1. I didn't realize you were still
in the house.
Copy !req
2. - I'm sorry to startle you.
Copy !req
3. Here's the estimate.
Copy !req
4. House looks good.
Copy !req
5. Can't think you need much
beyond door and window sensors.
Copy !req
6. I included in the cost three keypads.
Copy !req
7. My husband wondered,
Copy !req
8. would you ever just sell the stickers
for the windows
Copy !req
9. and a sign for the front lawn?
Copy !req
10. Signs come with the sensors, I'm afraid.
Copy !req
11. Of course they do.
That makes sense.
Copy !req
12. - Monte Rissell.
Monte Rissell.
Copy !req
13. Falls Church, Virginia.
Copy !req
14. They sentenced him a few weeks ago.
Copy !req
15. Five victims, all women,
raped and murdered.
Copy !req
16. Method?
Copy !req
17. First and last victim were beaten
and then drowned. Middle three stabbed.
Copy !req
18. - I thought one of them was shot, no?
- No.
Copy !req
19. Virginia State Penitentiary.
Monte Ralph Rissell.
Copy !req
20. Monte Rissell.
Copy !req
21. - Why don't you have a seat?
- Monte.
Copy !req
22. Hey, you guys need me for any of this?
Copy !req
23. No, thank you.
We'd prefer to talk with you alone.
Copy !req
24. Behave yourself, Rissell. Move.
Copy !req
25. My name's Bill Tench.
This is my partner, Holden Ford.
Copy !req
26. We're from the Federal Bureau
of Investigation's
Copy !req
27. Behavioral Science Unit.
Copy !req
28. - Scientists?
- We're from the Behavioral Science Unit.
Copy !req
29. We're doing research.
Copy !req
30. Interviewing... men like you.
Copy !req
31. Men like me?
Copy !req
32. Murderers with multiple victims.
Copy !req
33. To better understand
why you do what you do.
Copy !req
34. I'd like to know, too.
Copy !req
35. - You think this might help?
- Help with what?
Copy !req
36. Find a cure.
Copy !req
37. No idea.
Copy !req
38. Think I could get some Big Red?
Copy !req
39. "Big Red"?
Copy !req
40. Pop.
Copy !req
41. You know, like, soda.
Copy !req
42. Used to have it when I was a kid.
Copy !req
43. - I always loved Big Red.
Um...
Copy !req
44. - We'll see what we can do.
- That'll depend on the insights.
Copy !req
45. I can't get stuff like that in here.
Copy !req
46. What do you say
we get down to brass tacks?
Copy !req
47. What do you want to know?
Copy !req
48. Why I raped those girls in Florida?
Copy !req
49. For starters,
how did you choose your victims?
Copy !req
50. Victims?
Copy !req
51. That doesn't sound good.
Copy !req
52. No, it doesn't.
Copy !req
53. How many other...
"men like me" are you talking to?
Copy !req
54. Quite a few, Monte.
Copy !req
55. They all talk to you?
Copy !req
56. It's... early days.
Copy !req
57. Hmm...
Copy !req
58. - Really think you can get some Big Red?
- Look at me, Monte.
Copy !req
59. Let's stay on track.
Copy !req
60. You know what?
Copy !req
61. - I don't think I'm interested.
- Fine.
Copy !req
62. You want to diddle around,
we'll walk out of here.
Copy !req
63. We'll go have a nice, leisurely lunch
wherever the fuck we want,
Copy !req
64. and then take the picturesque drive
back to Quantico.
Copy !req
65. What's the rest of your day look like?
Copy !req
66. What my partner's too polite to say is,
we're talking to men like you
Copy !req
67. because we can't understand
Copy !req
68. how someone could fuck up their life
so completely
Copy !req
69. before he's barely old enough to vote.
Copy !req
70. Okay.
Copy !req
71. I first got into trouble at 14.
Copy !req
72. They sent me to Florida. This, uh...
Copy !req
73. "juvenile facility."
Copy !req
74. Doctors watching over me all the time.
Copy !req
75. I had four girls
while I was under observation.
Copy !req
76. But you didn't kill those girls
in Florida, that came later.
Copy !req
77. What was different when you came back
from the hospital? What changed?
Copy !req
78. Hmm...
Copy !req
79. Let's see.
Copy !req
80. They let me out.
Copy !req
81. I come back up here,
Copy !req
82. get myself a job, a girlfriend.
Copy !req
83. Girlfriend's a year ahead,
she goes off to state college,
Copy !req
84. but, you know, we keep in touch, we write.
Copy !req
85. You're taping it, man.
Copy !req
86. Taking notes helps with transcription.
Copy !req
87. You were saying?
Back in school, a free man...
Copy !req
88. Not free, no, sir.
Copy !req
89. Probation, counseling, therapy.
Copy !req
90. I gotta keep checking in
or they send me back.
Copy !req
91. But you got yourself a girlfriend...
Copy !req
92. Do I, though?
Copy !req
93. You know chicks.
Copy !req
94. She sends me a letter.
Copy !req
95. Tells me, shocker, there's all these guys
up at school, you know.
Copy !req
96. There's all this, uh...
Copy !req
97. She tells me, in so many words,
she wants to ball other guys.
Copy !req
98. What am I supposed to do with that?
Copy !req
99. I hop in the car, gotta see it
for myself, and what do you know,
Copy !req
100. there she is, making out with some dork.
Copy !req
101. What a dumbshit, right?
Copy !req
102. Chicks.
Copy !req
103. What can you do?
Copy !req
104. You can't live with them.
Copy !req
105. I'll tell you what you can fucking do.
Copy !req
106. I get some beer,
because I'm fucking angry,
Copy !req
107. I have some weed,
Copy !req
108. and I'm smoking, and thinking,
Copy !req
109. and driving, and drinking, and then...
Copy !req
110. Then I'm back at my apartment,
Copy !req
111. in the parking lot,
Copy !req
112. no idea how I got there.
Copy !req
113. A car pulls into the lot.
Copy !req
114. Girl on her own, maybe 20, 25.
Copy !req
115. It's got to be four in the morning.
Copy !req
116. It's like...
Copy !req
117. the idea of doing it
Copy !req
118. pops in your head like a...
Copy !req
119. Like a sneeze, you know what I mean?
Copy !req
120. I hop out the car, tap on the window,
Copy !req
121. pull the gun,
Copy !req
122. drag her into the woods,
Copy !req
123. rip her fucking panties off,
hike up her skirt.
Copy !req
124. "Oh, yeah, give it to me, baby!
I want it, I'm so horny."
Copy !req
125. I'm trying to rape her,
but she won't shut up.
Copy !req
126. She takes off screaming,
Copy !req
127. runs through the parking lot,
down a ravine.
Copy !req
128. You know, she's stronger than me,
but I'm fast.
Copy !req
129. I catch up to her.
I get her in a headlock.
Copy !req
130. I choke her.
Copy !req
131. We go rolling down the hill into a stream.
The whole thing is fucking chaos.
Copy !req
132. I smash her head against a rock,
Copy !req
133. hold her underwater...
Copy !req
134. and that's that.
Copy !req
135. No more drama.
Copy !req
136. You had a gun, why not use it?
Copy !req
137. I wanted to cool her off.
Copy !req
138. Do you think— Pardon me.
Copy !req
139. Do you think it would've ended differently
if she hadn't...
Copy !req
140. - Like, if she wasn't—
Wasn't what?
Copy !req
141. A fucking prostitute?
Copy !req
142. Yeah, could be. Could be.
Copy !req
143. Your science buddy
might have something there.
Copy !req
144. Second time, this blonde chick,
she will not stop with the questions.
Copy !req
145. I have her driving at gunpoint,
and she's like,
Copy !req
146. "Why are you doing this?
Don't you have a girlfriend?
Copy !req
147. What are you planning to do? Why me?"
Copy !req
148. Is that why you stabbed her?
Copy !req
149. I had to.
Copy !req
150. Shut her the fuck up.
Copy !req
151. Then you drove around for hours
in her car.
Copy !req
152. Yeah.
Copy !req
153. By the third girl, you could say
I had, uh... perfected the routine.
Copy !req
154. You stabbed her, too?
Copy !req
155. Yeah.
Copy !req
156. I stabbed her so many times.
Copy !req
157. Yeesh...
Copy !req
158. I did let one of 'em go, though.
Copy !req
159. Yeah.
Copy !req
160. We're in the car, I'm getting ready,
she has no idea.
Copy !req
161. All of a sudden she starts crying,
out of nowhere.
Copy !req
162. Tells me her daddy's dying... Cancer.
Copy !req
163. My brother had cancer.
Copy !req
164. Cancer. It's, uh...
Copy !req
165. It's a bitch, man.
Copy !req
166. Yeah, it's hard on a human being.
Copy !req
167. So I let her go.
Copy !req
168. It's, uh...
Copy !req
169. - It's a weird feeling, man.
- What's a weird feeling, Monte?
Copy !req
170. Um...
Copy !req
171. How do I put it?
Copy !req
172. - Showing mercy.
What?
Copy !req
173. Come on, kid. You don't expect us
to buy your mercy horseshit.
Copy !req
174. I think what Agent Tench means is—
Copy !req
175. I think I've had enough science
for one day.
Copy !req
176. Throat's a little dry.
Copy !req
177. - Maybe next time you should be careful—
- Holden.
Copy !req
178. - I didn't say anything.
- You don't have to. I get it.
Copy !req
179. - Let's move on.
- I wasn't going to reprimand you.
Copy !req
180. I hope not.
Copy !req
181. Okay, we're moving on.
Copy !req
182. Here's the thing.
Copy !req
183. Monte Rissell danced around a bunch
of psychiatrists when he was a kid.
Copy !req
184. Did the same thing when he was on parole.
Copy !req
185. He's an Olympic-class bullshitter.
Copy !req
186. Why do we think
he's being honest with us?
Copy !req
187. But we don't think
he's being completely honest. Do we?
Copy !req
188. We just need to extract what's useful
and discard the rest.
Copy !req
189. So my mistake with Rissell was what?
Copy !req
190. - You okay?
- Yeah.
Copy !req
191. Fuck!
Copy !req
192. Jesus Christ!
What the fuck's the matter with you?
Copy !req
193. What were you doing, 80, 100?
Copy !req
194. - You turned without looking!
- You were speeding!
Copy !req
195. - Doesn't matter! I had the right of way!
- Doesn't matter?
Copy !req
196. - That's the law, buddy.
- The law?
Copy !req
197. - No. Here's the fucking law, pal!
- You can't do that.
Copy !req
198. I'm gonna call the police!
Copy !req
199. Stay away from me, man!
Copy !req
200. Unbelievable!
Copy !req
201. You fucking moron.
Copy !req
202. You sure you're all right?
Copy !req
203. No, I get it. You got a lot
going on. It's a lot of pressure.
Copy !req
204. I completely understand.
Copy !req
205. Let me talk to Bill
and I'll call you back.
Copy !req
206. Is that for me?
Copy !req
207. Thanks. Debbie says hi.
Copy !req
208. It's fine. As soon as class is over,
she'll come down.
Copy !req
209. She says she'd rather us get a room
so she can pick us up in the morning.
Copy !req
210. I'm a little ticked off.
Copy !req
211. I get Debbie doesn't want to do
all that driving,
Copy !req
212. but we have a situation here.
I'm asking her for help.
Copy !req
213. Okay, she's got midterms
and that's on her mind, but...
Copy !req
214. Why am I so upset?
Copy !req
215. Maybe 'cause she can't drop everything
when you call.
Copy !req
216. Because she doesn't want to.
Copy !req
217. Here you go.
Copy !req
218. - One more, please.
Yes, sir.
Copy !req
219. You want to call Nancy?
Copy !req
220. Are you okay?
Copy !req
221. Or we could just eat.
Copy !req
222. I didn't see it coming, Holden.
Copy !req
223. You could've been killed,
and I didn't see it coming.
Copy !req
224. It's one thing if it's the job.
Copy !req
225. But some fucking Pinto
comes shooting out of nowhere...
Copy !req
226. I think if I called Nancy,
Copy !req
227. if I heard her voice,
Copy !req
228. I'd just lose it.
Copy !req
229. You know, we adopted a boy...
Copy !req
230. three years ago.
Copy !req
231. He's six now.
Copy !req
232. Nancy always wanted a family.
Copy !req
233. And I guess I did, too.
Copy !req
234. But we can't have kids of our own, so...
Copy !req
235. It's not going well.
Copy !req
236. He's a beautiful boy.
Copy !req
237. At first, I thought he was just quiet,
you know, a quiet baby,
Copy !req
238. nothing wrong with that.
Copy !req
239. He can speak,
Copy !req
240. he just won't.
Copy !req
241. I feel like we're failing him somehow.
Copy !req
242. I'm sure you're not.
Copy !req
243. Maybe he was like this before.
Copy !req
244. But it's a real strain.
Copy !req
245. It's supposed to be this great thing,
having a son.
Copy !req
246. God, Bill.
Copy !req
247. I'm sorry to hear that.
Copy !req
248. When the car was spinning out, I just...
Copy !req
249. You have no idea what I'm trying to say,
do you?
Copy !req
250. Not exactly...
Copy !req
251. but I want to.
Copy !req
252. I don't know either.
Copy !req
253. It's nothing, it's fine.
Copy !req
254. Seriously, Bill...
Copy !req
255. Call Debbie.
Copy !req
256. Tell her she can come get us
in the morning.
Copy !req
257. Come on, kid.
Copy !req
258. You don't expect us to buy
your mercy horseshit.
Copy !req
259. I think what Agent Tench means is—
Copy !req
260. I think I've had enough science
for one day.
Copy !req
261. - Well, should we hear it again?
- Eventually, yeah.
Copy !req
262. Okay. So there are two triggers,
one right after the other, for Rissell.
Copy !req
263. Maybe trigger is the wrong word.
Too facile.
Copy !req
264. Also, in law enforcement,
has more than one meaning.
Copy !req
265. What about stresses? Stressors.
Copy !req
266. Let's make that our term of art.
Copy !req
267. Stress is more internal anyway.
It's more appropriate to our focus.
Copy !req
268. So, two stressors set Rissell off?
Copy !req
269. Her letter, obviously.
Copy !req
270. So, the girlfriend writes him
a Dear John letter and he—
Copy !req
271. Rissell cracks.
Copy !req
272. - But he doesn't call her or write back.
- No, he goes down there.
Copy !req
273. - Stalks her like a hunter.
Not like a hunter.
Copy !req
274. He doesn't kill the girlfriend,
he only watches her with her new beau.
Copy !req
275. - Big difference.
- "Beau"?
Copy !req
276. So what if Rissell doesn't mean to kill
anyone at this point?
Copy !req
277. He's still on track for rape,
Copy !req
278. but it's this first victim's compliance
Copy !req
279. that just kind of pushes him
over the edge.
Copy !req
280. He kills the first one
because she likes it or pretends to?
Copy !req
281. It's dominoes.
Copy !req
282. Her compliance makes him angry.
Copy !req
283. He throws her out of the car,
she tries to escape.
Copy !req
284. Where is it? He says,
"The whole thing is just fucking chaos."
Copy !req
285. - He needed to reassert control.
- Exactly.
Copy !req
286. Which means that the victim's behavior
is also a stressor.
Copy !req
287. I mean, it may be that they can't change
the ultimate outcome,
Copy !req
288. but they can affect
when and how it happens.
Copy !req
289. Exactly what I was thinking,
which is why I asked the question.
Copy !req
290. But...
Copy !req
291. But what?
Copy !req
292. Isn't that just life?
Copy !req
293. Your girlfriend dumps you?
Copy !req
294. You're trying to be intimate with someone,
and it goes wrong?
Copy !req
295. Obviously, not that wrong, but it seems
like Rissell just couldn't hack life.
Copy !req
296. Well, what else is a criminal except
somebody who can't function in society?
Copy !req
297. If we want to be reductive,
Copy !req
298. we can say these men can't handle
normal stages of development—
Copy !req
299. Why do I get the sense
"reductive" is your worst insult?
Copy !req
300. Not at all. I meant to say you were right.
Copy !req
301. How would most men feel
if they were being intimate with a woman
Copy !req
302. and they sensed
that she wasn't enjoying herself?
Copy !req
303. Come on, be scientists.
Copy !req
304. Disappointed.
Copy !req
305. - It would feel awful.
- Right.
Copy !req
306. You want her to have a good time.
Copy !req
307. But when Rissell sensed
that his victim was enjoying herself,
Copy !req
308. it turned him into a murderer.
Copy !req
309. So, yes, what happens to these men
is normal,
Copy !req
310. but the way that they process it is not.
Copy !req
311. That's our goal, to dig into the why,
like you did with Kemper.
Copy !req
312. We're headed to Altoona
for Road School.
Copy !req
313. We'll try and see Rissell again
when we get back, if he'll see us.
Copy !req
314. This is gonna take twice as long
if you can't do the interviews full-time.
Copy !req
315. What is it? A question of money,
of institutional rigidity,
Copy !req
316. scheduling, what?
Copy !req
317. All of the above.
Copy !req
318. You know, I've been in academia
all my life, let me see what I can do.
Copy !req
319. Honey, I gotta go.
Copy !req
320. Brian.
Copy !req
321. Come on.
Copy !req
322. Give your father a hug.
Copy !req
323. Say goodbye.
Copy !req
324. See you soon, son.
Copy !req
325. Ready?
Copy !req
326. Yep.
Copy !req
327. All yours.
Copy !req
328. Ain't easy to get
on the East Coast.
Copy !req
329. No, it's not.
Copy !req
330. So you're not from the East Coast,
originally?
Copy !req
331. What?
Copy !req
332. I'm sorry, I missed that.
I'm a little deaf.
Copy !req
333. I was just asking if you consider yourself
an East Coaster?
Copy !req
334. You don't have that in your file?
Copy !req
335. You were born in Wellington,
South Kansas.
Copy !req
336. You're the youngest of three,
Copy !req
337. and your parents divorced
when you were seven.
Copy !req
338. That's all in the file,
just not what you have to say about it.
Copy !req
339. Yeah, my mom blamed that on me.
No idea why.
Copy !req
340. My brother and sister were around,
Copy !req
341. but it was always on me
when things went bad.
Copy !req
342. Pretty soon after,
Mom up and married Hank.
Copy !req
343. - Dragged us out to Sacramento.
- You wanted to stay in Kansas?
Copy !req
344. Be with my real father? You bet.
Copy !req
345. I did not want to be in California,
that's for sure.
Copy !req
346. Nobody wanted me there, either.
Copy !req
347. Did your mother say
she didn't want you there?
Copy !req
348. Why you always want to do that after?
Copy !req
349. Crush the can.
Copy !req
350. It feels good.
Copy !req
351. Yeah, maybe.
Copy !req
352. What made you think
nobody wanted you in California?
Copy !req
353. Mom wanted to be with Hank.
Copy !req
354. And Hank didn't want to raise
somebody else's kids,
Copy !req
355. so he bought us shit.
Copy !req
356. Thought that'd be enough.
When I was seven, he bought me a gun.
Copy !req
357. - He bought you a gun?
- BB gun.
Copy !req
358. My brother and sister were drinking,
smoking a lot of weed,
Copy !req
359. doing all kinds of shit.
Copy !req
360. Sometimes they'd share.
Copy !req
361. When I was nine,
I shot my cousin in the ass with that gun.
Copy !req
362. That made me star of the show. I mean,
everybody fucking hated my cousin.
Copy !req
363. So you kids were left all alone.
Copy !req
364. Hank broke the fucking thing over my head.
Copy !req
365. He beat you?
- Yeah.
Copy !req
366. It's how I burst my eardrum.
Copy !req
367. I got into all kinds of shit, man.
Copy !req
368. Broke into some lady's house,
stole a hundred bucks.
Copy !req
369. Mom and Hank divorced when I was 12,
that was kind of my doing.
Copy !req
370. Fourteen, things got a little worse.
Copy !req
371. Burglary, larceny, car theft, rape twice.
Copy !req
372. My mom somehow got them
to send me to Florida.
Copy !req
373. Thanks, Ma!
Copy !req
374. I get back. I'm 17, living on my own,
working double shifts at Pizza Hut.
Copy !req
375. Nobody wanted me, man.
Copy !req
376. Nobody on this earth ever wanted me.
Copy !req
377. Put that on your fucking tape.
Copy !req
378. If only they'd let me stay with my dad...
Copy !req
379. it'd all be different.
Copy !req
380. I might even be a lawyer.
Copy !req
381. - So your dad wanted you?
Have a nice car.
Copy !req
382. House.
Copy !req
383. Be out in the backyard
perfecting my recipe for barbecue.
Copy !req
384. I'd have found my way.
Copy !req
385. So Rissell's the real victim here?
Copy !req
386. That's how he sees it, sure.
Copy !req
387. A pathological liar who murdered
five women sees himself as the victim.
Copy !req
388. And we're giving him a shoulder to cry on.
Copy !req
389. We're not giving him a shoulder to cry on.
Copy !req
390. We're not flattering him. Or helping him.
Copy !req
391. We're using him.
Copy !req
392. Yeah, okay.
Copy !req
393. Motive, means, opportunity.
Copy !req
394. The three pillars of criminal
what, why, who.
Copy !req
395. What happened...
Copy !req
396. When I'm involved
in a hostage negotiation,
Copy !req
397. the perpetrator is standing
right in front of me.
Copy !req
398. - Not a bad group tonight.
- Yeah.
Copy !req
399. We got one?
Copy !req
400. Look at him just standing there,
watching us.
Copy !req
401. He's just having a cigarette
before he heads home.
Copy !req
402. See how he's deliberately trying
not to look at us?
Copy !req
403. He's screwing up the nerve to approach.
Copy !req
404. - I put the over-under at half a minute.
- I'll definitely take under.
Copy !req
405. - That's a bet.
- Loser buys dinner.
Copy !req
406. Look out, he's on the move.
Copy !req
407. Hey.
Copy !req
408. You guys mind if I bother you a minute?
Copy !req
409. Sure. What's up?
Copy !req
410. Beverly Jean Shaw, 22.
Copy !req
411. Never came home
from her babysitting job.
Copy !req
412. Four days later, we find her in the dump
on Wopsononock Mountain.
Copy !req
413. Um, based on stomach contents,
we think she was killed right away,
Copy !req
414. around midnight Wednesday.
Copy !req
415. She was sitting like this at the dump
for four days?
Copy !req
416. Well, no, um...
Copy !req
417. See, there wasn't enough, um...
Copy !req
418. If she had been at the dump four days—
Copy !req
419. We'd see more insect infestation
and animal trauma.
Copy !req
420. So, between when she was murdered
on Wednesday
Copy !req
421. and the body was discovered
four days later,
Copy !req
422. she had to be someplace else?
Copy !req
423. Her breasts.
Copy !req
424. They were, I guess you'd say... amputated.
Copy !req
425. - Um, we have not been able to locate them.
- Was this postmortem or...
Copy !req
426. Coroner said she was
already dead. Yes, sir.
Copy !req
427. He blacked both her eyes,
Copy !req
428. broke her jaw, multiple stab wounds.
Copy !req
429. You can see he kind of
frogged her legs out there.
Copy !req
430. And there was, um...
Copy !req
431. Sorry.
Copy !req
432. We don't get this kind of thing.
Copy !req
433. - It's hard to—
- Take your time.
Copy !req
434. There was an incision. From her—
Copy !req
435. From her vagina to her, um... anus.
Copy !req
436. - God damn it. I'm sorry.
- You're doing fine.
Copy !req
437. - The family local?
- Uh...
Copy !req
438. Parents upstate. Fiancé in town.
Copy !req
439. - You don't think somebody local did this?
- Hard to say at this point.
Copy !req
440. I go to church with these people.
Copy !req
441. We get peeping Toms, sure.
But something like this?
Copy !req
442. It doesn't make sense.
Copy !req
443. To go from shoplifters
and underage kids buying beer to...
Copy !req
444. what happened to Beverly...
Has to be an outsider.
Copy !req
445. Draped over the ironing board here,
is that human hair?
Copy !req
446. Yes, sir.
Copy !req
447. You have it?
Copy !req
448. Sure.
Copy !req
449. Yeah, Forensics bagged it up.
Copy !req
450. It's all about Forensics.
I am starting to appreciate that.
Copy !req
451. And the ironing board,
you take that as well?
Copy !req
452. Uh, I mean, we dusted it for fingerprints
and everything, but, uh...
Copy !req
453. But you do think the unsub scalped Beverly
and then draped it over the ironing board?
Copy !req
454. That mean something?
Copy !req
455. Everything in this photo has meaning.
Copy !req
456. If the unsub meant to display the hair,
he was saying something.
Copy !req
457. - He could've put the hair anywhere.
- Right, no, I get it now. Uh...
Copy !req
458. Soon as Forensics confirms
it's Beverly's hair—
Copy !req
459. I'm sorry, what?
Copy !req
460. Well, we shouldn't jump ahead
of Forensics, am I right?
Copy !req
461. I think, in this case, we have
a dead body missing a chunk of hair,
Copy !req
462. a big chunk of hair nearby,
so we can go out on a limb and assume—
Copy !req
463. I think what Agent Ford is trying to say,
in his own way,
Copy !req
464. is we're behind the eight ball here,
we've come late to the party.
Copy !req
465. We're gonna have to go over ground
you've covered:
Copy !req
466. witnesses, crime scene.
Copy !req
467. We don't mean that as a challenge to you.
It's not any kind of a criticism.
Copy !req
468. We're just trying to catch up.
Am I right, Agent Ford?
Copy !req
469. Absolutely.
Copy !req
470. We may ask some obvious questions
and maybe a few you haven't thought of.
Copy !req
471. But it's not a contest or a competition.
We're all on the same side.
Copy !req
472. - Okay?
- Sure.
Copy !req
473. Let's go through the rest.
Copy !req
474. I'm curious why you're cutting this guy
so much slack.
Copy !req
475. He's never seen this kind of thing before.
He's rattled. It's not his fault.
Copy !req
476. Without a doubt you have more experience,
but why rub it in his face?
Copy !req
477. I'm not trying to make you feel bad.
Copy !req
478. Maybe a little.
Copy !req
479. The point is, local cops want to catch
their guy as much as we do, maybe more.
Copy !req
480. For them, it's not just theoretical,
it's where they live.
Copy !req
481. This is where your focus should be.
Copy !req
482. Not on the crime scene, not on the corpse,
not on the schematics.
Copy !req
483. Focus on Beverly.
Copy !req
484. What did the killer see in her?
Copy !req
485. We've learned that this is
a crucial detail, and not the only one.
Copy !req
486. Based on the facts
Detective Ocasek laid out earlier,
Copy !req
487. our methodology tells us
we're looking for a white male.
Copy !req
488. These crimes rarely cross racial lines.
Copy !req
489. He's probably around Beverly's age.
Copy !req
490. A killer will usually choose someone
smaller and weaker than himself.
Copy !req
491. He's a loner, hunts at night.
Copy !req
492. I'm sorry, "hunts"?
Is that a figure of speech?
Copy !req
493. It is not.
Copy !req
494. Coroner's report said Beverly
was killed and then butchered.
Copy !req
495. Isn't that what hunters do?
Copy !req
496. We're probably looking for a loner.
Copy !req
497. These men like to explore
the fantasy first,
Copy !req
498. bondage pornography, hardcore material.
Copy !req
499. It gives them a certain...
attitude towards women.
Copy !req
500. Hence, a loner.
Copy !req
501. Close-knit community like this,
you would've spotted that by now.
Copy !req
502. I think our man is an outsider,
probably a drifter.
Copy !req
503. Most likely, he'll move on from here
and kill again.
Copy !req
504. Again?
Copy !req
505. The killer thought of Beverly Jean
as just another piece of trash.
Copy !req
506. Folks loved Beverly Jean.
Trusted her with their kids.
Copy !req
507. Had to be a drifter, like you say.
Copy !req
508. Some stranger
passing through town.
Copy !req
509. All that pretty hair caught his eye.
Copy !req
510. He needed to possess it, then destroy it.
Copy !req
511. You talk to the fiancé?
Copy !req
512. There's only so much you can get
out of a man in that state.
Copy !req
513. Benjamin was still in shock.
Gotta take all that into account.
Copy !req
514. Well, I'm sure you know your people,
but let's just cover our bases.
Copy !req
515. And let's try to get him cold.
Make some excuse when you call.
Copy !req
516. Don't mention the FBI, or even the murder.
Copy !req
517. Help us get an unguarded response.
Copy !req
518. Soon as Benjamin gets back into town.
Copy !req
519. - Back into town?
- You let the fiancé leave?
Copy !req
520. He went up north for a bit
to be with his relatives.
Copy !req
521. You need to be with family
at times like this.
Copy !req
522. He'll be back soon. I'll vouch for that.
Copy !req
523. He'll be back.
Copy !req
524. Where was the body found?
Copy !req
525. Up here to the left.
Copy !req
526. Here's the ironing board.
Copy !req
527. Right. I'll have a couple of the boys
come pick it up. Sorry about that.
Copy !req
528. No apology necessary.
We're all learning as we go.
Copy !req
529. You can see why I went easy on the fiancé.
Copy !req
530. Ugly end for someone you just proposed to.
Copy !req
531. How long were they engaged?
Copy !req
532. Couple months, I think.
Copy !req
533. Could be he felt trapped.
Copy !req
534. By a pretty, young blonde?
Copy !req
535. Remember what Wendy said?
Copy !req
536. A colleague of ours, a psychologist.
Copy !req
537. Events we process as good news
sometimes hit these killers the wrong way.
Copy !req
538. Huh. That's interesting.
Copy !req
539. Who found the body?
Copy !req
540. A welder, Alvin Moran,
out taking his dog for a hike.
Copy !req
541. - At the dump?
- He have an alibi?
Copy !req
542. Alibi? He came to us.
Why's he need an alibi?
Copy !req
543. Sometimes the killer will
insinuate himself into the investigation.
Copy !req
544. Even report his own crime?
- Mm-hmm.
Copy !req
545. Can we talk to him?
Copy !req
546. Yeah.
Copy !req
547. Excuse me!
Copy !req
548. Mr. Moran?
Copy !req
549. Mr. Moran?
Copy !req
550. You remember me, Mr. Moran?
Copy !req
551. These men from the FBI
would like to talk to you. That all right?
Copy !req
552. Great.
Copy !req
553. We're told you found Beverly Jean's body.
Copy !req
554. How'd you happen to find yourself
at the dump?
Copy !req
555. Hiking. Wopsononock Mountain.
Copy !req
556. Like to take the trail, clear my head.
Copy !req
557. - Get a break from the wife and kids?
That's right.
Copy !req
558. Get up there a few times a week.
Take the dog for a walk.
Copy !req
559. Still not clear
how that puts you at the dump.
Copy !req
560. - The path comes in pretty close.
- Does it?
Copy !req
561. You see any sign of a hiking trail
out by the dump, Bill?
Copy !req
562. The other side of the railroad tracks,
up the hill.
Copy !req
563. Looks like a bunch of trees
from where you're standing.
Copy !req
564. But if there's no clear view
from the dump to the trail...
Copy !req
565. Are you really FBI?
Copy !req
566. Am I under suspicion here?
Copy !req
567. Okay.
Copy !req
568. So I come off the trail to take a piss,
no law against it.
Copy !req
569. There may be, actually,
but let's leave that for now.
Copy !req
570. You go to take a piss,
you see Beverly Jean's body...
Copy !req
571. I thought it was a store mannequin
or something.
Copy !req
572. Wouldn't your dog
have gone straight for it?
Copy !req
573. - Might have, but that's not what happened.
- What kind of dog?
Copy !req
574. - Retriever.
- And he didn't sniff it out first?
Copy !req
575. That seems odd.
Copy !req
576. - He's an old dog.
- Not too old for a hike.
Copy !req
577. I took care of my business, I collected
my dog, and I went to the police.
Copy !req
578. Right away? Few hours later? Next day?
Copy !req
579. Couple hours later. Maybe that night.
Copy !req
580. It was actually morning
when you came in, sir.
Copy !req
581. Why'd you wait so long
to report the body, Mr. Moran?
Copy !req
582. You're talking to the FBI, Mr. Moran.
If we want to find something out, we will.
Copy !req
583. I was scared the cops
might want me for it, okay?
Copy !req
584. My wife talked me out of that.
I did my duty as a citizen.
Copy !req
585. You thought they'd want you for a murder?
Copy !req
586. I seen cops get desperate,
grab whoever they can get.
Copy !req
587. But why you?
Copy !req
588. I got a bit of a record, all right?
Copy !req
589. It ain't much. I lit up a few fires
when I was a kid, got into a few fights.
Copy !req
590. I ain't proud of it.
Copy !req
591. Came here, met my wife.
Copy !req
592. - Family man now.
- Before that, did you move around a lot?
Copy !req
593. Not a good way to live.
I feel settled now.
Copy !req
594. Is that your statement, Mr. Moran?
Copy !req
595. I come into town,
grab a beer now and then.
Copy !req
596. I seen Beverly Jean a few times.
Copy !req
597. You saw Beverly Jean at a bar?
Copy !req
598. At The Kettle.
Copy !req
599. - Finally got up the nerve.
- The nerve to do what?
Copy !req
600. To buy her a drink.
Copy !req
601. She wasn't interested, end of story.
Copy !req
602. Maybe I asked her more than once.
Copy !req
603. More than once that night at the bar,
or on more than one occasion?
Copy !req
604. I guess you'd say
on more than one occasion.
Copy !req
605. - He's too old and too married.
He was a drifter until recently.
Copy !req
606. Beverly Jean rejected him.
Copy !req
607. He's got a record.
He tried to help the police.
Copy !req
608. And his alibi?
Home watching TV with the wife?
Copy !req
609. If a man like that took Beverly Jean,
he'd draw it out, make her suffer.
Copy !req
610. You saw the photos,
he must've tortured her for hours.
Copy !req
611. Those wounds were inflicted
posthumously. Can't forget.
Copy !req
612. You said that before.
What difference does that make?
Copy !req
613. When you're married, it's a contract.
Copy !req
614. There's children, a mortgage,
Copy !req
615. a house to keep up,
almost like a business.
Copy !req
616. Only you can't quit. She can't fire you.
Copy !req
617. Stock goes up, stock goes down...
Copy !req
618. doesn't matter, you're trapped.
Copy !req
619. Unless you want to bring on the lawyers
and open Pandora's box.
Copy !req
620. Resentment builds on both sides.
Copy !req
621. A thousand tiny cuts.
Copy !req
622. If Alvin Moran had a married man's anger,
Copy !req
623. he'd have tortured, then killed her.
Copy !req
624. No question in my mind.
Copy !req
625. Maybe we should talk to his wife.
See if there's anything there.
Copy !req
626. I mean, she's the whole alibi.
Copy !req
627. Wouldn't mind checking it holds up.
Copy !req
628. Mrs. Moran, thank you for coming in.
Copy !req
629. My name is Bill Tench.
This is my partner, Holden Ford.
Copy !req
630. Hello.
Copy !req
631. I don't understand.
I can't call my husband?
Copy !req
632. - Aren't I supposed to get my phone call?
- You're not under arrest, Mrs. Moran.
Copy !req
633. These men are from the FBI.
Copy !req
634. They just want to ask you
a couple questions.
Copy !req
635. Have you been following the investigation?
Copy !req
636. Can't look at that. Poor girl.
Copy !req
637. - Wouldn't hurt a fly.
- You knew her?
Copy !req
638. Can we ask how you knew her?
Copy !req
639. She was almost our babysitter.
- Almost?
Copy !req
640. Mrs. Moran?
Copy !req
641. We talked with her about it.
Copy !req
642. When she left,
Alvin wouldn't shut up about the girl.
Copy !req
643. Meaning?
Copy !req
644. You know what I mean.
Copy !req
645. It's best if we don't have to guess,
ma'am.
Copy !req
646. She was young, and skinny, and...
Copy !req
647. "Oh, such pretty blonde hair."
Copy !req
648. Didn't need that in my house.
Copy !req
649. Not with two little kids in the picture.
Copy !req
650. What do I look like?
Copy !req
651. Were you aware that your husband
made overtures to Beverly
Copy !req
652. on several occasions?
Copy !req
653. Didn't I just say
he had a thing for the poor girl?
Copy !req
654. Alvin does this.
Copy !req
655. It's like sportfishing.
He doesn't mean anything by it.
Copy !req
656. We were told he was home with you
watching television
Copy !req
657. the night Beverly disappeared.
Copy !req
658. You think Alvin did this?
Copy !req
659. Oh! No.
Copy !req
660. I mean, I'd love for him
to get a good scare,
Copy !req
661. bothering a girl half his age,
Copy !req
662. but... no.
Copy !req
663. The idiot was with me.
Copy !req
664. The whole night?
Copy !req
665. The whole night.
Copy !req
666. Okay, her husband made a pass
at a younger woman. He's an idiot.
Copy !req
667. But so are a million other men.
Copy !req
668. I don't see any of the anger
you've been talking about.
Copy !req
669. So lo and behold,
we're back to the fiancé.
Copy !req
670. Follow your own logic, Bill.
Copy !req
671. The anger makes no sense
in a young couple either.
Copy !req
672. This could be the first in a sequence.
Copy !req
673. Nine times out of ten, it's the boyfriend,
the husband, somebody close.
Copy !req
674. Nine times isn't every time, Bill.
Copy !req
675. Listen, uh...
Copy !req
676. Can't say how much
I appreciate all your help.
Copy !req
677. Sorry if I got off a little shaky there
at the start.
Copy !req
678. I'm gonna stick with Alvin,
if it's all the same, keep you posted.
Copy !req
679. So you're in the middle
of an ongoing investigation?
Copy !req
680. A local detective asked for our help.
What else could we do?
Copy !req
681. Tell them you have more important things
to do with your time.
Copy !req
682. We've been consulting with local cops
for years. No reason to change that now.
Copy !req
683. My assumption is you're good at your job.
Copy !req
684. Which means you're gonna be more
focused on solving an actual crime
Copy !req
685. than the theoretical work we're doing.
Copy !req
686. - And that's bad?
It's not good or bad.
Copy !req
687. We can't end crime, no matter what we do.
Copy !req
688. But in the long run, I think that
our project could have a deeper impact
Copy !req
689. than solving a single murder.
Copy !req
690. We can do both. It's not an issue.
Copy !req
691. What jumped out
when you were talking to Rissell?
Copy !req
692. He seems aware of the trap
of his childhood.
Copy !req
693. How things might be different
if he was allowed to stay with his dad.
Copy !req
694. Kemper said something similar.
Copy !req
695. They're both playing the victim,
looking for sympathy.
Copy !req
696. I think it's more complicated.
Copy !req
697. I think you're both right.
I mean, it's self-pity, absolutely.
Copy !req
698. And the psychopath understands
how that plays to his audience.
Copy !req
699. - Exactly.
- But the complicated part
Copy !req
700. is that they actually believe it.
They have to.
Copy !req
701. I mean, if they admitted
that they rape and murder for pleasure,
Copy !req
702. it would destroy them.
Copy !req
703. There's a tension.
Copy !req
704. They need to be seen
to have power over someone,
Copy !req
705. and yet circumstance demands
that they erase the only witness,
Copy !req
706. which means they have to do
the whole thing over again.
Copy !req
707. It must be hell.
Copy !req
708. So the self-pity angle works.
You have sympathy for both of them.
Copy !req
709. Yeah, of course.
How else could I do my job?
Copy !req
710. Do Kemper and Rissell
have other common traits?
Copy !req
711. That what you're doing with these cards,
figuring out similarities?
Copy !req
712. And differences.
I've been going through their files.
Copy !req
713. I'm trying to frame an overall taxonomy,
except I don't know where to start.
Copy !req
714. The crime scene.
Copy !req
715. Kemper's like a general,
planning his campaigns.
Copy !req
716. - But Rissell—
- Didn't intend to kill his first victim.
Copy !req
717. All of his victims seem spontaneous.
He just walks away when he's done.
Copy !req
718. Kemper took photographs,
and dissected the victims,
Copy !req
719. and was very good at hiding the remains.
Copy !req
720. So could we say "systematic"
and "anti-systematic"?
Copy !req
721. Maybe something a little less...
Copy !req
722. Something even a beat cop
could understand straight away.
Copy !req
723. Right.
Like "organized" and "disorganized."
Copy !req
724. Okay. Let's try it.
Copy !req
725. What goes where?
Copy !req
726. Well...
Copy !req
727. "High intelligence"
would go under "organized."
Copy !req
728. "Low intelligence": "disorganized."
Copy !req
729. - What do you think?
- Definitely.
Copy !req
730. The class is great, but he's obsessed
with the meaning of shit.
Copy !req
731. Does shit have meaning?
Copy !req
732. All shit has meaning, man.
Copy !req
733. Is that her?
Copy !req
734. No. Wendy's more...
Copy !req
735. not that.
Copy !req
736. Look at you.
Copy !req
737. Dr. Wendy has you all nervous.
Should I be jealous?
Copy !req
738. Would I have invited her to go out with us
if I was interested in her?
Copy !req
739. I've seen men do stranger things.
Copy !req
740. - So she's married.
- How does that follow?
Copy !req
741. If you're not interested,
she must be married.
Copy !req
742. For a man who picks up strange women
in bars, you have your scruples.
Copy !req
743. Thank you.
Copy !req
744. I don't think she is married.
Copy !req
745. That's her.
Copy !req
746. No.
Copy !req
747. Do you plan on getting married?
Copy !req
748. Having kids, the whole thing?
Copy !req
749. Are you proposing, Holden Ford?
Copy !req
750. Just curious.
Copy !req
751. - Your parents have a good marriage?
- I have no idea.
Copy !req
752. - Where's this coming from?
- The study.
Copy !req
753. We're talking a lot about parents.
Copy !req
754. Harsh mothers, absent fathers.
Copy !req
755. All fathers are absent fathers.
Copy !req
756. That's definitely her.
Copy !req
757. - No.
Copy !req
758. Hello.
Copy !req
759. Hi.
Copy !req
760. - Wendy Carr.
- Deborah Mitford.
Copy !req
761. It's a pleasure.
Copy !req
762. Thank you so much for the invitation.
It was unexpected, but appreciated.
Copy !req
763. Yeah, for a fed, he's not so bad
at having a good time.
Copy !req
764. Are you in law enforcement also?
Copy !req
765. No, I'm doing postgrad, actually.
Copy !req
766. - Sociology at UVA.
- What's your concentration?
Copy !req
767. Social deviance.
- So... Durkheim?
Copy !req
768. - Yes.
- Oh, God.
Copy !req
769. Because I didn't know who Durkheim was...
Copy !req
770. - Or Goring, or Blumer.
- It's fine.
Copy !req
771. I'm not intimidated being around women
who are smarter than me.
Copy !req
772. Men often say that,
but they rarely mean it.
Copy !req
773. Holden means it.
Copy !req
774. He has a lot of flaws,
but surprisingly, that's not one of them.
Copy !req
775. - I'm— Excuse me.
- Yes.
Copy !req
776. Could I get a Manhattan?
And will you have another round?
Copy !req
777. - Yeah, thank you.
- Yeah.
Copy !req
778. So he called you directly?
Copy !req
779. No, Andrea called.
Said he wanted to meet with us.
Copy !req
780. Any idea what this is about?
Copy !req
781. No. Usually, it's about finding clarity.
Copy !req
782. But he asked for me specifically?
Copy !req
783. All three of us.
Copy !req
784. Come in.
Copy !req
785. Dr. Carr, Unit Chief Shepard.
Nice to meet you finally.
Copy !req
786. You as well.
Copy !req
787. Sit, please. All of you.
Copy !req
788. So, how's everything? Progressing?
Copy !req
789. Uh, yes, thank you.
Copy !req
790. - Fine, thanks.
- Slowly, but yes.
Copy !req
791. Can I help with anything?
Copy !req
792. Is there anything I need to know?
Copy !req
793. - Sir, if this is about the car—
- Nobody cares about the car.
Copy !req
794. It was insured and I assume driven
by your protégé.
Copy !req
795. - It's not important who was driving.
I agree.
Copy !req
796. Dr. Carr, I'm aware of your consulting
with Bill over the years
Copy !req
797. and your help framing certain
psychological concepts with the BSU.
Copy !req
798. Uh, yes, a handful of times.
Special Agent Tench was—
Copy !req
799. I assume that meant you understood
how things were done here at Quantico.
Copy !req
800. I assumed the same for your cohorts.
Copy !req
801. You might think it is my job
to impede your progress
Copy !req
802. with my insistence on timelines
and established protocols.
Copy !req
803. - No, sir. Not at all.
- That is not my job.
Copy !req
804. My job is to provide guidance
and quite a bit of protection.
Copy !req
805. - I don't understand.
- Clearly.
Copy !req
806. You have stepped
outside the shade of my umbrella
Copy !req
807. and you are now exposed
to direct sunlight.
Copy !req
808. I applied for grant money
from several sources
Copy !req
809. anticipating a response months from now.
Copy !req
810. Much to my surprise,
Copy !req
811. the Law Enforcement Assistance
Administration was already aware
Copy !req
812. of our needs and activities.
Copy !req
813. I see. I had no intention
of embarrassing you, Unit Chief Shepard.
Copy !req
814. I was at a fund-raiser for the university
and I was talking to some—
Copy !req
815. Yes, talking to people outside the FBI
Copy !req
816. about something
you were not even supposed to be aware of.
Copy !req
817. The LEAA explained
that the application was anticipated.
Copy !req
818. How could that be, I wondered.
Copy !req
819. It seems they know more
about what's going on in our basement
Copy !req
820. than I was comfortable including
in the application.
Copy !req
821. - I so apologize. It—
- Sir, this is my fault.
Copy !req
822. Your research has been awarded $200,000.
Copy !req
823. - What?
There's more.
Copy !req
824. As I said, I applied to more
than one place for funding.
Copy !req
825. The National Institute of Justice
heard about the LEAA,
Copy !req
826. and they are in competition,
Copy !req
827. so the NIJ has awarded you
an additional $185,000.
Copy !req
828. You can't be serious.
Copy !req
829. This amount of money
comes with considerable scrutiny.
Copy !req
830. And I'm not talking about bookkeeping,
Copy !req
831. although you will certainly be required
to keep meticulous records.
Copy !req
832. I'm talking about Congress having
a real interest in everything we do.
Copy !req
833. So much for the protection
I might have afforded you.
Copy !req
834. Congratulations, I suppose.
Copy !req
835. Have a nice day.
Copy !req