. - I can't do that.
- You must!Copy !req
1122. You must.Copy !req
1123. Erin, you once said that you felt
you were on the right path.Copy !req
1124. Don't stray from that path.Copy !req
1125. Here, take this.Copy !req
1126. - What is this?
- Just read it.Copy !req
1127. And then decide
what you want to do.Copy !req
1128. I saw your eyes today in court when
I explained the significance of 3 a.m.Copy !req
1129. It's not going to stop
until Emily's story is told.Copy !req
1130. Are you gonna make a statement?Copy !req
1131. Do you believe it was the devil?Copy !req
1132. Is the defense ready to proceed?Copy !req
1133. Yes, Your Honor. The defense
recalls Father Richard Moore.Copy !req
1134. The witness is reminded
that he is still under oath.Copy !req
1135. - When did you last see Emily alive?
- The night before she died.Copy !req
1136. Her mother, Maria, called me
and said that Emily had asked for me.Copy !req
1137. - Why did she ask to see you?
- To give me this.Copy !req
1138. Did Emily explain to you
the letter's significance?Copy !req
1139. Yes. She said she'd written it the
morning after the failed exorcism...Copy !req
1140. and that it was important
for me to share.Copy !req
1141. Father Moore,
was Emily a good person?Copy !req
1142. I believe that one day
Emily will be recognized as a saint.Copy !req
1143. - So she loved God.
- Yes. She was very devout.Copy !req
1144. Father Moore, if Emily loved God...Copy !req
1145. if she was so good and so devout,
why do you think God...Copy !req
1146. - ... allowed this to happen?
- Objection.Copy !req
1147. What is the relevance
of that question?Copy !req
1148. Father Moore's belief
in this matter is crucial...Copy !req
1149. in establishing his and Emily's
understanding of her condition.Copy !req
1150. And that mutual understanding
is paramount in determining...Copy !req
1151. whether Father Moore was,
in fact, negligent.Copy !req
1152. I'm going to allow it.Copy !req
1153. Your Honor, you're not really gonna
let someone testify...Copy !req
1154. about why God would allow
the death of a young girl?Copy !req
1155. The objection has been overruled.Copy !req
1156. Again, Father Moore:Copy !req
1157. Why did God allow Emily to become
possessed by demons and then die?Copy !req
1158. I can let Emily answer that.Copy !req
1159. "Last night, on Allhallows' Eve...Copy !req
1160. Father Moore tried to cast
six demons from my body.Copy !req
1161. They refused to go.Copy !req
1162. After the attempted exorcism..."Copy !req
1163. I was taken to my room,
and I fell into a deep sleep.Copy !req
1164. I awoke a few hours later,
hearing a voice calling out my name.Copy !req
1165. "Again, I heard a voice
calling my name.Copy !req
1166. It was the Blessed Holy Mother
of God.Copy !req
1167. And when I looked at her...Copy !req
1168. she smiled at me and said:Copy !req
1169. 'Emily, heaven is not blind
to your pain."'Copy !req
1170. She said the Virgin Mary spoke to her
in the middle of a field?Copy !req
1171. - Yes.
- And do you believe her?Copy !req
1172. I believe Emily spoke the truth.Copy !req
1173. Please continue.Copy !req
1174. "I asked the Blessed Mother,
'Why do I suffer like this?"'Copy !req
1175. Why did the demons
not leave me tonight?Copy !req
1176. "She said, 'I am sorry, Emily.Copy !req
1177. The demons are going to stay
where they are.'Copy !req
1178. Then she said,
'You can come with me in peace...Copy !req
1179. free of your bodily form...Copy !req
1180. or you can choose
to continue this.Copy !req
1181. You will suffer greatly.Copy !req
1182. But through you, many will come to
see that the realm of the spirit is real.Copy !req
1183. The choice is yours."'Copy !req
1184. I choose to stay.Copy !req
1185. "In the end,
good will triumph over evil.Copy !req
1186. Through my experience...Copy !req
1187. people will know
that demons are real.Copy !req
1188. People say that God is dead.Copy !req
1189. But how can they think that...Copy !req
1190. if I show them the devil?"Copy !req
1191. Did you see these wounds on both
of Emily's hands and both feet?Copy !req
1192. Yes. Yes, the wounds
lasted for some time.Copy !req
1193. And did you attach any supernatural
significance to these wounds?Copy !req
1194. I believe they were stigmata.Copy !req
1195. By that, you mean
supernatural injuries...Copy !req
1196. that correspond to the crucifixion
wounds of Jesus Christ?Copy !req
1197. Yes.Copy !req
1198. Stigmata are a sign, a mark
indicating one is touched by God.Copy !req
1199. After that night, why do you think
Emily refused another exorcism?Copy !req
1200. I believe she'd accepted her fate.Copy !req
1201. Is there anything else
you'd like to say about Emily?Copy !req
1202. No.Copy !req
1203. The defense rests.Copy !req
1204. Father Moore attaches
divine significance...Copy !req
1205. to the wounds
on Emily's hands and feet.Copy !req
1206. Why?Copy !req
1207. Because he sees them as confirmation
of what he wants to believe.Copy !req
1208. That Emily was a saint,
touched by the hand of God.Copy !req
1209. I'm afraid the truth
is far less inspiring.Copy !req
1210. Because the truth is, by the time
these miraculous wounds appeared...Copy !req
1211. Emily had already shown
a tendency to injure herself...Copy !req
1212. and simply did so again
on one of the barbed-wire fences...Copy !req
1213. surrounding the Rose family farm.Copy !req
1214. Father Moore's beliefs are based on
archaic and irrational superstition.Copy !req
1215. Emily suffered
because she was sick...Copy !req
1216. not because she was a saint.Copy !req
1217. I'm a man of faith.
And I am also a man of facts.Copy !req
1218. And in here,
facts are what must matter.Copy !req
1219. And these are the facts of this case:Copy !req
1220. Emily Rose had epilepsy,
which caused psychosis.Copy !req
1221. And, given time,
medicine would have cured her.Copy !req
1222. But it didn't. Why? Because Father
Richard Moore convinced Emily...Copy !req
1223. that she wasn't ill,
that she didn't need medicine.Copy !req
1224. And in the weeks
leading up to her death...Copy !req
1225. when she was clearly in need
of medical treatment...Copy !req
1226. he failed to have her hospitalized.Copy !req
1227. So...Copy !req
1228. the defense has given us
an extraordinary...Copy !req
1229. creative explanation
for the events that led to this.Copy !req
1230. Ladies and gentlemen,
don't you believe it.Copy !req
1231. Because the fact is, it wasn't the devil
that did this to Emily Rose.Copy !req
1232. It was the defendant.Copy !req
1233. Counselor.Copy !req
1234. Ethan Thomas calls himself
a man of faith.Copy !req
1235. I, on the other hand,
am a woman of doubt.Copy !req
1236. Angels and demons.Copy !req
1237. God and the devil.Copy !req
1238. These things either exist,
or they do not exist.Copy !req
1239. Are we all alone in this life?Copy !req
1240. Or are we not alone?Copy !req
1241. Either thought is astonishing.Copy !req
1242. Do I really believe that this tragedy
is the work of the devil?Copy !req
1243. To be honest, I don't know.Copy !req
1244. But I cannot deny that it's possible.Copy !req
1245. The prosecution
wants you to believe...Copy !req
1246. that Emily's psychotic
epileptic disorder was a fact...Copy !req
1247. because facts leave no room
for reasonable doubt.Copy !req
1248. But this trial isn't about facts.Copy !req
1249. This trial is about possibilities.Copy !req
1250. Is it a fact that Emily
was a hypersensitive...Copy !req
1251. as Dr. Adani suggests?Copy !req
1252. A person who's more likely, by her
very nature, to become possessed?Copy !req
1253. I can't say that, but the question is:Copy !req
1254. Is it possible?Copy !req
1255. Is it a fact that Gambutrol
anesthetized Emily's brain...Copy !req
1256. so that the exorcism ritual
was rendered ineffective?Copy !req
1257. I can't be sure of that.Copy !req
1258. But is it possible?Copy !req
1259. Is it a fact that Emily
was beloved by God?Copy !req
1260. And that after her exorcism,
she chose to suffer till the end...Copy !req
1261. so that we might believe
in a more magical world?Copy !req
1262. A world where the spiritual realm
really exists?Copy !req
1263. I can't say that's a fact.Copy !req
1264. But ask yourself:Copy !req
1265. Is it possible?Copy !req
1266. It's what Emily believed.Copy !req
1267. It's what Father Moore believed.Copy !req
1268. And that sincere belief is what
determined her choices and his.Copy !req
1269. Now, for the most
important question:Copy !req
1270. Is Father Richard Moore guilty...Copy !req
1271. beyond a reasonable doubt,
of negligent homicide?Copy !req
1272. Did he, in fact, neglect
Emily's needs in such a way...Copy !req
1273. that her death
is now on his hands?Copy !req
1274. No! That is not a fact.Copy !req
1275. It is not a fact
that Emily was epileptic.Copy !req
1276. It is not a fact
that she was psychotic.Copy !req
1277. Facts...Copy !req
1278. leave no room for possibilities.Copy !req
1279. The only fact...Copy !req
1280. the only thing I know
beyond a doubt in this case...Copy !req
1281. is that Father Moore
loved Emily with his whole heart.Copy !req
1282. He did everything in his power
to help her.Copy !req
1283. He has risked his very freedom
so we could hear her story.Copy !req
1284. Ladies and gentlemen of the jury...Copy !req
1285. in my job I sometimes
have to defend bad men.Copy !req
1286. Father Richard Moore
is not one of them.Copy !req
1287. Don't send a good man to prison.Copy !req
1288. I'm not asking that you believe
everything that Father Moore believes.Copy !req
1289. I'm simply asking that you believe
in Father Moore.Copy !req
1290. Madam Foreman,
has the jury reached a verdict?Copy !req
1291. We have, Your Honor.Copy !req
1292. Please read the verdict out loud.Copy !req
1293. "In the case of The People
v. Father Richard Moore...Copy !req
1294. we, the jury, find the defendant...Copy !req
1295. guilty of negligent homicide."Copy !req
1296. The court thanks the jury
for its service.Copy !req
1297. Sentencing for this case
will be set for April 3rd.Copy !req
1298. Your Honor, if it pleases the court...Copy !req
1299. Father Moore requested
at the start of trial...Copy !req
1300. that if found guilty,
he would be sentenced immediately.Copy !req
1301. Yes, I recall that.Copy !req
1302. Does the prosecution have any
objection to expedited sentencing?Copy !req
1303. Very well.Copy !req
1304. Father Richard Moore,
do you understand this sentence...Copy !req
1305. - ... which has been found against you?
- Yes, Your Honor.Copy !req
1306. And do you understand
the gravity of this crime?Copy !req
1307. That you may, under the law, be
sentenced to a term of up to 10 years?Copy !req
1308. Yes, I do.Copy !req
1309. Are there any statements
you wish to make...Copy !req
1310. before I impose this sentence?Copy !req
1311. - No, Your Honor.
- Very well.Copy !req
1312. Excuse me, Your Honor...Copy !req
1313. but the jury would like to make
a recommendation...Copy !req
1314. - ... regarding the sentence.
- Objection.Copy !req
1315. Sit down, counselor.Copy !req
1316. It's only a recommendation,
and I would like to hear it.Copy !req
1317. We recommend a sentence
of time served.Copy !req
1318. I'll accept that.Copy !req
1319. You are guilty, Father Moore.Copy !req
1320. And you are free to go.Copy !req
1321. - This court is dismissed.
- All rise.Copy !req
1322. Thank you.Copy !req
1323. Well, you shocked us all.Copy !req
1324. Everyone at the firm sees this
as another victory.Copy !req
1325. The archdiocese is pleased.Copy !req
1326. They feel the trial has raised
public interest in the Church.Copy !req
1327. Have you seen the news?Copy !req
1328. There's our priest,
leaving the courthouse a free man...Copy !req
1329. right next to you.Copy !req
1330. Just like James Van Hopper.Copy !req
1331. All right, I'll say it. I was wrong.Copy !req
1332. But I'm ready to make it right.Copy !req
1333. I'm offering you
a full partnership in the firm.Copy !req
1334. Keep it.Copy !req
1335. Will you be able to return
to your parish?Copy !req
1336. I can't go back.Copy !req
1337. Not now.Copy !req
1338. Once you've looked
into the darkness...Copy !req
1339. I think you carry it with you
for the rest of your life.Copy !req
1340. What about you?Copy !req
1341. I believe you've seen
the darkness too.Copy !req
1342. I don't know.Copy !req
1343. I'm not sure what I've seen.Copy !req
1344. - Who chose the epitaph?
- I did.Copy !req
1345. It's from the second chapter
of Philippians, verse 12.Copy !req
1346. Emily recited it to me
the night before she died.Copy !req
1347. RobbieL811Copy !req