1. Every year, I choose four students to come work for me.Copy !req
2. Previously on "how to get away with murder"...Copy !req
3. Oh, my god. Get the hell out.Copy !req
4. Wes. He's in your wife's class, too.Copy !req
5. I'm sorry. Who's your wife?Copy !req
6. Professor Keating.Copy !req
7. There she is.Copy !req
8. Rebecca, I kind of had a weird night.Copy !req
9. Could use a drink. Sorry.Copy !req
10. Police are confirmingCopy !req
11. a woman's body was found on Middleton's campus.Copy !req
12. I bet you the boyfriend did it.Copy !req
13. Either we all agree or we stop right now.
Just do it.Copy !req
14. It's the only way to destroy the DNA.Copy !req
15. He should be here by now.Copy !req
16. It's fine. What if it's not?Copy !req
17. What if they got caught or went to the policeCopy !req
18. or she convinced him to pin it on us?Copy !req
19. Wes wouldn't do that.Copy !req
20. He wouldn't, but she would.Copy !req
21. Stop, okay? It's going to be fine.Copy !req
22. No, think about it.Copy !req
23. How we got here... it's all her fault.Copy !req
24. It's not her fault. We're all to blame.Copy !req
25. No, I'm gonna call Aiden. Michaela!Copy !req
26. No, I never agreed to this!Copy !req
27. Because you had a meltdown!Copy !req
28. You could barely form a sentence.Copy !req
29. And stop acting like a little bitch baby.Copy !req
30. Do not tell me how to feel right now!Copy !req
31. Hey!
Aah!Copy !req
32. Sorry it took so long.Copy !req
33. I went back for this.Copy !req
34. Nothing new?Copy !req
35. Doesn't look like it.Copy !req
36. Makes sense.Copy !req
37. All the time her body was in that water tankCopy !req
38. probably destroyed any evidence.Copy !req
39. I'm gonna be home late.Copy !req
40. Dean Jovich wants me at the meetingCopy !req
41. about how to handle the grief counseling.Copy !req
42. Really? Because you knew her?Copy !req
43. Because he wants someone thereCopy !req
44. from the psych department.Copy !req
45. Mm.Copy !req
46. But who knows?Copy !req
47. Maybe that's part of it, too.Copy !req
48. The question I'm asked most often as a defense attorneyCopy !req
49. is whether I can tell if my
clients are innocent or guilty.Copy !req
50. And my answer is always the same.Copy !req
51. I don't care.Copy !req
52. And it's not because I'm heartless,Copy !req
53. although that's up for debate, but because my clients,Copy !req
54. like all of us here in this room, lie.Copy !req
55. And that makes them unknowable.Copy !req
56. Take Mr. millstone, here.Copy !req
57. Are you really who you say you are,Copy !req
58. or are there other sordid details that we're missing?Copy !req
59. Criminal record, divorce, an
actual skeleton in your closet?Copy !req
60. I can assure you I've, uh, I've never hurt a fly.Copy !req
61. So you say.Copy !req
62. Look around you.Copy !req
63. At the quiet girl you share notes with,Copy !req
64. the cute guy you have a crush on,Copy !req
65. the gunner who talks too much in class,Copy !req
66. and ask yourselves, do you know who anyone really is?Copy !req
67. Your instincts better be good,Copy !req
68. or you'll find yourself choosing the wrong peopleCopy !req
69. to make a study group with,
to sleep with, or even marry.Copy !req
70. Just ask Marjorie St. Vincent,Copy !req
71. heir to her family'sCopy !req
72. billion-dollar department-store fortuneCopy !req
73. until she was stabbed 16 timesCopy !req
74. in the master bedroom of her Gladwyne Mansion.Copy !req
75. The alleged killer... her husband, of course.Copy !req
76. Max St. Vincent.Copy !req
77. I met Marjorie in Paris.Copy !req
78. I was shopping for my daughter
Eloise's fourth birthday.Copy !req
79. My wife had just passed.Copy !req
80. I needed something special.Copy !req
81. When Marjorie saw meCopy !req
82. struggling to speak to the owner in French,Copy !req
83. well, from the minute she
opened her mouth to translate,Copy !req
84. I knew this was the woman for me.Copy !req
85. And 20 years later,Copy !req
86. she's still the only woman who
knew how to make me happy.Copy !req
87. Well, as much as anybody can be happyCopy !req
88. in an institution as barbaric as a marriage.Copy !req
89. Don't you agree, Ms. Keating?Copy !req
90. Let's keep it moving.Copy !req
91. I asked Max to preserve the crime sceneCopy !req
92. until after the trial was over.Copy !req
93. You never know what forensic clues you'll findCopy !req
94. to help our case later.Copy !req
95. And the room needed some color, anyway.Copy !req
96. You gonna throw up?Copy !req
97. No. I'm good.Copy !req
98. Look around, take photos,Copy !req
99. be the fresh eyes we need to help this case.Copy !req
100. Is it time?Copy !req
101. I think it is.Copy !req
102. I need a volunteer.Copy !req
103. Ladies?Copy !req
104. I'll do it.Copy !req
105. Very well.Copy !req
106. You're about as pretty as my wife was.Copy !req
107. Yeah.Copy !req
108. Now...Copy !req
109. On the bed.Copy !req
110. The forensic report claimsCopy !req
111. that Marjorie was in bed readingCopy !req
112. when I joined her with, uh... ah!Copy !req
113. Your pen, dear. Pen.Copy !req
114. The knife, which I hid, like this.Copy !req
115. Then I pretended to initiate sexual relations.Copy !req
116. And just as we were about to kiss...Copy !req
117. I struck.Copy !req
118. But missed, hitting the carotid artery,Copy !req
119. which was now squirting like a loose fire hose,Copy !req
120. hence the walls,Copy !req
121. so then I struck again, number two.Copy !req
122. Hit here.Copy !req
123. Followed by number three, here.Copy !req
124. Number four, five, six, seven.Copy !req
125. 16.Copy !req
126. Sheesh.Copy !req
127. Or so that's the prosecution's theory.Copy !req
128. Theory?Copy !req
129. Good luck proving that, huh?Copy !req
130. Oh.Copy !req
131. The murder book, given to us by the prosecutionCopy !req
132. with all the evidence they've gathered in Max's case.Copy !req
133. Go through it.Copy !req
134. Find the holes to help get our guy a "not guilty."Copy !req
135. Max said there were three officers at the scene,Copy !req
136. but only two were on the report.Copy !req
137. We need the originals.Copy !req
138. I was thinking we send the puppy.Copy !req
139. Smart.Copy !req
140. Mr. Gibbons, my office... now.Copy !req
141. What do we think is going on there? What do you mean?Copy !req
142. We all earned our spot here, right?Copy !req
143. Don't call him that. Maybe he's her secret baby,Copy !req
144. like she gave him up for adoption
and he doesn't even know.Copy !req
145. Because all black people are related.Copy !req
146. What? No. I-I wasn't...Copy !req
147. My point is, something is going on.Copy !req
148. Otherwise, why would he be here?Copy !req
149. Why are any of you here?Copy !req
150. That's the question I'm still asking myself.Copy !req
151. Frank says that you're having second thoughtsCopy !req
152. and what Frank thinks, I usually agree with.Copy !req
153. So...Copy !req
154. Is he right?Copy !req
155. Are you regretting your decision to join us?Copy !req
156. No.Copy !req
157. I'm happy to be here.Copy !req
158. Good.Copy !req
159. Let's give you more responsibility, then.Copy !req
160. Go to this police departmentCopy !req
161. and get the supplemental arrest reportCopy !req
162. for Mr. St. Vincent.Copy !req
163. Don't give your name or mine.Copy !req
164. You think you could handle that?Copy !req
165. Yes.Copy !req
166. Thank you.Copy !req
167. Now get out.Copy !req
168. I just need the supplemental arrest reportCopy !req
169. on Max St. Vincent.Copy !req
170. Are you flipping kidding me?Copy !req
171. What? Of course you're not.Copy !req
172. Lucinda teaches you thisCopy !req
173. when you start working for her, right?Copy !req
174. That the rest of us only exist
to serve the D.A.'s office?Copy !req
175. DA's office?Copy !req
176. It's like that woman looks for ways to waste my time.Copy !req
177. You can tell that to Lucinda, okay?Copy !req
178. Sure.Copy !req
179. The dumb strippers upstairsCopy !req
180. must have flushed their drugs down the toilet,Copy !req
181. because now there's disgustingnessCopy !req
182. coming out of my shower drain. Can I use yours?Copy !req
183. Uh... I'll just be a minute.Copy !req
184. I can't sleep till I've washed all the beerCopy !req
185. and frat-boy stench off of me.Copy !req
186. Right.Copy !req
187. Wow. No offense.Copy !req
188. I think I liked Rudy's setup better.Copy !req
189. Uh, Rudy?Copy !req
190. Yeah, he's the freak who lived here before you.Copy !req
191. You actually kind of remind me of him.Copy !req
192. Probably because you both have that crazed lookCopy !req
193. on your face all the time.Copy !req
194. It's probably a law-school thing, right?Copy !req
195. I guess.Copy !req
196. Uh...Copy !req
197. I should get back to this work.Copy !req
198. Shut up! Shut up!Copy !req
199. It's two against two.Copy !req
200. We have no other choice. We flip a coin.Copy !req
201. That is the dumbest thing you've ever said.Copy !req
202. I'm not letting a freaking coin decide
whether or not I go to jail tonight!Copy !req
203. We don't have time to fight!Copy !req
204. We need to make a decision and commit to it.Copy !req
205. So if someone has a better idea, say it now!Copy !req
206. Heads, we get the body.Copy !req
207. Tails, we leave it where it is. Okay?Copy !req
208. Heads.Copy !req
209. We go back for the body.Copy !req
210. Let's go!Copy !req
211. Breaking news on
the lila stangard murder here.Copy !req
212. Police just released the medical examiner's rulingCopy !req
213. that Ms. Stangard's death was indeed a homicide.Copy !req
214. This comes a week after she was discovered deceasedCopy !req
215. in a water tank at her sorority
house, kappa kappa theta.Copy !req
216. Want to know the best part about that?Copy !req
217. 'Cause corpses crap themselves.Copy !req
218. So the sorority girls were all
drinking their friend's poop.Copy !req
219. Hey, is Professor Keating in? Shh.Copy !req
220. No suspects have been announced,Copy !req
221. but we do know police spent the morningCopy !req
222. interviewing her boyfriend, Griffin O'Reilly,Copy !req
223. a star of the Middleton football team.Copy !req
224. Get out of my apartment!Copy !req
225. Mr. Gibbons. Did you do what I asked?Copy !req
226. Uh, yes.Copy !req
227. Well done. Did you look inside?Copy !req
228. I-I did, but I actually found a discrepancyCopy !req
229. between what the supplemental report saysCopy !req
230. versus what's in the prosecution's murder book.Copy !req
231. What kind of discrepancy? A name.Copy !req
232. The murder book says the hunting knifeCopy !req
233. was found on the front lawn by Officer Jake...Copy !req
234. Dorsey. Jake Dorsey.Copy !req
235. Really?Copy !req
236. So you're not Officer Chad Mullens?Copy !req
237. Your honor, I'm not sureCopy !req
238. what Ms. Keating is insinuating here...Copy !req
239. I'm just reading from the supplemental arrest report,Copy !req
240. which says that Officer Mullens
found the hunting knife,Copy !req
241. not our witness here.Copy !req
242. Or am I misreading the name, Officer Dorsey?Copy !req
243. Uh... no.Copy !req
244. Says Officer Mullens.Copy !req
245. An Officer who I recently found outCopy !req
246. is under investigation for drinking on the job,Copy !req
247. which explains why your boss
might want to keep his nameCopy !req
248. off of the official arrest report,Copy !req
249. maybe even changing his name for yours.Copy !req
250. Your honor, can we take a recess?Copy !req
251. After we get the knife thrown
out, we attack the motive.Copy !req
252. - Any thoughts?
- I had one.Copy !req
253. Prosecution's going to use Marjorie's best friendCopy !req
254. to say that she wanted to divorce Max,Copy !req
255. which would have eliminated his
inheritance per the prenupCopy !req
256. and thereby giving him motive to kill.Copy !req
257. I looked into discrediting the friend,Copy !req
258. but I couldn't find anything just yet.Copy !req
259. I can make that happen. Why don't I help?Copy !req
260. You know, usually I require dinner before I agreeCopy !req
261. to illegally hack into a rich old lady's computer.Copy !req
262. Wednesday. What?Copy !req
263. Dinner. You and me.Copy !req
264. And the faster you type, the
faster you get your reward.Copy !req
265. Mrs. Taylor.Copy !req
266. You claim that your best friend Marjorie spoke to youCopy !req
267. about divorcing Max nearly a year ago.Copy !req
268. Yes.Copy !req
269. Even though you wrote the following toastCopy !req
270. at their anniversary party about two months ago.Copy !req
271. "I haven't seen two people more in loveCopy !req
272. "since the captain and Maria
performed their first danceCopy !req
273. in front of the Von Trapp children."Copy !req
274. Doesn't sound like a couple about to divorce to me.Copy !req
275. How in the hell do you find this crap?Copy !req
276. You'll never know.Copy !req
277. The alibi's next.Copy !req
278. Max claims he was out for a
walk when the murder occurred,Copy !req
279. so we need a neighbor who saw him.Copy !req
280. Frank... take who you need.Copy !req
281. You two... prom queen and doucheface.Copy !req
282. Come with me.Copy !req
283. This is you hazing us, right?Copy !req
284. You don't seriously dig through strangers' trashCopy !req
285. you want a desk job, go to a corporate firm.Copy !req
286. Now get in there and find us a winner.Copy !req
287. Boo-yah!Copy !req
288. This is a receipt from risky business.Copy !req
289. That is a strip club, and it is down on...Copy !req
290. Caster ave., yeah.Copy !req
291. This is good.Copy !req
292. I doubt dad will want mom to find outCopy !req
293. about where he's spending the kids' tuition.Copy !req
294. It was around 8:30 when I took
out the trash that night.Copy !req
295. Right after our nightly family dinner.Copy !req
296. And what did you see while you were outside?Copy !req
297. A man walking on the other side of the street.Copy !req
298. And did you recognize the man?Copy !req
299. Well, it was very dark that night,Copy !req
300. but I think it's very possible that it was my neighbor,Copy !req
301. Mr. St. Vincent.Copy !req
302. The prosecution has rested,Copy !req
303. so the first witness to take the
stand will be Max's daughter.Copy !req
304. I need someone to write up the prep questions.Copy !req
305. I'll do it.Copy !req
306. Frank's girl. Good.Copy !req
307. Have them on my desk by midnight.Copy !req
308. I'll meet you back at the house.Copy !req
309. Let me guess.Copy !req
310. You were sent to tell meCopy !req
311. to stop embarrassing cops on the stand.Copy !req
312. You need to be careful.Copy !req
313. There's gonna be pushback.Copy !req
314. Is that a threat?Copy !req
315. Not from me.Copy !req
316. You haven't returned my calls.Copy !req
317. I'm not here to talk about us.Copy !req
318. So that's it? We're done? Are you surprised?Copy !req
319. You know I never set out to hurt you on purpose.Copy !req
320. You blackmailed me on the stand,Copy !req
321. made me sell out my department.Copy !req
322. I'll be lucky if the chief gives
me another case all year.Copy !req
323. I'll talk to him.Copy !req
324. You're the last person I want talking for me right now.Copy !req
325. Now, I'm trying to make things right.Copy !req
326. Don't you want me to make things right?Copy !req
327. I'm done with your crazy.Copy !req
328. Nate. What do you want from me?Copy !req
329. You won your case, got laid.Copy !req
330. So how else can I be of service to you?Copy !req
331. You call me again, and I swear to godCopy !req
332. I'll tell your husband every dirty, nasty thingCopy !req
333. I did to you under his own roof.Copy !req
334. is that all for you?Copy !req
335. Room 203, please.Copy !req
336. It's me. Don't worry. It's a new phone.Copy !req
337. I know, but I just wanted to tell youCopy !req
338. they didn't want to at first,
but I got them to come around.Copy !req
339. We're gonna protect you.Copy !req
340. Sam?Copy !req
341. I'll be out in a minute.Copy !req
342. Have you eaten yet? No.Copy !req
343. How about that Indian place?Copy !req
344. They take forever to deliver,Copy !req
345. but I'll pick it up if you want to call.Copy !req
346. Annie?Copy !req
347. Everything okay?Copy !req
348. Yeah. Indian sounds good.Copy !req
349. Okay.Copy !req
350. Great.Copy !req
351. Well, look at us.Copy !req
352. You on your way home from work and me on my way there.Copy !req
353. Ships in the night.Copy !req
354. Uh, hey, uh, so I saw your friend on the news...Copy !req
355. The football player,Copy !req
356. about his girlfriend, Lila Stangard.Copy !req
357. And?Copy !req
358. I just wanted to say sorry...Copy !req
359. If she was your friend, too.Copy !req
360. She wasn't.Copy !req
361. You a cop or something?Copy !req
362. The news said the cops were questioning him.Copy !req
363. I just wanted to make sureCopy !req
364. you knew don't ever talk to them without a lawyer.Copy !req
365. Yeah. I know.Copy !req
366. I'm not an idiot, and you're not a lawyer.Copy !req
367. You're making me late.Copy !req
368. These are the prep questions for the daughter.Copy !req
369. Great.Copy !req
370. What?Copy !req
371. I thought about what you said,Copy !req
372. why, uh, why any of us are here,Copy !req
373. and I know now that Connor and MichaelaCopy !req
374. were both top of their class,Copy !req
375. Asher, he's got his father, and Wes, I don't know,Copy !req
376. but it seems like Annalise likes him.Copy !req
377. A lot.Copy !req
378. And meCopy !req
379. it's, uh, Frank, right?Copy !req
380. I mean, he picked me, not Professor Keating.Copy !req
381. I look nice, I know, but that's just my face.Copy !req
382. And you coming to me with your
questions and personal dramaCopy !req
383. is not going to make me nicer.Copy !req
384. So rather than me tell youCopy !req
385. the answer to what you just asked,Copy !req
386. let me just say that the time you are wastingCopy !req
387. worrying about Frank is time you should be usingCopy !req
388. getting Annalise to actually learn your name.Copy !req
389. I'm done talking to you.Copy !req
390. Can you trust your character witness on the stand?Copy !req
391. That is one of the biggest
dilemmas as a defense attorney.Copy !req
392. Your character witness is too positive,Copy !req
393. the jury feels manipulated.Copy !req
394. Too honest, and you shot your case in the foot.Copy !req
395. Which is why it all comes down to pretrial prep.Copy !req
396. Team.Copy !req
397. I'd like you to meet my daughter, Eloise.Copy !req
398. She's fresh off the plane from Stanford.Copy !req
399. She dropped everything the
minute we said we needed her.Copy !req
400. I'm getting a master's in poetry.Copy !req
401. There's not much to drop.Copy !req
402. Mm, Ellie.Copy !req
403. He's the one I mentioned in the car. Dad.Copy !req
404. Think of the beautiful babies you two would make.Copy !req
405. The challenge is in establishing
your witness's credibility.Copy !req
406. You have to show them being real,Copy !req
407. even critical of your client.Copy !req
408. He's your father.Copy !req
409. Are we really supposed to believeCopy !req
410. that you wouldn't lie for him on the stand?Copy !req
411. I love my father, obviously, but I also love Marjorie.Copy !req
412. If my father hurt her,Copy !req
413. I'd insist you give him the death penalty.Copy !req
414. See? Pretty and smart.Copy !req
415. Be as punishing as possible.Copy !req
416. No topic is off limits.Copy !req
417. What about when he sent you to the mental institution?Copy !req
418. He told you you were crazy, right?Copy !req
419. I was 15 and anorexic,Copy !req
420. just like every other girl at my private school.Copy !req
421. Because you were able to get
away from his bad parenting?Copy !req
422. He wasn't a bad parent.Copy !req
423. He's odd, yes, eccentric,
but it's just a defense mechanism.Copy !req
424. His parents died when he was a child.Copy !req
425. His first wife, my birth mother,Copy !req
426. died in a car accident when I was 3.Copy !req
427. That changes you.Copy !req
428. Makes you scared of losing people.Copy !req
429. That's why he clung to Marjorie and me.Copy !req
430. We were his entire world.Copy !req
431. Which is how I know there's no
way he could have hurt her.Copy !req
432. I get that's hard to believe coming from me,Copy !req
433. but it's the truth.Copy !req
434. Your witness.Copy !req
435. Your father met MarjorieCopy !req
436. after your first mother died in Switzerland.Copy !req
437. Is that correct? Yes.Copy !req
438. What if I told you that was a lie?Copy !req
439. That your father and Marjorie
were having an affair.Copy !req
440. No, my mother died before they met.Copy !req
441. Or at least that's what your father told you.Copy !req
442. Your honor, if the prosecutor wants to testify,Copy !req
443. swear her in.Copy !req
444. The state would like to introduceCopy !req
445. the certified Swiss death reportCopy !req
446. for Mr. St. Vincent's first wife,
Elizabeth Sims.Copy !req
447. It's been translatedCopy !req
448. So Ms. St. Vincent can read it for the jury.Copy !req
449. "Elizabeth Sims died at age 28Copy !req
450. "from a deeply incised woundCopy !req
451. of the upper neck in the manner of homicide."Copy !req
452. And the murder weapon?Copy !req
453. A hunting knife.Copy !req
454. "Stuart Sims was put on trial
in Glattbrugg, Switzerland,Copy !req
455. "for the murder of his wife, Elizabeth.Copy !req
456. "The prosecution argued his motiveCopy !req
457. "was to run away with his mistress, Marjorie Trask,Copy !req
458. "but Stuart was found not guilty.Copy !req
459. "He created a new identity for him and his daughterCopy !req
460. "as Max and Eloise St. Vincent,
then settled in PhiladelphiaCopy !req
461. with Marjorie for a fresh fake start."Copy !req
462. Charming.Copy !req
463. By lying to me about my entire life?Copy !req
464. How do you tell a young girlCopy !req
465. what good would that do? Because you did it, right?Copy !req
466. And now Marjorie, too?Copy !req
467. You killed the both of them.Copy !req
468. You're a murderer and a liar. Ellie, please.Copy !req
469. Do not come near me.Copy !req
470. I hope the jury decides to kill you.Copy !req
471. I kind of agree with her, yo.Copy !req
472. Hello, Stuart.Copy !req
473. So, would you have taken my case had I told you?Copy !req
474. You underestimate how much I like a challenge.Copy !req
475. You lie to me again, you no longer have an attorney.Copy !req
476. Frank, find out how the prosecutionCopy !req
477. knew about Max's first trial.Copy !req
478. Whoever slipped the informationCopy !req
479. could be a possible suspect.Copy !req
480. On it. And the rest of you,Copy !req
481. prove I wasn't wrong to hire you.Copy !req
482. I forgot. I'm sorry.Copy !req
483. My boss called us into work last minute,Copy !req
484. and I'll take you to dinner this weekend instead.Copy !req
485. Hello?Copy !req
486. Oliver?Copy !req
487. Boyfriend drama?Copy !req
488. I don't do boyfriends.Copy !req
489. Wait, you're gay?Copy !req
490. Hey, Bon. Is she in there?Copy !req
491. Yeah.Copy !req
492. Sam. About your student...Copy !req
493. I just wanted to say I'm sorry.Copy !req
494. Thanks.Copy !req
495. It's been a little rough, to be honest.Copy !req
496. Oh, I didn't hear you come home.Copy !req
497. Hey. I just walked in.Copy !req
498. Rework this motion to suppress.Copy !req
499. How did court go?Copy !req
500. Wow. That well?Copy !req
501. My client's a liar.Copy !req
502. Is there something you want to ask me?Copy !req
503. Hmm?Copy !req
504. This isn't your courtroom, Annie.Copy !req
505. You have something to say, say it.Copy !req
506. Were you screwing her? No.Copy !req
507. You sure about that? I said no!Copy !req
508. Absolutely not.Copy !req
509. Do your work.Copy !req
510. Good eye contact.Copy !req
511. Now you're just being belligerent.Copy !req
512. You're surprised?Copy !req
513. That my wife thinks that I slept with one my students?Copy !req
514. Well, she is pretty.Copy !req
515. Sorry. Was.Copy !req
516. Oh, god. Listen to yourself. You're acting crazy.Copy !req
517. Well, shouldn't I be? It's happened before!Copy !req
518. Come here.Copy !req
519. Look at me.Copy !req
520. Annie, look at me.Copy !req
521. There was nothing going on with me and that girl.Copy !req
522. I swear to god.Copy !req
523. I'm sorry.Copy !req
524. It's... it's just this case, this client.Copy !req
525. I'm gonna lose.Copy !req
526. You say that every time.Copy !req
527. Come in.Copy !req
528. You need to see this.Copy !req
529. I'll leave you guys to it.Copy !req
530. There's only one way to win this case.Copy !req
531. We prove that Max, even if he did kill his first wife,Copy !req
532. didn't kill Marjorie.Copy !req
533. use this room, look for clues that we missed,Copy !req
534. evidence that contradicts...Copy !req
535. Just get inside the murderer's head.Copy !req
536. We can swipe the room for DNA againCopy !req
537. and see if we can find another suspect.Copy !req
538. We already ran more tests.Copy !req
539. Did you not fully read up on the case?Copy !req
540. Let's put Max on the standCopy !req
541. and have him cry like a little baby.Copy !req
542. Argue the matrix defense.Copy !req
543. Sleepwalking defense.Copy !req
544. Battered husband syndrome.Copy !req
545. Bipolar mood swings.Copy !req
546. He's a hunter.Copy !req
547. An MSG massacre defense.Copy !req
548. - He's a hunter!
- Yeah, genius.Copy !req
549. I think the heads on the wall make that pretty obvious.Copy !req
550. No.Copy !req
551. He's a hunter. He knows how to kill.Copy !req
552. You've been huntingCopy !req
553. for approximately how many years, Mr. St. Vincent?Copy !req
554. Oh, practically my whole life.Copy !req
555. So, you're experienced at slaughtering animals, then?Copy !req
556. Yes, it's one of the first
things my father taught me...Copy !req
557. How to be humane, to minimize suffering.Copy !req
558. And there are ways to ensure that? Oh, yes.Copy !req
559. I could show you right now, if you like.Copy !req
560. Please.Copy !req
561. First, you bend the neck like thisCopy !req
562. so the chin is close to the chest.Copy !req
563. Then you put the knife here...Copy !req
564. Ms. Keating.Copy !req
565. Please explain the relevance of this.Copy !req
566. It'll become apparent, your honor.Copy !req
567. Continue.Copy !req
568. Once the knife is by the jugular, you slice...Copy !req
569. in one swift motion, and then, well,Copy !req
570. it just becomes about waiting for the stillness,Copy !req
571. which happens quite fast if you've done it correctly.Copy !req
572. And this technique... this very humane,Copy !req
573. painless way of killing an animal...Copy !req
574. Is that how you murdered your first wife?Copy !req
575. Yes, that's correct.Copy !req
576. She's given her client bad adviceCopy !req
577. in order to get a mistrial.Copy !req
578. Who says it's bad advice?Copy !req
579. My client was acquitted of the first murder.Copy !req
580. In Switzerland.Copy !req
581. Double jeopardy still stands,Copy !req
582. And if you'd just let me present
my next witness, your honor,Copy !req
583. you'll see the relevance of all of this.Copy !req
584. There's actual relevance to the things you do?Copy !req
585. How many years have you been chief medical examinerCopy !req
586. of the city of Philadelphia?Copy !req
587. 13 years. I left last mayCopy !req
588. to become chief of pathology at Penn state.Copy !req
589. And you've studied the autopsy reportsCopy !req
590. of both Elizabeth Sims and Marjorie St. Vincent. Yes.Copy !req
591. Can you describe the difference
between the two murders?Copy !req
592. Well, at first blush, they look quite similar.Copy !req
593. But a more in-depth review of the reportsCopy !req
594. indicates that the first murder,Copy !req
595. a laceration across the neck,Copy !req
596. was done by someone with a knowledge of anatomy.Copy !req
597. And the second murder?Copy !req
598. The numerous sharp injuries were messy, inaccurate.Copy !req
599. They hit bone.Copy !req
600. The killer clearly knew nothing about anatomy.Copy !req
601. Meaning the second killerCopy !req
602. probably did not have hunting experience.Copy !req
603. Definitely not.Copy !req
604. In fact, it is my expert opinionCopy !req
605. that there's no way that these two womenCopy !req
606. were killed by the same person.Copy !req
607. The defense rests.Copy !req
608. I think I know who the second murderer was.Copy !req
609. Oh? Eloise.Copy !req
610. The supplemental arrest report saidCopy !req
611. there was no forced entry.Copy !req
612. Who else would have a key?Copy !req
613. So maybe she found out the truth before we did...Copy !req
614. That Max killed her mother, then
stabbed Marjorie to frame him.Copy !req
615. Interesting theory.Copy !req
616. You need to see this.Copy !req
617. I got the IP address of the computerCopy !req
618. that e-mailed the D.A. about Max's first trial.Copy !req
619. Came from a Stanford computer lab.Copy !req
620. Eloise.Copy !req
621. Visiting her mom's hometown in Switzerland,Copy !req
622. dug up the real story how she died,Copy !req
623. started plotting her revenge.Copy !req
624. Like father, like daughter.Copy !req
625. We've rested our case, Mr. Gibbons.Copy !req
626. Now we wait for the verdict.Copy !req
627. Laurel.Copy !req
628. Speak up more. I like your ideas.Copy !req
629. And watch out for Mr. Gibbons and miss Castillo here.Copy !req
630. Quiet ones are usually the most dangerous.Copy !req
631. What the hell just happened?Copy !req
632. Told you I had good taste.Copy !req
633. We're not having this conversation again.Copy !req
634. I'm not gonna do anything.Copy !req
635. Besides, you're the one we need to worry about.Copy !req
636. You think you're the only one in that houseCopy !req
637. who notices things?Copy !req
638. Have you reached a verdict?Copy !req
639. We have, your honor.Copy !req
640. In the matter of commonwealth vs. St. Vincent,Copy !req
641. case number p1082971, we, the jury,Copy !req
642. find the defendant, Maxwell St. Vincent...Copy !req
643. Not guilty.Copy !req
644. You got away with murder, you pig!Copy !req
645. Okay, I don't like this part.Copy !req
646. You know, there was an easier way to do this.Copy !req
647. You mean throw her to the wolves?Copy !req
648. You obviously don't have any children.Copy !req
649. She killed your wife, a woman
that you apparently loved.Copy !req
650. And I'll find a way to punish Ellie for that.Copy !req
651. Don't you worry.Copy !req
652. You think I mean kill her?Copy !req
653. No, Ms. Keating.Copy !req
654. I'd rather not spend my entire inheritanceCopy !req
655. paying your legal bills.Copy !req
656. Well, I shouldn't make any promises.Copy !req
657. Now is not a good time.Copy !req
658. No, it's okay.Copy !req
659. No. I don't care what your boss needs.Copy !req
660. I'm not here for work. I'm here for dinner.Copy !req
661. You really think I'm that desperate?Copy !req
662. That you can buy me some takeout and bat your eyesCopy !req
663. and I'll get down on my knees like some sad twink.Copy !req
664. You're too old to be a twink.Copy !req
665. Okay.Copy !req
666. But tonight, I do you.Copy !req
667. Sam?Copy !req
668. In here.Copy !req
669. What's this all about?Copy !req
670. We are celebrating your win, which, let me just say...Copy !req
671. You predicted. I know.Copy !req
672. Here. Sit.Copy !req
673. I'm gonna head to the cellar and get us a bottle.Copy !req
674. Don't move.Copy !req
675. Annie? Everything okay?Copy !req
676. I found a bottle Ted and Leah gave us for our 20th.Copy !req
677. Where you going?Copy !req
678. I have a client who just called me from jail.Copy !req
679. I'll be home as soon as I can.Copy !req
680. Nia's inside.Copy !req
681. I just need a minute. No.Copy !req
682. It's about the Lila Stangard murder.Copy !req
683. It's not my case.Copy !req
684. I told you... I'm on probation.Copy !req
685. I know.Copy !req
686. But Sam knew her. She was his student.Copy !req
687. They were close.Copy !req
688. They were close.Copy !req
689. Hey. How'd it go?Copy !req
690. Fine. Got him out on a misdemeanor.Copy !req
691. Annie.Copy !req
692. Hmm? You sure we're okay?Copy !req
693. 'Cause if we're not, I'd rather talk about it.Copy !req
694. I promise it won't be as scary as you think.Copy !req
695. Annie.Copy !req
696. We're good. I promise.Copy !req
697. They were close.Copy !req
698. They were close.Copy !req
699. You serious?Copy !req
700. You think he had something to do with it?Copy !req
701. - I don't know.
- Why?Copy !req
702. Because she was his student?Copy !req
703. That's your case?Copy !req
704. One of his closest students.Copy !req
705. Which means he'd screw her. Yeah.Copy !req
706. We're all capable of terrible things, Nate.Copy !req
707. This is your job talking.Copy !req
708. It's making you see bad where there is none.Copy !req
709. But you got to stop, go home, and talk to him.Copy !req
710. He told me nothing happened.Copy !req
711. Then there's your answer. No, listen, all right?Copy !req
712. How many times has Nia asked
you those same questions, huh?Copy !req
713. And what did you tell her about us?Copy !req
714. The truth?Copy !req
715. He's my husband, Nate... my husband!Copy !req
716. Exactly.Copy !req
717. You don't do this to your husband...Copy !req
718. Sell him out to your boyfriend.Copy !req
719. Go home.Copy !req
720. I'm not gonna say it again.Copy !req
721. Nate!Copy !req
722. He was supposed to be at Yale the night she was killed,Copy !req
723. and I need for you to tell me that he was there,Copy !req
724. it's the only way to stop my mind, all right?Copy !req
725. That he didn't have anything to do with this.Copy !req
726. Please, Nate. All right?Copy !req
727. I don't know who else to go to.Copy !req
728. I wish it were someone else, but it's you.Copy !req
729. I need you.Copy !req
730. Okay.Copy !req
731. Okay.Copy !req
732. Okay.Copy !req
733. Annalise.Copy !req
734. Be careful.Copy !req
735. You have the right to remain silent.Copy !req
736. Can and will be held against you in a court of law.
Get off me! Don't... don't touch me!Copy !req
737. You have the right to speak with an attorney.
Get off of me!Copy !req
738. If you cannot afford an attorney... you're hurting me!Copy !req
739. one will be appointed to you at no charge. Stop it!Copy !req
740. Let go, let go, let go of me!Copy !req
741. Rebecca!Copy !req
742. Don't say anything!Copy !req
743. The two suspects,Copy !req
744. Griffin O'Reilly and Rebecca Sutter,Copy !req
745. were arrested within an hour of each other.Copy !req
746. The female suspect, Ms. Sutter,
worked at an off-campus bar,Copy !req
747. rumored to be the place Middleton students goCopy !req
748. to buy drugs.Copy !req
749. In fact, a just-released arrest record on Ms. SutterCopy !req
750. shows a history of drug charges,Copy !req
751. including the sale of hardcore narcotics...Copy !req
752. Cocaine, heroin, and meth.Copy !req
753. It's me.Copy !req
754. Room 203, please.Copy !req
755. It's all her fault. It's not her fault.Copy !req
756. Wes wouldn't do that.Copy !req
757. He wouldn't, but she would.Copy !req
758. We're gonna protect you.Copy !req
759. Rebecca. What took you so long?Copy !req
760. I'm sorry, but it's done.Copy !req
761. It's done.Copy !req
762. Okay.Copy !req
763. Don't you ever leave me like that again.Copy !req
764. I won't.Copy !req
765. I'm here now.Copy !req
766. I'm not going anywhere.Copy !req
767. You're safe now.Copy !req
768. You're safe.Copy !req