1. I've literally had arguments
with people from my generation
Copy !req
2. who say, you know, the number
one threat facing humanity
Copy !req
3. is the climate crisis.
Copy !req
4. Listen, it's terrifying and
it's a massive problem.
Copy !req
5. But the problem that
exists today, in this hour
Copy !req
6. as the minutes pass,
is nuclear weapons.
Copy !req
7. We don't see it in
the headlines, but the
Copy !req
8. threat of nuclear Armageddon
has never been greater.
Copy !req
9. And we just assume that
everything's okay.
Copy !req
10. Everything is not okay.
Copy !req
11. While our leaders
tell us we need atomic weapons
Copy !req
12. to deter a nuclear attack,
the truth is,
Copy !req
13. they have already
used them against us.
Copy !req
14. It was mass destruction
of our world.
Copy !req
15. And today, new nuclear weapons
are still being built,
Copy !req
16. enriching an elite few.
Copy !req
17. It's not strategy,
it's not logic.
Copy !req
18. It's money and politics.
Copy !req
19. Making the world more
dangerous by the minute.
Copy !req
20. It would take about an hour to
destroy everything humanity
Copy !req
21. has built up over
the millennia.
Copy !req
22. !
Copy !req
23. For over 70 years, our leaders
have told us one thing
Copy !req
24. under the bright lights...
Copy !req
25. The protection of the lives
and property of Americans
Copy !req
26. is the responsibility of
all public officials.
Copy !req
27. I care, we're trying.
Copy !req
28. We have it so well
under control.
Copy !req
29. Help is here and we will not
stop working for you.
Copy !req
30. But for decades, America's
shadow government and its
Copy !req
31. powerful friends have spent
trillions of dollars on an
Copy !req
32. agenda that serves their
interests, not ours.
Copy !req
33. You guys paid for all this.
Copy !req
34. So, when the shit really
hits the fan,
Copy !req
35. we're on our own.
Copy !req
36. This is not science fiction.
Copy !req
37. This is reality in America
right now.
Copy !req
38. The truth is, the rich and
powerful will do
Copy !req
39. whatever it takes to save themselves...
Copy !req
40. While The Rest of Us Die.
Copy !req
41. 10, 9...
Copy !req
42. 8, 7...
Copy !req
43. 6, 5, 4...
Copy !req
44. 3, 2, 1.
Copy !req
45. During the Cold War,
Copy !req
46. America's biggest
nuclear weapons test site
Copy !req
47. was less than 100 miles
downwind of Sin City.
Copy !req
48. It's a large desert area,
Copy !req
49. about 60 miles
north of Las Vegas.
Copy !req
50. In fact, in Las Vegas,
they were a tourist draw.
Copy !req
51. Welcome to the Desert Inn Hotel
in fabulous Las Vegas!
Copy !req
52. The one and only,
Jimmy Durante, in person!
Copy !req
53. I've got an
announcement to make.
Copy !req
54. In case of an atom bomb attack,
everyone is to leave the room
Copy !req
55. and hide under the
slot machines.
Copy !req
56. They haven't been hit since
the joint has been open.
Copy !req
57. You could go to the big
hotels in Vegas and get an
Copy !req
58. atomic cocktail and go and sit
on the roof of your hotel and
Copy !req
59. drink your cocktail
and watch...
Copy !req
60. science and technology, you
know, blossoming on the horizon.
Copy !req
61. The towering cloud of the
atomic age is a symbol of
Copy !req
62. strength, of defense,
of security for
Copy !req
63. freedom loving
people everywhere.
Copy !req
64. The nuclear age began
in July 1945,
Copy !req
65. when the United States
successfully detonated the
Copy !req
66. world's first atomic bomb.
Copy !req
67. It was an event that had a
profound effect on its creators.
Copy !req
68. The following month, the United
States dropped nuclear bombs
Copy !req
69. on the Japanese cities of
Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Copy !req
70. The Hiroshima bomb killed
over 100,000 people.
Copy !req
71. Those bombings were also
technically nuclear tests.
Copy !req
72. The 20-kiloton bomb dropped on
Nagasaki three days after
Copy !req
73. Hiroshima was a
different design.
Copy !req
74. It killed 74,000 more Japanese
and provided the Americans
Copy !req
75. more data on their new
weapon's capabilities.
Copy !req
76. They were only the second
and third nuclear weapons
Copy !req
77. that had ever been
built or detonated.
Copy !req
78. The bombings of Japan were
not simply acts of war.
Copy !req
79. They were also experiments,
conducted by the United States
Copy !req
80. to see what these
weapons would do.
Copy !req
81. In the aftermath of the
Second World War,
Copy !req
82. the United States became
locked in a global arms race
Copy !req
83. with the Soviet Union.
Copy !req
84. Spending trillions of
taxpayer dollars
Copy !req
85. on a vast nuclear arsenal.
Copy !req
86. In the 1950s,
we went nuclear nuts.
Copy !req
87. The arms race develops a
sick logic of its own,
Copy !req
88. where you feel that there's
some kind of advantage that you
Copy !req
89. can gain by having more nuclear
weapons than the other guy.
Copy !req
90. As a result, whereas we
started off the 50s with about
Copy !req
91. 200 nuclear weapons, by the
time John F. Kennedy
Copy !req
92. becomes president in 1960,
there were 20,000.
Copy !req
93. And we just kept racing
bigger, better, more everywhere.
Copy !req
94. This demand for new and
improved nukes
Copy !req
95. enriches a small
corporate elite.
Copy !req
96. An ultra-modern plant outside
Detroit plays host to
Copy !req
97. military representatives of
a dozen NATO nations.
Copy !req
98. Here in two million square feet
of floor space,
Copy !req
99. parallel assembly lines turn
out the Jupiter and
Copy !req
100. the Red Stone missiles.
Copy !req
101. America is truly keeping pace
in the missile age.
Copy !req
102. But before a new nuclear weapon
was integrated into the
Copy !req
103. military arsenal,
it had to be tested.
Copy !req
104. The United States conducted
over a thousand nuclear tests,
Copy !req
105. more than all the other
countries of the world combined.
Copy !req
106. When they went to test
their weapons,
Copy !req
107. they're not gonna test them
next to the people
Copy !req
108. who they care about.
Copy !req
109. Ideally, they're gonna test
them out where, you know,
Copy !req
110. people they don't
care about are.
Copy !req
111. The first location
chosen for testing
Copy !req
112. was the Marshall Islands
Copy !req
113. an American protectorate in
the Central Pacific.
Copy !req
114. And here is Bikini,
Copy !req
115. nearly 4,000 miles from
the United States.
Copy !req
116. A tiny coral atoll destined for
atomic bomb experiments.
Copy !req
117. These first pictures of the
little island show the 165 men,
Copy !req
118. women, and children, as they
prepare for the move
Copy !req
119. to another small island.
Copy !req
120. This is where the term bikini,
the swimsuit, comes from.
Copy !req
121. So, we have these
sort of legacies,
Copy !req
122. even in our vocabulary,
of this weird period of sort of
Copy !req
123. American nuclear culture
and enthusiasm.
Copy !req
124. In front of the palm thatched
community house,
Copy !req
125. an American naval officer,
through an interpreter,
Copy !req
126. discusses plans for
moving the people.
Copy !req
127. The people of Bikini are
a happy people,
Copy !req
128. and they chat gayly with the
Americans as they wait to leave.
Copy !req
129. Modern dentistry brings
only laughter.
Copy !req
130. The Marshall Islanders,
they were told that they were
Copy !req
131. gonna have to evacuate their
islands for a short time,
Copy !req
132. and then be brought back.
Copy !req
133. Instead, these bombs
eliminated their islands.
Copy !req
134. They vaporized their island.
Copy !req
135. They polluted the,
the fishing grounds.
Copy !req
136. But testing weapons so far from
the continental United States
Copy !req
137. was extremely expensive, so
the US government began
Copy !req
138. searching for alternative
sites closer to home.
Copy !req
139. The decision was made to start
testing nuclear weapons
Copy !req
140. in Nevada, and
that began in 1951.
Copy !req
141. Over the next 40 years, roughly
eight hundred underground tests
Copy !req
142. of nuclear weapons will be
conducted inside the US.
Copy !req
143. But it's the above ground tests
at the Nevada Test Site,
Copy !req
144. approximately 100 between
1951 and 1962,
Copy !req
145. that will have the most
devastating and lasting impact.
Copy !req
146. Elaborate fake communities are
built to replicate the impact
Copy !req
147. of a nuclear bomb hitting an
American town.
Copy !req
148. The impact on actual Americans
is not as elaborately planned.
Copy !req
149. And from the end of
World War Two until today,
Copy !req
150. the overwhelming majority
of people killed by
Copy !req
151. American atomic bombs...
Copy !req
152. will be Americans.
Copy !req
153. 2, 1...
Copy !req
154. What the Atomic Energy
Commission knew at this point,
Copy !req
155. is that these tests
would release
Copy !req
156. massive amounts of radiation,
and that that radiation
Copy !req
157. would drift with the wind.
Copy !req
158. And so, the decision was
made to aim these tests.
Copy !req
159. And the way they did that was by
monitoring weather conditions
Copy !req
160. and meteorological conditions
and testing nuclear weapons
Copy !req
161. only when the wind was
blowing east.
Copy !req
162. So, away from Las Vegas and
densely populated California.
Copy !req
163. So, a deliberate engineering
took place.
Copy !req
164. The fact remains, this fallout
wasn't falling on empty land.
Copy !req
165. The Nevada test site is about
100 miles as the crow flies to
Copy !req
166. the south of us, probably even
less than that to the areas
Copy !req
167. where weapons testing
took place.
Copy !req
168. Ian Zabarte is a leading member
of Western bands of the
Copy !req
169. Shoshone Nation of Indians, and
an activist who's on a mission
Copy !req
170. to bring justice to his people
for the horrors that have
Copy !req
171. befallen them when America
declared their sacred land
Copy !req
172. ground zero.
Copy !req
173. So, this is the federally
recognized Duckwater
Copy !req
174. Shoshone Indian Reservation.
Copy !req
175. And there's about 360 tribal
members here.
Copy !req
176. I'm related to just about everybody.
Copy !req
177. We're gonna talk to some
people that were here
Copy !req
178. during the period of
weapons testing.
Copy !req
179. These Shoshone elders
have never before
Copy !req
180. told their
stories on camera.
Copy !req
181. I slept in the house on a...
Copy !req
182. on a couch that was
in the living room.
Copy !req
183. And the living room
faced to the south.
Copy !req
184. And I can remember one morning
being woke before dawn...
Copy !req
185. Everything was just
bright and brilliant.
Copy !req
186. Whatever it was, it was almost
impossible to see,
Copy !req
187. it was so bright.
Copy !req
188. And it was one of the experiments.
Copy !req
189. We were alarmed when
we saw this great,
Copy !req
190. big dust coming from our
southern side.
Copy !req
191. And it was just a great big,
big rolling dust storm, like,
Copy !req
192. coming into Duckwater.
Copy !req
193. And my mom and dad
told us that fallout,
Copy !req
194. that's that atomic bomb
they let off.
Copy !req
195. As I get older, I notice that
several of the family members
Copy !req
196. here in Duckwater have cancer.
Copy !req
197. And so, exposure to fallout...
Copy !req
198. you know, in any form,
the consequences
Copy !req
199. are basically,
parts of your body die.
Copy !req
200. And significant exposure means
more parts of it die,
Copy !req
201. eventually to the point where...
Copy !req
202. the cells can't
reproduce themselves.
Copy !req
203. Or they reproduce in a way
that's mutated and that
Copy !req
204. leads to a cancer.
Copy !req
205. And in places with high
contamination there's a
Copy !req
206. legacy of cancer history that
never would have existed
Copy !req
207. in the absence of nuclear
weapons testing.
Copy !req
208. So, when I returned home...
Copy !req
209. permanently in 1983,
my family was dying.
Copy !req
210. I find my uncle is dying.
Copy !req
211. His throat is falling out
from cancer.
Copy !req
212. And my grandfather,
his skin fell off.
Copy !req
213. And then he died a month later
from the stress,
Copy !req
214. and they said it was...
Copy !req
215. a heart attack.
Copy !req
216. I look around here and I see
cascading effects as a result
Copy !req
217. of radiation exposure and
fallout among my family.
Copy !req
218. When the United States began
testing these weapons,
Copy !req
219. we didn't know what
was going on.
Copy !req
220. The radioactive fallout
beyond several miles from
Copy !req
221. the test site has not been
known to be serious.
Copy !req
222. We must remember that
radiation, it is part of nature.
Copy !req
223. The health of people in these
communities was seen as an
Copy !req
224. acceptable sacrifice by the
Atomic Energy Commission,
Copy !req
225. in order to have a larger
and more sophisticated
Copy !req
226. nuclear weapons arsenal.
Copy !req
227. To fall behind any other
nation in atomic progress
Copy !req
228. is a national risk.
Copy !req
229. And so, when people from the
downwind area went to the AEC,
Copy !req
230. and said, "Why didn't you
warn us?" The Atomic Energy
Copy !req
231. Commission said things like,
"We have to make sacrifices
Copy !req
232. in order to
protect democracy."
Copy !req
233. Yes, the very nature of testing
weapons for natural defence...
Copy !req
234. requires we accept the
possibility of some exposure
Copy !req
235. to additional radiation.
Copy !req
236. But the western Shoshone
sacrificed both their blood and
Copy !req
237. treasure for America's
nuclear industrial complex.
Copy !req
238. The first thing to keep in mind
about the Nevada testing site
Copy !req
239. is that it's actually
legally the property of the
Copy !req
240. Western Shoshone Nation.
Copy !req
241. It was deeded to them in the
1863 Treaty of Ruby Valley,
Copy !req
242. and they have never
actually ceded that land.
Copy !req
243. During the height of
America's bloody civil war,
Copy !req
244. the Shoshone signed one of
the last Indian treaties
Copy !req
245. with the US government.
Copy !req
246. America was weak
during the civil war.
Copy !req
247. It needed alliance
with the Shoshone.
Copy !req
248. We allowed for the
overland stage.
Copy !req
249. We allowed for the telegraph.
We allowed for the railroad.
Copy !req
250. Not what we have today with
nuclear weapons testing.
Copy !req
251. No nation would enter into a
treaty that would end
Copy !req
252. in its ultimate destruction.
Copy !req
253. According to the Treaty
of Ruby Valley,
Copy !req
254. the Western Shoshone lands
stretched for nearly
Copy !req
255. 100,000 square miles
covering much of Nevada and
Copy !req
256. into California,
Idaho, and Utah.
Copy !req
257. But with the advent of the
nuclear age in 1945,
Copy !req
258. the United States began forcing
the tribe off their land
Copy !req
259. creating a vast patchwork of
Copy !req
260. high security military installations.
Copy !req
261. And then I run into
a weapon of war.
Copy !req
262. A fence was put up
around this site.
Copy !req
263. And, the Western Shoshone
were denied access to
Copy !req
264. traditional hunting
and gathering sites...
Copy !req
265. Sites that were spiritually
significant to them.
Copy !req
266. And not only was it
going to be off limits,
Copy !req
267. it was going to be destroyed.
Copy !req
268. This is the violence of colonialism,
Copy !req
269. which is really
fundamental to the...
Copy !req
270. the birth of the nuclear age.
Copy !req
271. The Western bands of the
Shoshone nation of Indians
Copy !req
272. are the most bombed
nation in the world.
Copy !req
273. It was mass destruction
of our world, really.
Copy !req
274. It was just being
destroyed forever.
Copy !req
275. And you can actually
see the scars of this.
Copy !req
276. If you go on and look at
satellite pictures,
Copy !req
277. it looks like the moon.
It's all craters.
Copy !req
278. I'm trying to get back to
where my ancestors are from.
Copy !req
279. And I can't, because...
Copy !req
280. these people have decided to
kill my land and people.
Copy !req
281. What happened to the Shoshone
people has left Ian Zabarte
Copy !req
282. angry at a government that
still occupies what he sees
Copy !req
283. as his people's sacred land.
Copy !req
284. This is Shoshone property!
Get the ... off!
Copy !req
285. Leave!
Copy !req
286. But the Shoshone Nation
were not the only victims
Copy !req
287. of America's
nuclear testing.
Copy !req
288. Trespassing with a badge.
Copy !req
289. Can't even ... ing
prove ownership.
Copy !req
290. Trespassing.
Copy !req
291. All ... ing trespassers.
Copy !req
292. This is Shoshone property!
Get the ... off!
Copy !req
293. Leave!
ing trespassers!
Copy !req
294. You violate the US Constitution!
Copy !req
295. You violate the ... ing
Nevada Constitution!
Copy !req
296. You're ... ing trespassers!
Get the ... out of here!
Copy !req
297. Ian Zabarte shouting at
security officers along a
Copy !req
298. remote Nevada highway,
is evidence of his frustration
Copy !req
299. of being unable to get back
the land taken from
Copy !req
300. his tribe to facilitate
nuclear testing.
Copy !req
301. I don't relish
shaming people.
Copy !req
302. My life would be
easier without the,
Copy !req
303. the stress of having to
watch the abuses.
Copy !req
304. And having to check Americans
and tell them the difference
Copy !req
305. between right and wrong.
Copy !req
306. But he's trying to teach
lessons about right and wrong
Copy !req
307. to a government that, today,
puts average Americans at risk
Copy !req
308. from a nuclear disaster
and was once willing to
Copy !req
309. sacrifice the lives
of US soldiers.
Copy !req
310. All in the name of
nuclear supremacy.
Copy !req
311. The first atomic warfare
maneuvers begin.
Copy !req
312. Selected at random,
Copy !req
313. these men will see the
A-bomb close up.
Copy !req
314. In the 1950s, America's atomic
weapons experiments at the
Copy !req
315. Nevada Test Site also included
testing on human subjects.
Copy !req
316. The US Army wanted to
understand what it would
Copy !req
317. take to fight on a
nuclear battlefield.
Copy !req
318. Sergeant O'Brien?
How about radiation?
Copy !req
319. Do you think there's much
danger from radiation?
Copy !req
320. Well, radiation is the
least of the worries that
Copy !req
321. the men are thinking about.
Copy !req
322. I think most people thought
the radiation was
Copy !req
323. the greatest danger,
didn't they?
Copy !req
324. Where did they learn different?
Copy !req
325. We were prior to our
instructions here.
Copy !req
326. We received a very thorough
briefing before we even
Copy !req
327. came this close to
contact with it.
Copy !req
328. You feel that those
instructions have given you
Copy !req
329. confidence in your abilities?
Copy !req
330. - Very much so.
- To protect yourself?
Copy !req
331. Yes, sir.
Copy !req
332. And so, they began doing
these series of tests.
Copy !req
333. They would dig trenches.
Copy !req
334. The men were told to get
down in the trenches and
Copy !req
335. cover their eyes
with their hands.
Copy !req
336. Soldiers who were on site
for these tests described
Copy !req
337. seeing all of the bones
in their hands...
Copy !req
338. with their eyes closed.
Copy !req
339. While the mushroom cloud
is still being formed,
Copy !req
340. the soldiers pop out of the
ground and run towards it...
Copy !req
341. because they were told it's
important to understand
Copy !req
342. how to fight on a
radioactive battlefield.
Copy !req
343. Many of them described
walking past cages that had
Copy !req
344. test animals wearing various
military uniforms.
Copy !req
345. Model homes that
were constructed.
Copy !req
346. So, these soldiers are
marching through these
Copy !req
347. sort of apocalyptic landscapes...
Copy !req
348. that are extremely radioactive,
you know,
Copy !req
349. directly onto the site where
the actual weapon was detonated.
Copy !req
350. And we now know
without a doubt,
Copy !req
351. you don't fight on a
radioactive battlefield,
Copy !req
352. you die there.
Copy !req
353. Some of these soldiers were
ordered to advance
Copy !req
354. within half a mile
of ground zero.
Copy !req
355. When I see the footage of
young men walking into
Copy !req
356. what is effectively a
suicide mission...
Copy !req
357. it breaks my heart,
it outrages me.
Copy !req
358. But it also underscores that
there are some leaders in the
Copy !req
359. American government who will
violate the sacred compact
Copy !req
360. they have with our American
men and women in uniform.
Copy !req
361. You're not supposed to send
them on suicide missions
Copy !req
362. unless there's a
higher calling.
Copy !req
363. And what higher calling was
there in sending 19-year-old
Copy !req
364. and 20-year-old soldiers
trudging into a nuke blast?
Copy !req
365. It's unconscionable.
Copy !req
366. And a lot of these folks
developed cancers and
Copy !req
367. other problems
over the time.
Copy !req
368. And when some of them went to
the Veterans Administration,
Copy !req
369. in order to get health care,
they were told that leukemia
Copy !req
370. wasn't covered under
their VA benefits.
Copy !req
371. It's not just that that
exposure and testing happens,
Copy !req
372. but every single time, American
veterans have to fight for
Copy !req
373. recognition that it happened.
Copy !req
374. They have to fight for health
care support after it happened.
Copy !req
375. And they have to claw and
battle for compensation.
Copy !req
376. So, a number of these men
who were still very young,
Copy !req
377. who had young families, and
were receiving death sentences,
Copy !req
378. essentially,
from their doctors,
Copy !req
379. a number of them contacted their
elected officials and said,
Copy !req
380. "I need help getting
medical care."
Copy !req
381. And these gentlemen who
became known as the
Copy !req
382. atomic vets, really
galvanized public concern.
Copy !req
383. As many as 400,000 American
servicemen may have been
Copy !req
384. exposed to radiation from
nuclear weapons testing.
Copy !req
385. And they helped people who,
you know, ordinary people.
Copy !req
386. Housewives, Indigenous families.
Copy !req
387. People who had been pointing to
health problems they believed
Copy !req
388. were connected to
radiation exposure.
Copy !req
389. In 1990, the government finally
passed the Radiation Exposure
Copy !req
390. Compensation Act,
granting financial payouts
Copy !req
391. of between 50 and $100,000.
Copy !req
392. Anyone who's gone through a
bout with cancer can tell you,
Copy !req
393. if you're uninsured, $50,000
doesn't cover a whole lot of
Copy !req
394. chemotherapy, unfortunately,
nor does it actually make up
Copy !req
395. for the loss of a family member.
Copy !req
396. Over 38,000 total claims
have been approved.
Copy !req
397. And around $2.5 billion has
been paid out in compensation.
Copy !req
398. But over 13,000 applicants have
had their claims denied,
Copy !req
399. including many members of
the Shoshone Nation.
Copy !req
400. There were a lot of people
like my husband who...
Copy !req
401. was an engineer.
And, they would
Copy !req
402. take all the information
from the experiments.
Copy !req
403. So, they'd go into the test
area soon after the experiment.
Copy !req
404. He had died of cancer.
Copy !req
405. He drank a little bit after
that, that experiment,
Copy !req
406. and they said that that was
probably a cancer that
Copy !req
407. was caused by the alcohol.
Copy !req
408. So, we didn't get any
compensation at all.
Copy !req
409. And it's not only the Shoshone
Copy !req
410. who are struggling to
get compensation.
Copy !req
411. The Marshall Islanders are
still denied medical treatment
Copy !req
412. for their conditions or
payments for their conditions.
Copy !req
413. It is a constant fight.
Copy !req
414. Rough guess, hundreds of
thousands of people...
Copy !req
415. in the United States and
our possessions,
Copy !req
416. have died in the production, testing,
Copy !req
417. and maintenance of our
nuclear weapons arsenal.
Copy !req
418. They're dying still.
Copy !req
419. And even today, we are all at
risk from new and potentially
Copy !req
420. deadly nuclear threats that
are kept hidden from us.
Copy !req
421. Most of the public,
most politicians...
Copy !req
422. believe that nuclear weapons
are safe and secure.
Copy !req
423. And that the day-to-day
operations are reliable.
Copy !req
424. That is not true.
Copy !req
425. I, John Fitzgerald Kennedy,
do solemnly swear
Copy !req
426. I will faithfully
execute the office
Copy !req
427. of President of the
United States.
Copy !req
428. - So help you God.
- So help me God.
Copy !req
429. January 20th, 1961.
Copy !req
430. President Kennedy takes
the oath of office.
Copy !req
431. Three days later, a nuclear
armed B-52 bomber begins
Copy !req
432. a routine flight over
North Carolina.
Copy !req
433. They had some engine
trouble and, actually,
Copy !req
434. part of the bomber exploded.
Copy !req
435. In this particular case, it was
carrying two extremely large
Copy !req
436. thermonuclear weapons,
two hydrogen bombs.
Copy !req
437. Came right out of the fuselage.
Copy !req
438. The hydrogen bomb is
basically like bringing
Copy !req
439. a piece of the
sun down on earth.
Copy !req
440. Now, there are safety devices
on all nuclear weapons
Copy !req
441. precisely intended to stop them
from going off,
Copy !req
442. unless they're supposed to.
Copy !req
443. And in the case of one of
these nuclear weapons,
Copy !req
444. the parachute deployed,
it floated safely to Earth,
Copy !req
445. and it was recovered.
Copy !req
446. The other one
wasn't so lucky.
Copy !req
447. The parachute didn't deploy.
Copy !req
448. And the signal to the bomb
to fire was actually given.
Copy !req
449. So, the bomb should
have exploded.
Copy !req
450. There was one safety feature,
Copy !req
451. apparently a low voltage
switch, that held.
Copy !req
452. We were saved by a
tiny microcircuit.
Copy !req
453. A switch, really.
Copy !req
454. If it had gone off, we would
have lost about
Copy !req
455. half a North Carolina.
Copy !req
456. When a nuclear weapon
is stolen, dropped,
Copy !req
457. somehow damaged,
it's called a broken arrow.
Copy !req
458. Basically, meaning that the
weapon is no longer
Copy !req
459. in the custody of who it's
supposed to be in,
Copy !req
460. or that it won't function
as intended.
Copy !req
461. And over the course of the
nuclear era in the US,
Copy !req
462. there have been dozens of
broken arrow incidents.
Copy !req
463. In addition to Broken
Arrows, there have been a
Copy !req
464. terrifying number of
white-knuckle close calls.
Copy !req
465. One of the most significant was
in June 3rd, 1980,
Copy !req
466. when the NORAD board...
Copy !req
467. lit up with a ballistic
missile attack
Copy !req
468. from the Soviet Union.
Copy !req
469. So, National Security
Advisor Brzezinski
Copy !req
470. was woken up in the
middle of the night.
Copy !req
471. And he was told by the
military assistant,
Copy !req
472. "We've detected 220 incoming
ICBMs from the Soviet Union."
Copy !req
473. And he decided to go back to
the military aid, and said,
Copy !req
474. "Are you sure?" And the
military aid checked and
Copy !req
475. came back and said, "No,
we've made a mistake."
Copy !req
476. "It's not 220."
Copy !req
477. "It's 2,200."
Copy !req
478. Brzezinski thought this was it.
Copy !req
479. He looked over at his wife, sleeping,
Copy !req
480. and decided not to wake her
because in thirty minutes,
Copy !req
481. we'd all be dead.
Copy !req
482. And Brzezinski says
he was very close
Copy !req
483. to recommending retaliation.
Copy !req
484. Fortunately, there was
a third phone call.
Copy !req
485. "It's a mistake.
We're standing down."
Copy !req
486. NORAD did not detect any
incoming nuclear weapons.
Copy !req
487. What happened is a
computer chip failed,
Copy !req
488. and somehow triggered a warning
that actually didn't exist.
Copy !req
489. Everything was perfectly fine.
Copy !req
490. The computer chip
apparently cost 46 cents.
Copy !req
491. A computer chip almost caused
World War Three.
Copy !req
492. Now, one might be tempted to
say this was a one off,
Copy !req
493. but in fact it wasn't.
Copy !req
494. A similar computer chip
failed 3 days later,
Copy !req
495. creating another warning of
incoming nuclear weapons
Copy !req
496. that actually didn't exist.
Copy !req
497. There have been dozens of very
significant false alarms.
Copy !req
498. Training tapes being inserted
into computers simulating a
Copy !req
499. nuclear attack, and nobody knew
it was just a training exercise.
Copy !req
500. Flocks of geese mistaken
for a missile flight.
Copy !req
501. A rising moon over Norway
mistaken for bomber launch.
Copy !req
502. But false alarms involving
nuclear weapons
Copy !req
503. are not just a Cold War phenomena.
Copy !req
504. A false emergency alert about
a ballistic missile threat
Copy !req
505. had people
running for cover.
Copy !req
506. In 2018, all the
residents of Hawaii got
Copy !req
507. emergency alert systems
on their phone.
Copy !req
508. "Ballistic missile attack,
seek cover.
Copy !req
509. This is not a drill."
Copy !req
510. And there was reason to
believe it was true.
Copy !req
511. Rocket Man should have been
handled a long time ago.
Copy !req
512. People thought this was it,
cause tensions had been high
Copy !req
513. between Donald Trump
and Kim Jong Un,
Copy !req
514. the dictator of North Korea,
with talk of fire and fury.
Copy !req
515. People are freaking out and,
you know,
Copy !req
516. as well they should be.
Copy !req
517. Imagine just picking up your
cell phone and seeing that the
Copy !req
518. government is telling you that
you're about to be met with
Copy !req
519. nuclear Armageddon.
Copy !req
520. And so, people called family
members in the mainland
Copy !req
521. to say goodbye.
Copy !req
522. I just want you to know
that I love you guys.
Copy !req
523. You know, they took shelter
anywhere they could think of.
Copy !req
524. People even took the covers
off of manholes,
Copy !req
525. so that they could put their
children in the storm drains.
Copy !req
526. And that maybe they would be
protected there from
Copy !req
527. an incoming
ballistic missile.
Copy !req
528. And for 38 terrifying minutes,
Copy !req
529. people thought this was
the end of their lives.
Copy !req
530. Maybe the,
the end of the world,
Copy !req
531. before it was disclosed that
this was a mistake.
Copy !req
532. So, what went wrong?
Copy !req
533. An employee at the Hawaii
Emergency Management Agency
Copy !req
534. accidentally sent out a real
alert during a drill.
Copy !req
535. But if Hawaii had been connected
to the national network,
Copy !req
536. and it was a national alert,
Copy !req
537. the entire country would have
put been put into this panic
Copy !req
538. with no way of knowing
whether it was real or not.
Copy !req
539. The point of all of
these false alarms,
Copy !req
540. is once you get to
the president,
Copy !req
541. how does the president know
that it's a false alarm?
Copy !req
542. The president would have
15 minutes or less,
Copy !req
543. to make a decision about
whether or not to respond.
Copy !req
544. How do we know that during
that time, any mistake, any,
Copy !req
545. any problem, any glitch in the
computer system would be
Copy !req
546. resolved, and that someone
would be able to get to the
Copy !req
547. president and say,
"Uh, wait a minute, um,
Copy !req
548. it's not 2,200 incoming
nuclear weapons.
Copy !req
549. It's actually a faulty
computer chip. My bad.
Copy !req
550. Sorry, we woke you"?
Copy !req
551. It's a bomb!
Duck and cover!
Copy !req
552. But while Cold War fears
led to irrational behavior,
Copy !req
553. they've been replaced by a
complacency that may prove
Copy !req
554. to be even more dangerous.
Copy !req
555. The Bulletin of Atomic
Scientists say that we're
Copy !req
556. closer to the use of nuclear
weapons now than
Copy !req
557. we were during the Cold War.
Copy !req
558. November 2008.
Copy !req
559. The world watches in stunned
horror as terrorists carry out
Copy !req
560. a series of coordinated attacks
in Mumbai, India.
Copy !req
561. The November attacks
killed 164 people,
Copy !req
562. stirring fear that India
and Pakistan,
Copy !req
563. both with nuclear arms,
could slide toward war.
Copy !req
564. The attacks were the work of
an Islamist militant group
Copy !req
565. based in Pakistan.
Copy !req
566. The terrorist attack was
designed to kill large numbers
Copy !req
567. of people and provoke India
into taking military action
Copy !req
568. against Pakistan, in order to
trigger a larger war.
Copy !req
569. The Bulletin of Atomic
Scientists say that
Copy !req
570. we're closer to the use of
nuclear weapons now
Copy !req
571. than we were during
the Cold War.
Copy !req
572. The Cold War, in some ways,
provided a kind of stability.
Copy !req
573. It was the US and
the Soviet Union.
Copy !req
574. Today, there are more parties,
more places for
Copy !req
575. miscalculations, more places
about concern.
Copy !req
576. There are over 13,000 nuclear
weapons in the world today.
Copy !req
577. While over 90% belong to the
United States and Russia,
Copy !req
578. well over a thousand are
in other countries.
Copy !req
579. These include North Korea,
China, India and Pakistan.
Copy !req
580. And it's India and Pakistan
where experts believe
Copy !req
581. the next nuclear war
might break out.
Copy !req
582. These are captured
Pakistani raiders.
Copy !req
583. This is a sample of their
handywork at Batamaloo,
Copy !req
584. near Srinagar.
Copy !req
585. India and Pakistan have
fought 4 wars or conflicts
Copy !req
586. since independence.
Copy !req
587. There's constant tension
between the two sides.
Copy !req
588. What's changed since 1998,
is that both sides
Copy !req
589. are now building
nuclear arsenals.
Copy !req
590. And both of their arsenals
were born out of a bizarre
Copy !req
591. American Cold War program
called Atoms for Peace.
Copy !req
592. If a danger exists
in the world,
Copy !req
593. it is a danger shared by all.
Copy !req
594. The Atoms for Peace program
was kind of a demented,
Copy !req
595. utopian view of what nukes
could be without recognizing
Copy !req
596. the unfortunate late-stage
reality that we face today.
Copy !req
597. Information about the
beneficial uses of atomic
Copy !req
598. energy knows no
national boundaries.
Copy !req
599. The peaceful atom is
here and now,
Copy !req
600. to serve what President
Eisenhower has termed
Copy !req
601. the needs rather than
the fears of mankind.
Copy !req
602. Under the program, the United
States sent nuclear technology
Copy !req
603. to countries like the Congo and
Iraq to for use developing
Copy !req
604. cheap, renewable energy,
as long as they promised
Copy !req
605. not to use it for the
development of atomic weapons.
Copy !req
606. The Atoms for Peace program was
maybe the ultimate weapons
Copy !req
607. proliferation program
in history.
Copy !req
608. Instead of sending AK 47s
or sending fighter jets,
Copy !req
609. we sent the capacity to create
nuclear weapons.
Copy !req
610. And thanks in part to
US technology,
Copy !req
611. India successfully detonated
its first nuclear bomb in 1974.
Copy !req
612. With Pakistan following in 1998.
Copy !req
613. Pakistan has said that if it
fears that it's going to lose a
Copy !req
614. conventional war with India,
it's gonna nuke India.
Copy !req
615. And India said if they nuke
us, we're gonna nuke em back.
Copy !req
616. India and Pakistan
both have about
Copy !req
617. 150 nuclear weapons, each.
Copy !req
618. Just a hundred nuclear
weapons used on the largely
Copy !req
619. wooden urban course
of South Asia...
Copy !req
620. would put enough smoke and
particulates into the
Copy !req
621. atmosphere that would cover
the Earth in a shroud.
Copy !req
622. That would last two
or three years,
Copy !req
623. and you're gonna kill 40% of
the food crops in the world,
Copy !req
624. unleashing a famine
that would kill about
Copy !req
625. a billion to two
billion people.
Copy !req
626. That is a civilization
ending event.
Copy !req
627. And it's not only warring
nations who may be able to
Copy !req
628. trigger a nuclear conflict.
Copy !req
629. Cyber-attacks have already
happened on pipelines.
Copy !req
630. They've happened
on the Pentagon.
Copy !req
631. They've happened on
Fortune 500 companies.
Copy !req
632. Hackers have been able to
get almost everywhere into
Copy !req
633. global computer systems.
Copy !req
634. Nuclear weapons are not
unique to this.
Copy !req
635. I can tell you right now,
there are definitely Chinese or
Copy !req
636. Russian spies who've gotten
access to the power grids in
Copy !req
637. the United States and know
how to take them out
Copy !req
638. in the event that they go
to war with the US.
Copy !req
639. When it comes to
nuclear weapons,
Copy !req
640. they're also not immune...
Copy !req
641. Everything could be hacked.
Copy !req
642. But cyber threats are more
than the hacking of systems.
Copy !req
643. They also involve
misinformation campaigns
Copy !req
644. that could cascade into a
deadly confrontation.
Copy !req
645. April 23rd, 2013.
Copy !req
646. A tweet from the Associated
Press's twitter account
Copy !req
647. sends the stock
market into free fall.
Copy !req
648. The tweet was quickly deleted,
but it shows what's possible.
Copy !req
649. I mean, the technology
vulnerabilities are
Copy !req
650. pretty well documented
at this point.
Copy !req
651. So, it's not beyond the realm
of possibility that hackers
Copy !req
652. could get into a military
Twitter account.
Copy !req
653. Or even a news organization and
report false information that
Copy !req
654. would necessitate a response
from an adversary that could
Copy !req
655. create a real-life
war games scenario.
Copy !req
656. It'd be one thing if we had
nuclear war because
Copy !req
657. we and the Russians or
the Chinese just like
Copy !req
658. couldn't stop
ourselves from it.
Copy !req
659. That would be a
terrible tragedy.
Copy !req
660. But to do it because
somebody is, you know,
Copy !req
661. playing with Twitter accounts?
Copy !req
662. It's impossible to reckon with
how tragic that would be.
Copy !req
663. While our leaders tell us
these nu clearweapons are
Copy !req
664. essential for national
security, the truth is
Copy !req
665. they want them for
another reason.
Copy !req
666. You can make a lot of money,
making nuclear weapons.
Copy !req
667. That's why we still
have these weapons.
Copy !req
668. It's not strategy,
it's not logic.
Copy !req
669. It's all because of money.
Copy !req
670. Today, the Cold War has
disappeared but
Copy !req
671. thousands of those
weapons have not.
Copy !req
672. In a strange turn of history,
the threat of global nuclear war
Copy !req
673. has gone down, but the risk of a
nuclear attack has gone up.
Copy !req
674. April 5th, 2009.
Copy !req
675. A recently elected Barack
Obama makes his first major
Copy !req
676. foreign policy speech in the
Czech Republic.
Copy !req
677. I state clearly and with
conviction America's commitment
Copy !req
678. to seek the peace and
security of a world
Copy !req
679. without nuclear weapons.
Copy !req
680. And then in the process of
trying to get to that goal,
Copy !req
681. he starts to talk to the
Russians about
Copy !req
682. arms control agreements.
Copy !req
683. Today is an
important milestone
Copy !req
684. for nuclear security and nonproliferation.
Copy !req
685. And for US, Russian relations.
Copy !req
686. And the Republicans in Congress
"We have a price for
Copy !req
687. agreeing to, to arms control
with Russia".
Copy !req
688. That price was for President
Obama to agree to modernize the
Copy !req
689. nuclear submarines, bombers and
intercontinental ballistic
Copy !req
690. missiles that make up
the US nuclear triad.
Copy !req
691. All these missiles, bombers
and subs that we had built in
Copy !req
692. the Reagan buildup of the
1980s are coming to the
Copy !req
693. end of their
operational life.
Copy !req
694. And so, the Republicans and the
nuclear industrial complex
Copy !req
695. wanted to get new
systems online.
Copy !req
696. And so, the agreement
Obama made,
Copy !req
697. is now a $1.7 trillion
modernization program,
Copy !req
698. to literally, modernize all
parts of the nuclear triad.
Copy !req
699. To be sure, we do need to
modernize some of these weapons.
Copy !req
700. But there's a big difference
between a sort of fixer upper
Copy !req
701. that's gonna keep these nukes
around for another few decades
Copy !req
702. and a total overhaul of the
system. And unfortunately,
Copy !req
703. we're paying for the latter
Copy !req
704. under the rhetoric
of the former.
Copy !req
705. And that's gonna give us a
whole new generation of subs,
Copy !req
706. bombers, and missiles
that are gonna last
Copy !req
707. until the end
of this century.
Copy !req
708. We're locking ourselves into
this Cold War arsenal
Copy !req
709. for another century.
Copy !req
710. Now we're coming off of a
pandemic where the economy is
Copy !req
711. having problems, where there
are lots of health issues...
Copy !req
712. and we're talking about $1.7
trillion for nuclear weapons?
Copy !req
713. If you had $1.7 trillion
today to spend,
Copy !req
714. and you could spend it on
something to improve the lives
Copy !req
715. of Americans, where would
nuclear weapons spending
Copy !req
716. be on that list?
Copy !req
717. My guess is it's not
anywhere near that list.
Copy !req
718. Instead, this new arsenal means
multi-billion-dollar contracts
Copy !req
719. for some of the biggest
weapons manufacturers
Copy !req
720. in the United States.
Copy !req
721. The entire nuclear procurement
process is deeply corrupt.
Copy !req
722. From the contractors who
generate the requirements
Copy !req
723. inside the Pentagon, to the
politicians in Congress who
Copy !req
724. accept contributions from these
same contractors.
Copy !req
725. Doveryai, no proveryai.
Copy !req
726. Trust, but verify.
Copy !req
727. You repeat that at
every meeting.
Copy !req
728. The end of the Cold War brought
an end to the arms race
Copy !req
729. with the Soviet Union.
Copy !req
730. But while the ideological
necessity for our
Copy !req
731. nuclear arsenal
quickly disappeared,
Copy !req
732. the weapons, themselves,
did not...
Copy !req
733. as defense contractors fought
to maintain the huge profits
Copy !req
734. they made building them.
Copy !req
735. There are two ways
that this works.
Copy !req
736. One is just direct campaign contributions.
Copy !req
737. So, if you look at the
Democrat, Jim Cooper,
Copy !req
738. is the chairman of the
strategic subcommittee of the
Copy !req
739. House Armed Services Committee,
a very good man.
Copy !req
740. But some of his
largest contributors
Copy !req
741. are nuclear contractors. So,
he's directly taking money
Copy !req
742. from nuclear contractors
to keep him in office.
Copy !req
743. The second conflict
of interest is jobs.
Copy !req
744. The defense contractors make
sure that there is someone in
Copy !req
745. every congressional district,
some subcomponent,
Copy !req
746. some manufacturing,
Copy !req
747. something in every
congressional district...
Copy !req
748. that actually is part of
that weapon system.
Copy !req
749. All of us, I think have a responsibility,
Copy !req
750. to insist that the politicians
who are overseeing our nuclear
Copy !req
751. weapons not be tempted by
financial or career
Copy !req
752. considerations when they're
making the decisions,
Copy !req
753. cause these issues about
the life of our planet,
Copy !req
754. about the risks Americans and
the world are exposed to by
Copy !req
755. these nuclear weapons, they're
decided by politics and money.
Copy !req
756. As long as these weapons
exist, we're always
Copy !req
757. just minutes away from
nuclear Armageddon.
Copy !req
758. It would take about an hour
to destroy everything
Copy !req
759. humanity has built up
over the millennia.
Copy !req
760. And so, really, the only way to
kind of backpedal out of this
Copy !req
761. incredible state of national
and global precarity,
Copy !req
762. is to disarm these weapons.
Copy !req
763. The more we're able to see
that nuclear weapons are
Copy !req
764. the problem, that they're
our ultimate threat,
Copy !req
765. not our ultimate security,
Copy !req
766. the more the public
will start to think that
Copy !req
767. we have to have
policies to reduce the risks
Copy !req
768. associated with these
weapons and, eventually,
Copy !req
769. eliminate them altogether.
Copy !req