1. In the criminal justice
system, sexually based offences
Copy !req
2. are considered especially heinous.
Copy !req
3. In New York City,
the dedicated detectives
Copy !req
4. who investigate these vicious felonies
Copy !req
5. are members of an elite squad
Copy !req
6. known as the Special Victims Unit.
Copy !req
7. These are their stories.
Copy !req
8. Gorgeous crowd.
Copy !req
9. For the most part.
Copy !req
10. No woman is ever
perfect enough for you, is she?
Copy !req
11. One is, and I'm looking right at her.
Copy !req
12. Mm.
Copy !req
13. Let's mingle.
Copy !req
14. Okay, so, take some Blue Curacao,
Copy !req
15. add it to your Moscow Mule,
and voilà, a Blue Mule.
Copy !req
16. I love it!
Copy !req
17. Yeah, it goes with
the theme of the party, girl.
Copy !req
18. Drink your winter blues away.
Copy !req
19. My God, your friends
are so damn good looking.
Copy !req
20. Yeah, get on out there.
Copy !req
21. Cuffing season is in
full swing, you know?
Copy !req
22. I mean just because it's cold
and people are lonely
Copy !req
23. doesn't mean that they're desperate
Copy !req
24. to cuff up with some rando.
Copy !req
25. Although, wow, he could make me
ignore my better angels.
Copy !req
26. Ah, thank you.
Copy !req
27. - Where were we?
- Hm...
Copy !req
28. Ohh, last bad date,
Chinese guy with the boat.
Copy !req
29. Oh, God, you have been listening.
Copy !req
30. Yeah, enough to know that that guy
Copy !req
31. brings nothing to the table.
Copy !req
32. - Eh, his family's rich.
- Well, I'm broke.
Copy !req
33. But I'm fun.
Copy !req
34. - Hi there, are you the host?
- Yes, guilty.
Copy !req
35. Well, thank you so much for having us.
Copy !req
36. My pleasure.
Copy !req
37. Here, let me help you with that, uh...
Copy !req
38. - Trina.
- I'll trade you, Trina.
Copy !req
39. - Okay.
- These look interesting.
Copy !req
40. Oh, I love Italian reds.
Copy !req
41. Everything the French
brag about, but cheaper.
Copy !req
42. - Hey, are you all right?
- Yeah, yeah.
Copy !req
43. Just, um, too many Moscow Mules.
Copy !req
44. My boyfriend's a doctor.
Let me get him.
Copy !req
45. Excuse me. Sorry.
Copy !req
46. Okay, everyone out. Let's go.
Copy !req
47. Bedroom's off limits.
Copy !req
48. - My bad.
- I said everyone. Come on.
Copy !req
49. - Have you seen Ava?
- Who?
Copy !req
50. The girl you were dancing with.
Copy !req
51. - Um, blonde, petite.
- So not as hot as you?
Copy !req
52. She was wasted. I think she left.
Copy !req
53. Help me.
Copy !req
54. Help. Help me. Help, please.
Copy !req
55. Please.
Copy !req
56. Hello? Help.
Copy !req
57. Ugh.
Copy !req
58. - Hello?
- You got the wrong house.
Copy !req
59. No! Wait, please. Please...
Copy !req
60. - Please.
- What's wrong?
Copy !req
61. Honey, what happened to you?
Copy !req
62. I was raped.
Copy !req
63. Bill?
Copy !req
64. I'll call 911.
Copy !req
65. Hey, Lieu, here you go.
Almond milk, no sugar.
Copy !req
66. Ah, you're the best.
So the victim was found
Copy !req
67. wandering the streets
ringing doorbells?
Copy !req
68. Ava Parcell, she's 30 years old.
Copy !req
69. Tox screen showed MDMA,
Clonazepam, and BAC was.15.
Copy !req
70. - Rape kit?
- Minor trauma.
Copy !req
71. She had bruising in the thighs,
Copy !req
72. semen in the throat and her mouth.
Copy !req
73. The lab is running DNA right now.
Copy !req
74. Oh, my God, with
that level of intoxication,
Copy !req
75. let's hope she knows
what planet she's on.
Copy !req
76. I don't do drugs, ever.
Copy !req
77. Okay, well, it's possible
Copy !req
78. that he may have slipped you something.
Copy !req
79. - Like, in my drink?
- Maybe.
Copy !req
80. Do you remember
where you were last night?
Copy !req
81. Yeah, my new boss, Trina,
had a party at her loft.
Copy !req
82. - I had a few Moscow Mules.
- Okay, were you with anyone?
Copy !req
83. This guy, Lee. We were dancing.
Copy !req
84. My body started to feel heavy and hot.
Copy !req
85. Do you remember what happened next?
Copy !req
86. I went to the bathroom.
Copy !req
87. I thought I was going to throw up.
Copy !req
88. Then after that,
everything just got fuzzy.
Copy !req
89. Ava, you said that you were assaulted.
Copy !req
90. Do you have any idea
where or when that was?
Copy !req
91. Was... was it at the loft party?
Copy !req
92. I'm not sure.
Copy !req
93. I woke up... in a strange bed.
Copy !req
94. My ankles were tied.
Copy !req
95. I untied them... and then I just ran.
Copy !req
96. Can you remember
any other details, maybe?
Copy !req
97. A noise, a sound, a specific smell?
Copy !req
98. He smelled... he smelled sweet.
Copy !req
99. Like... like Gucci Rush.
Copy !req
100. It made me think of high school.
Copy !req
101. That's helpful.
Was there... was there a woman?
Copy !req
102. No, oh, my God, it was hers.
It was hers.
Copy !req
103. My hands were pinned down
and I couldn't move
Copy !req
104. and they were taking turns.
Copy !req
105. They?
Copy !req
106. It was a couple.
Copy !req
107. It was a man and a woman.
Copy !req
108. They both raped me.
Copy !req
109. Oh, my God. That's horrible.
Copy !req
110. I found her purse and her phone
last night under the table.
Copy !req
111. Did you see who Ava left with?
Copy !req
112. No, it was so crowded.
Friends, friends of friends.
Copy !req
113. I don't even think I knew
half the people that were here.
Copy !req
114. - So you didn't see her leave?
- No, sorry.
Copy !req
115. - What about a guy named Lee?
- Lee Black?
Copy !req
116. - He didn't assault her.
- You sound pretty sure.
Copy !req
117. Yeah, because I am.
Copy !req
118. He was with me all night.
Copy !req
119. We're going to need to talk to him.
Copy !req
120. I don't see why.
Copy !req
121. Ava said she was raped by a couple.
Copy !req
122. You don't think that I'm... Okay, look.
Copy !req
123. Ava was long gone by the time
Lee and I hooked up
Copy !req
124. and that was after 5 a.m.?
Copy !req
125. Well, do you remember Ava hanging out
Copy !req
126. with any other couples at this party?
Copy !req
127. Yeah, there was this...
this one couple.
Copy !req
128. I didn't really know them.
Copy !req
129. Um, I think the guy
said he was a doctor.
Copy !req
130. Did you get a name?
Copy !req
131. No, but they did bring
a bottle of wine.
Copy !req
132. I saw that it was expensive so...
Copy !req
133. I hid it.
Copy !req
134. Lee Black. He's an unemployed actor.
Copy !req
135. Tox screen shows MDMA and cannabis.
Copy !req
136. But he's not the one who assaulted Ava?
Copy !req
137. His DNA was not a match.
Copy !req
138. Okay, so we're back to square one.
Copy !req
139. Okay, but maybe... maybe not.
Copy !req
140. The Calloway-Crowne,
Copy !req
141. they ID'd all the buyers
Copy !req
142. of their $500 Barbaresco
in the last week.
Copy !req
143. There was a web order
shipped to Connecticut,
Copy !req
144. a delivery to Brooklyn,
Copy !req
145. and an in-store purchase yesterday.
Copy !req
146. The name on the credit card
is Dr. Heath Barron.
Copy !req
147. The woman who threw the loft party,
Copy !req
148. she said the guy was a doctor.
Copy !req
149. Dr. Heath Barron.
Copy !req
150. He's a celebrity plastic surgeon.
Copy !req
151. "Mr. Mommy Make-Over."
He does reality TV.
Copy !req
152. He's a regular
on the talk show circuit.
Copy !req
153. And this is his girlfriend,
Sadie Parker.
Copy !req
154. She owns Sadie's Sugar Shack.
Designer cupcakes.
Copy !req
155. Okay, so let's see
if Ava can make an ID.
Copy !req
156. That's him. The guy from the party.
Copy !req
157. You sure? You... you recognize him?
Copy !req
158. Yes, that... he looks so familiar.
Copy !req
159. I-Is it possible
that you've seen him on TV?
Copy !req
160. No, I don't watch TV.
He was definitely there.
Copy !req
161. Trina said that he brought
Copy !req
162. a way expensive bottle of red wine.
Copy !req
163. And what about her?
Copy !req
164. She was so nice.
Copy !req
165. She took me outside
when I was feeling sick.
Copy !req
166. Do you remember getting
in a car with those two?
Copy !req
167. Uh, maybe. I don't know.
Copy !req
168. Okay, what do you...
Copy !req
169. what do you remember about them?
Copy !req
170. She gave me a drink
from her water bottle
Copy !req
171. and after that I went into a dark hole.
Copy !req
172. But before I blacked out she said
Copy !req
173. that she was going
to go get her boyfriend.
Copy !req
174. That he was a doctor.
Copy !req
175. Dr. Barron, I'm Lieutenant Benson.
Copy !req
176. Ah, the big gun. I'm impressed.
Copy !req
177. Sorry we, uh, screwed up your lunch.
Copy !req
178. Ah, I wasn't really
feeling sushi anyway.
Copy !req
179. Come in.
Copy !req
180. So I'm sure we could
put this to bed quickly.
Copy !req
181. About last night, uh, what can I say?
Copy !req
182. Sex can become complicated.
Copy !req
183. Well, we're just trying
to figure out why
Copy !req
184. Ava Parcell would accuse you of rape.
Copy !req
185. Yeah, I would like to know that, too.
Copy !req
186. You can ask me anything.
Copy !req
187. - Okay. Did you drug her?
- No.
Copy !req
188. Actually, she offered
Sadie and me ecstasy.
Copy !req
189. Sadie took a pill, I didn't.
Copy !req
190. I had patients to see today... so.
Copy !req
191. Ava was into it.
Copy !req
192. Can I talk to her?
Clear up the confusion?
Copy !req
193. Well, she didn't seem too confused.
Copy !req
194. Well, she must be.
Copy !req
195. How did you meet at the party?
Copy !req
196. We were drinking these
horrible blue drinks.
Copy !req
197. We started sharing.
Copy !req
198. Sharing what?
Copy !req
199. She said I was pretty,
Heath was handsome.
Copy !req
200. Uh, she mentioned she'd had
a bad three-way in college
Copy !req
201. and that maybe
it was time to try again.
Copy !req
202. So, uh, Ava was coming onto you?
Copy !req
203. Yes, but I didn't mind.
Copy !req
204. She wasn't into the guy
she was dancing with.
Copy !req
205. I ran into her in the bathroom.
She was queasy.
Copy !req
206. I took her outside for some air.
Copy !req
207. She offered me ecstasy. I took it.
Copy !req
208. And then?
Copy !req
209. We started rolling.
We got handsy, we kissed.
Copy !req
210. Then Heath found us.
Copy !req
211. Ava's tox screen showed
that she also had
Copy !req
212. Klonopin in her system.
Copy !req
213. Huh. That's a dangerous combination.
Copy !req
214. So you didn't give that to her?
Copy !req
215. No, that would be against
any doctor's ethical code.
Copy !req
216. No, we, uh, we met, connected.
Copy !req
217. She suggested taking the party home.
Copy !req
218. Sadie and I like to have fun
on our off hours.
Copy !req
219. Whose idea was it to take her home?
Copy !req
220. Hers.
Copy !req
221. She didn't have to twist my arm.
Copy !req
222. - And when you got here?
- Ava pulled me on top of her,
Copy !req
223. then she told Heath to tie her up.
Copy !req
224. Huh, the neckties. So that was...
Copy !req
225. - that was her idea, too?
- Yes.
Copy !req
226. We even had plans to go to breakfast.
Copy !req
227. When we woke up, she was gone.
Whatever she's saying...
Copy !req
228. She's saying that she was raped.
Copy !req
229. That she couldn't move,
she couldn't scream for help.
Copy !req
230. That is what she's saying.
Copy !req
231. I met this woman for
the first time last night.
Copy !req
232. She seemed cool but she was
obviously on drugs,
Copy !req
233. acting out a sexual fantasy.
Copy !req
234. She was using us.
Copy !req
235. Hm.
Copy !req
236. So, this is a regular thing,
picking up other women?
Copy !req
237. Sadie and I have
been together forever.
Copy !req
238. We're like an old married couple.
Copy !req
239. She jokes, "Add sugar
to maintain freshness."
Copy !req
240. She's a baker. That's why.
Copy !req
241. And Ava was the sweetener?
Copy !req
242. I have a public profile.
Copy !req
243. I don't know anything about
this woman or her agenda.
Copy !req
244. Is that on me? Yes.
Copy !req
245. Did I or Sadie assault her?
Absolutely not.
Copy !req
246. And if she keeps this up,
Copy !req
247. I'm going to have to call
my lawyer, okay?
Copy !req
248. You know, we've heard
this sex-games-gone-wrong story
Copy !req
249. a hundred times before. You buying it?
Copy !req
250. Well, Botox and Cupcakes?
Sounds tempting.
Copy !req
251. - You would've?
- No, but I can dream, right?
Copy !req
252. Dr. Barron, he's... he's
good-looking and he's nice,
Copy !req
253. he's successful, and Sadie
looks like she just stepped off
Copy !req
254. of a cover of some magazine, right?
Copy !req
255. I mean, if Ava's
into that sort of thing
Copy !req
256. and you throw some vodka
and ecstasy in the mix?
Copy !req
257. I get it. Look right there.
Copy !req
258. - Hi.
- Ava.
Copy !req
259. Hey, uh, why don't you
step into my office?
Copy !req
260. Yeah, can I get you coffee or anything?
Copy !req
261. No, I'm fine.
Copy !req
262. So what are they saying?
Copy !req
263. Well, they're claiming that
the three-way was consensual.
Copy !req
264. Consensual? No.
Copy !req
265. They also said that
you gave them the drugs.
Copy !req
266. I told you that I don't do drugs,
Copy !req
267. so, no, I didn't drug them.
Copy !req
268. Do you believe them?
Copy !req
269. We're just trying
to figure out what happened.
Copy !req
270. All right, there were
three people in that room
Copy !req
271. and two of them are saying
that you're lying.
Copy !req
272. - I'm not lying.
- Okay, well, Sadie also said
Copy !req
273. that you'd had a three-way in college.
Copy !req
274. Maybe you wanted to try it again?
Copy !req
275. Even if I wanted to try it
again, I did not want this.
Copy !req
276. Oh, my God. You don't believe me?
Copy !req
277. I did not want this.
Copy !req
278. - They raped me!
- Okay.
Copy !req
279. Okay, what? What are you going to do?
Copy !req
280. Are you going to arrest them?
Copy !req
281. We are going to build a case
and we're going to start
Copy !req
282. by getting a search warrant
for their apartment.
Copy !req
283. Okay?
Copy !req
284. There must be a lot of
beautiful people in this city.
Copy !req
285. Couldn't pay me to
inject poison in my face.
Copy !req
286. Damn, it's like a pharmacy in here.
Copy !req
287. Codeine, Oxy, Xanax, Ambien.
Copy !req
288. All prescribed to her by him.
Copy !req
289. Perks of living with
a doctor... nothing illegal.
Copy !req
290. Yeah, but you don't stash
your non-prescription drugs
Copy !req
291. in your medicine cabinet.
Copy !req
292. He's got some weed over here,
Copy !req
293. but he's got a prescription
for this, too.
Copy !req
294. Ey, whatever happened
Copy !req
295. to bottles of champagne and candles?
Copy !req
296. You don't really want me
to answer that, do you?
Copy !req
297. No, I don't.
Copy !req
298. Hey, I got some thumb drives over here.
Copy !req
299. Look at this.
Copy !req
300. Number 12. Jane, Mary, Jenny,
Copy !req
301. Nita, Melissa, and Ava.
Copy !req
302. Ava ever mention being recorded?
Copy !req
303. You like watching, babe?
Copy !req
304. You know I do.
Copy !req
305. - What about you, sweetheart?
- Okay.
Copy !req
306. Ava is clearly unconscious.
That's Rape One.
Copy !req
307. We found dozens more,
Copy !req
308. all labeled with girls'
first names and dates.
Copy !req
309. Going back ten years.
Copy !req
310. Lots of dilated pupils.
Copy !req
311. And Ava's the first to complain?
Copy !req
312. We could be looking
at a lot of victims here.
Copy !req
313. Well, let's start with one.
Copy !req
314. Pick up Sadie and Barron
for the rape of Ava Parcell.
Copy !req
315. Looking for Dr. Heath Barron.
Copy !req
316. Aren't we all? Get in line, honey.
Copy !req
317. Hey, where the hell is he?
Copy !req
318. He's in a private booth.
Copy !req
319. Mm, yeah.
Copy !req
320. Excuse me, Dr. Barron?
Copy !req
321. Uh, is there a problem, detectives?
Copy !req
322. I know you searched our house.
Copy !req
323. All the drugs were legal.
You could have just asked.
Copy !req
324. Look, I've been accommodating, polite.
Copy !req
325. I know you're just doing your jobs
Copy !req
326. but this is getting irritating.
Copy !req
327. - Oh, it's getting irritating?
- Yeah.
Copy !req
328. Heath, can they do this?
Copy !req
329. It'll be all right, Sadie.
I'm calling my lawyer.
Copy !req
330. You know what? That is a good idea,
Copy !req
331. because you're both under arrest
Copy !req
332. - for the rape of Ava Parcell.
- What?
Copy !req
333. So three-ways are illegal now?
Copy !req
334. I thought this was New York, not Texas.
Copy !req
335. The tyranny of the parochial, babe.
Copy !req
336. It's everywhere.
Copy !req
337. You arrested my client
because a party girl
Copy !req
338. enlisted him and his girlfriend
for a threesome?
Copy !req
339. What am I missing?
Copy !req
340. The video we have of our witness.
Copy !req
341. She's passed out in your client's bed,
Copy !req
342. incapable of consent.
Copy !req
343. Yeah, you and your girlfriend
Copy !req
344. got quite a collection
of sex tapes, Heath.
Copy !req
345. If watching sex is now illegal,
Copy !req
346. you're going to have to arrest
90% of the country.
Copy !req
347. Well, that's a good point,
but some of your victims
Copy !req
348. were too high to consent.
Copy !req
349. That woman is unconscious.
Copy !req
350. She's not unconscious.
Copy !req
351. She's pretending to be unconscious.
Copy !req
352. He name is Melissa Nochack.
Copy !req
353. She fantasized about
being a living doll.
Copy !req
354. So what, you can just do
whatever you want with her?
Copy !req
355. The important thing is
it's what she wanted.
Copy !req
356. Don't judge it until you've tried it.
Copy !req
357. You wouldn't mind that,
would you, Detective?
Copy !req
358. Two women,
both melting under your touch,
Copy !req
359. every erotic sense in your body
churning and churning
Copy !req
360. until they all explode simultaneously
Copy !req
361. in total mental and physical ecstasy?
Copy !req
362. You got a number
for this Melissa Nochack?
Copy !req
363. So do you tape all of your threesomes?
Copy !req
364. I like to watch.
Copy !req
365. You do more than watch, Sadie.
Copy !req
366. That's Jenny Abrams.
Copy !req
367. And she looks like she's
in quite a bit of distress.
Copy !req
368. Oh, she was orgasming.
Copy !req
369. It was a big one.
Copy !req
370. They say if you put photos side by side
Copy !req
371. of people in pain and people orgasming,
Copy !req
372. it's hard to tell the difference.
Copy !req
373. Have you ever made love to a woman?
Copy !req
374. Oh, I... I know you want to.
Copy !req
375. You want someone who understands you.
Copy !req
376. Your needs, your fantasies, your body.
Copy !req
377. Someone with gentle lips and
a curious and generous tongue
Copy !req
378. searching your mouth while
a man takes you hard, rough...
Copy !req
379. No, that's okay.
Copy !req
380. Sadie, are you aware
Copy !req
381. that your boyfriend brought a lawyer?
Copy !req
382. - I don't need a lawyer.
- Did he tell you that?
Copy !req
383. I have nothing to hide.
Copy !req
384. They got an answer for everything.
Copy !req
385. So did Ted Bundy, until he didn't.
Copy !req
386. They were forthcoming about details
Copy !req
387. I wouldn't want to get into.
Copy !req
388. Yeah, and they know
we're going to check.
Copy !req
389. So we check all of them.
Copy !req
390. Talk to each of the women they named
Copy !req
391. and anyone else you can
find from the tapes.
Copy !req
392. Yeah, that's me.
Copy !req
393. Uh, Jenny, I'm not trying
to embarrass you here, I just...
Copy !req
394. I need to know if what happened
on this night
Copy !req
395. was consensual or not.
It's... it's fine if it was.
Copy !req
396. It was.
Copy !req
397. Did you know
that they were filming you?
Copy !req
398. Sure. We watched it together after.
Copy !req
399. You seem pretty out of it
on the video, Nita.
Copy !req
400. Wait, you watched me?
Copy !req
401. Cool.
Copy !req
402. So this isn't a regular thing?
Copy !req
403. I wouldn't tell you if it was.
Copy !req
404. Look, I'm an attorney
at a high profile firm.
Copy !req
405. My private life is my private life.
Copy !req
406. That's fair enough, Melissa.
Copy !req
407. I just need to know if what
happened with Dr. Barron
Copy !req
408. and Sadie Parker was consensual.
Copy !req
409. So someone they've been intimate with
Copy !req
410. alleges it wasn't, right?
Copy !req
411. Well, I can only speak for myself,
Copy !req
412. but we had a very enjoyable evening.
Copy !req
413. Can I go?
Copy !req
414. Okay, thanks, Peter.
Copy !req
415. Heath and Sadie have been
arraigned and released R.O.R.
Copy !req
416. - Of course they were.
- These guys are Teflon.
Copy !req
417. We couldn't find anybody else
to say anything bad about them.
Copy !req
418. We've still got Ava.
Copy !req
419. Whose story will be a lot
less compelling to a jury
Copy !req
420. after they hear the other girls.
Copy !req
421. Okay, so keep looking.
Somebody's got to step up.
Copy !req
422. Or not.
Copy !req
423. Heath and Sadie
obviously aren't worried.
Copy !req
424. Now there are some
Copy !req
425. very troubling allegations against you,
Copy !req
426. specifically that you've
had non-consensual sex
Copy !req
427. with a number of women.
Copy !req
428. Yeah, and they are all 100% false.
Copy !req
429. Oh, they're going on the offensive.
Copy !req
430. This must have been aired this morning.
Copy !req
431. You have one of the most successful
Copy !req
432. plastic surgery practices in the city.
Copy !req
433. - Well, thank you.
- So what's going on?
Copy !req
434. Look, I certainly would have
preferred to have kept
Copy !req
435. my sex life private but, uh, yes.
Copy !req
436. The fact is, I enjoy having sex
Copy !req
437. with my girlfriend and our friends.
Copy !req
438. And what about you, Sadie?
Are you up for this?
Copy !req
439. Frankly, it was my idea.
It's normal, what we do.
Copy !req
440. Isn't she beautiful?
Copy !req
441. Look, I think in this one
instance, Ava... uh, sorry...
Copy !req
442. this young woman got
embarrassed after the fact,
Copy !req
443. which is a shame.
Copy !req
444. They're liars.
Copy !req
445. - Ava.
- I-I saw it.
Copy !req
446. My phone has been ringing off the hook.
Copy !req
447. They're making me out
to be the bad guy.
Copy !req
448. The... the prude.
Copy !req
449. You're not a prude,
Copy !req
450. because you didn't
want to be assaulted.
Copy !req
451. Listen to me. You just put that
Copy !req
452. out of your head.
That's... that's false.
Copy !req
453. I'm being vilified on TV, online.
Copy !req
454. They're saying that
I am doing this for a payoff.
Copy !req
455. Okay, just... just...
let's... let's take a breath.
Copy !req
456. You know, let's just drop
the whole thing.
Copy !req
457. I don't want to press charges.
I'm done.
Copy !req
458. Ava, they're going to keep going.
Copy !req
459. There's going to be more girls,
more victims.
Copy !req
460. Let them testify.
Copy !req
461. Hey, Lieu, I finally
got something on that S.O.B.
Copy !req
462. I found an encrypted video
on the doc's computer.
Copy !req
463. TARU enhanced it.
Copy !req
464. It's, uh... it's particularly vivid.
Copy !req
465. The ending's no surprise.
Copy !req
466. She can't be more than 14 or 15.
Copy !req
467. I don't think the feds
are going to prosecute
Copy !req
468. for possession of one video,
but look at this.
Copy !req
469. Medical books.
Copy !req
470. You think that Barron made this video?
Copy !req
471. Yeah. I sent that girl's
image to NCMEC.
Copy !req
472. Now they matched it
through facial recognition.
Copy !req
473. Her name is Ceci Taylor.
She went missing
Copy !req
474. from Brooklyn 14 years ago.
That is one year before
Copy !req
475. Heath Barron graduated Stony Point Med.
Copy !req
476. That's two hours north of the city.
Copy !req
477. Now, if we can just prove
that he shot this video there...
Copy !req
478. Go, go.
Copy !req
479. The Dean told me you were in
Heath Barron's class
Copy !req
480. in med school, Professor.
Copy !req
481. Louise is fine. My little Heath Bar.
Copy !req
482. That's what I called him.
It was a long time ago.
Copy !req
483. - So you two were close?
- Sure.
Copy !req
484. How do I put this?
He wanted to be a lot closer.
Copy !req
485. But you didn't want that.
Copy !req
486. I was dating a guy with dirt
under his fingernails.
Copy !req
487. Contractor.
Copy !req
488. How did Heath handle rejection?
Copy !req
489. Let me count the ways. Flowers, candy.
Copy !req
490. Once I went to his place to study.
Copy !req
491. He had a five course meal laid out
Copy !req
492. including some
chichi bottle of Italian red.
Copy !req
493. Cost more than my rent.
Copy !req
494. Do you remember where his place was?
Copy !req
495. It's out near the lake.
Copy !req
496. I live out that way
if you want to follow.
Copy !req
497. Oh, my God.
Copy !req
498. I'm so sorry, Mr. Taylor.
Copy !req
499. One day Cecilia went to school
Copy !req
500. and she never came home.
Copy !req
501. That's not out there on the Internet?
Copy !req
502. No, no, no, no.
Copy !req
503. As far as we know, it's just
on one person's computer.
Copy !req
504. What the hey?
Copy !req
505. Thank heaven for the little things.
Copy !req
506. She's dead, isn't she?
Copy !req
507. We don't know.
Copy !req
508. My wife and I didn't
raise her like that.
Copy !req
509. Ceci was a good girl.
Copy !req
510. Sure, she smoked a little weed.
Who didn't?
Copy !req
511. But she told us about it.
Copy !req
512. She and Ruth were so close.
Copy !req
513. Your wife?
Copy !req
514. Passed away last year.
Copy !req
515. Hit by a drunk driver
on Nostrand Avenue.
Copy !req
516. Ceci and Ruth talked about everything.
Copy !req
517. She was mostly happy till high school.
Copy !req
518. She told Ruth all about
her... her first crush,
Copy !req
519. Rob Kurtz.
Copy !req
520. You know how it is with teen girls.
Copy !req
521. She wasn't in with the "in" crowd.
Copy !req
522. So she assumed it was
because she wasn't...
Copy !req
523. pretty.
Copy !req
524. There was nothing we could do or say
Copy !req
525. to convince her otherwise.
Copy !req
526. Rob's a lawyer now out in LA.
Copy !req
527. Mr. Taylor...
Copy !req
528. I know how difficult this is.
Copy !req
529. Is it possible that Ceci ever...
Copy !req
530. ever tried to get ahold
of you via text or via email?
Copy !req
531. Maybe... maybe the phone rang
and no one was there?
Copy !req
532. Believe me, we prayed every night
Copy !req
533. for a sign she was alive.
Copy !req
534. Seven years ago on Ceci's birthday,
Copy !req
535. Ruthie and I had a fake funeral.
Copy !req
536. Father John said it would
give us some kind of closure.
Copy !req
537. There's no such thing as closure.
Copy !req
538. What the hey?
Copy !req
539. Maybe it's a good thing Ruthie's gone.
Copy !req
540. Come on, girls, here we go.
Coo, coo-coo-coo.
Copy !req
541. - Excuse me.
- Huh? Hmm?
Copy !req
542. Oh, can I help you?
Copy !req
543. Sergeant Tutuola, Detective Carisi.
Copy !req
544. Can we talk to you for a minute?
Copy !req
545. - Is something wrong?
- We just want to ask you
Copy !req
546. about somebody who used to live here.
Copy !req
547. Heath Barron?
Copy !req
548. Yeah. Oh, please.
Copy !req
549. - I'll get it.
- Thanks.
Copy !req
550. Yeah, so my husband and I
just split up.
Copy !req
551. Sorry to hear that.
Copy !req
552. Ugh, Noel ran off
with our lawyer's assistant.
Copy !req
553. This house just had too many memories.
Copy !req
554. My sister asked me to move in
with her in Philly.
Copy !req
555. That's where we grew up.
Copy !req
556. And Heath was the first person
to answer the ad,
Copy !req
557. so I rented it to him.
Copy !req
558. Mrs. Kimbel, um, did anybody
ever move in here with Heath?
Copy !req
559. - You mean like a girl?
- That's exactly what we mean.
Copy !req
560. - I doubt it.
- Why's that?
Copy !req
561. When he came to look at the place,
Copy !req
562. we had a cup of coffee and a long talk,
Copy !req
563. and he told me he was fixed
on this med student,
Copy !req
564. but she was living with another
guy who worked construction.
Copy !req
565. So I told him about girls like that,
Copy !req
566. girls who prefer men with
calluses on their hands
Copy !req
567. to grey matter in their heads.
Copy !req
568. I'm a girl like that.
Look where it got me.
Copy !req
569. Does this house have a basement?
Copy !req
570. - Yeah.
- Can we take a look?
Copy !req
571. Yes, of course.
Copy !req
572. He shot the video right there.
Copy !req
573. Let me see it.
Copy !req
574. Mrs. Kimbel, did you do
any remodeling down here?
Copy !req
575. No, never.
Copy !req
576. So you didn't replace
any of these panels?
Copy !req
577. Actually, I never noticed that before.
Copy !req
578. Mrs. Kimbel, would you do me a favor
Copy !req
579. and wait for us upstairs?
Copy !req
580. Oh, sure.
Copy !req
581. Guess we know what happened
to Ceci Taylor.
Copy !req
582. Seven years for child porn.
Murder he goes away for life.
Copy !req
583. Oh, my God!
Copy !req
584. He covered the body in lye
to stop the smell.
Copy !req
585. Something a med student
would know. I have...
Copy !req
586. Well, he's not just a perv anymore.
Copy !req
587. He's a perv murderer.
Copy !req
588. Guys, let's... let's not get
out ahead of our skis.
Copy !req
589. Let's not get ahead of our skis?
Copy !req
590. Lieutenant, no disrespect but
we got a little girl on video.
Copy !req
591. We got a little girl's bones.
Copy !req
592. From where I'm standing,
two plus two equals four.
Copy !req
593. And sometimes it doesn't.
Copy !req
594. The ME ran the DNA
from the bones in the bag
Copy !req
595. against a sample from a hair
brush that her father gave us.
Copy !req
596. It doesn't match up.
Copy !req
597. The body in the bag is not Ceci Taylor?
Copy !req
598. Not if you believe science.
Copy !req
599. Maybe that new video of Ceci
will convince Ava to testify.
Copy !req
600. That video was very convincing.
Copy !req
601. Maybe it'll convince someone else.
Copy !req
602. Thanks for coming in, Sadie.
Copy !req
603. I didn't really have a choice, did I?
Copy !req
604. No, you didn't.
Copy !req
605. I actually feel sorry for Ava.
Copy !req
606. Sex shouldn't be a shameful thing.
Copy !req
607. Heath's lawyer says
she doesn't want to testify.
Copy !req
608. Well, not everyone's
as open as you are.
Copy !req
609. But I actually didn't want to
speak to you about Ava.
Copy !req
610. Why don't you have a seat?
Copy !req
611. Is someone else telling
more lies about us?
Copy !req
612. I wanted to talk to you about a video
Copy !req
613. that Heath kept hidden on his computer.
Copy !req
614. Yeah, I wondered why he didn't
want you to see this one.
Copy !req
615. Her name is Ceci Taylor.
Copy !req
616. She was 14 when you recorded this
Copy !req
617. so that makes you a pedophile, Doc.
Copy !req
618. You think that's me?
Copy !req
619. Oh, for God's sakes.
Copy !req
620. - Somebody emailed it to me.
- And you kept it.
Copy !req
621. It was years ago. I forgot about it.
Copy !req
622. I have no idea who made that.
Copy !req
623. That's weird, because it was recorded
Copy !req
624. when and where you
lived during med school.
Copy !req
625. The odds are pretty good that, uh,
Copy !req
626. that you're telling
a little white one here.
Copy !req
627. Pretty good doesn't cut it
in a criminal trial, Detective.
Copy !req
628. I'm sorry, how do you know
Copy !req
629. where I lived during medical school?
Copy !req
630. I'm glad you asked me that.
Your old classmate, Louise,
Copy !req
631. took my colleagues there.
Copy !req
632. Yeah, did you know Louise
teaches at your alma mater now?
Copy !req
633. You spoke to Louise?
Copy !req
634. Yeah. Looks like somebody
Copy !req
635. might still be carrying a torch.
Copy !req
636. Please, that's ridiculous.
Copy !req
637. That's one possibility.
Copy !req
638. The other possibility is that
you've been looking
Copy !req
639. for Ms. Louise
ever since she walked out
Copy !req
640. of your five course
Italian feast 14 years ago.
Copy !req
641. We also found this at the house.
Copy !req
642. Now my guess is that's another one
Copy !req
643. of your boyfriend's victims.
Copy !req
644. You think Heath killed somebody?
Copy !req
645. I do.
Copy !req
646. A teenage runaway that he used
before he found Ceci.
Copy !req
647. She was a great substitute
for Louise for a minute,
Copy !req
648. but then you got tired of her.
Enter Ceci.
Copy !req
649. And I suppose I killed her too?
Copy !req
650. I'm thinking
we'll be digging up her bones
Copy !req
651. sooner or later, yeah.
Copy !req
652. God. What is it with you people?
Copy !req
653. Do you hate sex
or are you just scared of it?
Copy !req
654. We enjoy what's natural,
what's beautiful.
Copy !req
655. You get your jollies by turning it all
Copy !req
656. into something sick and criminal.
Copy !req
657. Truth be told, I couldn't
care less what you and Heath
Copy !req
658. do in your private life,
Copy !req
659. as long as nobody else gets hurt.
Copy !req
660. That's the only thing
that I'm concerned with.
Copy !req
661. But somebody else did get hurt, Sadie.
Copy !req
662. Somebody ended up
in the wall of his house.
Copy !req
663. Now I'm assuming that you
didn't know about that.
Copy !req
664. He's a healer, not a killer.
Copy !req
665. What the hey?
You'll never prove any of it.
Copy !req
666. Oh, my God.
Copy !req
667. Oh, my God.
Copy !req
668. You're Ceci.
Copy !req
669. I don't know what you're talking about.
Copy !req
670. You're the girl in this video.
Copy !req
671. You're crazy... look at her.
She looks nothing like me.
Copy !req
672. Of course she doesn't,
Copy !req
673. because Dr. Heath Barron
took care of that.
Copy !req
674. He got bored with Ceci,
so he turned her into Sadie?
Copy !req
675. - Stop!
- Stop? Ceci, you were 14.
Copy !req
676. You should have been out
shopping for prom dresses or...
Copy !req
677. or gossiping with your friends
about Rob Kurtz.
Copy !req
678. I said stop!
Copy !req
679. He's in LA, by the way.
He's a lawyer there.
Copy !req
680. Heath Barron stole
all of that from you.
Copy !req
681. It's time for you to stop
protecting him.
Copy !req
682. You've never been in love, have you?
Copy !req
683. But does he love you?
Copy !req
684. That's a stupid question.
Copy !req
685. I'm everything to him.
Copy !req
686. Then why does he keep inviting
Copy !req
687. other women into your bed?
Copy !req
688. Her name is Moira.
Copy !req
689. I met her at a bowling alley
in Brooklyn.
Copy !req
690. It was raining.
I didn't have my umbrella.
Copy !req
691. She said her friend
would drive me home.
Copy !req
692. But he took you up to his lake house?
Copy !req
693. I thought it would be fun.
Copy !req
694. So what happened to Moira?
Copy !req
695. One day I woke up and she was gone.
Copy !req
696. He told me she went back home
to her mom.
Copy !req
697. I saw him re-paneling the wall,
Copy !req
698. but he said it was a water leak.
Copy !req
699. Do you know what I think, Ceci?
Copy !req
700. I think that Moira
Copy !req
701. didn't live up to his fantasy
Copy !req
702. and so...
Copy !req
703. He's not a killer.
Copy !req
704. Oh, that's... that's not what he is.
Copy !req
705. Maybe it was an accident.
Copy !req
706. Maybe he didn't mean to kill her.
Copy !req
707. But whatever it was,
when he got bored with her,
Copy !req
708. you became his fantasy girl.
Copy !req
709. And then when he got bored with you,
Copy !req
710. he molded you into
what he saw as perfection.
Copy !req
711. No, no! He loves me.
Copy !req
712. No, he loves the idea of you.
Copy !req
713. The perfect beauty.
Copy !req
714. But beauty fades, Ceci.
Copy !req
715. Even the perfect beauty
that he created.
Copy !req
716. That's why he brings
other women home to your bed.
Copy !req
717. Because he's searching for something
Copy !req
718. that can never, ever really exist.
Copy !req
719. Look, women are fragile beings.
Copy !req
720. They're tortured by the what-ifs.
Copy !req
721. What if I didn't have that damn mole?
Copy !req
722. What if my lips were a little plumper?
Copy !req
723. What if my breasts
were a little firmer?
Copy !req
724. I'm sure you know
Copy !req
725. what I'm talking about, Detective.
Copy !req
726. I'm sure you've spent more than
one sleepless night wondering,
Copy !req
727. "What if my body doesn't
return to where it was?"
Copy !req
728. We don't need to talk about me.
Copy !req
729. Why not? You're a woman.
Copy !req
730. You have fantasies.
Copy !req
731. I make those fantasies real.
Copy !req
732. I do not kill little girls.
Copy !req
733. You don't care about
your patient's fantasies.
Copy !req
734. You care about your own.
Copy !req
735. But that's the thing about fantasies.
Copy !req
736. They're not going to be
about flesh and blood.
Copy !req
737. - They're never going to be real.
- Okay, you know what?
Copy !req
738. I've heard enough of this.
Let's go home.
Copy !req
739. The only place you're going
is Rikers; sit down.
Copy !req
740. - He's already been R.O.R.
- Yeah, for Ava's rape.
Copy !req
741. Now he's looking at murder,
so I said sit.
Copy !req
742. Did you rape Ava Parcell?
Copy !req
743. I know that you weren't in
control of what you were doing,
Copy !req
744. and I know that you did
everything for him.
Copy !req
745. - He needs me.
- Yes, he does.
Copy !req
746. But you don't need to spend
Copy !req
747. the rest of your life in prison.
Copy !req
748. So tell me what happened, Ceci,
and we can work out a deal.
Copy !req
749. We gave Ava a lot of drugs.
It's not like we hurt her.
Copy !req
750. Yes, you did.
Copy !req
751. And you more than anyone
should know that.
Copy !req
752. I didn't mean to. I just like being...
Copy !req
753. Being what, Ceci?
Copy !req
754. Being beautiful.
Copy !req
755. She's so sad.
Copy !req
756. They were both searching for
something that didn't exist.
Copy !req
757. I'll testify.
Copy !req
758. Good.
Copy !req
759. It's the right thing.
Copy !req
760. So Stone says he'll work with Ceci
Copy !req
761. if she testifies against Barron.
Copy !req
762. NCMEC found two Moiras
missing in the time frame.
Copy !req
763. I would not want to make those calls.
Copy !req
764. Mr. Taylor.
Copy !req
765. I came as soon as I could. Is she okay?
Copy !req
766. She's a little rattled,
Copy !req
767. but I'm sure that this will help.
Copy !req
768. This way. Hey, can we open it up?
Copy !req
769. Hi.
Copy !req
770. Ceci?
Copy !req
771. Daddy, I'm sorry.
Copy !req
772. Oh, baby. Oh, baby, ohh.
Copy !req
773. - Oh, baby.
- I'm so sorry.
Copy !req
774. Oh, it's okay.
Copy !req
775. Oh, it's okay. Ohh.
Copy !req