1. - In the criminal justice
Copy !req
2. system,
Copy !req
3. sexually based offenses
Copy !req
4. are considered
especially heinous.
Copy !req
5. In New York City,
the dedicated detectives
Copy !req
6. who investigate
these vicious felonies
Copy !req
7. are members of an elite squad
Copy !req
8. known as
the Special Victims Unit.
Copy !req
9. These are their stories.
Copy !req
10. - There's a crease
in my collar.
Copy !req
11. - Nobody can tell, Josh.
- Think my eyebrows
Copy !req
12. are too bushy?
- I cannot believe somebody's
Copy !req
13. actually marrying you.
Copy !req
14. - Ah, man.
Who is calling me today?
Copy !req
15. - Unknown caller.
Copy !req
16. It's probably one of those
Chinese robo-calls.
Copy !req
17. - Or it's a patient.
Here, give me my phone.
Copy !req
18. - No—Hey—
- You know, for a shrink
Copy !req
19. you're incredibly uptight.
- You wanna talk issues, Alan?
Copy !req
20. Come on, come on.
- Ah, we promised Lana,
Copy !req
21. no patient phone calls today.
- What are you guys,
Copy !req
22. 12 years old?
Copy !req
23. - Can they kick you out of
church on your wedding day?
Copy !req
24. - Beth has weed.
- For later.
Copy !req
25. - I am getting married today.
Copy !req
26. Whoo!
Copy !req
27. And if I'm lucky,
pregnant tonight.
Copy !req
28. - Well, cheers to that.
Copy !req
29. - Marriage is to be entered
into reverently,
Copy !req
30. deliberately,
Copy !req
31. in accordance with
the purpose for which
Copy !req
32. it was instituted by God.
Copy !req
33. If anyone assembled here
has just cause
Copy !req
34. why this man and this woman
should not be joined together,
Copy !req
35. speak now
or forever hold your peace.
Copy !req
36. - I do.
Copy !req
37. And I have a good reason.
Copy !req
38. - Josh, who is that?
Copy !req
39. - Dr. Hensley raped me.
Copy !req
40. - Excuse me, Father.
Copy !req
41. - I didn't know what else
to do.
Copy !req
42. - You did the right thing
by calling us.
Copy !req
43. - Everyone's inside.
Copy !req
44. But I have to tell you,
it's not pretty.
Copy !req
45. The wedding party
is over there on the right.
Copy !req
46. Miss Bennett is over here.
Copy !req
47. - Hi, I'm Lieutenant Benson.
Copy !req
48. - I am so sorry.
I was just trying to help.
Copy !req
49. - Every heard of a phone?
Copy !req
50. - I'm Detective Carisi.
Copy !req
51. Now, you gotta be the groom,
right?
Copy !req
52. - Yes, yeah.
- Let's go someplace
Copy !req
53. and straighten this all out.
Copy !req
54. - I'm not leaving my wife.
- She's not your wife yet!
Copy !req
55. - Take my advice, you don't
wanna be here right now.
Copy !req
56. - Oh, my God.
Lana.
Copy !req
57. Lana, I love you, okay?
I love you!
Copy !req
58. - Why don't we go someplace
where we can talk more quietly?
Copy !req
59. - Lana, one day you're gonna
thank me for this.
Copy !req
60. - Do not speak to her!
- Hey, excuse me.
Copy !req
61. Back up, please, both of you.
Let's go.
Copy !req
62. - I just wanted somebody
to know.
Copy !req
63. - Well, now everyone does.
Copy !req
64. - Why don't we start
from the beginning?
Copy !req
65. How did you even meet
Josh Hensley?
Copy !req
66. - He was my therapist.
Copy !req
67. I went to see him
three months ago
Copy !req
68. after my mom passed away.
Copy !req
69. - Oh, I'm so sorry
to hear about your mother.
Copy !req
70. - And when was that
appointment?
Copy !req
71. - It was December 11th.
Copy !req
72. You know, I just wanted
somebody to talk to.
Copy !req
73. - Well, we certainly understand
how difficult this could be.
Copy !req
74. - How many times had you seen
him before the incident?
Copy !req
75. - I mean, never.
Copy !req
76. It was my first time going
to therapy.
Copy !req
77. I didn't even know what
to expect.
Copy !req
78. - Okay.
So, what time did you arrive?
Copy !req
79. - Well, it was after work,
so... 6:15.
Copy !req
80. - Okay, was anybody
else there?
Copy !req
81. There were—I mean,
there were a lot of
Copy !req
82. other doctors in the medical
suite where he worked.
Copy !req
83. I made the appointment with
the receptionist on the phone,
Copy !req
84. but by the time I got there
she must've gone home.
Copy !req
85. - Okay, so what happened?
Copy !req
86. - Well, he was just
really nice at first.
Copy !req
87. He was professional.
Copy !req
88. And I gave him, you know,
my history.
Copy !req
89. I'm an only child, my father
left when I was a kid.
Copy !req
90. And I just missed my mom
so much that I started to cry.
Copy !req
91. And that's when
Dr. Hensley came and sat
Copy !req
92. on the couch next to me.
Copy !req
93. And he asked if he could
give me a hug.
Copy !req
94. He said that it was normal.
- It's not.
Copy !req
95. - And he gave me hug,
and he stroked my hair.
Copy !req
96. And I knew that
it was inappropriate,
Copy !req
97. but I was too afraid
to challenge him.
Copy !req
98. - Okay.
Copy !req
99. - And that's when
he pushed me back,
Copy !req
100. he put his hand up my skirt,
he pulled down my underwear,
Copy !req
101. and that is when I told him
to stop, but he didn't listen.
Copy !req
102. He just forced himself
inside of me.
Copy !req
103. And I laid there like
a ragdoll while he finished.
Copy !req
104. - I cannot believe that
I am here with a detective
Copy !req
105. on my wedding day.
Copy !req
106. What's this woman's name?
Copy !req
107. - Kitty Bennett.
- I have no idea who that is.
Copy !req
108. - So this is a case
of mistaken identity?
Copy !req
109. - I don't know, but I sure
as hell didn't rape her.
Copy !req
110. - All right, so she's lying?
Copy !req
111. - You tell me.
Copy !req
112. All I know is she just ruined
the best day of my life.
Copy !req
113. - Did you tell anyone
about the rape,
Copy !req
114. a friend, a family member,
Copy !req
115. a co-worker, anyone at all?
Copy !req
116. - No.
Copy !req
117. I mean, I was just too ashamed.
Copy !req
118. I thought that nobody
would believe me.
Copy !req
119. - So what did you do
the next day?
Copy !req
120. - I called in sick at
the ad agency where I worked.
Copy !req
121. But I missed so much time
because of this,
Copy !req
122. they've let me go.
Copy !req
123. - Oh, I'm so sorry.
Copy !req
124. - Did you have any contact
with Dr. Hensley
Copy !req
125. after he sexually
assaulted you?
Copy !req
126. Any phone calls or emails?
Copy !req
127. - And it's okay if you did.
Copy !req
128. - How did you know he was
getting married today?
Copy !req
129. - Instagram.
Copy !req
130. I started to look at
his photos.
Copy !req
131. I know that it's crazy, right?
Copy !req
132. - Well, it's normal
to be curious
Copy !req
133. after something
like this happens.
Copy !req
134. - I mean, I never thought
that the police
Copy !req
135. would be getting involved.
Copy !req
136. - But you did want people
to know that he had raped you.
Copy !req
137. - I guess I wanted him
to be punished.
Copy !req
138. You know, to be humiliated
like I was.
Copy !req
139. - You know,
I gotta talk to Lana.
Copy !req
140. You know, I gotta make sure
that she's okay.
Copy !req
141. - Well, I can tell you that
she's not okay.
Copy !req
142. And everybody's gone, okay?
Copy !req
143. - Hey, Kitty Bennett says that
she is a patient of yours.
Copy !req
144. - What?
Copy !req
145. - She came to see you
in December after her mom died.
Copy !req
146. - Well, clearly, she's not well
because that never happened.
Copy !req
147. - All right, well,
let me tell you
Copy !req
148. what's gonna happen next,
okay?
Copy !req
149. We're gonna go to your office,
we're gonna comb through
Copy !req
150. your appointment book,
all your files.
Copy !req
151. And if Kitty was ever
a patient of yours,
Copy !req
152. we're gonna figure that out.
Copy !req
153. - Great, let's go right now.
Copy !req
154. Because there's no file,
there's no billing record.
Copy !req
155. I mean, whatever's gonna make
this nightmare go away.
Copy !req
156. - Help us understand why
this woman is accusing you.
Copy !req
157. - I wish that I knew.
Copy !req
158. - Maybe it wasn't a rape,
maybe it was a fling,
Copy !req
159. you know, like you guys do
before you get married.
Copy !req
160. - I have never
cheated on Lana, ever.
Copy !req
161. I mean, this is gonna
destroy me, you understand?
Copy !req
162. You gotta help me.
Copy !req
163. - I mean, Kitty is exhibiting
all the guilt
Copy !req
164. and the self-loathing typical
of rape victims.
Copy !req
165. - And Hensley swears that
he never saw her in his life.
Copy !req
166. - Do you believe him, Carisi?
Copy !req
167. - I mean he's adamant,
I'll give him that.
Copy !req
168. - Well, so far,
Kitty's story checks out.
Copy !req
169. Dr. Hensley did post a photo
of his rehearsal dinner
Copy !req
170. on his Instagram page.
Copy !req
171. - So, can we confirm this
Copy !req
172. therapy appointment
in December?
Copy !req
173. - Chelsea Medical opens up
at 7:00 a.m. on Monday.
Copy !req
174. - Perfect.
Copy !req
175. - Chelsea Medical.
Copy !req
176. Dr. Young... one second.
Copy !req
177. - Uh—uh, Friday at 10:00
for a chemical peel.
Copy !req
178. Great, we'll see you then.
Copy !req
179. - Hi.
We're from SVU.
Copy !req
180. We just need to confirm
an appointment
Copy !req
181. of Dr. Hensley's;
Copy !req
182. December 11th, at 6:15,
a patient named Kitty Bennett.
Copy !req
183. - Dr. Hensley's
on his honeymoon.
Copy !req
184. - Right, we just need
to take a look at
Copy !req
185. his appointment book, though.
Copy !req
186. If it's not too much trouble.
Copy !req
187. - Isn't that a HIPAA violation?
Copy !req
188. - No, we don't need to see
any medical records
Copy !req
189. or anything, so it's good.
Copy !req
190. - Okay.
Copy !req
191. For December 11th?
Copy !req
192. - Mm-hmm.
- That's right.
Copy !req
193. - Hmm...
Copy !req
194. There was no appointment
for 6:15 that day.
Copy !req
195. - Okay, these are written
in pencil?
Copy !req
196. So is it possible that
somebody could have
Copy !req
197. erased the appointment?
Copy !req
198. - If a patient cancels
or changes the date.
Copy !req
199. - Okay.
- All right, thank you.
Copy !req
200. - Did you catch the name
of Hensley's
Copy !req
201. next appointment that day?
Copy !req
202. - Hannah Berkowitz.
Clocked the phone number, too.
Copy !req
203. - Okay, good.
So if Kitty was here,
Copy !req
204. maybe Hannah saw her leave.
Copy !req
205. - Tuesdays at 7:15
is my usual appointment,
Copy !req
206. but December 11th... that
was the day that I no-showed.
Copy !req
207. I was coming from
a big recital in Philly,
Copy !req
208. and I ran into some ridiculous
traffic on the turnpike.
Copy !req
209. - No-show, huh?
Copy !req
210. All right,
thanks for your time.
Copy !req
211. - Sure.
Copy !req
212. - You know what, can I ask you
a personal question?
Copy !req
213. Was Dr. Hensley ever
inappropriate with you?
Copy !req
214. - Inappropriate how?
Copy !req
215. - Like,
did he come on to you?
Copy !req
216. - I'm gay.
I came out two years ago.
Copy !req
217. Dr. Hensley was the one
who helped me feel comfortable
Copy !req
218. with my sexuality.
Copy !req
219. Is he in some kind of trouble?
Copy !req
220. - Um, one of
his female patients
Copy !req
221. may have had some issues.
Copy !req
222. - Wait a minute.
Is her name Kitty Bennett?
Copy !req
223. - You know her?
Copy !req
224. - Not in real life,
Copy !req
225. but she stalked me
on Instagram.
Copy !req
226. I left a comment on
one of Dr. Hensley's photos,
Copy !req
227. and she followed me after that.
Copy !req
228. Then came the private messages.
Copy !req
229. - What were those messages
about?
Copy !req
230. - She kept insisting that
we get coffee
Copy !req
231. to talk trash about
Dr. Hensley.
Copy !req
232. - But you never met up
with her?
Copy !req
233. - I don't even talk to
my best friend
Copy !req
234. about my therapy.
Copy !req
235. I'm not about to spill
my guts to some rando,
Copy !req
236. especially about someone
who pretty much saved my life.
Copy !req
237. - So that's the only contact
that you had with Kitty?
Copy !req
238. - Well, I made the mistake of
replying to her first message.
Copy !req
239. She took that as an invitation
to write me every day
Copy !req
240. for, like, a month.
Copy !req
241. I finally had to block her.
Copy !req
242. That chick is
straight-up psycho.
Copy !req
243. - I tracked three of
Copy !req
244. Dr. Hensley's
Copy !req
245. other female patients.
Copy !req
246. They had nothing but nice
things to say about him.
Copy !req
247. - Well, meanwhile,
Kitty Bennett's got more than
Copy !req
248. her fair share of run-ins
with the law.
Copy !req
249. Got disorderly conduct,
a few shop-lifting arrests,
Copy !req
250. and my personal favorite—
restraining order.
Copy !req
251. - Who filed for
the restraining order?
Copy !req
252. - Guy by the name of
Bo Albrecht.
Copy !req
253. - Kitty Bennett?
Copy !req
254. She's accusing me of something?
Copy !req
255. Because you know
she's loony tunes, right?
Copy !req
256. - You were going out
with her?
Copy !req
257. - I met her one time
at a cooking class.
Copy !req
258. I mentioned
Copy !req
259. Next thing I know,
she's blowing up
Copy !req
260. my Facebook Messenger.
Copy !req
261. - Okay, was there
some flirtation
Copy !req
262. going on between you two?
Copy !req
263. - I was just trying
to be nice.
Copy !req
264. Then she found out
I was a trainer,
Copy !req
265. started sending me daily
exercise videos of herself
Copy !req
266. in these sexy gym outfits.
Copy !req
267. Well, that's when I told her
I had a girlfriend.
Copy !req
268. - I'm guessing that didn't
go too well.
Copy !req
269. - She accused me of
leading her on,
Copy !req
270. so I blocked her.
Copy !req
271. That only added fuel
to the fire.
Copy !req
272. - She didn't stop
harassing you?
Copy !req
273. - Not me, my girlfriend.
Copy !req
274. Kitty found out Megan waited
tables at The Red Cat.
Copy !req
275. She showed up during
one of Megan's shifts,
Copy !req
276. told her I was hitting on her.
Copy !req
277. That's when I took her to court
and got a restraining order.
Copy !req
278. - Did you arrest
Dr. Hensley yet?
Copy !req
279. - Well, there are a few things
that we need to clear up first.
Copy !req
280. - Like what?
Copy !req
281. - Well, we spoke to
a few people that
Copy !req
282. you've been in contact with,
virtual strangers, really.
Copy !req
283. And from what I understand,
Copy !req
284. you've engaged in
some behavior that
Copy !req
285. might be considered stalking.
Copy !req
286. - Did you talk to Bo?
Copy !req
287. Mm-hmm. Oh, and did he tell you
that he lied to me
Copy !req
288. and said that he was single?
- And that the judge
Copy !req
289. gave him a restraining order
against you.
Copy !req
290. That was for his girlfriend.
Copy !req
291. And when I saw them both
in court, I said I was sorry.
Copy !req
292. I mean, I apologized.
Copy !req
293. - Okay, Kitty, we also spoke
with Hannah Berkowitz.
Copy !req
294. - Okay, look...
Copy !req
295. I may have, like, crossed
a line with Hannah,
Copy !req
296. but I was just desperate
to talk to somebody
Copy !req
297. who had seen Dr. Hensley,
you know?
Copy !req
298. I wanted to understand
why he had targeted me.
Copy !req
299. - We spoke with
Dr. Hensley's receptionist,
Copy !req
300. and there's no record
of any appointment.
Copy !req
301. - What are you saying,
that I made this up?
Copy !req
302. - I'm just trying to understand
what really happened.
Copy !req
303. - I mean, look,
I'm not like some choir girl.
Copy !req
304. I've made some bad decisions
in my life,
Copy !req
305. but that is why he thought
he could get away with this.
Copy !req
306. And you know something?
You're proving him right.
Copy !req
307. - No.
Copy !req
308. Kitty, how 'bout we start over?
Okay?
Copy !req
309. Kitty, I want to believe you,
I do.
Copy !req
310. Why don't we have a seat?
Copy !req
311. But I need you to help me.
Copy !req
312. Are there any details
from that night
Copy !req
313. that you can remember?
Copy !req
314. Maybe, you know,
a physical characteristic
Copy !req
315. or the way he smelled—
any detail at all.
Copy !req
316. - I mean, I just remember lying
on that red leather couch
Copy !req
317. and staring up at the ceiling
Copy !req
318. and just praying for it
to be over.
Copy !req
319. - I do have a leather couch
in my office.
Copy !req
320. It's burgundy, not red.
Copy !req
321. - Red, burgundy—we're not
really Sherwin-Williams here.
Copy !req
322. So, how would she know that
if she was never there?
Copy !req
323. - His professional web page.
Copy !req
324. There's a photo of Josh
at his desk.
Copy !req
325. The couch is in the background.
Copy !req
326. - Why make this
false accusation against you?
Copy !req
327. - I have no idea.
Please.
Copy !req
328. - Is there any chance that
you had a casual interaction
Copy !req
329. with this woman,
something that maybe
Copy !req
330. she construed as flirtatious?
Copy !req
331. - I just—I cannot think
of anything.
Copy !req
332. - Does she have a history
of this kind of thing?
Copy !req
333. - Well,
we're still investigating.
Copy !req
334. But has anything come up
on your phone
Copy !req
335. or social media accounts
that seems out of the ordinary?
Copy !req
336. - Last month somebody sexted
Josh a bunch of nude pics.
Copy !req
337. - You just bringing
this up now?
Copy !req
338. - Honestly, I didn't see
the connection.
Copy !req
339. I mean, the photos were
all different women
Copy !req
340. like they were pulled from
a porno site.
Copy !req
341. I figured it was just spam.
Copy !req
342. - And what about that
dating profile?
Copy !req
343. - Hold on, what profile?
Copy !req
344. - I got an email
at my work address.
Copy !req
345. It was a link to
Josh's dating profile page.
Copy !req
346. - And I've never done
any online dating.
Copy !req
347. - I was furious,
but when I really looked at it,
Copy !req
348. I could tell it was fake.
Copy !req
349. I mean, the photos of Josh
were also on Google
Copy !req
350. and some of the information
was wrong.
Copy !req
351. - Did you reply to the email,
try to figure out who sent it?
Copy !req
352. - The next day, but the reply
just bounced right back.
Copy !req
353. - Also, we had a burglary here.
Copy !req
354. It was about, uh,
what was that,
Copy !req
355. like, two months ago?
Copy !req
356. And we reported it to
the 11th Precinct.
Copy !req
357. - Was anything stolen?
Copy !req
358. - No, no, I mean, we figured
it was just some kids.
Copy !req
359. All they did was they poured
a bottle of tomato juice
Copy !req
360. all over
our wedding invitations.
Copy !req
361. - Huh.
Copy !req
362. - All right,
so now they're saying
Copy !req
363. I broke into their apartment?
Copy !req
364. - Did you?
Copy !req
365. - No.
Copy !req
366. - The text,
the fake dating profile,
Copy !req
367. those tracked back
to your old job.
Copy !req
368. You were harassing
these people.
Copy !req
369. - No, I mean, I was just trying
to protect Lana.
Copy !req
370. I mean, she needed to know
the truth about the man
Copy !req
371. she was gonna marry.
Copy !req
372. - So maybe you met
Dr. Hensley in the city, right?
Copy !req
373. You thought he was attracted
to you,
Copy !req
374. so you looked him up
on Instagram
Copy !req
375. and you found out
he was engaged?
Copy !req
376. - No, I saw him for therapy.
Copy !req
377. - Okay, okay.
Kitty...
Copy !req
378. There are so many
inconsistencies in your story.
Copy !req
379. We're just trying to figure out
what happened.
Copy !req
380. - You okay?
Copy !req
381. Oh, my God.
Copy !req
382. - Kitty, are you pregnant?
Copy !req
383. - Um...
Copy !req
384. I mean, after I was raped,
I just missed my period.
Copy !req
385. And I was really hoping
it was from the stress,
Copy !req
386. but then I started feeling
nauseous in the morning.
Copy !req
387. I took the test
right before you got here.
Copy !req
388. I'm pregnant,
and he did this to me.
Copy !req
389. - Yeah, and I always dreamed
Copy !req
390. of being a mom.
Copy !req
391. I had this doll
when I was five, Penelope.
Copy !req
392. She came with a bottle
and a diaper.
Copy !req
393. My imaginary husband was this
Copy !req
394. handsome prince
named Sebastian.
Copy !req
395. I never thought that
my baby's father
Copy !req
396. would be a man who raped me.
Copy !req
397. - Okay, I'll send these off
to the lab.
Copy !req
398. - Yeah, if you could put
a rush on that,
Copy !req
399. I'd appreciate it.
Copy !req
400. Thank you.
Copy !req
401. So, Kitty, I know that
it doesn't feel like it...
Copy !req
402. But you're strong,
and you're gonna
Copy !req
403. get through this.
Copy !req
404. - Well, a judge
can't make me keep it.
Copy !req
405. - No, of course not.
Copy !req
406. - Good, 'cause if Dr. Hensley
tries to stop me
Copy !req
407. from getting an abortion—
Copy !req
408. - Listen, even if he is
the father,
Copy !req
409. he has no right to do that.
Copy !req
410. - Good, 'cause I could never
love a baby
Copy !req
411. who was conceived by a monster.
Copy !req
412. You don't think
I should keep it?
Copy !req
413. - You know, whatever...
whatever you decide.
Copy !req
414. - What would you do?
Copy !req
415. - If it was me...
Copy !req
416. You know, I'm—I'm, um...
Copy !req
417. It's hard for me
to be objective.
Copy !req
418. But I think that you're raw
right now,
Copy !req
419. and with some distance
you'll realize that...
Copy !req
420. that this baby is half yours.
Copy !req
421. And no matter what happened
to you,
Copy !req
422. he or she...
Copy !req
423. It's not their fault.
Copy !req
424. - All right, and if I wait
Copy !req
425. and it's too late
to do anything...
Copy !req
426. - Yeah, but that's why
maybe you should
Copy !req
427. talk to someone.
Copy !req
428. - Another psychologist?
No, thank you.
Copy !req
429. I mean, as soon as these labs
come back,
Copy !req
430. I'm going right to the clinic.
Copy !req
431. I'm getting rid of this thing.
Copy !req
432. - If this woman is insisting
I impregnated her,
Copy !req
433. she must have some kind of
personality disorder
Copy !req
434. and she needs help.
Copy !req
435. - When the results come back,
you'll be my first call.
Copy !req
436. - Thanks.
- Thanks, Fitz.
Copy !req
437. - So once this DNA test
clears me,
Copy !req
438. this will all be over,
right?
Copy !req
439. - Not necessarily.
Copy !req
440. - But I'm not the father.
Copy !req
441. That means she's fabricating
the entire thing.
Copy !req
442. - Well, let's just take this
one step at a time.
Copy !req
443. - Fine.
Copy !req
444. But after this case
is dropped,
Copy !req
445. I'm gonna sue this woman
for every penny
Copy !req
446. in her bank account.
Copy !req
447. - You okay?
Copy !req
448. Sure.
Copy !req
449. - Kitty is not your mom.
Copy !req
450. - Well, she might as well be.
Copy !req
451. When I was 15 years old,
I overheard her on the phone...
Copy !req
452. Talking to someone.
Copy !req
453. And I heard her say,
Copy !req
454. "How could I love someone that
Copy !req
455. was conceived by...
Copy !req
456. a monster?"
Copy !req
457. That's exactly what...
what Kitty said to me.
Copy !req
458. - Hey.
Copy !req
459. Sorry, should I...
Copy !req
460. - What?
Copy !req
461. - The paternity came back.
It's a match.
Copy !req
462. - Pick him up.
Copy !req
463. - Ugh, what now?
- Bad news, Doc.
Copy !req
464. Paternity test came back,
and you're it.
Copy !req
465. - God.
Copy !req
466. - There must be
some mistake here.
Copy !req
467. - DNA doesn't lie.
- Lana, listen to me.
Copy !req
468. I did not rape that woman.
- Shut up!
Copy !req
469. Just shut up!
Copy !req
470. For once in your life
just shut up!
Copy !req
471. - I'm with Lana on this one.
Copy !req
472. Put your hands behind
your back.
Copy !req
473. - Lana, I love you, all right?
Do not give up on me!
Copy !req
474. - Let's go.
- Lana! I love you!
Copy !req
475. - I didn't rape Kitty.
Copy !req
476. - So how else do you explain
her being pregnant
Copy !req
477. with your unborn child?
Copy !req
478. - I lied about one thing.
- Oh, only one.
Copy !req
479. - Okay, more than one.
Copy !req
480. But Kitty and I,
we had consensual sex
Copy !req
481. three times
before I ended it.
Copy !req
482. I couldn't admit it before—
Copy !req
483. - Only after the DNA came back.
Copy !req
484. - She accused me of rape
in front of my entire family.
Copy !req
485. - You are very convincing.
Copy !req
486. And I don't believe a word
that comes out of your mouth.
Copy !req
487. - Will you at least
just hear me out?
Copy !req
488. - What do you got?
Hmm?
Copy !req
489. - Kitty was never my patient,
okay?
Copy !req
490. We met at a bar
around the corner
Copy !req
491. from where she lives.
Copy !req
492. - Okay, does this bar
have a name?
Copy !req
493. - Yeah, it's the Empty Room.
Copy !req
494. It's on 20th between
Ninth and Tenth.
Copy !req
495. It's a block from
Kitty's apartment.
Copy !req
496. - So much for not cheating
on Lana.
Copy !req
497. - Yeah, I'll give him
an A for creativity.
Copy !req
498. - Okay, so let me guess.
Copy !req
499. You're at the bar
and Kitty came on to you?
Copy !req
500. - No, not exactly.
Copy !req
501. She was sitting alone
at the bar,
Copy !req
502. I bought her a drink,
Copy !req
503. talked to her for about
ten minutes,
Copy !req
504. and realized how easy
this was gonna be.
Copy !req
505. - So why does Kitty claim
that she was her patient?
Copy !req
506. - Because she's vindictive,
okay?
Copy !req
507. And you don't believe me.
Copy !req
508. - Lie to me once...
- Okay, you know what?
Copy !req
509. After the second time that
Kitty and I slept together,
Copy !req
510. she gave me a key
to her apartment, here.
Copy !req
511. Apartment 4B.
Copy !req
512. - Giving how this case
is going,
Copy !req
513. you just knew the elevator
would be out.
Copy !req
514. - Liv doing okay
with all this?
Copy !req
515. - Yeah, it's a tough one,
but she's handling it.
Copy !req
516. - 4B.
- Yeah.
Copy !req
517. You sure this is kosher?
Copy !req
518. - Yeah, go ahead, stick it in,
see if it fits.
Copy !req
519. - No. Okay, but why play us
with something so stupid
Copy !req
520. if he knows it's not her key?
Copy !req
521. - Let's go to the videotape.
Copy !req
522. - The manager for
Kitty's building
Copy !req
523. pulled the last six months
of security footage
Copy !req
524. from the camera that
was on Kitty's floor.
Copy !req
525. - Yeah, TARU found the days
Hensley claims
Copy !req
526. Kitty took him home.
Copy !req
527. - They're both liars.
Copy !req
528. - I know how this looks.
Copy !req
529. - Well, Kitty it looks like
you were in
Copy !req
530. a consensual relationship
with Josh Hensley.
Copy !req
531. - Okay.
Copy !req
532. I mean, I did sleep
with Josh a few times,
Copy !req
533. but it was after he raped me
in his office.
Copy !req
534. I'm not lying about that.
Copy !req
535. - Kitty, Josh says that
you two first met in a bar
Copy !req
536. called The Empty Room.
Copy !req
537. - We talked to the bartender,
Copy !req
538. he said he saw
you two together.
Copy !req
539. - Yeah, but that was a few days
after my appointment.
Copy !req
540. - An appointment
that nobody can confirm.
Copy !req
541. - Did you give him your key?
Copy !req
542. - Yeah, but I changed the locks
after he dumped me.
Copy !req
543. - And that's what
this is about, right?
Copy !req
544. I mean, we know how hurt
you must have been
Copy !req
545. after you slept with Hensley,
Copy !req
546. and then you found out
he was engaged.
Copy !req
547. And he ended it,
you started to stalk him.
Copy !req
548. - No, that is not
how it happened.
Copy !req
549. - Okay, okay.
Copy !req
550. So, Kitty,
how did it happen?
Copy !req
551. - Okay, look,
after he raped me,
Copy !req
552. I went to confront him
outside of his office.
Copy !req
553. You know, I told him that
I was going to the police,
Copy !req
554. but he talked me out of it.
Copy !req
555. - How?
Copy !req
556. - Well, he insisted
that we go to a bar
Copy !req
557. so he could explain himself.
Copy !req
558. You know, and he said that
I wanted to be overpowered,
Copy !req
559. that there's a condition
for it—
Copy !req
560. "Erotic Rape Fantasy Disorder."
Copy !req
561. And he said, like,
how I played with my hair,
Copy !req
562. the way that I cross my legs
so he could see under my skirt,
Copy !req
563. that I was consciously
trying to seduce him.
Copy !req
564. - And then... and then
you took him home?
Copy !req
565. - He said that
I had intimacy issues.
Copy !req
566. You know, that the grief
from my mom was masking
Copy !req
567. my real problems and that
he would help me work that out.
Copy !req
568. Look, I'm sorry.
Copy !req
569. I know I screwed this up.
Copy !req
570. Is Josh in jail now?
Copy !req
571. - He was arraigned,
but he made bail,
Copy !req
572. so if he tries to contact you,
you gotta let us know.
Copy !req
573. - So Kitty,
we're gonna continue
Copy !req
574. with the investigation.
Copy !req
575. But if there's anything else,
you have—
Copy !req
576. - There isn't, I promise.
Copy !req
577. And I am so sorry that I didn't
tell you the whole truth.
Copy !req
578. - We'll be in touch.
Copy !req
579. What is she doing here?
Copy !req
580. You're not the victim—
I am!
Copy !req
581. I have your disgusting
Copy !req
582. - Please, leave me alone.
- Kitty, don't do this.
Copy !req
583. - Why does she hate me so much?
Copy !req
584. She's the one who destroyed
my life.
Copy !req
585. - Well, I think that that
might have something
Copy !req
586. - Last weekend I was walking
down the aisle to get married
Copy !req
587. and now... this nightmare
just keeps getting worse.
Copy !req
588. Josh finally told me that
he had an affair with her
Copy !req
589. while we were engaged.
Copy !req
590. - I heard.
Copy !req
591. So Lana, can we talk
about that?
Copy !req
592. When did you and Josh
first meet?
Copy !req
593. - Josh was my therapist.
Copy !req
594. But it wasn't like that.
Copy !req
595. We didn't start seeing
each other until
Copy !req
596. after I stopped seeing
him professionally.
Copy !req
597. I'm a real estate broker.
Copy !req
598. Josh reached out to me when
he started looking for
Copy !req
599. a loft in Manhattan.
Copy !req
600. - Uh-huh.
Copy !req
601. And that's when you two
started spending time together?
Copy !req
602. - I was going out with
another guy at the time,
Copy !req
603. and he convinced me
to break it off.
Copy !req
604. - Is that what you wanted?
Copy !req
605. - Josh has always been
really good to me.
Copy !req
606. Josh taught me about
classical music,
Copy !req
607. and Russian novels.
Copy !req
608. He took me to art galleries
and museums.
Copy !req
609. - Are those things that
you like to do?
Copy !req
610. - Josh makes all the decisions.
Copy !req
611. - Like... like what?
Copy !req
612. - Like, in the bedroom.
Copy !req
613. - Hmm.
Copy !req
614. - He likes to be dominant.
Copy !req
615. - Is that—
is that what you like?
Copy !req
616. - Sure.
Copy !req
617. - Hey, how'd it go with Lana
today?
Copy !req
618. - Oh, she is a mess.
Copy !req
619. This Josh Hensley is really
doing a number on her.
Copy !req
620. - She's still defending him?
- Oh, it gets better.
Copy !req
621. You ready for this?
He was her therapist.
Copy !req
622. - What?
- Yes.
Copy !req
623. I mean, she says that
they didn't start dating
Copy !req
624. until after she stopped
seeing him.
Copy !req
625. - But by then he knows
exactly what makes her tick.
Copy !req
626. - And how to manipulate her.
Copy !req
627. His power over her
is almost pathological.
Copy !req
628. I'm starting to think that
Kitty actually told us
Copy !req
629. the truth about what happened
in that office—
Copy !req
630. - Go back and sleep with your
rapist—we've seen it before.
Copy !req
631. - We have.
- Hey. I just got a heads up
Copy !req
632. from the 11 Precinct.
Patrol's responding to
Copy !req
633. a 911 call at Josh Hensley's
address right now.
Copy !req
634. - Let's go.
Copy !req
635. Hey, what do we got?
Copy !req
636. - Some kind of dispute
with a female intruder.
Copy !req
637. - Did you get her name?
- Kitty Bennett.
Copy !req
638. - Okay, did you try to go in?
Copy !req
639. - Sarge said you know
the parties, wait for you.
Copy !req
640. - Here we go.
- Okay, come on, Rollins.
Copy !req
641. - Lieutenant Benson!
- Are you okay?
Copy !req
642. - She said she would kill him
Copy !req
643. if he didn't admit
he raped her.
Copy !req
644. - Okay, Kitty.
Kitty, put the bottle down.
Copy !req
645. All right?
Let's just have a conversation.
Copy !req
646. - You think I'm lying.
- No, I don't.
Copy !req
647. - Okay, well, she does.
Copy !req
648. - Doesn't matter what
she thinks.
Copy !req
649. - Listen, you come any closer
to me and I'm just gonna do it.
Copy !req
650. - And then I'll have to
shoot you.
Copy !req
651. - Kitty, please.
Copy !req
652. Please, let him go
and just talk to me.
Copy !req
653. Just talk to me.
- What do you wanna talk about?
Copy !req
654. Huh? You wanna
talk about this thing
Copy !req
655. that's growing inside of me?
Copy !req
656. - I promise you Kitty,
we can figure that out.
Copy !req
657. We can get through that.
Copy !req
658. - I didn't want any of this.
- I know you didn't.
Copy !req
659. I know that.
Copy !req
660. - Josh, just do it,
just tell her the truth!
Copy !req
661. Okay? Just tell her!
Copy !req
662. - You need help, Kitty.
Let us help you.
Copy !req
663. - Kitty, Kitty,
do not listen to him.
Copy !req
664. - You think I need help
from you?
Copy !req
665. Like the way you helped me
Copy !req
666. with my so-called
"Rape Fantasy"? Huh?
Copy !req
667. The way you insisted
it was my fault,
Copy !req
668. how my body language
was an invitation.
Copy !req
669. - Kitty, nobody needs
to get hurt here.
Copy !req
670. - How I wanted you to take me
because I didn't fight back.
Copy !req
671. You know what, Josh?
Copy !req
672. Maybe I should just kill you
so you don't hurt anybody else.
Copy !req
673. - Kitty, Kitty, Kitty—
- Go ahead and kill him!
Copy !req
674. I know you're telling
the truth!
Copy !req
675. I know that Josh raped you!
Copy !req
676. - Oh, God, how dare you?
- No, please!
Copy !req
677. Listen to me, you said those
exact same words to me!
Copy !req
678. Remember, Josh?
Copy !req
679. The first time we had sex...
after you raped me.
Copy !req
680. - Kitty.
Kitty.
Copy !req
681. - Oh, my God.
Oh.
Copy !req
682. - It's okay, honey.
It's over.
Copy !req
683. It's okay.
Copy !req
684. - When Josh was looking
Copy !req
685. at lofts,
Copy !req
686. we drove all over Manhattan.
Copy !req
687. And we had lunches together
Copy !req
688. and drinks after appointments.
Copy !req
689. - Sure, so your professional
relationship turned personal.
Copy !req
690. - Josh really helped me
build my confidence.
Copy !req
691. I mean, I was new
to real estate.
Copy !req
692. He was charming
and really supportive.
Copy !req
693. - What happened on the day
he assaulted you?
Copy !req
694. - Josh and I went to see
a couple listings.
Copy !req
695. I had on this...
Copy !req
696. red silk dress, heels.
Copy !req
697. I had plans to go out
with friends that night.
Copy !req
698. - Yeah.
Copy !req
699. - We went to look at a loft
in Chelsea.
Copy !req
700. - The one you live in now.
Copy !req
701. - We were checking out
the bedroom
Copy !req
702. and that's when he grabbed me
by the waist
Copy !req
703. and he started kissing me.
Copy !req
704. And I was kind of flattered,
Copy !req
705. so I kissed him back.
Copy !req
706. But then he pushed me hard
on the bed...
Copy !req
707. And he climbed on top of me.
Copy !req
708. - Did you tell him to stop?
- Over and over again.
Copy !req
709. It just made him
more aggressive.
Copy !req
710. He pulled up my dress...
Copy !req
711. and he raped me.
Copy !req
712. And then I drove him home.
Copy !req
713. - Hey.
Copy !req
714. That doesn't make what
he did to you okay.
Copy !req
715. - I was so confused
about what had happened.
Copy !req
716. He called me the next day
and asked me to
Copy !req
717. make an offer on the loft.
Copy !req
718. When the seller accepted,
he showed up at my apartment
Copy !req
719. with flowers and champagne.
Copy !req
720. It was an apology for being
so rough with me.
Copy !req
721. When I tried to talk to him
about it,
Copy !req
722. he said it was okay that
I used my sexuality
Copy !req
723. to cement the relationship.
Copy !req
724. - He's sick.
Copy !req
725. - Lana...
Copy !req
726. I need to ask if you're willing
to testify against him
Copy !req
727. for what he did to you.
Copy !req
728. I didn't wanna admit to
myself what he really was.
Copy !req
729. Yeah, but when Kitty repeated
the very same things
Copy !req
730. he said to me...
Copy !req
731. Yes.
Copy !req
732. I'll testify.
Copy !req
733. - Pick him up again.
Copy !req
734. - What's going on here?
Copy !req
735. - It's a new case, Counselor.
Rape One.
Copy !req
736. - You managed to sink
your claws into
Copy !req
737. another supposed victim?
Copy !req
738. - I'm not the one
who has claws here.
Copy !req
739. That would be your client.
Copy !req
740. A grieving woman came to you
for help.
Copy !req
741. And in the space of an hour,
Copy !req
742. you managed to destroy
her life.
Copy !req
743. - Be that as it may,
what's this new arrest about?
Copy !req
744. - The complaining witness's
name is Lana Stallworth.
Copy !req
745. - Very funny.
- Hold on, no way.
Copy !req
746. No, Lana would never
turn on me.
Copy !req
747. - No?
Copy !req
748. She's testifying in front of
the Grand Jury as we speak.
Copy !req
749. - I gave both those women
exactly what they wanted.
Copy !req
750. - No, you conned them
into believing that
Copy !req
751. that's what they wanted.
Copy !req
752. And like any good con man,
Copy !req
753. you've convinced yourself
that your victims
Copy !req
754. got what they deserved.
Copy !req
755. You are done, Doctor.
You're done.
Copy !req
756. - Yeah, I mean,
I've been seeing
Copy !req
757. the therapist you
recommended.
Copy !req
758. She's really helping me
already.
Copy !req
759. - Very glad to hear that.
Copy !req
760. You know,
you've been through a lot.
Copy !req
761. - I mean, I still have
a lot of work to do.
Copy !req
762. I haven't decided what
I'm gonna do about this baby.
Copy !req
763. I mean, I thought for sure
I was gonna get an abortion.
Copy !req
764. - And now?
Copy !req
765. - I felt the baby kick
this morning.
Copy !req
766. It really reminded me
of what you said,
Copy !req
767. you know, what happened to me
is not this baby's fault.
Copy !req
768. - That doesn't mean
that it's not gonna be hard.
Copy !req
769. You know, I've known women
in your exact position
Copy !req
770. who have decided to raise
their daughter or their son.
Copy !req
771. And some days they don't
even think about it,
Copy !req
772. and other days...
Copy !req
773. You know, even though
your baby was conceived
Copy !req
774. in an act of violence,
Copy !req
775. your baby is innocent...
Copy !req
776. and deserves to be
unconditionally loved.
Copy !req
777. Promise me that if you decide
to become a mother...
Copy !req
778. That you'll remember that.
Copy !req
779. - I will.
Copy !req
780. - Take care.
Copy !req