1. by two separate
yet equally important groups:
Copy !req
2. the police,
who investigate crime
Copy !req
3. and the district attorneys
who prosecute the offenders.
Copy !req
4. These are their stories.
Copy !req
5. Must have been
a good party.
Copy !req
6. All parties are good
Copy !req
7. after 12:00
and before 3:00.
Copy !req
8. Do you think Sarah Louise
drinks too much?
Copy !req
9. You were counting?
Copy !req
10. I'm just jealous.
Copy !req
11. I can't touch a drop
Copy !req
12. if we're really going
to start trying.
Copy !req
13. You really want to?
Copy !req
14. Don't you?
Copy !req
15. As long as I don't have
to do the 2:00 feeding.
Copy !req
16. Honey, the flowers.
Copy !req
17. My brother, he say ain't
no woman good enough for him.
Copy !req
18. Including his wife.
Copy !req
19. It came from the garage.
Two shots, man.
Copy !req
20. 1290 Sixth Avenue,
1-2-9-0 Sixth.
Copy !req
21. Check him out.
Copy !req
22. Captioning sponsored by
NBC/UNIVERSAL
Copy !req
23. Can she talk?
Copy !req
24. Yeah, at the hospital.
Copy !req
25. Yeah, the good citizens
outside, they heard screams.
Copy !req
26. Yean, and they fell
all over each other,
Copy !req
27. trying to help, right?
Copy !req
28. Robbery?
Copy !req
29. Her purse was empty,
and his wallet's gone.
Copy !req
30. It's probably in a garbage can
a block away. I.D.?
Copy !req
31. Car registration.
Copy !req
32. Ralston, Janet, Alan.
Copy !req
33. They live a block away.
Copy !req
34. In the stairwell,
crack pipe.
Copy !req
35. Still warm.
Copy !req
36. Witnesses?
Copy !req
37. 32 Of them,
all blind.
Copy !req
38. Car like that?
Copy !req
39. They should have bought
a clunker
Copy !req
40. and spent the money
on a better neighborhood.
Copy !req
41. Or one at least more than a
block from a police precinct.
Copy !req
42. Those people,
how much paper they got?
Copy !req
43. A couple hundred grand?
Copy !req
44. I was them,
I'd have me a driver.
Copy !req
45. You don't even
have a car.
Copy !req
46. If I had a car.
Copy !req
47. And if I did,
it wouldn't be no Lincoln.
Copy !req
48. Ladies, you see
anybody at all?
Copy !req
49. No, I ain't hear nothing,
I ain't seen nothing.
Copy !req
50. That's what
she's good at, nothing.
Copy !req
51. He was black.
A kid.
Copy !req
52. Came out that door
running.
Copy !req
53. You get a look
at him?
Copy !req
54. Designated driver says
he saw a kid.
Copy !req
55. How many fingers?
Copy !req
56. Three.
Copy !req
57. WOMAN OVER P.A.:
Dr. Ostroski to Room 408.
Copy !req
58. Mrs. Ralston
was very lucky.
Copy !req
59. Lucky?
Copy !req
60. She lost her husband.
Copy !req
61. Well, let's say her children
were lucky, then.
Copy !req
62. At least she's
still around.
Copy !req
63. When can we get a
description
from her?
Copy !req
64. As soon as she wakes up,
I would think.
Copy !req
65. So the wounds
weren't serious, then.
Copy !req
66. Defense wound
to the forearm
Copy !req
67. and one
to the left gluteus maximus.
Copy !req
68. Last year, Janet was mugged.
Central Park.
Copy !req
69. Ardsley, Hastings...
Copy !req
70. she wanted to move
somewhere up the Hudson.
Copy !req
71. Someplace
with a backyard.
Copy !req
72. The city's no place
to raise a family anymore.
Copy !req
73. Just last week I was getting
their finances in order.
Copy !req
74. They wanted to move
before the third kid.
Copy !req
75. Alan's mother.
Copy !req
76. I called, uh... I called Denise,
the baby-sitter.
Copy !req
77. She's taking care
of the kids.
Copy !req
78. You were with the children
last night?
Copy !req
79. Those poor babies.
Copy !req
80. Without Alan...
Copy !req
81. Excuse me.
Copy !req
82. a seminar next Monday
There will be
WOMAN OVER P.A.:
Copy !req
83. care center.
about the comprehensive
Copy !req
84. Mr. Himes, could you get
a list of the stuff
Copy !req
85. they were carrying—
jewelry, credit cards?
Copy !req
86. I'll have it to you
first thing in the morning.
Copy !req
87. $50,000
for information
Copy !req
88. leading to the arrest
and conviction
Copy !req
89. of whoever killed
Alan Ralston.
Copy !req
90. I'll have my lawyer notify
the papers in the morning.
Copy !req
91. 50 grand.
Copy !req
92. If that's what it took
to get a killer,
Copy !req
93. they'd get rid of us and use
our salaries as rewards.
Copy !req
94. Couldn't look worse.
Copy !req
95. Could have happened
in front of the precinct.
Copy !req
96. Half a block away! Two cops!
Copy !req
97. They don't issue
telepathy with badges.
Copy !req
98. Oh, really?
Well, I'm telepathic,
Copy !req
99. and this is the message
I'm sending.
Copy !req
100. I don't like looking
like a freaking incompetent!
Copy !req
101. The message I'm getting is
that we're at a dead end.
Copy !req
102. 30 people on the street.
Copy !req
103. The only good citizen
to come forward is a wino.
Copy !req
104. Well, then you squeeze him
for everything he's got.
Copy !req
105. Then you interview
everybody who was on
the street that night.
Copy !req
106. Then you interview everybody
who lives on the street.
Copy !req
107. Are you getting the picture?
Copy !req
108. Shelters...
Copy !req
109. rather sleep on the street.
Copy !req
110. Company's better.
Copy !req
111. No room service, though.
Copy !req
112. Him.
Copy !req
113. Maybe.
Copy !req
114. Yup.
Copy !req
115. Same guy. Twice.
Copy !req
116. Willie Tivnan.
Copy !req
117. You want to buy me a drink?
Copy !req
118. Mr. Tivnan has a scar
on his thumb.
Copy !req
119. Cut himself deep once.
Copy !req
120. One thing crack stems
are good for,
Copy !req
121. clear prints.
Copy !req
122. Nine millimeter.
Copy !req
123. Marks on the shell casing
says it's probably a Beretta.
Copy !req
124. Fancy gun
for the street.
Copy !req
125. My guess?
Copy !req
126. He didn't go
to Italy to buy it.
Copy !req
127. Willie got
an armed robbery?
Copy !req
128. Twice with knives.
Plead down to misdemeanors.
Copy !req
129. Breaking and entering,
four hotel burglaries...
Copy !req
130. Hotel! Well, now we know
where he got the Beretta.
Copy !req
131. Nothing with guns.
Copy !req
132. Four juvenile
detention facilities.
Copy !req
133. Sing Sing. Attica.
Copy !req
134. Hey, well,
at least Willie visits
Copy !req
135. all the best vacation spots.
Copy !req
136. The last three busts,
popped at the same location.
Copy !req
137. Let's go book him
another trip.
Copy !req
138. Did she call?
Copy !req
139. Oh, yeah.
Copy !req
140. Oh, yeah.
Copy !req
141. Yo, wait up there.
Copy !req
142. Principles
of Eastern philosophy.
Copy !req
143. How much?
Copy !req
144. I didn't know
cops could read.
Copy !req
145. I can read a rap sheet, Willie.
Copy !req
146. Just words, man.
Copy !req
147. That's all I sell,
you know.
Copy !req
148. Magazines and books.
Copy !req
149. Law says you
can sell them
Copy !req
150. on the street
without a license.
Copy !req
151. What were you selling
Saturday night, Willie?
Copy !req
152. Man...
Copy !req
153. Hey, man!
Copy !req
154. Watch out, man!
Copy !req
155. Hey, you jerk!
Copy !req
156. Your car, Willie.
Copy !req
157. A garage?
Copy !req
158. I ain't got no wheels.
Copy !req
159. What am I going
to park in there?
Copy !req
160. Except my butt.
Copy !req
161. Your fingerprints.
Copy !req
162. The ones you left
on the crack pipe
Copy !req
163. that you left in the garage.
Copy !req
164. Okay, man.
Copy !req
165. Look, I was there.
Copy !req
166. I was just smoking, that's all.
Copy !req
167. Where did you get the Beretta?
Copy !req
168. Man, I told...
Copy !req
169. I hear somebody
coming down.
Copy !req
170. I figure it's the Rican,
Copy !req
171. but then I hear shots.
Copy !req
172. You know, one, then two more.
Copy !req
173. Bam, bam!
Copy !req
174. So, what,
you going to arrest me?
Copy !req
175. Better get me a lawyer.
Copy !req
176. Alan was coming around
the front of the car
Copy !req
177. to open my door.
Copy !req
178. I got out of the car.
Copy !req
179. I gave him a kiss.
Copy !req
180. I noticed there were
some flowers in the back seat.
Copy !req
181. I asked him to get the flowers.
Copy !req
182. He opened the back door.
Copy !req
183. He was looking for something
in his pocket.
Copy !req
184. He said, "Did you lock it?"
Copy !req
185. The car, he meant.
Copy !req
186. I turned to look.
Copy !req
187. He went towards the stairwell.
Copy !req
188. The door opened.
Copy !req
189. A man came out...
Copy !req
190. black.
Copy !req
191. I didn't see a gun.
Copy !req
192. I heard the shot
Copy !req
193. and saw the look
on Alan's face
Copy !req
194. like he'd been punched.
Copy !req
195. Look at these carefully.
Copy !req
196. Number three.
Copy !req
197. I don't...
Copy !req
198. Take your time.
Copy !req
199. Uh, number five.
Copy !req
200. Thank you.
Copy !req
201. They're still crawling
out of the woodwork.
Copy !req
202. Eight mugging victims,
Copy !req
203. and the paper's only been out
for four hours.
Copy !req
204. They all get positive I.D.s?
Copy !req
205. Logan is finishing up
the last one now.
Copy !req
206. The first seven?
Copy !req
207. If Willie didn't do them,
he's got a twin.
Copy !req
208. Number eight. Same M.O.--
six-inch switchblade.
Copy !req
209. What?
Copy !req
210. These kids...
Copy !req
211. He never killed anybody.
Copy !req
212. His M.O.?
He uses a knife.
Copy !req
213. He was in there
smoking crack.
Copy !req
214. but he didn't
kill Ralston?
Copy !req
215. We don't tie him to a gun,
we got no case.
Copy !req
216. We don't arraign him,
he's out in 48 hours,
Copy !req
217. we'll never
see him again.
Copy !req
218. Call the D.A.
Copy !req
219. Willie Tivnan.
Copy !req
220. The charges are murder
in the second degree,
Copy !req
221. attempted murder
and assault in the first degree.
Copy !req
222. Does the defendant
wish to enter a plea?
Copy !req
223. Not guilty.
Copy !req
224. The defendant is indigent,
Miss Strickland, is that right?
Copy !req
225. Yes, Your Honor, and the
public defendant's office
Copy !req
226. feel strongly
that the facts do not
warrant these charges.
Copy !req
227. Without and indictment...
Copy !req
228. Your Honor, we feel
there's sufficient evidence.
Copy !req
229. Also, the defendant
has previous convictions,
Copy !req
230. and has missed
two court appearances.
Copy !req
231. It's two
violent felonies,
Copy !req
232. and one of them
a homicide.
Copy !req
233. And the defendant
has no known residence.
Copy !req
234. Bail is set at $100,000.
Copy !req
235. Next case.
Copy !req
236. Docket #94628.
Copy !req
237. People vs Pike...
Where's your boss?
Copy !req
238. You think he shows up
for the arraignment
of every two-bit
Copy !req
239. crackhead
who's dead-bang guilty?
Copy !req
240. No one is guilty
until the verdict comes in.
Copy !req
241. Look, I talked
to Tivnan.
Copy !req
242. He's copped to
the eight muggings.
Copy !req
243. He did those,
he admits it,
Copy !req
244. but he didn't
kill Ralston.
Copy !req
245. Come on, Elizabeth.
Come on.
Copy !req
246. You don't have
a positive I.D.
from Janet Ralston.
Copy !req
247. He doesn't use guns.
Copy !req
248. Stone's not gonna
deal on this one.
Copy !req
249. The public doesn't like
getting killed coming home.
Copy !req
250. I do this a lot.
Copy !req
251. This kid's
telling the truth.
Copy !req
252. Well, I hope for your sake,
you're wrong,
Copy !req
253. 'cause everybody else
on Manhattan Island
thinks he did it.
Copy !req
254. Wrapped up.
Copy !req
255. Another killer
off the streets.
Copy !req
256. Hey, Max,
Copy !req
257. we'll find the gun.
Copy !req
258. Willie Tivnan has a rap sheet
Copy !req
259. as long as
the Encyclopedia Britannica.
Copy !req
260. And no mention
of him ever
Copy !req
261. using a gun.
Copy !req
262. You just think I'm wrong
because I'm sure I'm right.
Copy !req
263. I think that
he's a street-wise little kid.
Copy !req
264. Who shot two people for the
price of a couple of grams.
Copy !req
265. Who knows the difference
between mugging and murder.
Copy !req
266. When Marie
was mugged,
Copy !req
267. you know, on the
East Side last year?
Copy !req
268. What was the first
thing that I did?
Copy !req
269. Picked up your gun
and went looking.
Copy !req
270. Think.
Copy !req
271. You've been mugged.
Copy !req
272. You wallet's gone.
After you call the cops,
Copy !req
273. the first thing you do is what?
Copy !req
274. Willie shoots the Ralstons,
Copy !req
275. cleans out her purse,
takes his wallet...
Copy !req
276. Sells the credit cards.
Copy !req
277. It's been three days,
but not word one from the banks.
Copy !req
278. Nobody's used the Ralston cards.
Copy !req
279. Didn't even try.
Copy !req
280. An ad
in the Times Sunday magazine.
Copy !req
281. A ten-room house, good schools.
Copy !req
282. Alan always said
Copy !req
283. we weren't the kind of people
who lived in the suburbs.
Copy !req
284. What kind of people
live in the suburbs?
Copy !req
285. The kind
that are still alive.
Copy !req
286. The night it happened...
Copy !req
287. Alan was coming around
the front of the car
Copy !req
288. to open my door...
Copy !req
289. I got out of the car.
Copy !req
290. I gave him a kiss.
Copy !req
291. I noticed there were
some flowers in the back seat.
Copy !req
292. I asked him to get the flowers.
Copy !req
293. He opened the door.
Copy !req
294. Um... he was... he was looking
for something in his pocket.
Copy !req
295. He... he said,
"Did you lock it?"
Copy !req
296. I turned to look.
Copy !req
297. He went towards
the stairwell.
Copy !req
298. A man came out.
Copy !req
299. He was black.
Copy !req
300. I didn't see a gun.
Copy !req
301. I heard the shot,
and I saw Alan's face.
Copy !req
302. He looked like
he'd been punched.
Copy !req
303. Yeah, it's amazing.
Copy !req
304. She repeated her
story perfectly.
Copy !req
305. Yeah. Word for word.
Copy !req
306. You know, I took the kids
to Duchess Stables last weekend.
Copy !req
307. I hate horseback riding—
scares the hell out of me.
Copy !req
308. Scary for
the horse, too.
Copy !req
309. You know... I last on the saddle
maybe two, three minutes.
Copy !req
310. I get off,
I can't remember one second.
Copy !req
311. Her husband gets shot,
she gets shot.
Copy !req
312. She sees a black guy,
gets scared
Copy !req
313. she remembers every second.
Copy !req
314. I know cops been
in shooting cases,
Copy !req
315. lucky if they can remember
their badge number.
Copy !req
316. I didn't take no ring.
Copy !req
317. And the wallet?
Copy !req
318. I didn't take no wallet.
Copy !req
319. Come on.
Where did you unload
the credit cards?
Copy !req
320. Look, the light went off
and I ran.
Copy !req
321. Light?
Copy !req
322. Yeah, in the stairs.
Copy !req
323. That's why
I couldn't find my stem.
Copy !req
324. Okay, Willie,
one more time,
real slow.
Copy !req
325. You light up
a rock...
Copy !req
326. The lights went off
in the stairwell
Copy !req
327. and then, you know,
bang, bang— shots.
Copy !req
328. I ran.
Copy !req
329. Willie, you may just
have bought yourself
Copy !req
330. a ticket out of here.
Copy !req
331. The light went out, huh?
Copy !req
332. Where's the switch?
Copy !req
333. I think Willie's
jerking us around.
Copy !req
334. See if it screws in.
Copy !req
335. Whoa! Whoops. Sorry.
Copy !req
336. That's my foot.
Copy !req
337. How many killers
does it take to...
Copy !req
338. Take the bulb, huh?
Copy !req
339. Thanks.
Copy !req
340. Nothing on Janet.
Copy !req
341. Mr. Himes—
the Ralston's financial advisor?
Copy !req
342. Public lewdness.
Copy !req
343. He a kink?
Copy !req
344. Last January.
Copy !req
345. He's coming down the sawmill,
11:00 at night,
Copy !req
346. stops at the toll booth.
Copy !req
347. He's half naked.
Copy !req
348. Some woman's her head
in his lap.
Copy !req
349. She was probably napping.
Copy !req
350. He's in
the automatic lane.
Copy !req
351. Tosses the token.
Copy !req
352. Guy in the next booth
looks over, sees him.
Copy !req
353. He calls the cops.
Copy !req
354. P.O.'d because they didn't
drive through his booth.
Copy !req
355. State Trooper stops them.
Copy !req
356. Issues a warning,
but makes out a report.
Copy !req
357. Janet Ralston.
Copy !req
358. Brenda Smith.
Copy !req
359. Cop describes Brenda.
Copy !req
360. Brenda sounds a lot like Janet.
Copy !req
361. Guess what.
Copy !req
362. I can hardly wait.
Copy !req
363. The car.
Copy !req
364. The Ralstons'.
Copy !req
365. That big, shiny,
1989 Lincoln town car.
Copy !req
366. Reopen the case?
Copy !req
367. I love this.
Copy !req
368. I really love this.
Copy !req
369. Just before Willie ran,
he said the lights went out.
Copy !req
370. In his brain.
Copy !req
371. The bulb— we got there today—
it was still unscrewed.
Copy !req
372. So?
Copy !req
373. Willie got a reason
to lie about this?
Copy !req
374. So?
Copy !req
375. Look, there were
two sets of prints
Copy !req
376. on that bulb.
Copy !req
377. One of them, Gil Himes.
Copy !req
378. Janet Ralston was shot twice.
Copy !req
379. So you're telling me
that Gil Himes shot her husband,
Copy !req
380. then shot her twice,
and now she's covering for him?
Copy !req
381. She's out of the hospital.
Copy !req
382. I want to put everything on hold
and just stick to her.
Copy !req
383. On a hunch?
Copy !req
384. On a hunch that Gil Himes
doesn't change light bulbs
Copy !req
385. on his day off.
Copy !req
386. It's not even
Himes's garage.
Copy !req
387. There's no
possible explanation
Copy !req
388. for his prints
being on that bulb.
Copy !req
389. Anybody finds out
we break this case
Copy !req
390. and then want
to unbreak it...
Copy !req
391. somebody wanted
that hallway dark.
Copy !req
392. Three days.
Copy !req
393. tell anybody.
And you don't
Copy !req
394. You're going
to be happy
Copy !req
395. you did this,
captain.
Copy !req
396. No, I'm not.
Copy !req
397. Weather report?
Copy !req
398. Cloudy... no rain.
Copy !req
399. Last 24 hours, she's been
to the butcher,
Copy !req
400. the florist, the greengrocer...
Copy !req
401. dry cleaners,
beauty parlor
Copy !req
402. and she took the kids
to school.
Copy !req
403. Leads a rich and full life,
this lady.
Copy !req
404. Male visitors?
Copy !req
405. No visitors, period.
Copy !req
406. A regular nun.
Copy !req
407. Detective Vitello
should know.
Copy !req
408. He worships me.
Copy !req
409. He thinks I might
raise the dead.
Copy !req
410. You do this routine
every shift?
Copy !req
411. Only on stakeouts.
Copy !req
412. No, Max.
Copy !req
413. No more time.
Copy !req
414. Two days.
Copy !req
415. How does this sound—
Copy !req
416. "Widow, two kids,
victim of a horrible crime
Copy !req
417. "and the police department
Copy !req
418. "spends 2,000 bucks a day
Copy !req
419. to find out when
she goes to the can."
Copy !req
420. You want to read that
in tomorrow's Post?
Copy !req
421. One day.
Copy !req
422. What's it
going to buy?
Copy !req
423. Maybe it will buy me
a good night's sleep.
Copy !req
424. One freaking day.
Copy !req
425. What?
Copy !req
426. Hold on.
Copy !req
427. They're together—
Hamstead Hotel.
Copy !req
428. What's she doing?
Copy !req
429. It's four hours.
Copy !req
430. Serving him
clams casino?
Copy !req
431. Looks like
he ate well.
Copy !req
432. Let's pick him up.
Copy !req
433. No, no, no.
Copy !req
434. I want to talk
to her first.
Copy !req
435. Mrs. Ralston.
Copy !req
436. Excuse me.
Copy !req
437. Could you help us out here,
Mrs. Ralston?
Copy !req
438. Mr. Himes
Copy !req
439. was in the garage
that night.
Copy !req
440. He got home late.
Copy !req
441. You know what I think?
Copy !req
442. I think you and Mr. Himes
are having an affair.
Copy !req
443. I think your boyfriend
shot your husband.
Copy !req
444. I think the D.A.
Is going to charge you
Copy !req
445. as an accessory
to the crime.
Copy !req
446. I think you're too smart
not to cooperate.
Copy !req
447. Oh, God.
Copy !req
448. I was having an affair...
Copy !req
449. but I broke it off.
Copy !req
450. Something must have happened
Copy !req
451. because he got really enraged
and...
Copy !req
452. he snapped and...
Copy !req
453. he came after Alan and I
and he shot us.
Copy !req
454. The charges
are murder in the second degree
Copy !req
455. and assault in the first degre.
Copy !req
456. Does the defendant
wish to enter a plea?
Copy !req
457. Your Honor, if we may,
Copy !req
458. we question whether
the prosecutor's information
Copy !req
459. merits our client
being held.
Copy !req
460. Mr. Shell,
Copy !req
461. you got to the door
but you didn't knock.
Copy !req
462. If you're questioning
the merits,
Copy !req
463. does that mean
you want a hearing?
Copy !req
464. No, no, Your Honor.
Copy !req
465. Then let's have the defendant
enter a plea.
Copy !req
466. Mr. Himes?
Copy !req
467. Not guilty.
Copy !req
468. Your Honor, Mr. Himes is
a substantial member
Copy !req
469. of the community
and has no criminal record.
Copy !req
470. We ask that he be
released on...
Copy !req
471. If you're suggesting
"own recognizance"
Copy !req
472. the answer is no.
Copy !req
473. This is two felonies,
Copy !req
474. one of them
a homicide.
Copy !req
475. Mr. Stone?
Copy !req
476. We'd like to guarantee
Mr. Himes appears, Your Honor.
Copy !req
477. Bail is set at $200,000,
Copy !req
478. cash or bond.
Copy !req
479. Murder in
the second degree, Stone?
Copy !req
480. You have to show the public
you go after the rich?
Copy !req
481. Your client
killed in cold blood.
Copy !req
482. I don't care if he's homeless
or owns Grand Central Station.
Copy !req
483. You get murder two
from the grand jury,
it's abusive.
Copy !req
484. Under extreme
emotional disturbance,
Copy !req
485. you're lucky if you get
manslaughter two.
Copy !req
486. The emotionally disturbed
Copy !req
487. do not plan as well
as Himes did.
Copy !req
488. It's a crime of passion,
Stone, pure and simple.
Copy !req
489. A crime of passion is never pure
and it's certainly not simple.
Copy !req
490. Gil was like the guys
I dated in college.
Copy !req
491. The ones
you didn't marry?
Copy !req
492. The ones you met
Copy !req
493. after your respectable dates
dropped you off.
Copy !req
494. How long had this
been going on?
Copy !req
495. Do we have to go into this?
Copy !req
496. Mrs. Ralston,
Copy !req
497. you're going to be a witness
against Mr. Himes.
Copy !req
498. Three months.
Copy !req
499. I loved Alan.
Copy !req
500. I didn't want
to throw that away.
Copy !req
501. How did Mr. Himes react
when you told him that?
Copy !req
502. Well, he said
he understood.
Copy !req
503. Why did you lie to the police?
Copy !req
504. He tried to kill me.
Copy !req
505. I was afraid.
Copy !req
506. He was crazy, irrational.
Copy !req
507. He looked at me
Copy !req
508. like he didn't even know
who I was.
Copy !req
509. He was...
Copy !req
510. a completely changed person.
Copy !req
511. The Ralstons?
Copy !req
512. The night of our party,
they were getting along fine.
Copy !req
513. Until he wanted to leave.
Copy !req
514. Dorothy.
Copy !req
515. 12:00, He wants to go home.
Copy !req
516. Janet says she's having
too good a time.
Copy !req
517. Dorothy...
2:30, The queen
wants to leave.
Copy !req
518. Alan's got
a second wind.
Copy !req
519. She dragged him out
like she had a plane to catch.
Copy !req
520. You never
liked her.
Copy !req
521. That's because she's a bitch,
darling.
Copy !req
522. but I always liked him.
Copy !req
523. The evening ran
on Janet's schedule.
Copy !req
524. He wants to go; she says no.
She wants to go; they leave.
Copy !req
525. He had an appointment.
Copy !req
526. Run a gun check
on Himes and Janet.
Copy !req
527. Registration,
out-of-state sales.
Copy !req
528. It's still thin.
Copy !req
529. Make it strong
and make it fit.
Copy !req
530. I want a conviction
on this.
On who?
Copy !req
531. The only one on trial here
is Himes,
Copy !req
532. but I'd love to get her, too.
Copy !req
533. A little bloodlust, Adam?
Copy !req
534. You ever look at a calendar?
Copy !req
535. Oh, next year
is an election year.
Copy !req
536. If it's easy to buy a gun,
Copy !req
537. That means they don't
a lot of paperwork.
Copy !req
538. State requires
a lot of paperwork,
Copy !req
539. then it's not so easy
to buy a gun.
Copy !req
540. We need a place no waiting time,
Copy !req
541. but where they still keep
accurate records.
Copy !req
542. That leaves Kentucky,
Delaware, Tennessee,
Copy !req
543. Virginia, North Carolina.
Copy !req
544. That's it?
Copy !req
545. We strike out with those,
we're in trouble.
Copy !req
546. Maybe we can get
Himes's credit card stubs,
Copy !req
547. her credit card stubs going back
a year, year-and-a-half.
Copy !req
548. Business trips, vacations—
Copy !req
549. did they hit
any of those states?
Copy !req
550. The guy offered
a $50,000 reward.
Copy !req
551. Crime of passion.
Copy !req
552. Short of a mob killing,
I'm beginning to think
Copy !req
553. this is the most
dispassionate murder
Copy !req
554. I've ever seen.
Copy !req
555. That hump Himes,
acting like their Dutch Uncle.
Copy !req
556. Helping the Ralstons
look for a new house
Copy !req
557. checking out the schools
in the suburbs for the kids,
Copy !req
558. clearing the decks
for their new baby.
Copy !req
559. One hell of a financial advisor.
Copy !req
560. What about their finances?
Copy !req
561. Had this woman, right?
Smart-looking broad.
Copy !req
562. She come in here
five, six, seven times a day,
Copy !req
563. each time with a different guy.
Copy !req
564. Turns out she's using the booth
over there to turn tricks.
Copy !req
565. And when we caught her, she said
Copy !req
566. "Hey, it's a hell of a lot
cheaper than a hotel."
Copy !req
567. Find what you're looking for?
Copy !req
568. There are standards
Copy !req
569. but it's up to the individual
insurance agent.
Copy !req
570. Just tell me
about the standards.
Copy !req
571. Before the new policy
was issued,
Copy !req
572. the Ralstons already
had $2 million
Copy !req
573. in life insurance, all on him.
Copy !req
574. $2 million?
Copy !req
575. Most couples, now, they
also insure the wife.
Copy !req
576. Her role costs money
to replace— child care,
Copy !req
577. housekeeping...
Not the Ralstons.
Copy !req
578. What about
the new policy?
Copy !req
579. An additional $3 million?
Copy !req
580. Well, let's say that's
borderline excessive.
Copy !req
581. So, the agent shouldn't
have written it?
Copy !req
582. The agent should have wondered
what was going on.
Copy !req
583. On top of the personal,
Copy !req
584. $4 million more paid for
by the business.
Copy !req
585. Is that unusual?
Copy !req
586. Not if the partners
are collecting.
Copy !req
587. Alan Ralston's beneficiary?
Copy !req
588. His wife.
Copy !req
589. This wasn't life insurance.
Copy !req
590. It was the lottery.
Copy !req
591. Mrs. Ralston hits
the right number.
Copy !req
592. She collects
$9 million.
Copy !req
593. What does it
look like to you?
Copy !req
594. Like to me like
Himes is interested
Copy !req
595. in seeing Ralston
overinsured.
Copy !req
596. After Janet broke his heart,
cut off the affair?
Copy !req
597. That guy is
a positive humanitarian.
Copy !req
598. Candidate for best
friend of the year.
Copy !req
599. What if she didn't break off
the affair?
Copy !req
600. No, got nothing on the girl.
Copy !req
601. The gun?
Copy !req
602. We got word
from Kentucky, Tennessee,
Copy !req
603. Delaware and North Carolina.
No luck.
Copy !req
604. And that leaves...?
We'd better get lucky
with Virginia.
Copy !req
605. A year ago, right after
Janet was mugged.
Copy !req
606. Richmond, Virginia.
Copy !req
607. Tracy's
Field and Sport Shop.
Copy !req
608. A sporting gun?
Copy !req
609. If you're hunting people.
Copy !req
610. Beretta, model 94,
blowback semi-automatic
nine millimeter.
Copy !req
611. Sold to Himes, Gilbert?
Copy !req
612. And not to Ralston, Janet,
either.
Copy !req
613. Ralston, Alan?
Copy !req
614. And they stick
to their stories
Copy !req
615. the worst we get him for
is maybe man two.
Copy !req
616. She still gets a walk.
Copy !req
617. She's already set up
Copy !req
618. a diminished capacity defense
for him.
Copy !req
619. Said he looked crazy.
Copy !req
620. You used Alan's gun,
didn't you, Mr. Himes?
Copy !req
621. I love Janet Ralston.
Copy !req
622. You want to talk a deal?
Copy !req
623. I want to talk guns.
Copy !req
624. How did you get the Beretta?
Copy !req
625. Did she give it to you
before the party?
Copy !req
626. No more questions, Stone,
Copy !req
627. till you put a proposal
on the table.
Copy !req
628. He rolls on Mrs. Ralston,
comes up with some evidence—
manslaughter one.
Copy !req
629. That's not a proposal.
Copy !req
630. It's an insult.
Copy !req
631. Come on, Gil.
Copy !req
632. Himes really does
love her.
Copy !req
633. Maybe he loves
manslaughter two more.
Copy !req
634. We don't find out
how it went down,
Copy !req
635. we may have to
offer it to him..
Copy !req
636. Well, then let's find out
how it went down.
Copy !req
637. Let's start over, Willie.
Copy !req
638. How many times
I got to tell you?
Copy !req
639. The lights go out. Then what?
Copy !req
640. Look, I hear a scream,
then a shot.
Copy !req
641. Righ after the
lights went out?
Copy !req
642. Same time.
Copy !req
643. Run that past me again.
Copy !req
644. The lights went off.
Copy !req
645. I hear a shot.
Copy !req
646. The door opens,
a couple seconds later,
Copy !req
647. I hear two more shots,
I get the hell out of there.
Copy !req
648. If the light was off,
Copy !req
649. how do you know the door opened?
Copy !req
650. Light came in from the garage.
Copy !req
651. After the first shot.
Copy !req
652. Am I talking too fast?
That's what I said.
Copy !req
653. You know, lights off,
then bang.
Copy !req
654. Door opens. Bang, bang.
Copy !req
655. Willie fires up
a rock.
Copy !req
656. The light goes out.
Copy !req
657. The first shot came
before the door opened?
Copy !req
658. Then the door opens,
then there's two more shots.
Copy !req
659. But if it's Himes coming down
the stairs, and it is,
Copy !req
660. he goes to the light...
Copy !req
661. He unscrews it...
Copy !req
662. the door yet.
He hasn't opened
Copy !req
663. A gun goes off.
Copy !req
664. So, who shot Alan Ralston?
Copy !req
665. Is Willie
a good enough witness?
Copy !req
666. Good enough for me.
Copy !req
667. Pick her up.
Copy !req
668. Janet Ralston?
Copy !req
669. You're under arrest
Copy !req
670. for the murder
of Alan Ralston.
Copy !req
671. You have the right
to remain silent
Copy !req
672. and refuse
to answer questions.
Copy !req
673. Anything you do say
may be used against
you in a court of law.
Copy !req
674. So you're saying
the first shot came
Copy !req
675. before the door opened.
Copy !req
676. Lights out. Bang.
Copy !req
677. Then the door opens.
Copy !req
678. But after the lights went out,
couple of seconds later,
Copy !req
679. another two shots.
Copy !req
680. Bang, bang.
Copy !req
681. Thank you.
Copy !req
682. No further questions,
Your Honor.
Copy !req
683. Mr. Tivnan,
Copy !req
684. what were you doing
on the stairs of the garage?
Copy !req
685. Smoking crack.
Copy !req
686. Uh-huh.
Copy !req
687. Your habit?
Copy !req
688. How much does it cost?
Copy !req
689. $200 a day.
Copy !req
690. Oh.
Copy !req
691. Do you have a job, Mr. Tivnan?
Copy !req
692. Objection, Your Honor.
Copy !req
693. His employment has nothing
to do with his testimony.
Copy !req
694. Mr. Tivnan's state of mind
is at issue here.
Copy !req
695. Overruled.
Copy !req
696. The witness will answer.
Copy !req
697. I sell books, magazines
on the streets.
Copy !req
698. Does that pay
for your crack habit?
Copy !req
699. People do a lot of reading.
Copy !req
700. Thank you, Mr. Tivnan.
Copy !req
701. In your autopsy,
you examined the entrance wound
Copy !req
702. on Mr. Ralston's body?
Copy !req
703. Yes, I did.
Copy !req
704. What were your findings?
Copy !req
705. Light powder burns
on Mr. Ralston's tux
Copy !req
706. indicated that the gun had fired
Copy !req
707. at a distance
of approximately three feet.
Copy !req
708. The bullet entered Mr. Ralston
at the bottom of the thorax.
Copy !req
709. It traveled upward.
Copy !req
710. It pierced his right lung
and then entered his heart.
Copy !req
711. From that description,
Mr. Borak,
Copy !req
712. can you tell the height
of the person who fired the gun?
Copy !req
713. Yes, I could.
Copy !req
714. From the, uh, the angle
of the bullet's entry,
Copy !req
715. the person who shot him
Copy !req
716. would have to be no taller
than five foot six.
Copy !req
717. In other words, someone shorter
than Mr. Ralston.
Copy !req
718. Yes, that's right.
Copy !req
719. Nothing further, Your Honor.
Copy !req
720. If I told you the floor
of that garage slopes,
Copy !req
721. would that affect
your estimation
Copy !req
722. of the height
of the gunman you described?
Copy !req
723. Oh, yes, yes,
it would.
Copy !req
724. Good. It slopes.
Copy !req
725. So it's possible that
Mr. Ralston was shot
by a six-foot man
Copy !req
726. standing at the bottom
of a sloping floor.
Copy !req
727. Yes, that is possible...
Copy !req
728. Thank you.
Copy !req
729. Nothing further, Your Honor.
Copy !req
730. Mrs. Stark,
this was some months ago.
Copy !req
731. Do you remember the Ralstons?
Copy !req
732. Yes. They were a nice-looking
couple on vacation.
Copy !req
733. Just come from the mountains.
Copy !req
734. Did Mr. Ralston know
what kind of gun
Copy !req
735. he wanted to buy?
Copy !req
736. Well, he didn't know anything
about guns,
Copy !req
737. so I showed him
some nice personal weapons.
Copy !req
738. And he picked one out?
Copy !req
739. she kept telling him
Well, the missus,
Copy !req
740. that they had to have it,
Copy !req
741. and he told her he did not want
the gun in the house,
Copy !req
742. that one of the kids
might get his head blown off.
Copy !req
743. And she kept reminding him
that she had been mugged
Copy !req
744. on the street.
Copy !req
745. So, Mr. Ralston
didn't want to buy a gun.
Copy !req
746. No, it was Mrs. Ralston
who was all steamed up.
Copy !req
747. She insisted that
he buy the Beretta.
Copy !req
748. Thank you.
Copy !req
749. No further questions.
Copy !req
750. It's your meeting.
Copy !req
751. Himes battered
Copy !req
752. Mrs. Ralston
emotionally,
Copy !req
753. but she never believed him
when he said
Copy !req
754. he'd kill her and her husband.
Copy !req
755. After he shot you,
Mrs. Ralston,
Copy !req
756. you didn't go to the police.
Copy !req
757. I told you.
Copy !req
758. I was frightened.
Copy !req
759. The only thing
Mrs. Ralston
Copy !req
760. might have done wrong
Copy !req
761. was to mention where Mr. Ralston
kept his gun.
Copy !req
762. Nevertheless,
we will plead
Copy !req
763. criminal facilitation four,
conspiracy five,
Copy !req
764. and she'll testify
against Mr. Himes.
Copy !req
765. You've got to be kidding.
Copy !req
766. It's like he's on trial
for murder.
Copy !req
767. You're offering us
two misdemeanors?
Copy !req
768. I don't joke
about plea bargains, Mr. Stone.
Copy !req
769. If you want to think
about manslaughter one,
Copy !req
770. we might have something
to talk about.
Copy !req
771. Well, I guess we have nothing
to talk about.
Copy !req
772. They're not biting.
She doesn't think
we can convince a jury.
Copy !req
773. Then plea it out
at man two.
Copy !req
774. Slap on the wrist?
Copy !req
775. Since when's two acquittals
better than one?
Copy !req
776. Take one more run
at them.
Copy !req
777. Don't blow this.
Copy !req
778. I'll take man two.
Copy !req
779. Mr. Himes,
Copy !req
780. she's getting ready
to burn you.
Copy !req
781. That testimony about
how tall the gunman was?
Copy !req
782. Your lover's lawyer
is trying
Copy !req
783. to make it look like
you pulled the trigger.
Copy !req
784. Janet's lawyer
was trying to prove
Copy !req
785. neither of us did it.
Copy !req
786. Listen to this.
Copy !req
787. This is a transcript
Copy !req
788. from one of the interviews
with Mrs. Ralston
Copy !req
789. after you were arrested.
Copy !req
790. "I loved Gil Himes,
Copy !req
791. "but he turned out
to be weak and pathetic.
Copy !req
792. "The only solution he found
to his unhappiness
Copy !req
793. was to get a gun."
Copy !req
794. That's how she depicts you.
Copy !req
795. You're playing a bad hand,
Mr. Himes,
Copy !req
796. and the dealer's crooked.
Copy !req
797. Suppose the murder weapon
should... happen to turn up.
Copy !req
798. Mr. Himes, you are now skirting
obstruction of justice.
Copy !req
799. Don't push it, Stone.
Copy !req
800. He said "suppose,"
Copy !req
801. and he's on trial for murder.
Copy !req
802. Suppose we add obstruction.
Copy !req
803. Suppose you never get the gun.
Copy !req
804. Manslaughter one.
Copy !req
805. You'll lose.
Copy !req
806. That jury will never convict.
Copy !req
807. True love.
Copy !req
808. They'd sell each other
for a nickel.
Copy !req
809. Give victor Norris a call.
Copy !req
810. You said you have something
we want to hear?
Copy !req
811. A rumor Mr. Himes
is thinking of producing
Copy !req
812. a murder weapon.
Copy !req
813. Auction block.
Copy !req
814. Going, going...
Copy !req
815. Two misdemeanors
Copy !req
816. and she'll take
a year in jail.
Copy !req
817. Manslaughter one.
Copy !req
818. Going, going...
Copy !req
819. No way.
Copy !req
820. Gone.
Copy !req
821. You don't scare me, Mr. Stone.
Copy !req
822. Oh, yes, I do, Mrs. Ralston.
Copy !req
823. I scare you a great deal.
Copy !req
824. And I should.
Copy !req
825. There's another offer
on the table from Mrs. Ralston.
Copy !req
826. This is an idiotic game.
Copy !req
827. She's up from
two misdemeanors
to jail time.
Copy !req
828. We'll take manslaughter two.
Copy !req
829. Oh, you'll have to do better
than that.
Copy !req
830. Manslaughter one
he produces the weapon,
Copy !req
831. and he tells the jury
how he planned it.
Copy !req
832. Whoever gets to my door first.
Copy !req
833. You know why
we're here.
Copy !req
834. You can't do this, Stone.
Copy !req
835. Last chance,
ladies and gentlemen.
Copy !req
836. You've got nothing.
Copy !req
837. Manslaughter one.
Copy !req
838. Sold.
Copy !req
839. You damn fool!
Copy !req
840. We would have been acquitted.
Copy !req
841. They've got nothing.
Copy !req
842. God, you are a pathetic, limp...
Copy !req
843. Oh, God!
Copy !req
844. You are such a gutless...
Copy !req
845. She came to me with the plan.
Copy !req
846. And what did
Mrs. Ralston suggest?
Copy !req
847. She would tell Alan
she had been mugged.
Copy !req
848. Would force him
to buy a gun.
Copy !req
849. Was there more to the plan?
Copy !req
850. Yes.
Copy !req
851. She told me I would have
to shoot her, too.
Copy !req
852. I said, "What?"
Copy !req
853. She said I would shoot her
Copy !req
854. after she shot him.
Copy !req
855. On the night
of the shootings,
Copy !req
856. did the plan go awry?
Copy !req
857. I was supposed to be there
before she shot Alan,
Copy !req
858. but, uh, he saw the gun
in her hand,
Copy !req
859. so she had to shoot him
Copy !req
860. before he came
into the stairwell.
Copy !req
861. Who shot Mrs. Ralston?
Copy !req
862. I did.
Copy !req
863. Is this gun,
marked "People's Exhibit 26"
Copy !req
864. the one you used
the night of the shootings?
Copy !req
865. Yes.
Copy !req
866. Now, Mr. Himes,
Copy !req
867. please tell the jury
what happened
Copy !req
868. after Mrs. Ralston
talked to the police
Copy !req
869. at the Hamstead Hotel.
Copy !req
870. She called me— Janet called me
from a pay phone.
Copy !req
871. Told me I was going
to be arrested
Copy !req
872. and I should
go along with it.
Copy !req
873. I said she was going
to hang us both.
Copy !req
874. What were her
exact words?
Copy !req
875. She said,
"You dumb son of a bitch.
Copy !req
876. "You'll get manslaughter two.
Copy !req
877. "Minimum sentence.
Copy !req
878. "Out in a third.
Copy !req
879. Less than two years."
Copy !req
880. "We'll have each other,"
she said.
Copy !req
881. "And the money."
Copy !req
882. Has the jury
reached a verdict?
Copy !req
883. We have, Your Honor.
Copy !req
884. Will the defendant
please rise?
Copy !req
885. On the first count
of the indictment,
Copy !req
886. the charge of murder
in the second degree,
Copy !req
887. how does the jury find?
Copy !req
888. We find the defendant guilty.
Copy !req
889. On the second count
of the indictment,
Copy !req
890. conspiracy in the first degree,
how does the jury find?
Copy !req
891. We find the defendant guilty.
Copy !req
892. Janet Ralston's planning
to sue her lawyer.
Copy !req
893. She doesn't quit.
Copy !req
894. Reach any
conclusions?
Copy !req
895. I'm trying
to forget her.
Copy !req
896. Two men
in love with her.
Copy !req
897. Kills one, ready to
sell out the other.
Copy !req
898. What is it?
Greed? Power? Evil.
Copy !req
899. I thought
you didn't believe in evil.
Copy !req
900. Never met Janet Ralston before.
Copy !req
901. She's either evil
or she's two years old.
Copy !req
902. She wants what she wants
when she wants it.
Copy !req
903. That's cute.
Copy !req