1. Who are we?
Copy !req
2. I've no doubt that we are those
who will inherit the coming age.
Copy !req
3. Having broken free of the prejudices
and discrimination of old,
Copy !req
4. we will freely, nimbly, and elegantly
Copy !req
5. plunge into the unknown.
Copy !req
6. And today, a new comrade
has joined our quest.
Copy !req
7. His name is Albert.
Copy !req
8. Welcome!
Copy !req
9. We're glad to have you!
Copy !req
10. I've served as his tutor,
Copy !req
11. and his clear thinking has amazed me.
Copy !req
12. It's as if a master theoretician
Copy !req
13. has entered into a young boy's body.
Copy !req
14. However, what I find even more remarkable
Copy !req
15. is his intense curiosity.
Copy !req
16. No other talent
Copy !req
17. is more important
to the future of academia.
Copy !req
18. I say that because I am afraid.
Copy !req
19. Perhaps in the future,
Copy !req
20. the view that truth is conceived,
rather than discovered,
Copy !req
21. may become an assumption of sorts.
Copy !req
22. Written works of the past
and other countries
Copy !req
23. all describe different histories,
cultures, and faiths.
Copy !req
24. Information is in short supply now,
Copy !req
25. but if we connect with those
foreign to us in the days to come,
Copy !req
26. even truth may one day
be seen as relative.
Copy !req
27. When that happens,
Copy !req
28. awe and admiration
for the ideal of universal truth
Copy !req
29. may fade from human hearts.
Copy !req
30. As a result, research will become
increasingly specialized.
Copy !req
31. The grand desire for contact
with knowledge as a whole,
Copy !req
32. in other words, curiosity itself,
Copy !req
33. may be despised as frivolous and wasteful.
Copy !req
34. If that happens,
Copy !req
35. I can't help but feel sad.
Copy !req
36. That's why I choose
Copy !req
37. to believe.
Copy !req
38. I believe in all of you
Copy !req
39. and your curiosity.
Copy !req
40. Here's to your curiosity
and that of our newest member!
Copy !req
41. Cheers!
Copy !req
42. - Cheers!
- Cheers!
Copy !req
43. ON THE MOVEMENTS OF THE EARTH
Copy !req
44. Oh man, I spoke too long again.
Copy !req
45. Um, excuse me.
Copy !req
46. Thank you again.
Copy !req
47. I don't know what to say,
Copy !req
48. but I'm very happy
that you invited me here!
Copy !req
49. Don't be so humble.
Copy !req
50. We're equals here.
Copy !req
51. Anyway, I have an errand to attend to,
so I'll take my leave.
Copy !req
52. But you should enjoy yourself.
Copy !req
53. They're probably discussing cosmology
at that table over there.
Copy !req
54. It should interest you.
Copy !req
55. Cosmology?
Copy !req
56. You came all the way here,
Copy !req
57. so it would be a shame if you left early.
Copy !req
58. Be sure to stay until the end.
Copy !req
59. Yes, of course!
Copy !req
60. Well then, see you later.
Copy !req
61. That's where the secret information
I obtained comes in.
Copy !req
62. A prominent man named Ibn al-Shatir
Copy !req
63. adopted the stance of the Maragha scholars
Copy !req
64. and refined the uniform motion
of Ptolemy's—
Copy !req
65. - Oh!
- Huh?
Copy !req
66. Sorry, it's nothing!
Copy !req
67. Please continue.
Copy !req
68. Right. Anyway, what Ibn al-Shatir did was...
Copy !req
69. Oh, no.
Copy !req
70. I forgot to record my observations today.
Copy !req
71. What do I do?
Copy !req
72. If I go home now,
Copy !req
73. the meeting will be over
by the time I get back.
Copy !req
74. Then again, this is a special day.
Copy !req
75. It won't hurt if I skip
my observations just this once.
Copy !req
76. there's another way to look at it.
Copy !req
77. - Huh?
- Sorry, I have to go.
Copy !req
78. Thank you very much for today!
Copy !req
79. Huh? Sure.
Copy !req
80. Come again, okay?
Copy !req
81. I will. Farewell!
Copy !req
82. If I'm lucky,
Copy !req
83. I can borrow Father's horse
and go back right away.
Copy !req
84. I might make it in time!
Copy !req
85. I'm back!
Copy !req
86. Huh?
Copy !req
87. Oh, my.
Copy !req
88. Huh? W-What are you...
Copy !req
89. Oh, uh...
Copy !req
90. Man, this is a dilemma.
Copy !req
91. Well, I understand how you feel.
Copy !req
92. You must be confused.
Copy !req
93. Even so, I'd like you to stay calm.
Copy !req
94. If you deal with it rationally,
Copy !req
95. this too can be understood.
Copy !req
96. I have faith in you.
Copy !req
97. Let me say first
Copy !req
98. that I never intended this to happen.
Copy !req
99. I wanted to settle things peacefully.
Copy !req
100. Anyway, I'll start from the beginning.
Copy !req
101. Recently, I heard a rumor
Copy !req
102. that your father possessed
certain materials.
Copy !req
103. These materials deal
with a revolutionary theory
Copy !req
104. that could change
the shape of the universe.
Copy !req
105. I've been interested in that theory
for as long as I can remember,
Copy !req
106. but I had given up hope
of ever tracking it down.
Copy !req
107. I thought I had finally found
an entry point.
Copy !req
108. So I proposed sharing the materials
Copy !req
109. and engaging in joint research.
Copy !req
110. It wasn't a bad offer, I'd say.
Copy !req
111. To be honest,
Copy !req
112. the theory is beyond your father's grasp.
Copy !req
113. Without my intellect and social position,
Copy !req
114. its value will be lost.
Copy !req
115. I would have compensated him fairly,
Copy !req
116. and we both would have benefited.
Copy !req
117. But that's when the problem started.
Copy !req
118. He refused my offer.
Copy !req
119. Without a second thought.
Copy !req
120. Instead,
Copy !req
121. he insisted that the theory
conflicted with the prevailing models
Copy !req
122. and that it might be suppressed.
Copy !req
123. "I have a child.
I can't take on anything dangerous."
Copy !req
124. Those were his words.
Copy !req
125. He was an awfully fussy man.
Copy !req
126. With the right political moves,
suppression can easily be avoided.
Copy !req
127. But he wouldn't listen.
Copy !req
128. No, it was worse than that.
Copy !req
129. When I tried to convince him,
Copy !req
130. he grew angry.
Copy !req
131. In the end, he said
he would burn the materials.
Copy !req
132. I have to say,
Copy !req
133. that left me speechless.
Copy !req
134. Despite all his talk
of knowledge and learning,
Copy !req
135. he was a boor
concerned only with self-preservation.
Copy !req
136. Oh, I guess I shouldn't
speak ill of your father.
Copy !req
137. I take that back. Sorry.
Copy !req
138. In any case, he grew hysterical,
Copy !req
139. and I thought he might
do something drastic.
Copy !req
140. And so, I pacified him.
Copy !req
141. In the only way I could.
Copy !req
142. Your father
Copy !req
143. kept knowledge to himself
and refused to share.
Copy !req
144. That is an intolerable sin.
Copy !req
145. That way of thinking must be eliminated.
Copy !req
146. Understand?
Copy !req
147. The important thing here
Copy !req
148. is that the knowledge
your father inherited
Copy !req
149. will no longer be lost.
Copy !req
150. To pursue the beauty of this world,
Copy !req
151. sacrifices are unavoidable.
Copy !req
152. Now then, that clears things up, right?
Copy !req
153. In the end,
Copy !req
154. just as he finished his speech,
Copy !req
155. he was captured by the townspeople.
Copy !req
156. I don't know the rest.
Copy !req
157. It's ridiculous, right?
Copy !req
158. It all meant so little.
Copy !req
159. My father
Copy !req
160. told me to doubt.
Copy !req
161. As a result, he trusted no one
Copy !req
162. and was killed
for not sharing his materials.
Copy !req
163. My teacher
Copy !req
164. told me to believe.
Copy !req
165. As a result,
he had such faith in his convictions
Copy !req
166. that he didn't question murder.
Copy !req
167. That's the fate of people
who deal with knowledge.
Copy !req
168. "Truth" and "learning"
are too big a burden for humans.
Copy !req
169. That's why university
Copy !req
170. is a fool's path.
Copy !req
171. Do you have to choose between them?
Copy !req
172. Huh?
Copy !req
173. Doubt and conviction.
Copy !req
174. Would it hurt to have both?
Copy !req
175. Yes, it would.
Copy !req
176. They contradict each other.
Copy !req
177. St. Thomas Aquinas wrote that knowledge
Copy !req
178. is both material
Copy !req
179. and immaterial.
Copy !req
180. Body and soul.
Copy !req
181. Reason and faith.
Copy !req
182. Philosophy and theology.
Copy !req
183. Doubt and belief.
Copy !req
184. These contradictions coexist.
Copy !req
185. Why?
Copy !req
186. Because we're human.
Copy !req
187. Human beings are neither God nor beast.
Copy !req
188. They exist between the two.
Copy !req
189. But that's exactly why
Copy !req
190. they can accept contradiction,
ambiguity, and confusion.
Copy !req
191. In fact, such things provide
a breather from reason.
Copy !req
192. Listening to you,
Copy !req
193. it seems that you no longer
feel God's presence.
Copy !req
194. In other words,
Copy !req
195. you no longer sense what a miracle it is
Copy !req
196. that our world exists.
Copy !req
197. Miracles are chance phenomena
that occur when inevitability rules.
Copy !req
198. At the same time,
Copy !req
199. they are also inevitable phenomena
that occur when chance rules.
Copy !req
200. You felt those things back then.
Copy !req
201. You knew that everything
in this world is a miracle.
Copy !req
202. But as you cast aside
experience and memory,
Copy !req
203. your past and roots,
and finally pain itself,
Copy !req
204. you also lost the miraculous.
Copy !req
205. Even though that realm
is where you truly belong.
Copy !req
206. That's not for you to decide.
Copy !req
207. Do you know what you should do?
Copy !req
208. I don't have a clue.
Copy !req
209. It's simple.
Copy !req
210. Look up at the sky.
Copy !req
211. And then, take a deep breath.
Copy !req
212. My problems aren't that simple.
Copy !req
213. Of course not.
Copy !req
214. But even so, they are not insurmountable.
Copy !req
215. Letters to the Corinthians,
Copy !req
216. Chapter 10, Verse 13.
Copy !req
217. "God is faithful;
Copy !req
218. and he will not let you
be tempted beyond your ability,
Copy !req
219. but with the temptation
Copy !req
220. he will also provide the way of escape,
that you may be able to endure it."
Copy !req
221. Now then,
Copy !req
222. you showed the courage to speak,
Copy !req
223. so I will confess my own secret worry.
Copy !req
224. In my case...
Copy !req
225. Long ago,
Copy !req
226. I left a friend for dead.
Copy !req
227. In the course of his work,
Copy !req
228. my friend committed a terrible crime.
Copy !req
229. Something irreversible.
Copy !req
230. As a result,
Copy !req
231. he died.
Copy !req
232. But it was the very severity of his sin
Copy !req
233. that made it important
to show him the path of salvation.
Copy !req
234. What was the correct choice
for me at that moment?
Copy !req
235. I still have no answer.
Copy !req
236. I don't know if I ever will.
Copy !req
237. However, one thing is clear.
Copy !req
238. Before today,
Copy !req
239. I had turned a blind eye to my past.
Copy !req
240. But now I was able to express it
in words for the first time.
Copy !req
241. By doing so, I'll probably suffer
even more from now on.
Copy !req
242. But at the same time,
Copy !req
243. I'll believe today was a first step.
Copy !req
244. The same goes for you.
Copy !req
245. You told me your worries.
Copy !req
246. Now you can move forward.
Copy !req
247. God will accept us.
Copy !req
248. And God will always offer us a refuge.
Copy !req
249. But for that to happen,
Copy !req
250. we must overcome ourselves
Copy !req
251. and face God with sincerity.
Copy !req
252. In addition,
Copy !req
253. we must question in solitude
Copy !req
254. whether we are worthy of God's acceptance.
Copy !req
255. But no matter how much
we struggle with that question,
Copy !req
256. God will remain silent.
Copy !req
257. That's right.
Copy !req
258. And that's what enables us
Copy !req
259. to continue thinking, without end.
Copy !req
260. I'd like to believe that is happiness.
Copy !req
261. Finally,
Copy !req
262. I have one question for you.
Copy !req
263. To obtain bread, one offers coin.
Copy !req
264. To obtain rights, one offers taxes.
Copy !req
265. To obtain wages, one offers labor.
Copy !req
266. So then,
Copy !req
267. what must one offer up
Copy !req
268. to obtain the truth of our world?
Copy !req
269. What do you think?
Copy !req
270. Go in search of the answer.
Copy !req
271. Why?
Copy !req
272. So you can resume living in this world.
Copy !req
273. I think going to university
Copy !req
274. might be one way to find out.
Copy !req
275. Farewell, and may God bless you.
Copy !req
276. To pursue the beauty of this world,
sacrifices are unavoidable.
Copy !req
277. No matter what happens,
Copy !req
278. I'll never criticize your curiosity.
Copy !req
279. Teacher,
Copy !req
280. I want to pursue the beauty of this world.
Copy !req
281. To do so, sacrifices are unavoidable.
Copy !req
282. To be honest,
Copy !req
283. I feel the same way.
Copy !req
284. But you couldn't reach beauty
Copy !req
285. with the methods you chose.
Copy !req
286. I don't know what must be offered up
Copy !req
287. to know the truth of this world.
Copy !req
288. But I'm certain
Copy !req
289. that hiding things like my father
or eliminating others like you
Copy !req
290. is not how it's done.
Copy !req
291. We all lack something.
Copy !req
292. That's why we work together.
Copy !req
293. The world is too big
of a challenge otherwise.
Copy !req
294. Humans are social animals.
Copy !req
295. Teacher,
Copy !req
296. I too feel thaumazein.
Copy !req
297. I will continue to affirm that feeling
Copy !req
298. in ways different from you.
Copy !req
299. I'll doubt as I move forward
Copy !req
300. and believe as I turn back.
Copy !req
301. My pursuit of beauty
Copy !req
302. and inspiration
Copy !req
303. will never end.
Copy !req
304. Oh, you're back.
Copy !req
305. - That took longer than expected.
- Master!
Copy !req
306. Please allow me to attend university.
Copy !req
307. Let's see.
Copy !req
308. You're our new applicant.
Copy !req
309. Albert, wasn't it?
Copy !req
310. Yes.
Copy !req
311. In that case, sign here.
Copy !req
312. Albert... Brudzewski?
Copy !req
313. Yes.
Copy !req
314. Brudzewo is the name of my hometown.
Copy !req
315. I use that name for my signature.
Copy !req
316. I see.
Copy !req
317. Well, anything will do.
Copy !req
318. Starting tomorrow,
take whatever classes you like.
Copy !req
319. What? A letter?
Copy !req
320. For me?
Copy !req
321. Yes. It's addressed to Potocki.
Copy !req
322. Potocki?
Copy !req
323. I don't know anyone by that name.
Copy !req
324. Still, this is definitely the address.
Copy !req
325. Well, that is what it says.
Copy !req
326. But then... could it be intended
Copy !req
327. for the previous occupant?
Copy !req
328. I mean, I've never seen
anything like this.
Copy !req
329. "Certificate of title."
Copy !req
330. "In the event that
the following book is published,
Copy !req
331. you will receive
ten percent of the profits."
Copy !req
332. It's kind of creepy.
Copy !req
333. Plus, isn't this a weird name for a book?
Copy !req
334. "On the Movements of the Earth," it says.
Copy !req
335. That must be a mistake.
Copy !req
336. After all, it's the heavens that move.
Copy !req
337. It's way too suspicious.
Copy !req
338. They didn't even send
the book in question.
Copy !req
339. Then again, if it brings me money,
I'm fine with that.
Copy !req
340. On the Movements of the Earth, huh?
Copy !req
341. Hmm?
Copy !req
342. In 1468,
Copy !req
343. Albert Brudzewski enrolled
at the University of Kraków at age 23.
Copy !req
344. He would eventually work there
as a teacher for 20 years.
Copy !req
345. His lectures focused mainly
on mathematics and natural philosophy.
Copy !req
346. At one point,
Copy !req
347. he expressed skepticism toward
the traditional geocentric model
Copy !req
348. but refrained from drawing conclusions.
Copy !req
349. In 1482,
Copy !req
350. he wrote a commentary
on the astronomy textbook of the time,
Copy !req
351. New Theories of the Planets.
Copy !req
352. It would go on to be widely read
at the university.
Copy !req
353. In 1491,
Copy !req
354. one of the students
who learned astronomy from his commentary
Copy !req
355. was a young man named Copernicus.
Copy !req
356. ON THE MOVEMENTS OF THE EARTH
THE END
Copy !req