1. We are exposed to toxic
chemicals all day, every day.
Copy !req
2. They're in the air, the water,
and in our bloodstream.
Copy !req
3. They're inescapable.
Copy !req
4. For decades, companies have
put the health of their
Copy !req
5. bottom line,
above the health of citizens.
Copy !req
6. You don't see a concern
for the public.
Copy !req
7. You only see them talk about
a concern for profit.
Copy !req
8. Farm trials with Roundup made
up to 12 more bushels an acre.
Copy !req
9. while censoring
and harassing
Copy !req
10. anybody who gets
in their way.
Copy !req
11. We don't want your toxic...
Copy !req
12. The public demands action
to stem the toxic tide.
Copy !req
13. Your heart is black,
you can have your oil back.
Copy !req
14. The founding of the EPA came
about because the nation
Copy !req
15. realized that there
wasn't anyone
Copy !req
16. protecting the environment.
Copy !req
17. But its secret history
reveals how the
Copy !req
18. Environmental Protection
Agency became more about
Copy !req
19. the protection
of big business.
Copy !req
20. It is astonishing how
closely the EPA works
Copy !req
21. to protect the interests of
these companies.
Copy !req
22. For over 70 years, our leaders
have told us one thing
Copy !req
23. under the bright lights...
Copy !req
24. The protection of the lives
and property of Americans
Copy !req
25. is the responsibility of
all public officials.
Copy !req
26. I care, we're trying.
Copy !req
27. We have it so well
under control.
Copy !req
28. Help is here and we will not
stop working for you.
Copy !req
29. But for decades, America's
shadow government and
Copy !req
30. its powerful friends have
spent trillions of dollars
Copy !req
31. on an agenda that serves
their interests, not ours.
Copy !req
32. You guys paid for all this.
Copy !req
33. So, when the shit
really hits the fan,
Copy !req
34. we're on our own.
Copy !req
35. This is not science fiction.
Copy !req
36. This is reality in
America right now.
Copy !req
37. The truth is, the rich and
powerful will do
Copy !req
38. whatever it takes to
save themselves...
Copy !req
39. While The Rest of Us Die.
Copy !req
40. April 20th, 2010.
Copy !req
41. In the Gulf of Mexico,
a fireball lights up
Copy !req
42. the night sky, visible
from 40 miles away.
Copy !req
43. An explosion has ripped apart
the Deepwater Horizon,
Copy !req
44. a massive oil rig in the Gulf.
Copy !req
45. First responders begin battling
the blaze and evacuating crew.
Copy !req
46. But eleven rig workers
are lost at sea.
Copy !req
47. As the oil inferno burns
on into the next day,
Copy !req
48. a man identifying himself as
a BP official reports
Copy !req
49. everything is under control.
Copy !req
50. It would turn out to be
the largest marine
Copy !req
51. oil spill in history.
Copy !req
52. You have information now that
this, this rig has gone under?
Copy !req
53. Uh it has gone
under the surface.
Copy !req
54. At about 10:21 this morning.
Copy !req
55. We've got...
Copy !req
56. the potential 336,000
gallons of crude oil per day
Copy !req
57. coming out of that well.
Copy !req
58. After two days,
the Deepwater Horizon sinks,
Copy !req
59. rupturing its connection
at the sea floor.
Copy !req
60. The spill grows.
Copy !req
61. It's now a blob the size
of Delaware and
Copy !req
62. Rhode Island, combined.
Copy !req
63. The nation watches in horror on
live TV as millions of gallons
Copy !req
64. of crude oil spew
into the Gulf
Copy !req
65. threatening hundreds of
thousands of jobs and
Copy !req
66. an entire marine ecosystem.
Copy !req
67. What made Deepwater Horizon so
unique was the way that it made
Copy !req
68. so painfully clear the moral
hazard that these companies
Copy !req
69. took on, that they were
extracting the wealth and
Copy !req
70. the fossil fuels.
Copy !req
71. And yet,
if anything went wrong,
Copy !req
72. it was going to be the US
government and the US taxpayer
Copy !req
73. that stepped in to try to solve
the catastrophe afterwards.
Copy !req
74. Frustration over the spill has
been simmering for weeks,
Copy !req
75. even in the Oval Office.
Copy !req
76. We learned today that in the
first days of this crisis,
Copy !req
77. an angry President Obama
snapped at a meeting,
Copy !req
78. Plug the damn hole.
Copy !req
79. It takes 87 days before
the Deepwater well
Copy !req
80. is finally capped.
Copy !req
81. By that time, more than
200 million gallons of oil
Copy !req
82. have spilled into the sea.
Copy !req
83. BP, your heart is black!
You can have your oil back!
Copy !req
84. BP is eventually forced to pay
more than $20 billion
Copy !req
85. in damages to the
families of the dead,
Copy !req
86. and to clean up the Gulf.
Copy !req
87. That settlement shifts blame
away from the US government
Copy !req
88. department responsible for
keeping this from
Copy !req
89. ever happening: The
Department of Interior and
Copy !req
90. its Minerals
Management Service.
Copy !req
91. Rather than checking out the
rig independently,
Copy !req
92. they simply took BP and its
partners at their word
Copy !req
93. that the project was safe.
Copy !req
94. But for the Interior Department,
Copy !req
95. being in the pocket of
companies like BP and helping
Copy !req
96. them extract oil and gas isn't
the image it likes to project.
Copy !req
97. - Mm, it's pretty out here.
- Sure is.
Copy !req
98. We're lucky, Candy.
Not only us,
Copy !req
99. but millions of other folks
all over the country.
Copy !req
100. Able to enjoy the forest,
trees, water.
Copy !req
101. In the eyes of the public,
the Interior Department is
Copy !req
102. a folksy bureaucracy
responsible for conserving
Copy !req
103. forest land and running
national parks.
Copy !req
104. Smokey!
Copy !req
105. While most Americans think of
the Department of the Interior
Copy !req
106. as park rangers and
Smokey the Bear hats,
Copy !req
107. it is really the Mineral
Management Service that
Copy !req
108. is in many ways the heart
of that department.
Copy !req
109. It is a little-known agency
with a far outsized impact
Copy !req
110. on our daily life.
Copy !req
111. It is the agency in charge of
helping industry maximize the
Copy !req
112. wealth and extraction of
fossil fuels and minerals
Copy !req
113. from across the
nation's public lands.
Copy !req
114. !
Copy !req
115. The Department of Interior's
role has been
Copy !req
116. quite explicitly to...
Copy !req
117. make the resources of the
United States available
Copy !req
118. to big business.
Copy !req
119. The Department of Interior
has opened forests to
Copy !req
120. lumbering interests,
and public lands
Copy !req
121. to mining and drilling.
Copy !req
122. Yet, we, the taxpayers,
lose money in allowing
Copy !req
123. these corporate interests to
have our resources.
Copy !req
124. But this goes back to the
founding of the country.
Copy !req
125. In 1776, the United States was
just 13 eastern colonies.
Copy !req
126. But from the very first days
of independence,
Copy !req
127. each colony had its eyes set
on westward expansion.
Copy !req
128. And they all have these western
land claims that extend
Copy !req
129. as far as they can imagine.
Copy !req
130. America's land claims
include vast swaths of land
Copy !req
131. inhabited by people who'd
been there for millennia.
Copy !req
132. But none of that mattered.
Copy !req
133. In the eyes of the
federal government,
Copy !req
134. all that territory represented
a virtually endless source of
Copy !req
135. natural resources,
ripe for exploitation.
Copy !req
136. A series of wars and broken
treaties keep pushing the
Copy !req
137. country's borders outward.
Copy !req
138. There's the,
the Louisiana Purchase.
Copy !req
139. That more than doubles
the size of the US.
Copy !req
140. Then, the Mexican American War.
Copy !req
141. Texas, New Mexico, Arizona,
Copy !req
142. Nevada, Utah, California,
Copy !req
143. all taken from Mexico by force.
Copy !req
144. A big part of the story of the
expansion of the United States
Copy !req
145. has always been the rush
for natural resources.
Copy !req
146. It's the rush for new forms of
energy and land, for lumber.
Copy !req
147. And this has been
a key part of
Copy !req
148. the Department
of the Interior's
Copy !req
149. mission since the earliest days
of the department.
Copy !req
150. Today the job of building
this nation geographically
Copy !req
151. is completed.
Copy !req
152. There are no new frontiers
within our borders.
Copy !req
153. To what new horizons
can we look now?
Copy !req
154. As the 20th Century dawns,
the US government expands
Copy !req
155. its push for natural
resources around the world
Copy !req
156. all with the help of the
Department of the Interior.
Copy !req
157. Guam, Puerto Rico
are acquired in 1898.
Copy !req
158. That's the point where a kind
of formal imperial project
Copy !req
159. gives way to informal empire.
Copy !req
160. US corporations go abroad,
but the US doesn't seek to
Copy !req
161. establish dominion
over new places.
Copy !req
162. It realizes that financial
control, military control,
Copy !req
163. diplomatic control can be
exercised without
Copy !req
164. the formal trappings
of possession.
Copy !req
165. And this desire to control the
resources of other countries
Copy !req
166. goes into overdrive when the
Cold War competition with
Copy !req
167. the Soviet Union for global
supremacy becomes
Copy !req
168. a national obsession.
Copy !req
169. So much of the Cold War was
really a battle for natural
Copy !req
170. resources and fossil fuels
around the world.
Copy !req
171. And while spy thrillers play
up the CIA's role in
Copy !req
172. battling communism, few
realize the shadowy role
Copy !req
173. the Department of the
Interior plays in this
Copy !req
174. planetary game of thrones.
Copy !req
175. You would often see engineers
and scientists from the
Copy !req
176. Department of the Interior,
helping to identify the targets
Copy !req
177. for diplomatic interventions,
for covert actions,
Copy !req
178. for the desire to
bring in the CIA.
Copy !req
179. One of those targets is Iran.
Copy !req
180. The Shah who had fled to Rome,
comes home.
Copy !req
181. After its elected government
nationalizes its lucrative
Copy !req
182. western-controlled oil
industry in 1953,
Copy !req
183. the CIA works behind the
scenes to overthrow it.
Copy !req
184. Iranian oil may again
flow westward.
Copy !req
185. The American hunger for
oil in the 50s and 60s
Copy !req
186. was unparalleled
in world history.
Copy !req
187. This was a moment when the
US desperately needed
Copy !req
188. more oil wherever it
could be found.
Copy !req
189. In its crude state, just as it
comes out of the ground,
Copy !req
190. oil is a useless mixture of
very useful substances.
Copy !req
191. Oil, the mineral on which the
whole world depends,
Copy !req
192. and which is won
with so much effort
Copy !req
193. in so many distant places.
Copy !req
194. Abroad or back
in the States,
Copy !req
195. America's insatiable appetite
for oil needs to be fed.
Copy !req
196. So, the federal government
claims new territory for
Copy !req
197. exploitation, on the
continental shelf off the coast.
Copy !req
198. Lyndon Johnson greatly expanded
at huge environmental risk,
Copy !req
199. the nation's exploration
of the continental shelf,
Copy !req
200. which turned out to be
rich for oil.
Copy !req
201. And so, the Department of the
Interior opened up offshore
Copy !req
202. drilling in a way that America
had never seen before.
Copy !req
203. And soon after,
Copy !req
204. what some people feared
would happen, happens.
Copy !req
205. In 1969 off the coast of Santa
Barbara, a massive oil spill...
Copy !req
206. an explosion as part of an
oil exploration project,
Copy !req
207. left oil gushing into one of
the most pristine
Copy !req
208. natural environments
in the country.
Copy !req
209. The spill exposes the
Department of the Interior's
Copy !req
210. willingness to let big oil
engage in dangerous drilling.
Copy !req
211. Now, a nation galvanized by
protests against the
Copy !req
212. Vietnam War, turns its
attention to saving
Copy !req
213. the environment,
and demands action.
Copy !req
214. So, this culminates with the
Nixon administration,
Copy !req
215. believe it or not, a very
right-wing president,
Copy !req
216. presiding over the
creation of the
Copy !req
217. Environmental
Protection Agency.
Copy !req
218. Signing into law the
Clean Air Act,
Copy !req
219. the Clean Water Act, the
Endangered Species Act.
Copy !req
220. The great question
of the 70s is,
Copy !req
221. shall we surrender to our
surroundings?
Copy !req
222. Or, shall we make our peace
with nature and begin to make
Copy !req
223. reparations for the damage we
have done to our air,
Copy !req
224. to our land, and to our water?
Copy !req
225. The founding of the EPA really
came about because the nation
Copy !req
226. realized that there wasn't
anyone paying attention to
Copy !req
227. the needs of protecting
the environment.
Copy !req
228. But as the Deepwater Horizon
event will demonstrate,
Copy !req
229. laws are one thing and
enforcement is another.
Copy !req
230. They're some of the most
powerful environmental
Copy !req
231. regulations in the world.
Copy !req
232. The fact is that they're
just very often ignored,
Copy !req
233. and the laws broken.
Copy !req
234. The EPA, which begun under
such promise and with such
Copy !req
235. bipartisan enthusiasm,
in the decades since,
Copy !req
236. has become one of the most
partisan tools and
Copy !req
237. weapons of modern
American politics.
Copy !req
238. And where you live, and the
color of your skin will help
Copy !req
239. determine when those
regulations are enforced.
Copy !req
240. It's the poor and those who
are racially excluded and
Copy !req
241. targeted who
suffer the most.
Copy !req
242. I know I live at the
back end of town,
Copy !req
243. and I should just be quiet,
and not make a sound.
Copy !req
244. You might even find this
a little profound,
Copy !req
245. but me and my neighbors are a
light and dark shade of brown.
Copy !req
246. And you see this where there's
lots and lots of oil refineries
Copy !req
247. and just enormous
amounts of cancer.
Copy !req
248. Today's date is
September the 19, 2017.
Copy !req
249. I get a call saying there's
been some kind of explosion.
Copy !req
250. It looked like a storage tank
of some sort just blew up.
Copy !req
251. Maybe in the Valero tank yard.
Copy !req
252. Port Arthur lies just 90 miles
east of Houston...
Copy !req
253. on the Texas Gulf coast.
Copy !req
254. It's surrounded by
a gauntlet of
Copy !req
255. petrochemical and hazardous
waste facilities,
Copy !req
256. a lasting legacy of the role the
city played in Texas history.
Copy !req
257. We have the Motiva oil refinery.
We have Valero oil refinery.
Copy !req
258. And we also have
Chevron Chemical,
Copy !req
259. and we have Oxbow Calcined
Petroleum Coke facility
Copy !req
260. on the west side.
Copy !req
261. Veolia Chemical
Incineration facility.
Copy !req
262. And on the east end
of our town,
Copy !req
263. we have Total Oil Refinery,
Copy !req
264. the French owned company.
Chemical,
Copy !req
265. a German owned company.
Copy !req
266. And we have Indorama,
a chemical facility as well.
Copy !req
267. Along with a few other smaller
refineries and chemical plants.
Copy !req
268. Here in east Texas,
the petrochemical companies
Copy !req
269. have been earning vast sums of
money for nearly a century,
Copy !req
270. while the residents
of Port Arthur
Copy !req
271. and some more than others
Copy !req
272. have been paying a
very high price.
Copy !req
273. The American
Lung Association
Copy !req
274. gives Port Arthur's
air quality an F.
Copy !req
275. Asthma rates for children
are more than double
Copy !req
276. the national average.
Copy !req
277. And cancer rates are about 40%
higher in the Black community
Copy !req
278. than in the rest of the state.
Copy !req
279. Well, on the west side
of Port Arthur,
Copy !req
280. you have a disproportionate
number of individuals that
Copy !req
281. suffer with respiratory issues.
Copy !req
282. One out of every five
households have someone in it
Copy !req
283. that have to use a
nebulizer to clear their,
Copy !req
284. their breathing passage.
Copy !req
285. Or they take breathing
treatments before
Copy !req
286. they go to bed at night.
Copy !req
287. In Port Arthur, like in many
southern communities,
Copy !req
288. the historical line dividing
Black and white is a set of
Copy !req
289. railroad tracks that cuts
across the town.
Copy !req
290. It's the legacy of Jim Crow,
the set of racist laws that
Copy !req
291. enforced segregation in the
South after the end of slavery.
Copy !req
292. Black citizens were forced
to live on the
Copy !req
293. wrong side of the tracks',
Copy !req
294. right up until the end
of the 1960s.
Copy !req
295. Where we're at now
is the divide.
Copy !req
296. To my right, this is where
white folks lived and
Copy !req
297. where we are turning now,
Copy !req
298. this is where all Black
people had to live.
Copy !req
299. We are literally about to cross
the railroad track and head
Copy !req
300. into the African American community.
Copy !req
301. I left Port Arthur when
I was 18 years old.
Copy !req
302. I joined the United States Navy.
Copy !req
303. And, I decided to
stay in California
Copy !req
304. when I got out
of the service.
Copy !req
305. In 2000, Hilton Kelly
came back home,
Copy !req
306. for what was supposed
to be a short stay.
Copy !req
307. Every time I went home,
somebody had died.
Copy !req
308. And it was always
cancer related.
Copy !req
309. I noticed that the air still
smelled kinda like rotten eggs.
Copy !req
310. It was real foul.
Copy !req
311. And so, May of 2000, I ended up
moving back to Port Arthur,
Copy !req
312. and I started my mission
with fighting
Copy !req
313. for environmental justice.
Copy !req
314. Right now, we're right next
to the Motiva oil refinery.
Copy !req
315. They put out 633,000
barrels of oil per day.
Copy !req
316. Many times, when you have a
power failure, those derricks,
Copy !req
317. those tall structures there.
Copy !req
318. Well, they have a flare coming
off the tip of them,
Copy !req
319. 40 feet up in the air.
Copy !req
320. And you have this black smoke
pouring off the tip of it.
Copy !req
321. And that's
particulate matter.
Copy !req
322. In 2020, the three big
petrochemical companies
Copy !req
323. in Port Arthur earned over
$300 billion dollars
Copy !req
324. in revenue...
Copy !req
325. while the average income of
people living in the shadow of
Copy !req
326. their facilities was under
$20,000 a year,
Copy !req
327. with more than one in four
living under the poverty line.
Copy !req
328. Meanwhile, in 2019,
Copy !req
329. the top four petrochemical
companies in
Copy !req
330. Port Arthur released over a
million pounds of pollutants.
Copy !req
331. Toxic, cancer-causing chemicals
like benzine are often released
Copy !req
332. in these so-called
"upset" events.
Copy !req
333. Many times, what you'll find
is that the refineries get a
Copy !req
334. slap on the wrist from the
state regulatory agencies
Copy !req
335. when it comes
to actual fines.
Copy !req
336. And many times,
the fine does not fit the crime.
Copy !req
337. 500,000 dollars,
maybe a million dollars.
Copy !req
338. Even multi-million-dollar fines
don't have much impact on a
Copy !req
339. company like Valero, with
$102 billion in earnings and
Copy !req
340. a CEO that reportedly makes
over 20 million a year.
Copy !req
341. And the fines often don't go
to help the people injured
Copy !req
342. by the illegal activities.
Copy !req
343. Even when the Valero oil
refinery had a major
Copy !req
344. federal fine posed against
them, we had to
Copy !req
345. petition the Environmental
Protection Agency
Copy !req
346. in Washington, D. C.,
and ask them to allow
Copy !req
347. some of that money to come
back to the community
Copy !req
348. that was harmed by
those emissions instead of
Copy !req
349. just putting it all
in the treasury.
Copy !req
350. After a major fine was imposed
by the federal government,
Copy !req
351. the offending company was also
ordered to build a non-profit
Copy !req
352. healthcare center to serve
low-income patients
Copy !req
353. they'd helped to make sick,
on Port Arthur's west side.
Copy !req
354. And over here, what you see at
the Gulf Coast Health Center,
Copy !req
355. the Valero oil refinery
contributed to that
Copy !req
356. to the community.
Copy !req
357. I mean, everything that our
community has gotten from the
Copy !req
358. oil and gas industries,
we had to fight for it.
Copy !req
359. A lot of people are probably
walking around here sick and
Copy !req
360. don't even know
that they're sick.
Copy !req
361. But the cycle of
contamination and fines
Copy !req
362. doesn't address
the real problem.
Copy !req
363. Even if all the refineries
shut down today,
Copy !req
364. west side residents are stuck
living in a community that
Copy !req
365. has been permanently poisoned.
Copy !req
366. And stuck' is the
right word.
Copy !req
367. Packing up and leaving is
not a viable option.
Copy !req
368. You'd get maybe, for one of
those houses on the
Copy !req
369. west end of town, you're
looking at maybe $65,000.
Copy !req
370. You move across the
railroad track that,
Copy !req
371. you just that's just a down
payment on a house
Copy !req
372. on the other end of town.
Copy !req
373. And so, this is why you see so
many Black and Brown people
Copy !req
374. living in heavily
industrialized areas,
Copy !req
375. because we were
forced to live there,
Copy !req
376. great-great grandmother
started off there.
Copy !req
377. She passed a property on
to your grandmother.
Copy !req
378. Your grandmother passed it
on to your mom,
Copy !req
379. and your mom passed the
property on to you.
Copy !req
380. Now, that's all they have.
Copy !req
381. So, systemic racism
continues to keep
Copy !req
382. Black and Brown people
stuck in low lying,
Copy !req
383. polluted communities.
Copy !req
384. Today about 70 million People
of Color live in counties that
Copy !req
385. received a failing grade for
ozone and particle pollution.
Copy !req
386. Wherever these big
polluters are,
Copy !req
387. you will find predominantly
Black people.
Copy !req
388. But it's very difficult to pull
yourself up by your bootstraps
Copy !req
389. if you don't even have
enough money to buy boots
Copy !req
390. to put on your feet.
Copy !req
391. I see your smoke
rising in the air.
Copy !req
392. Two or three in the morning
when you think no one is there.
Copy !req
393. In the still of the night,
my child starts to sneeze.
Copy !req
394. In the still of the night,
the other starts to wheeze.
Copy !req
395. Your bright, bright torch,
it burns all night.
Copy !req
396. To find my way
through the house,
Copy !req
397. I don't even need a light.
Copy !req
398. I know I live at the
back end of town,
Copy !req
399. and I should just be quiet,
and not make a sound.
Copy !req
400. You might even find this
a little profound,
Copy !req
401. but me and my neighbors are a
light and dark shade of brown.
Copy !req
402. But if you die tonight, would
your killers confess to the
Copy !req
403. poisoning put inside you that
laid you down to rest?
Copy !req
404. Would your family have to fight
to pay your doctor bills,
Copy !req
405. as you lay six foot under
up on a grassy hill?
Copy !req
406. Now your job is gone, and your
company grievance has faded.
Copy !req
407. Your spouse and kids tried
to collect from them,
Copy !req
408. but they said your death
was not job related.
Copy !req
409. My toxic reality.
Copy !req
410. And for many of us, our toxic
reality is on display
Copy !req
411. at the local hardware store.
Copy !req
412. Roundup herbicide by Monsanto.
Copy !req
413. You only see them talk about
a concern for profit.
Copy !req
414. And keeping these products on
the market at all cost and,
Copy !req
415. silencing and censoring and harassing
Copy !req
416. anybody who gets
in their way.
Copy !req
417. Lee Johnson was a
groundskeeper for the
Copy !req
418. Benicia School District
in California.
Copy !req
419. His main job was spraying
Roundup or Ranger Pro,
Copy !req
420. these products that were
developed by Monsanto.
Copy !req
421. And he would spray them around
the areas of the school
Copy !req
422. where children would
congregate and play.
Copy !req
423. Johnson had a large tank
filled with the chemical
Copy !req
424. mounted on the
back of his truck.
Copy !req
425. He was wearing protective gear,
but the tank sprayer broke off
Copy !req
426. from the hose and a
large fountain of the
Copy !req
427. chemical exploded
up into the air.
Copy !req
428. Lee is soaked to the skin.
Copy !req
429. And it was a few months later
that he noticed a lesion
Copy !req
430. develop on his on his leg a
little bit above his knee.
Copy !req
431. And over time, these lesions
took over his whole body.
Copy !req
432. And he eventually was told he
had a form of non-Hodgkin
Copy !req
433. lymphoma that was terminal,
and he was given
Copy !req
434. about 18 months
left to live.
Copy !req
435. I will now read the verdict in
the matter of Dewayne Johnson,
Copy !req
436. plaintiff, versus Monsanto
Company, defendant.
Copy !req
437. Was the Roundup Pro
or Ranger Pro
Copy !req
438. a substantial factor in
causing harm to Mr. Johnson?
Copy !req
439. yes.
Copy !req
440. Did Monsanto fail to adequately
warn of the potential risks?
Copy !req
441. yes.
Copy !req
442. August 10, 2018.
At age 46
Copy !req
443. four years after being diagnosed
with terminal cancer
Copy !req
444. Dewayne Anthony Lee
Johnson is handed
Copy !req
445. an historic victory
in a landmark case.
Copy !req
446. The verdict makes headlines
across the country.
Copy !req
447. A jury has just decided that
agriculture giant Monsanto
Copy !req
448. is liable for allowing a
cancer-causing chemical
Copy !req
449. in its products.
Copy !req
450. Today's jury awarded $289
million to Dewayne Johnson,
Copy !req
451. a school groundskeeper in
northern California who says
Copy !req
452. use of Roundup led to a
diagnosis of terminal
Copy !req
453. Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma.
Copy !req
454. So, to have the verdict of
$289 million was just stunning.
Copy !req
455. One of the most important
aspects of the Lee Johnson
Copy !req
456. trial and the trials
that followed,
Copy !req
457. was the discovery of the
internal Monsanto papers,
Copy !req
458. the documents, the emails,
the records,
Copy !req
459. the memos, the reports...
Copy !req
460. that documented and
showed that for,
Copy !req
461. you know, 40 some years, basically,
Copy !req
462. Monsanto had been working
really hard to deceive
Copy !req
463. the public and to deceive
regulators about
Copy !req
464. the risks of its products.
Copy !req
465. Roundup is better!
Copy !req
466. It goes through the
plant to kill it.
Copy !req
467. But is it worth it?
Copy !req
468. Farm trials with Roundup made
up to 12 more bushels an acre.
Copy !req
469. You don't see them talk about
a concern for the public.
Copy !req
470. You only see them talk about
a concern for profit.
Copy !req
471. It's the early 2000s.
Copy !req
472. Genetically modified crops
may be heartier,
Copy !req
473. and more productive.
Copy !req
474. But to grow them,
you need to buy the seeds,
Copy !req
475. then kill the weeds that
root on their turf.
Copy !req
476. Conveniently, the same company
that sells the seeds also sells
Copy !req
477. the herbicides that kill
those weeds but leave
Copy !req
478. your super-plant standing.
Copy !req
479. Roundup Herbicide by Monsanto.
Copy !req
480. There's never been a
herbicide like it before.
Copy !req
481. The key to unlocking the
power of the pesticide
Copy !req
482. is a chemical called glyphosate.
Copy !req
483. Monsanto's seeds are
genetically manipulated to be
Copy !req
484. resistant to the chemical,
the key ingredient in
Copy !req
485. Roundup and Ranger Pro.
Copy !req
486. Why is your head in the ground?
Copy !req
487. I'm gonna watch Roundup
kill these roots!
Copy !req
488. Hey, this is Spike's area!
Copy !req
489. Bob, Roundup can be used where
kids and pets will play and
Copy !req
490. breaks down into
natural material!
Copy !req
491. Come on down and take a peek.
Copy !req
492. Monsanto started out really as
a chemical company,
Copy !req
493. but more of an industrial
chemical company.
Copy !req
494. They actually were involved
in the manufacturing of
Copy !req
495. Agent Orange during
the Vietnam War.
Copy !req
496. Agent orange is Round Up
on steroids an herbicide
Copy !req
497. developed to kill not just
weeds but to wipe out
Copy !req
498. whole swaths of the
Vietnamese jungle.
Copy !req
499. After the war, hundreds of
thousands of Vietnamese
Copy !req
500. citizens and American service
members developed cancers.
Copy !req
501. And in Vietnam, an entire
generation suffers
Copy !req
502. horrific birth defects.
Copy !req
503. But that didn't stop the
company from promoting its new
Copy !req
504. patented chemical, glyphosate,
as a high-tech miracle that
Copy !req
505. would degrade and disappear
after it did its job.
Copy !req
506. Except, it didn't.
Copy !req
507. One - kills weeds to the roots.
Two - forms a barrier,
Copy !req
508. preventing new ones for
up to four months.
Copy !req
509. Roundup Extended Control.
Copy !req
510. While Lee Johnson was the first
plaintiff to sue Monsanto for
Copy !req
511. causing his Non-Hodgkin's
Lymphoma,
Copy !req
512. 100,000 have followed since.
Copy !req
513. Monsanto's lawyers provided
thousands of pages of data
Copy !req
514. to back-up their claim
that their products
Copy !req
515. don't cause cancer.
Copy !req
516. One of the things that stood
out to me the worst is that
Copy !req
517. when they told me that it was
safe enough to drink.
Copy !req
518. It became a joke almost like,
it was like, What?
Copy !req
519. Monsanto's defense
has always been that,
Copy !req
520. while they feel great sympathy
for people who suffer from
Copy !req
521. non-Hodgkin lymphoma,
their products, you know,
Copy !req
522. are proven safe, and that it is
simply, you know, junk science,
Copy !req
523. politically motivated
scientists who say otherwise.
Copy !req
524. But internal documents
uncovered by Carey Gillam show
Copy !req
525. that in 1983, a study funded by
Monsanto and submitted to the
Copy !req
526. EPA, found glyphosate was
causing cancer in mice.
Copy !req
527. Monsanto protested.
Copy !req
528. Monsanto then brought in an
expert to look at the data
Copy !req
529. again and to give the EPA
a new authoritative analysis.
Copy !req
530. The internal Monsanto documents
show that the company
Copy !req
531. knew in advance that this
scientist that they hired
Copy !req
532. was going to
find a loophole.
Copy !req
533. If he could find a tumor in
the control group mice,
Copy !req
534. then that would invalidate
this cancer finding.
Copy !req
535. He did in fact, find a tumor,
and that changed the
Copy !req
536. classification from possibly
causing cancer to, you know,
Copy !req
537. doesn't cause cancer.
Copy !req
538. Like big oil and the
Department of the Interior,
Copy !req
539. Monsanto figured out how to
wield its power over the agency
Copy !req
540. that's supposed to
keep it in check.
Copy !req
541. It is astonishing when you
look at the EPA history,
Copy !req
542. and you look at how closely
the EPA works to
Copy !req
543. protect the interests of
these companies.
Copy !req
544. You see time and time again,
EPA scientists,
Copy !req
545. the working guys and gals
inside the agency,
Copy !req
546. really trying to do their jobs
and raise their hands and say:
Copy !req
547. Hey, this looks like it
could be dangerous.
Copy !req
548. You see the higher ups pushing
down and censoring.
Copy !req
549. On the eve of the
Lee Johnson verdict,
Copy !req
550. aspirin giant Bayer buys out Monsanto,
Copy !req
551. and in 2020 agrees to
pay $11 billion
Copy !req
552. to settle other lawsuits.
Copy !req
553. But neither Lee nor his lawyers
will see his $289 million.
Copy !req
554. The amount gets
reduced on appeal
Copy !req
555. by more than 90 percent
to $20.5 million.
Copy !req
556. And that was largely because
Lee was expected to die so soon.
Copy !req
557. He was not expected to live
a long life with a lot of
Copy !req
558. medical bills and
a lot of suffering.
Copy !req
559. And under California law,
Copy !req
560. that reduces the damages
that you can receive.
Copy !req
561. A large chemical corporation
is found guilty,
Copy !req
562. then thrown a life preserver by
the courts for the very same
Copy !req
563. reason they were held
accountable to begin with:
Copy !req
564. their products were
killing Lee Johnson.
Copy !req
565. Meanwhile, thousands of
other sick plaintiffs
Copy !req
566. wait for their day in court.
Copy !req
567. The company maintains that
they're just doing this,
Copy !req
568. you know, as a
cost of business,
Copy !req
569. and it is no admission that
their products are dangerous.
Copy !req
570. But as you'll see,
Monsanto is not the only
Copy !req
571. multi-billion-dollar
corporation battling the EPA
Copy !req
572. to keep its toxic chemicals
on the market.
Copy !req
573. I just want to say
one word to you.
Copy !req
574. - Just one word.
- Yes, sir?
Copy !req
575. - Are you listening?
- Yes, I am.
Copy !req
576. Plastics.
Copy !req
577. In The Graduate,
Dustin Hoffman is pulled aside.
Copy !req
578. And the advice he's giving him,
is that this is the future
Copy !req
579. that he should invest in.
Copy !req
580. There's a great
future in plastics.
Copy !req
581. Think about it.
Will you think about it?
Copy !req
582. Yes, I will.
Copy !req
583. And many, many people did.
Copy !req
584. In 1960s America,
industrial chemistry and
Copy !req
585. its prized creation
petroleum-based plastics
Copy !req
586. seemed to be the answer to
Copy !req
587. every problem posed
to modern society.
Copy !req
588. Here's a scene that has
long-since ceased
Copy !req
589. causing any surprise.
Copy !req
590. The womenfolk washing dishes
made of plastic.
Copy !req
591. Dishes that bounce when
they drop to the floor.
Copy !req
592. Around that time,
science was really king.
Copy !req
593. Here we see coasters being
packed for shipment.
Copy !req
594. And in a matter of minutes,
the line could
Copy !req
595. be producing water tumblers
or tomato slicers,
Copy !req
596. bread boxes or pitchers.
Copy !req
597. The future of plastics
is bright indeed.
Copy !req
598. Science had helped end the war.
Copy !req
599. There were a lot of
miraculous things invented,
Copy !req
600. including for example, penicillin.
Copy !req
601. So, people were not
at all critical,
Copy !req
602. and there was not regulation.
Copy !req
603. People wanted to have
this modern life.
Copy !req
604. What it comes down to is that
the oil industry has to please
Copy !req
605. Mrs. Martin and
millions just like her.
Copy !req
606. Already today, she's used
some 87 petroleum products,
Copy !req
607. including the plastic
bacon wrapper and
Copy !req
608. the wax of the milk carton.
Copy !req
609. These ads, for example...
Copy !req
610. better living through chemistry.
Copy !req
611. For this is the age of
industrial chemistry.
Copy !req
612. All around us are the products
of modern chemistry.
Copy !req
613. Plastic, an important
part of your diet!
Copy !req
614. Babies being
delivered in plastic.
Copy !req
615. This fit very well with the
growth of the petrochemical
Copy !req
616. industry because the byproducts
of the petrochemical industry
Copy !req
617. could be used to
make these plastics,
Copy !req
618. which we're now facing
damages from.
Copy !req
619. As America's post-war
prosperity was producing
Copy !req
620. a baby boom, the big
chemical companies
Copy !req
621. were cashing in.
The Du Pont family,
Copy !req
622. founders of the chemical giant,
Copy !req
623. are still one of America's
richest families,
Copy !req
624. worth over 16 billion today.
Copy !req
625. But the boom in chemicals
was beginning, silently,
Copy !req
626. to poison future generations.
Copy !req
627. The new petrochemical titans
had products that
Copy !req
628. reached into every corner
of American life.
Copy !req
629. At this point, we are
exposed to toxic chemicals
Copy !req
630. all day, every day.
Copy !req
631. The idea that you can escape
them, at this point that,
Copy !req
632. you know, it's just not
true. They're inescapable.
Copy !req
633. We drink lots of different
contaminants in our water.
Copy !req
634. We breathe chemicals in dust.
Copy !req
635. And they're also coming
through our skin.
Copy !req
636. The body is very permeable.
Copy !req
637. And so, these things will
come in through
Copy !req
638. all of these entry points.
Copy !req
639. Unfortunately, unlike drugs
and say, vaccines,
Copy !req
640. which we know have to be tested
for safety and efficacy before
Copy !req
641. they're used, there wasn't
that kind of regulation
Copy !req
642. in the United States.
Copy !req
643. In 1971, in response
to public pressure,
Copy !req
644. Congress proposed the Toxic
Substances Control Act.
Copy !req
645. But when the law was finally
passed five years later later,
Copy !req
646. the chemical giants had
found a way to keep
Copy !req
647. doing their toxic
business as usual.
Copy !req
648. Industry knew that there
were 62,000 chemicals
Copy !req
649. on the market at the time.
Copy !req
650. And they were worried that
all of those chemicals
Copy !req
651. would have to undergo
some sort of review.
Copy !req
652. So, in order to
appease industry,
Copy !req
653. they allowed these chemicals
to be grandfathered in.
Copy !req
654. And the coup of the
chemical industry,
Copy !req
655. which was heavily involved in
the writing of the legislation,
Copy !req
656. is that companies don't have
to give the EPA data
Copy !req
657. on the safety of
their chemicals.
Copy !req
658. Government gives the
company the responsibility
Copy !req
659. to do their own testing.
But it doesn't verify this,
Copy !req
660. and even when a company
releases a product
Copy !req
661. that's found to be harmful,
government has
Copy !req
662. very little authority to
remove it from the market.
Copy !req
663. The EPA began with these lofty
intentions, but all along,
Copy !req
664. they have been tasked with
regulating industries that have
Copy !req
665. so much more money
than they do,
Copy !req
666. and so much more power.
Copy !req
667. When you're flooded with
dollars that can lobby,
Copy !req
668. that can influence senators,
that can spend and spend and
Copy !req
669. spend and still not fully,
you know,
Copy !req
670. erase the profits
they're making,
Copy !req
671. you have an agency that's
cowed by industry,
Copy !req
672. and they're scared
in many cases.
Copy !req
673. So, by 2005, there were
82,000 chemicals
Copy !req
674. registered for
use on the market.
Copy !req
675. And only 5 had been flagged as
needing extra regulatory review.
Copy !req
676. The level of evidence that's
required to convince regulators
Copy !req
677. to restrict a chemical
is so high that
Copy !req
678. it very rarely happens.
Copy !req
679. In the rare case when a
chemical is banned by the EPA,
Copy !req
680. there are no rules governing
the replacement.
Copy !req
681. Nothing is done to make sure
that the substitute chemical
Copy !req
682. is safer than the
previous chemical.
Copy !req
683. One step forward and
one step back.
Copy !req
684. It's a pattern that keeps
consumers locked in
Copy !req
685. a dangerous status quo.
Copy !req
686. It's different from how Europe
deals with the chemical
Copy !req
687. regulation, which is to use
this precautionary principle
Copy !req
688. that we have to assume,
if we don't know,
Copy !req
689. that it could potentially
cause dangers.
Copy !req
690. The way we've done it is, to
kind of flip that and to say,
Copy !req
691. We need to prove the risk to
get it off the market.
Copy !req
692. We need a program like that so
that a chemical is tested
Copy !req
693. before it's put into commerce.
Otherwise, it's tested on us!
Copy !req
694. Right? We're the
guinea pigs then.
Copy !req
695. Waiting till they're in the
public and then doing studies
Copy !req
696. to figure out what harms they
did, is just not sustainable.
Copy !req
697. You know, you pay for the
costs of pollution by fighting
Copy !req
698. your personal battle
with illness, right?
Copy !req
699. But it's not just a
personal battle.
Copy !req
700. The toxic chemicals that
surround us may be threatening
Copy !req
701. our very ability to survive
as a species.
Copy !req
702. There did, indeed, seem to
be a very significant
Copy !req
703. decline in sperm count
over the prior 50 years.
Copy !req
704. This is a crisis.
Copy !req
705. A health alert tonight
regarding sperm count.
Copy !req
706. Male sperm count has plummeted
by 50% since the 1970s.
Copy !req
707. But why?
Copy !req
708. And this morning researchers
are sounding the alarm.
Copy !req
709. It was a study that made
headlines around the world and
Copy !req
710. left the scientific community
struggling to make sense of
Copy !req
711. why it was happening.
Copy !req
712. If this trend continues,
some epidemiologists predict
Copy !req
713. that sperm counts could
reach zero by the year 2045.
Copy !req
714. The chemicals that were
threatening the health of the
Copy !req
715. average person seemed to be
posing an even bigger danger:
Copy !req
716. jeopardizing our future
as a species.
Copy !req
717. The paper that really started
the discussion claimed that
Copy !req
718. sperm count had declined
significantly worldwide
Copy !req
719. over the prior 50 years.
Copy !req
720. I see a very concerning picture
about the reproductive health
Copy !req
721. of our planet.
Copy !req
722. Shanna Swan is one of the
world's leading environmental
Copy !req
723. and reproductive epidemiologists.
Copy !req
724. After confirming the results
of the original study,
Copy !req
725. she was compelled to find out
why it was happening.
Copy !req
726. Her findings were unsettling:
Copy !req
727. Americans, at large,
were being poisoned.
Copy !req
728. The why is the big question.
Copy !req
729. I spent many years
looking at how
Copy !req
730. environmental chemicals
affect sperm count.
Copy !req
731. I focused on one particular
class of chemicals: Phthalates.
Copy !req
732. They're in so many of
our daily products.
Copy !req
733. They make plastic
soft and flexible.
Copy !req
734. They are in shower curtains.
They're in our cosmetics.
Copy !req
735. Because they help retain
scent and color,
Copy !req
736. the chemicals are used in nail
polish, lipstick and hairspray.
Copy !req
737. Phthalates also
increase absorption,
Copy !req
738. so they're found
in hand creams,
Copy !req
739. suntan lotions and
even pesticides.
Copy !req
740. Phthalates are part of a group
of chemicals known as
Copy !req
741. endocrine disruptors.
Copy !req
742. Endocrine disrupting
chemicals can interfere with
Copy !req
743. the body's natural
hormone system.
Copy !req
744. So, the effect of these
chemicals on birth,
Copy !req
745. and birth rate, is huge.
Copy !req
746. But there's no doubt that the
entire organism is affected.
Copy !req
747. We have really an epidemic of
particularly endocrine related
Copy !req
748. problems that we know are
linked to chemical exposure.
Copy !req
749. The declining sperm counts are
one signal that we get about
Copy !req
750. the reproductive health
of the planet.
Copy !req
751. Most of us have these
within our bodies.
Copy !req
752. We've been altered,
and that was not a decision
Copy !req
753. that we were
allowed to make.
Copy !req
754. It was a decision that
was essentially made
Copy !req
755. by these corporations.
Copy !req
756. Every living creature on the
planet has been found with
Copy !req
757. plastic in their bodies,
when it's been looked for.
Copy !req
758. And of course, we use these
animals for food.
Copy !req
759. In order to really protect
yourself from chemicals,
Copy !req
760. you would have to, in a sense,
live in a bubble,
Copy !req
761. where you're exposed to only
those things that you have
Copy !req
762. direct control over.
Copy !req
763. And the truth is,
no one can do that.
Copy !req
764. It's really frustrating to
be someone who has spent
Copy !req
765. so many years now
interacting with and
Copy !req
766. studying the EPA,
the USDA, the FDA,
Copy !req
767. to see how manipulated
and how corrupt...
Copy !req
768. and how much collusion
goes on within the agency.
Copy !req
769. And it really shouldn't
be that way.
Copy !req
770. They should be implementing
policies to protect.
Copy !req
771. And they have not
been doing that.
Copy !req
772. We keep coming back to
the power of profit.
Copy !req
773. And that sounds like there's
someone, you know,
Copy !req
774. really evil in a back room
surrounded by bags of money
Copy !req
775. that doesn't care about
human well-being.
Copy !req
776. But in the end, profit is a
powerful motivator.
Copy !req
777. And, the truth is,
reforming our regulatory system
Copy !req
778. is gonna take so much work,
Copy !req
779. and it's really going
to require the
Copy !req
780. industry does business
very differently.
Copy !req