1. In the criminal justice system,
Copy !req
2. sexually based offenses
Copy !req
3. are considered especially heinous.
Copy !req
4. In New York City,
the dedicated detectives
Copy !req
5. who investigate these vicious felonies
Copy !req
6. are members of an elite squad
Copy !req
7. known as the Special Victims Unit.
Copy !req
8. These are their stories.
Copy !req
9. There's no reason
for you to be scared, honey.
Copy !req
10. I don't bite.
Copy !req
11. Do I look scared?
Copy !req
12. You could sit a little bit closer.
Copy !req
13. How's this?
Copy !req
14. Are you ready for some fun, Daddy?
Copy !req
15. Call me Adam, I don't need
the whole Daddy shtick.
Copy !req
16. What do you need?
Copy !req
17. How 'bout seeing what you look like
Copy !req
18. underneath this dress, huh?
Copy !req
19. That can be arranged.
Copy !req
20. Ooh.
Copy !req
21. Oh!
Copy !req
22. God, you're hot.
Copy !req
23. How old are you?
Copy !req
24. It's not polite to ask a lady her age.
Copy !req
25. Good morning.
Copy !req
26. Is it? You tell me.
Copy !req
27. Considering I've barely closed my eyes
Copy !req
28. since Rob Miller got out of prison.
Copy !req
29. He's targeting me, Fin.
Copy !req
30. He wants me to know that
he has all the power.
Copy !req
31. Liv, we have a unmarked car
on your block,
Copy !req
32. one in front of Noah's school.
Copy !req
33. There's no way he can get at you.
Copy !req
34. There's no way he can get at me?
Copy !req
35. He walked right into that restaurant
Copy !req
36. and introduced himself to Noah.
Copy !req
37. I should have shot the son of a bitch.
Copy !req
38. No, not so loud.
Stone is in your office, okay?
Copy !req
39. I called him in.
Copy !req
40. Okay.
Copy !req
41. - Hey.
- Hey.
Copy !req
42. Wish I had better news.
Copy !req
43. Please don't tell me it's worse
Copy !req
44. than Rob Miller making bail.
Copy !req
45. Feds dropped the charges.
Copy !req
46. Damn.
Copy !req
47. He blackmailed the judge,
he threatened witnesses,
Copy !req
48. he threatened Nikki Staines.
Copy !req
49. We have him on tape saying,
"No Nikki, no case."
Copy !req
50. A federal judge ruled
that statement didn't rise
Copy !req
51. to the legal standard.
Copy !req
52. - What now?
- What about Nikki's rape?
Copy !req
53. There's nothing there. Nikki's scared.
Copy !req
54. She's claiming it was consensual.
Copy !req
55. I'll talk to her.
Copy !req
56. Oh, my baby. It's gonna be okay.
Copy !req
57. Why don't you go to your room
and lie down?
Copy !req
58. What kind of person...?
Copy !req
59. What?
Copy !req
60. Miller killed my daughter's dog.
Copy !req
61. - Are you sure?
- Yeah, I'm sure.
Copy !req
62. This is Penny's ashes right there.
Copy !req
63. The vet said that it was rat poison.
Copy !req
64. Now, the landlord didn't
put down any rat poison,
Copy !req
65. and I sure didn't put down
any rat poison.
Copy !req
66. So how?
Copy !req
67. My daughter said that
there's this woman
Copy !req
68. that offered Penny a treat
on their walk last night,
Copy !req
69. and she thought it was okay, right?
Copy !req
70. And then.. and then this
morning, the dog was...
Copy !req
71. Oh, Nikki, I'm so sorry.
Copy !req
72. Listen, the woman said,
Copy !req
73. "Say hello to your mom."
Copy !req
74. Why?
Copy !req
75. Rob Miller knows that
I wasn't gonna testify.
Copy !req
76. So that's why I'm here.
Copy !req
77. We need you to testify, Nikki.
Copy !req
78. Listen to me.
Copy !req
79. The Feds dropped the charges.
Copy !req
80. No.
Copy !req
81. No, no, no, no.
Copy !req
82. Absolutely not.
Copy !req
83. Okay, Nikki, just hear me out.
Copy !req
84. - Hear me...
- No!
Copy !req
85. Just hear me out. I understand.
Copy !req
86. So talk to me about
the Wally Stevens case,
Copy !req
87. the underage girls.
Copy !req
88. Miller obviously thought that
he'd be implicated,
Copy !req
89. and that's why he stole your phone.
Copy !req
90. For nothing!
Copy !req
91. There is not a word on that phone
Copy !req
92. that connects him to the case.
Copy !req
93. So why? What was he afraid of?
Copy !req
94. Can Wally put him at those sex parties?
Copy !req
95. - Tell me, what did he...
- I can't!
Copy !req
96. Attorney-client privilege, right?
Copy !req
97. Ever heard of it?
Copy !req
98. I'm not about to risk
getting myself disbarred.
Copy !req
99. Listen, I am incredibly appreciative
Copy !req
100. of what you've done for me,
Copy !req
101. Olivia, but you gotta go now.
Copy !req
102. Go now.
Copy !req
103. There has to be a way to tie Rob Miller
Copy !req
104. to Wally Stevens to the sex parties.
Copy !req
105. He blackmailed a judge,
he stole Nikki Staines' phone;
Copy !req
106. has to be connected.
Copy !req
107. What are we missing?
Copy !req
108. We've gone over the case
forwards and backwards.
Copy !req
109. - It's fallen apart.
- No.
Copy !req
110. The three 16-year-olds,
Copy !req
111. that we put at the party are
all backing off their story.
Copy !req
112. They're claiming that nothing happened.
Copy !req
113. Right, because he got to
them or got to their parents.
Copy !req
114. Check the bank accounts.
Copy !req
115. This guy doesn't leave
a fingerprint on the knife.
Copy !req
116. Fin, we have half a dozen witnesses...
Copy !req
117. We had witnesses. They all lawyered up.
Copy !req
118. Exactly! That's my point.
Copy !req
119. Judge Leonard retired to the Maldives.
Copy !req
120. This Wally Stevens guy's
untouchable, Double Jeopardy.
Copy !req
121. I know, Fin. I was there, thank you.
Copy !req
122. Lieu, listen,
I hear you on all of this,
Copy !req
123. but we got something from
the Harbor Unit
Copy !req
124. that we have to deal with right now.
Copy !req
125. A young female washed up
Copy !req
126. at a pier on the Hudson River.
Copy !req
127. Let's go.
Copy !req
128. Can't be more than 15, 16;
naked, no ID.
Copy !req
129. How long was she in the water?
Copy !req
130. My guess, a couple of hours,
day at the most.
Copy !req
131. The ME can give you
a more accurate time frame.
Copy !req
132. Did she fall off a boat?
Copy !req
133. Looks like every bone
in her body is broken.
Copy !req
134. Her organs are liquefied.
Copy !req
135. This girl fell out of the sky.
Copy !req
136. I just wanted to let you know,
Copy !req
137. that a uniformed officer
will be with the sitter,
Copy !req
138. when she picks Noah
up from school today.
Copy !req
139. Great. Thank you so much,
I appreciate it.
Copy !req
140. How is Noah doing?
Copy !req
141. Ah, he's thrilled.
Copy !req
142. He gets to ride to and
from school in a squad car,
Copy !req
143. but the school administration,
Copy !req
144. - not so much.
- Miller's a bad guy,
Copy !req
145. but do you really think
that he would go after
Copy !req
146. - a Lieutenant's kid?
- Rollins, I don't know,
Copy !req
147. what he's capable of.
Copy !req
148. The prelim report
from the ME on our Jane Doe.
Copy !req
149. No water in her lungs,
Copy !req
150. so she was dead
before she hit the river.
Copy !req
151. - So cause of death?
- OD.
Copy !req
152. China White,
highly-concentrated fentanyl.
Copy !req
153. This girl wasn't an addict.
Copy !req
154. There's no trace in her hair
or nails, no needle marks.
Copy !req
155. So she was given a hot shot.
Copy !req
156. The ME's ruling it
undetermined for now,
Copy !req
157. but they also found
the presence of semen
Copy !req
158. from two different men.
Copy !req
159. No DNA hits.
Copy !req
160. And there's no matches
with Missing Persons?
Copy !req
161. Not yet.
Copy !req
162. This girl is healthy,
she has expensive dental work,
Copy !req
163. she had parents, I mean,
Copy !req
164. they have to be looking for her.
Copy !req
165. Well, it's only been 24 hours.
Copy !req
166. We'll keep checking.
Copy !req
167. The ME just finished the autopsy.
Copy !req
168. Go. Go.
Copy !req
169. From the condition of the body,
Copy !req
170. I'd say she fell at least 2,000 feet.
Copy !req
171. All right, so small plane,
maybe a helicopter.
Copy !req
172. That's your department.
Copy !req
173. I can tell you that
she was in the water
Copy !req
174. less than 15 hours
before she washed ashore.
Copy !req
175. All right, great. So we get
Copy !req
176. a grid of the tidal pattern
from the Coast Guard,
Copy !req
177. we find out where she hit the water,
Copy !req
178. we cross reference that with the FAA,
for aircraft in that area...
Copy !req
179. So we know,
Copy !req
180. where, when, how...
Copy !req
181. we still don't know who.
Copy !req
182. Just getting to that.
Copy !req
183. At first, I was at a loss
for this little mermaid.
Copy !req
184. No tattoos, breast implants,
but then I found these.
Copy !req
185. What is that, a contact lens?
Copy !req
186. Two of them.
Copy !req
187. It's a miracle they stayed on
the eyeball through the fall.
Copy !req
188. Right, so we can contact
the manufacturer,
Copy !req
189. but the phrase "needle in a haystack"
comes to mind.
Copy !req
190. If you let me finish...
Copy !req
191. these lenses have
a unique prescription.
Copy !req
192. The left eye corrects 20/40.
Copy !req
193. The right, 20/400.
Copy !req
194. That kind of difference
in visual acuity
Copy !req
195. from eye to eye is one in a million.
Copy !req
196. Narrow it down enough for you?
Copy !req
197. Hmm.
Copy !req
198. - Hey.
- Hey.
Copy !req
199. Lindsay Parker, 16.
Copy !req
200. Her ophthalmologist confirmed
the contacts lens prescription.
Copy !req
201. She lived here with her parents,
Copy !req
202. Vanessa and Hugo Parker.
Copy !req
203. And they didn't file
a Missing Persons report
Copy !req
204. - for a 16-year-old girl.
- Well, she's 16.
Copy !req
205. These days, that's pretty independent.
Copy !req
206. I mean, who knows if they even
realize she's missing.
Copy !req
207. Yeah, this never gets easier, does it?
Copy !req
208. No.
Copy !req
209. Yes?
Copy !req
210. I'm Lieutenant Benson,
this is Detective Rollins.
Copy !req
211. We're from the Special Victims Unit.
Copy !req
212. So you found her?
Please tell me you found her.
Copy !req
213. - Can we come in?
- Of course.
Copy !req
214. Vanessa, it's the police.
Copy !req
215. Where's Lindsay? Where's my baby?
Copy !req
216. Lieutenant, Detective.
Copy !req
217. What are you doing here?
Copy !req
218. I'm just here to help, Lieutenant.
Copy !req
219. I can assure you.
Copy !req
220. Rob's been our family
attorney for ten years.
Copy !req
221. When Lindsay didn't come home,
he was my first call.
Copy !req
222. We need to speak with you
about Lindsay.
Copy !req
223. Lindsay was spending the weekend
Copy !req
224. at her friend Brooke's house
in Sag Harbor.
Copy !req
225. When she didn't answer
her phone, we called the house.
Copy !req
226. The parents told us
their daughter told them
Copy !req
227. that she was with us.
Copy !req
228. Okay, we're gonna need their contact.
Copy !req
229. Oh, of course.
Copy !req
230. We didn't call the police.
Copy !req
231. They're teenage girls
and Lindsay's been
Copy !req
232. to parties before and come home late.
Copy !req
233. And we just... we didn't wanna
embarrass her.
Copy !req
234. So we called Rob to hire
a private detective
Copy !req
235. if it came to that.
Copy !req
236. So, Mr. and Mrs. Parker...
Copy !req
237. we are so very sorry.
Copy !req
238. Wait, Lindsay's all right, isn't she?
Copy !req
239. - No.
- I'm sorry.
Copy !req
240. Is this your daughter?
Copy !req
241. Oh, my God.
Copy !req
242. Yes, wha... what...?
Copy !req
243. No. No, that's not Lindsay.
Copy !req
244. I mean, that's not...
That's not Lindsay.
Copy !req
245. What happened?
Was this some kind of accident?
Copy !req
246. We're still investigating.
Copy !req
247. We wanna find out
what happened to Lindsay,
Copy !req
248. so we're gonna need her phone records,
Copy !req
249. access to her social media...
Copy !req
250. - I can get you all of that.
- Okay.
Copy !req
251. Again, we're so very sorry.
Copy !req
252. If there's anything that
we can do to help you...
Copy !req
253. Her body... what are we supposed to do?
Copy !req
254. Where is she?
Copy !req
255. We'll help you make arrangements.
Copy !req
256. Yeah.
Copy !req
257. So, we'll give you some time,
Copy !req
258. and we'll be in touch.
Copy !req
259. If you have any questions, feel free.
Copy !req
260. I can show you out.
Copy !req
261. Anything the police need,
obviously, I'm here to help.
Copy !req
262. You know what?
I'm gonna meet you outside.
Copy !req
263. - You sure?
- Yep. I'm good, Amanda.
Copy !req
264. I'll be out front.
Copy !req
265. I realize this is awkward.
Copy !req
266. I don't even know where
to begin with you.
Copy !req
267. Do your clients know that
you're a criminal?
Copy !req
268. They're aware that
I was falsely charged.
Copy !req
269. Their daughter is dead;
shouldn't that be our priority?
Copy !req
270. Well, that's my top priority,
believe me.
Copy !req
271. But what is your role in all of this?
Copy !req
272. Excuse me?
Copy !req
273. Well, their 16-year-old daughter
Copy !req
274. was murdered one week
after you are released
Copy !req
275. from federal custody.
Copy !req
276. Do you hear yourself?
Copy !req
277. This is just a tragic coincidence.
Copy !req
278. I don't believe in coincidences.
Copy !req
279. What you're saying right now
is clear evidence
Copy !req
280. of police bias, your bias.
Copy !req
281. Okay.
Copy !req
282. Are you angry because I figured out
Copy !req
283. your little CSU ruse at the bar
two months ago?
Copy !req
284. Yeah, I'm angry.
Copy !req
285. I'm very angry,
but not because of that.
Copy !req
286. Or maybe because I declined
to pursue our relationship.
Copy !req
287. Don't flatter yourself.
Copy !req
288. If there weren't two grieving parents
Copy !req
289. in the next room, I'd break your jaw.
Copy !req
290. You'd regret that, Lieutenant.
Copy !req
291. Stay away from me.
Stay away from my son.
Copy !req
292. Because if you don't, I promise you,
Copy !req
293. I will do something that
we both regret.
Copy !req
294. Okay.
Copy !req
295. We don't wanna get you
in trouble, Brooke,
Copy !req
296. but your friend is dead.
Copy !req
297. I know. I can't believe it.
Copy !req
298. Okay, when's the last time
you saw Lindsay?
Copy !req
299. We were at this party.
Copy !req
300. - Where?
- Uh, somewhere in the city.
Copy !req
301. We took a car service from Sag Harbor.
Copy !req
302. Lindsay had the address.
I was pretty wasted.
Copy !req
303. What happened at this party?
Copy !req
304. I don't wanna tell you.
Copy !req
305. Brooke, I'm sorry, but you have to.
Copy !req
306. I'm scared.
Copy !req
307. Honey, I know you're scared.
Copy !req
308. Listen, none of this
is your fault, okay?
Copy !req
309. We just need to figure out
what happened to Lindsay.
Copy !req
310. This wasn't a party with
your friends, was it, Brooke?
Copy !req
311. It's okay.
Copy !req
312. But you need to tell us the truth.
Copy !req
313. - There were men there.
- Mm-hmm.
Copy !req
314. Lindsay and I, uh...
Copy !req
315. sometimes they treated us like adults.
Copy !req
316. You know, champagne, coke...
Copy !req
317. It was exciting.
Copy !req
318. One guy even gave me a Birkin bag.
Copy !req
319. Please don't tell my parents.
Copy !req
320. Lindsay's cell phone went dead
Copy !req
321. at 2:36 a.m. Sunday morning.
Copy !req
322. - Where?
- The signal was picked up
Copy !req
323. by a cell tower in Tribeca.
Copy !req
324. We can pinpoint a five-block radius.
Copy !req
325. So run every single building
in the zone.
Copy !req
326. I'm already on it.
Copy !req
327. I'm checking car services
that made trips
Copy !req
328. from Sag Harbor to Manhattan
that night.
Copy !req
329. Okay, so, this may be a long shot,
Copy !req
330. but I want you to show
this girl a picture
Copy !req
331. of Wally Stevens and everyone else that
Copy !req
332. we've picked up
at an underage sex party
Copy !req
333. in the last six months.
Copy !req
334. There has to be a connection,
Copy !req
335. and Rob Miller is at the center of it.
Copy !req
336. And just let us know
if you recognize anybody.
Copy !req
337. No.
Copy !req
338. No.
Copy !req
339. Oh, that's Wally.
Copy !req
340. We met at The Maidstone.
He was really nice.
Copy !req
341. Did he invite you to the party?
Copy !req
342. - Yes.
- Okay.
Copy !req
343. Anybody else?
Copy !req
344. No.
Copy !req
345. No.
Copy !req
346. Mm-mm.
Copy !req
347. Are you sure about that?
Copy !req
348. I don't know.
I guess he looks familiar.
Copy !req
349. From the party?
Copy !req
350. No, maybe I saw him on TV.
Copy !req
351. Okay.
Copy !req
352. Anybody else?
Copy !req
353. Wait, go back.
Copy !req
354. - I know him.
- How do you know him?
Copy !req
355. He was at a party
in the Hamptons last September.
Copy !req
356. He was with this girl,
Copy !req
357. an Italian foreign exchange student.
Copy !req
358. Do you know her?
Copy !req
359. Brooke. She was adorable.
Copy !req
360. You're not helping yourself here, Alex.
Copy !req
361. I didn't have sex with her.
Copy !req
362. What about this girl?
Copy !req
363. She looks familiar.
Copy !req
364. Familiar, how?
Copy !req
365. Did you see these two girls
go to a party
Copy !req
366. in the Hamptons last September?
Copy !req
367. Are you kidding me, almost a year ago?
Copy !req
368. Tell them what you know, Alex,
Copy !req
369. if you wanna get out by 70.
Copy !req
370. Fine, I recognize them,
Copy !req
371. but I didn't have sex
with either of them.
Copy !req
372. - I swear.
- Did he?
Copy !req
373. I... I don't know who that is.
Copy !req
374. The way you're twitching,
pal, I don't believe you.
Copy !req
375. Is there a question here?
Copy !req
376. Yeah. Does he know her?
Copy !req
377. I can't say.
Copy !req
378. Well, you should know she's dead.
Copy !req
379. I had nothing to do with that.
Copy !req
380. I think you should listen
to your lawyer
Copy !req
381. and tell us what you know.
Copy !req
382. If you wanna get out of here by 70,
Copy !req
383. you'll still have a little life left;
Copy !req
384. 90, not so much.
Copy !req
385. If you saw this guy
with this pants down,
Copy !req
386. if you saw him within five feet
of these two girls,
Copy !req
387. if you saw him so much
as light up a cigarette
Copy !req
388. in a no smoking area,
then we can work with you.
Copy !req
389. But you have gotta tell us
how you know him.
Copy !req
390. Okay.
Copy !req
391. Okay.
Copy !req
392. Maybe I saw him at that party
in the Hamptons.
Copy !req
393. But I am not testifying
against Rob Miller.
Copy !req
394. I'll take my chances inside.
Copy !req
395. Hey, Jim.
Copy !req
396. You looking for Noah, Ms. Benson?
Copy !req
397. Yeah, where is he?
Copy !req
398. - There must be some mix up.
- What?
Copy !req
399. He got checked off for early pickup.
Copy !req
400. Not by me.
Copy !req
401. How could you not know?
Copy !req
402. Two uniformed officers said that
they had authorization for...
Copy !req
403. No, I didn't send them.
Copy !req
404. Signed off, Lieutenant
Olivia Benson right there.
Copy !req
405. - That wasn't me.
- Oh, jeez, I'm sorry.
Copy !req
406. - Amanda.
- Yeah, Liv.
Copy !req
407. Amanda, I need you
to put out an all-city alert.
Copy !req
408. Somebody's taken Noah.
Copy !req
409. No. No, Noah's here.
Copy !req
410. I've got him.
Two unis from the 21st dropped him off.
Copy !req
411. They said you asked for a pickup.
Copy !req
412. No, I didn't, Amanda.
Copy !req
413. It was Rob Miller.
Copy !req
414. It had to be.
Copy !req
415. He... he's sending me a message,
Amanda.
Copy !req
416. He's sending me a message
that he can take my son
Copy !req
417. whenever he wants.
Copy !req
418. Just don't let him out
of your eyesight, okay?
Copy !req
419. Okay.
Copy !req
420. Liv, it's all right. I've got him.
Copy !req
421. Okay? He's safe.
Copy !req
422. You son of a bitch.
Copy !req
423. Take it easy. Noah's fine.
Copy !req
424. Stay away from my son.
Copy !req
425. Or what, you'll shoot me?
Copy !req
426. Take my advice,
Copy !req
427. make life easier on yourself.
Copy !req
428. Drop this case.
Copy !req
429. Go to hell.
Copy !req
430. So Rob Miller and Wally Stevens.
Copy !req
431. Rob Miller stole Nikki Staines' phone,
Copy !req
432. because he was scared
that Stevens would
Copy !req
433. implicate him in the underage sex case.
Copy !req
434. There was nothing on the phone.
Copy !req
435. The charges against Stevens
were dropped,
Copy !req
436. but that's how we know that
Copy !req
437. Rob Miller got to Judge Leonard.
Copy !req
438. Which we also can't prove.
What about the girls?
Copy !req
439. Well, okay. So, Brooke Davis,
Copy !req
440. was with Lindsay Parker
Copy !req
441. the night she was killed.
Brooke ID'd Alex Kay,
Copy !req
442. who put Miller at a sex party
last September in the Hamptons,
Copy !req
443. but now refuses to testify
against Miller.
Copy !req
444. So here's my working theory.
Copy !req
445. Rob Miller runs into Lindsay,
Copy !req
446. who just happens to be
his clients' daughter,
Copy !req
447. at a party Saturday night.
Copy !req
448. Miller panics because he thinks
that Lindsay can ID him.
Copy !req
449. He gives her a hot shot.
Copy !req
450. Okay, I know that there are
Copy !req
451. definitely a lot of dots to connect...
Copy !req
452. I'd say that's
an understatement, Lieutenant.
Copy !req
453. He's a man, not a supervillain.
Copy !req
454. He had to have made a mistake.
Copy !req
455. If he did, I don't see it.
Copy !req
456. My office, Counselor.
Copy !req
457. Whose side are you on?
Copy !req
458. Not Rob Miller's.
Copy !req
459. Doesn't look that way.
Copy !req
460. You're accusing me of something.
Copy !req
461. I'm just asking.
Copy !req
462. I know that Rob Miller is guilty.
Copy !req
463. - How?
- How?
Copy !req
464. Because he had unis pick up
my son from his school.
Copy !req
465. He was clearly threatening me.
Copy !req
466. He looked me in the eye and he told me
Copy !req
467. to drop the case.
Copy !req
468. When were you gonna tell me this?
Copy !req
469. That's irrelevant to the investigation.
Copy !req
470. Olivia, it is completely
relevant to the investigation.
Copy !req
471. He's threatening Noah.
Copy !req
472. Anything you find out,
Copy !req
473. his lawyer will claim
Copy !req
474. you have a personal
vendetta against him.
Copy !req
475. Peter, I'm worried that
he's going to hurt my son.
Copy !req
476. Rob Miller is a criminal, Peter.
Copy !req
477. He's a rapist, he's a murderer...
Copy !req
478. and we got nothing.
Copy !req
479. And he's gonna get away
with all of this.
Copy !req
480. Hey.
Copy !req
481. - Oh.
- Thanks for meeting me.
Copy !req
482. Look, I am only here because you swore
Copy !req
483. you wouldn't ask me to testify.
Copy !req
484. I'm not.
Copy !req
485. So, what do you want?
Copy !req
486. Same thing you want,
Rob Miller behind bars.
Copy !req
487. How the hell are we gonna do that?
Copy !req
488. We're gonna break a couple of rules.
Copy !req
489. Brooke, you can come on in.
Just leave your stuff there.
Copy !req
490. Have a seat on the couch.
Copy !req
491. You got a judge to sign off
on an arrest warrant.
Copy !req
492. - I did.
- With what evidence?
Copy !req
493. Just trust me.
Copy !req
494. Do I have a choice?
Copy !req
495. Parkers are here.
Copy !req
496. - With their lawyer?
- Yeah.
Copy !req
497. - Mr. and Mrs. Parker.
- You have a break in the case?
Copy !req
498. Yes, we have a suspect
in your daughter's murder.
Copy !req
499. - Who?
- Actually, it's your lawyer.
Copy !req
500. - What?
- Rob Miller.
Copy !req
501. You're under arrest
Copy !req
502. for the murder of Lindsay Parker.
Copy !req
503. Get him out of here.
Copy !req
504. So you're just gonna
keep me in the dark?
Copy !req
505. Well, the fisherman
shouldn't worry about
Copy !req
506. what the chef is gonna
do with his catch.
Copy !req
507. I love metaphors, Peter,
but not so much
Copy !req
508. when it involves a
rapist/murderer's day in court.
Copy !req
509. And even less when
the State's case is...
Copy !req
510. Circumstantial?
Copy !req
511. Only circumstantial.
Copy !req
512. For all I know, all we have is
a bunch of arrows
Copy !req
513. on a corkboard signifying
a whole lot of nothing.
Copy !req
514. Do you think Rob Miller raped
Nikki Staines?
Copy !req
515. Of course.
Copy !req
516. Do you think he murdered
Lindsay Parker?
Copy !req
517. - You know that I do.
- Good.
Copy !req
518. You caught the fish,
now let me cook it.
Copy !req
519. At first we thought it was weird,
Copy !req
520. you know,
partying with old guys, but...
Copy !req
521. But?
Copy !req
522. I mean, we could hook up
with guys from our school,
Copy !req
523. but they don't...
Copy !req
524. They don't give you Birkin bags?
Copy !req
525. I mean, it's not like
we were whores or anything.
Copy !req
526. No, no, of course not.
Copy !req
527. You were 16-year-old girls
who were taken advantage of
Copy !req
528. by rich, horny old men.
Copy !req
529. - Objection.
- Withdrawn.
Copy !req
530. And tell me, Miss Davis,
was one of these men,
Copy !req
531. the defendant?
Copy !req
532. I'm not sure.
Copy !req
533. I've never seen his face before.
Copy !req
534. So it's just a coincidence,
Copy !req
535. that you and Mr. Miller ate
lunch at BLT Steakhouse?
Copy !req
536. I've never been to the BLT.
Copy !req
537. That's odd...
Copy !req
538. because your phone was.
Copy !req
539. These are GPS records
from two cell phones.
Copy !req
540. Do you recognize the 631 number?
Copy !req
541. Yes, that's my number.
Copy !req
542. Where was your phone located
on Tuesday, May 13th
Copy !req
543. between 1:17 p.m. and 2:34 p.m.?
Copy !req
544. 106 East 57th Street.
Copy !req
545. The same place during the same time
Copy !req
546. as the 914 number.
Copy !req
547. - That's what it looks like.
- Good.
Copy !req
548. In case you're wondering,
Copy !req
549. that number belongs
to the defendant, Rob Miller.
Copy !req
550. And the location is BLT Steakhouse.
Copy !req
551. The exact one, the same place that
Copy !req
552. you swore you'd never eaten at before.
Copy !req
553. Now tell me, at that lunch,
Copy !req
554. did Mr. Miller give you any money?
Copy !req
555. No, I told you.
I've never been to that restaurant.
Copy !req
556. - This is nonsense.
- Sit, Mr. Miller.
Copy !req
557. Be that as it may,
Copy !req
558. has Mr. Miller ever given you any cash?
Copy !req
559. No.
Copy !req
560. Miss Davis...
Copy !req
561. do you recognize this document?
Copy !req
562. Yes, that's my bank statement.
Copy !req
563. Direct your attention
to transaction on May 13th.
Copy !req
564. That's impossible.
Copy !req
565. What happened at 3:40 p.m.
on the 13th, Miss Davis?
Copy !req
566. There was a deposit for $9,500,
Copy !req
567. but I've never had that much cash.
Copy !req
568. I didn't make that deposit.
Copy !req
569. So you didn't deposit the money
Copy !req
570. on the same day you didn't
have lunch with the defendant?
Copy !req
571. - Objection.
- Withdrawn.
Copy !req
572. You know what it looks like
to me, Miss Davis?
Copy !req
573. It looks like Mr. Miller paid you
Copy !req
574. to un-remember his face.
Copy !req
575. - Objection.
- Sustained.
Copy !req
576. Nothing further.
Copy !req
577. Let me ask you something, Brooke.
Copy !req
578. Did you ever meet Rob Miller?
Copy !req
579. No.
Copy !req
580. - Did he ever give you $9,500?
- No way.
Copy !req
581. Thank you.
Copy !req
582. No, he's not a member.
Copy !req
583. As a matter of fact,
I have no idea who he is,
Copy !req
584. and I've been working
for the club for 27 years.
Copy !req
585. You just let anyone in?
Copy !req
586. No, he was looking for a member,
Copy !req
587. so I said he could wait in the lobby.
Copy !req
588. Which member was he looking for?
Copy !req
589. Mr. Miller.
Copy !req
590. I've never even seen this guy.
Copy !req
591. That's two strikes, Mr. Miller.
Copy !req
592. - Now that's him, isn't it?
- Yes.
Copy !req
593. And that's Mr. Miller's guest leaving.
Copy !req
594. Do you notice anything
different about him?
Copy !req
595. He came in with an envelope,
he left without one.
Copy !req
596. And that was 15 minutes
after Mr. Miller arrived.
Copy !req
597. 17, if you look
at the time stamp on the video.
Copy !req
598. Huh.
Copy !req
599. Mr. Burton, did you actually see.
Copy !req
600. Mr. Miller greet his so-called guest?
Copy !req
601. No.
Copy !req
602. Did you actually see him take
Copy !req
603. the envelope from his guest?
Copy !req
604. No.
Copy !req
605. That's Lamar Jackson.
Copy !req
606. Have you had occasion
to meet Mr. Jackson?
Copy !req
607. Yeah, he's a con.
I arrested him in 2014.
Copy !req
608. - For what?
- Selling narcotics.
Copy !req
609. Have you ever heard of China White?
Copy !req
610. Yeah, that's the street term
for fentanyl.
Copy !req
611. That's what he was selling
when I busted him.
Copy !req
612. Where is Mr. Jackson now?
Copy !req
613. I wouldn't know.
Copy !req
614. Would it surprise you
if Mr. Stone asked him
Copy !req
615. to take the stand?
Copy !req
616. Nothing surprises me anymore.
Copy !req
617. Well, I'll tell you this much,
Copy !req
618. it'd surprise me,
because that would mean.
Copy !req
619. Mr. Stone was suborning perjury.
Copy !req
620. - Objection.
- Withdrawn.
Copy !req
621. I have no more questions
for the witness, Your Honor.
Copy !req
622. The People rest, Your Honor.
Copy !req
623. Mr. Biegel?
Copy !req
624. The Defense calls Nikki Staines.
Copy !req
625. On the afternoon of May 13th,
Copy !req
626. did you make a visit
Copy !req
627. to the Commerce Bank of Manhattan?
Copy !req
628. I did.
Copy !req
629. You remember how much money
you deposited?
Copy !req
630. It was $9,500.
Copy !req
631. Into your personal account?
Copy !req
632. - No.
- No.
Copy !req
633. Because you don't have
an account at Commerce do you?
Copy !req
634. - No.
- I didn't think so.
Copy !req
635. Can you tell me into whose
account you made a deposit?
Copy !req
636. It was Brooke Davis' account.
Copy !req
637. $9,500. Whoa.
Copy !req
638. Feeling generous, were you?
Copy !req
639. - Objection.
- Sustained.
Copy !req
640. Ms. Staines, can you tell me
why you would deposit money
Copy !req
641. into a complete stranger's account?
Copy !req
642. I was trying to frame your client.
Copy !req
643. Excuse me?
Copy !req
644. I was trying to frame Rob Miller.
Copy !req
645. I'm speechless, Ms. Staines.
Copy !req
646. Speechless.
Copy !req
647. Why would you try to frame
the defendant, Ms. Staines?
Copy !req
648. Because he threatened me.
Copy !req
649. How did he threaten you?
Copy !req
650. I was in the middle
of a contested custody battle,
Copy !req
651. and Rob Miller had compromising
photos of me
Copy !req
652. that he threatened to turn over
to my ex-husband.
Copy !req
653. And you were scared you would
lose custody of your daughter?
Copy !req
654. He's evil.
Copy !req
655. He'll do whatever it takes
to get what he wants
Copy !req
656. no matter who it hurts.
Copy !req
657. Are you still scared of him?
Copy !req
658. Um, I don't know.
Copy !req
659. She was completely blacked out.
Copy !req
660. She doesn't remember anything.
Copy !req
661. What if she does?
Copy !req
662. What if Benson convinces her
to testify?
Copy !req
663. It'll be taken care of.
Copy !req
664. - How?
- No Nikki, no case.
Copy !req
665. Do you recognize
those voices, Ms. Staines?
Copy !req
666. That was Chief Dodds and the defendant.
Copy !req
667. Which one of them said,
"No Nikki, no case."?
Copy !req
668. That was Rob Miller.
Copy !req
669. I'll ask again.
Copy !req
670. Are you still scared?
Copy !req
671. He killed Lindsay Parker, didn't he?
Copy !req
672. Objection.
Copy !req
673. The jury will disregard
the witness' last statement.
Copy !req
674. In fact, you were so scared
of Rob Miller
Copy !req
675. that you manufactured
circumstantial evidence
Copy !req
676. in order to trick the jury
into convicting him.
Copy !req
677. Yes.
Copy !req
678. You were so scared that
you risked your career
Copy !req
679. and your freedom to put him in prison.
Copy !req
680. I have a daughter.
Copy !req
681. He would be a threat to me
for the rest of my life
Copy !req
682. if I didn't do anything.
Copy !req
683. What the hell?
Copy !req
684. I shouldn't be talking to you.
Copy !req
685. Oh, I see.
Copy !req
686. Now you worry about ethics.
Copy !req
687. Haven't you learned by now that people
Copy !req
688. that screw with me typically
don't have happy endings?
Copy !req
689. Endings I want. Endings I control.
Copy !req
690. It's called power, Lieutenant.
Copy !req
691. Good night.
Copy !req
692. I've got it.
Copy !req
693. You pissants don't comprehend it.
Copy !req
694. You'll see, when the dust settles,
Copy !req
695. you, your friend Nikki Staines...
Copy !req
696. You okay, Liv?
Copy !req
697. Get this piece of dirt away from me.
Copy !req
698. Do not touch me.
Copy !req
699. A word to the wise, Lieutenant.
Copy !req
700. You're a tiny fish.
Copy !req
701. Tiny fish always get eaten
by the bigger fish.
Copy !req
702. Like it or not,
it's how the world works.
Copy !req
703. Somebody's freaking out.
Copy !req
704. You were at the trial?
Copy !req
705. No, but I heard Nikki put on
quite a show.
Copy !req
706. What, Nikki? What are you doing?
Copy !req
707. Oh, my God, stop it.
Copy !req
708. What I did, I didn't just do it
for me, you know.
Copy !req
709. Whoa.
Copy !req
710. I would have never agreed to this.
Copy !req
711. Yeah, that's why we didn't
say anything to you.
Copy !req
712. "We"? Who's "we"?
Copy !req
713. Stone knew about this?
Copy !req
714. Christ, Liv.
Copy !req
715. It was his idea.
Copy !req
716. You and Stone tried to frame Miller?
Copy !req
717. Yeah. He is guilty.
Copy !req
718. You could both be disbarred for this.
Copy !req
719. Oh, God. You know what?
Copy !req
720. There are things that are
more important
Copy !req
721. than a license to tap dance
around a courtroom.
Copy !req
722. Oh, my God.
Copy !req
723. We've been doing this a long time, Liv.
Copy !req
724. And we don't say it out loud
or when the lights are on,
Copy !req
725. but there are times in the dark
Copy !req
726. when we whisper, "Sometimes the law's"
Copy !req
727. "just not good enough."
Copy !req
728. And a threat to my child's
safety is one of those times.
Copy !req
729. At least I won't have to look
Copy !req
730. over my shoulder for
the rest of my life.
Copy !req
731. Oh, and guess what. Neither will you.
Copy !req
732. No. No.
Copy !req
733. I am not part of this.
Copy !req
734. Yeah, you are.
Copy !req
735. Have you reached a verdict?
Copy !req
736. We have.
Copy !req
737. What say you?
Copy !req
738. On the sole count of the indictment,
Copy !req
739. Murder in the Second Degree,
Copy !req
740. we find the defendant,
Robert Alan Miller,
Copy !req
741. guilty.
Copy !req
742. Wait, what?
Copy !req
743. - You've gotta be kidding me.
- Rob, that can't...
Copy !req
744. Rob. Rob, hold on a sec.
Copy !req
745. Son of a bitch.
Copy !req
746. You set me up, you son of a bitch!
Copy !req
747. You set me up!
Copy !req
748. Order! Order!
Copy !req
749. I don't even know what to say.
Copy !req
750. Congratulations?
Copy !req
751. I mean, you won the case
Copy !req
752. without a single piece of evidence.
Copy !req
753. I proved Miller was a bad guy,
Copy !req
754. and the jury put him away
for that alone.
Copy !req
755. For once the arrow
on the wheel of justice
Copy !req
756. - stopped at the right place.
- Yeah, with a little help.
Copy !req
757. Everybody needs a little help, Liv.
Copy !req
758. Even me.
Copy !req
759. Actually, you're the one
person who could probably
Copy !req
760. - make it on her own.
- Okay, well, let's take it easy.
Copy !req
761. We both know that's not true.
Copy !req
762. Yeah, I do, but...
Copy !req
763. that's not what most
people wanna hear, is it?
Copy !req
764. Peter.
Copy !req
765. - Thank you.
- Why?
Copy !req
766. Because I put my integrity
and my career
Copy !req
767. and everything I believe in
in jeopardy for a good friend?
Copy !req
768. Yes. Yes.
Copy !req
769. And I didn't ask for this.
Copy !req
770. I know you didn't ask for it.
I did it anyway.
Copy !req
771. I was always gonna do it.
Copy !req
772. I hope you find someone
like that again.
Copy !req
773. What does that mean?
Copy !req
774. Look at what I just did in there.
Copy !req
775. Now, I don't regret any of it
for a minute, none of it.
Copy !req
776. I simply lost perspective.
This is on me.
Copy !req
777. It's a... it's a weakness
and it's a crack
Copy !req
778. in my character.
Copy !req
779. But the fact is,
you became more important to me
Copy !req
780. than the case I was trying
and that is not me, Liv.
Copy !req
781. You can look at a case
with an open heart.
Copy !req
782. I can't do that. I have... no, stop.
Copy !req
783. I have to look
at a case through clear eyes.
Copy !req
784. - Hold on, hold on.
- I will risk...
Copy !req
785. Stop, just listen. I have to move on.
Copy !req
786. I have to go or risk
getting blinded again.
Copy !req
787. Wait.
Copy !req
788. You take care of yourself, Liv.
Copy !req