1. - Four of the lures are made
from materials including
Copy !req
2. human remains.
- Kade purnell,
Copy !req
3. office of the inspector general,
FBI oversight.
Copy !req
4. - I'm pleading innocent.
Copy !req
5. - You'll be found guilty and
given the federal death penalty.
Copy !req
6. - What defense
do you think I have?
Copy !req
7. - You had no control of what
you were doing, much less
Copy !req
8. remember doing it.
Copy !req
9. - Betrayal was
the only thing that felt
Copy !req
10. real to me.
I trusted you.
Copy !req
11. - Let me help you.
- I need your help.
Copy !req
12. - We investigated
your claims about Dr. Lecter.
Copy !req
13. We found nothing. You stood
over Cassie boyle's body
in that field and
Copy !req
14. you described yourself to me.
- No, I described
Hannibal Lecter.
Copy !req
15. - You
think will is innocent.
- I don't know what I think.
Copy !req
16. - I think he still wants to save
lives. That's what I think.
Copy !req
17. - (Man): Mr. Graham, it's time.
Copy !req
18. - Let me tell you the story of
a mild-mannered FBI instructor
Copy !req
19. who was asked to create
a psychological profile
of a murderer -
Copy !req
20. garret Jacob hobbs,
the Minnesota shrike.
Copy !req
21. He killed young women
that looked
Copy !req
22. just like his daughter.
He killed them
Copy !req
23. and he ate them.
Copy !req
24. Will Graham understood
the way hobbs thought.
That's how he caught him.
Copy !req
25. He shot hobbs dead while he cut
his daughter's throat.
Copy !req
26. So, will Graham was able
to save Abigail
Copy !req
27. hobbs' life. But
Copy !req
28. the profile
that he created
Copy !req
29. of her father was so vivid
that he couldn't escape it.
Copy !req
30. - See.
Copy !req
31. See.
Copy !req
32. - And in an unconscious state...
He killed
Copy !req
33. four more women.
Copy !req
34. Cassie boyle.
Copy !req
35. Marissa schuur.
Copy !req
36. Georgia madchen.
Copy !req
37. Abigail hobbs.
Copy !req
38. He was able to save
Abigail hobbs
Copy !req
39. from her father, but he wasn't
able to save her from himself.
Copy !req
40. He killed her
Copy !req
41. and he ate her.
Copy !req
42. At the very least,
he ate her ear. What happened
Copy !req
43. to the rest of Abigail hobbs
is locked away
Copy !req
44. in the recesses of will Graham's
traumatized mind,
Copy !req
45. or so he would
have you believe.
Copy !req
46. Something else you should know
about will Graham: He has
Copy !req
47. remarkable visual memory;
Copy !req
48. he's keenly insightful
to the human condition; And...
Copy !req
49. I would argue,
the smartest person
Copy !req
50. in this room.
Copy !req
51. He's capable
Copy !req
52. of creating
a psychological profile
Copy !req
53. of a completely different kind
of murderer.
Copy !req
54. One that would
become his alibi.
Copy !req
55. - Moment of truth.
Copy !req
56. - If I only knew
what the truth was.
Copy !req
57. - There's nothing wrong
with your instincts.
Copy !req
58. - My instincts have not yet
arrived at conviction.
Copy !req
59. - Mine have, with the benefit
of no previous involvement
Copy !req
60. and no personal connections
to the accused.
Copy !req
61. - Meaning I can't be impartial?
- Of course you can
be impartial,
Copy !req
62. but right now you're not.
You have to believe something,
Copy !req
63. as long as there is reason
and evidence to believe.
Copy !req
64. You've got reason;
You've got evidence.
Copy !req
65. Will Graham is
playing a game.
Copy !req
66. I understand why that might be
hard for you to accept.
Copy !req
67. - Do you?
Copy !req
68. - It's easier to be a man who
missed his friend's suffering
Copy !req
69. than it is to be the head
of behavioral sciences
Copy !req
70. at the FBI who missed a killer
standing right in front of him.
Copy !req
71. There's a reason
Copy !req
72. that you're a witness for
the prosecution, agent Crawford.
Copy !req
73. - Remind me
what that reason is.
Copy !req
74. - If you can't represent
your own beliefs,
Copy !req
75. represent the bureau's.
Copy !req
76. - Agent Crawford?
Copy !req
77. Let yourself
off the hook, Jack.
Copy !req
78. - How did you meet will Graham?
- I met him at the opening
of the evil minds
Copy !req
79. research museum. He didn't agree
with what we called it.
Copy !req
80. He told me that the title
mythologized banal and cruel men
Copy !req
81. who didn't deserve to be
thought of as super-villains.
Copy !req
82. - And what was
your first impression?
- He was intelligent.
Copy !req
83. And arrogant.
Copy !req
84. And very likely
on the spectrum.
Copy !req
85. - Which is why he wasn't
real FBI. He didn't pass
Copy !req
86. the screening procedures.
- Yes.
Copy !req
87. - But you felt that he was
qualified to work in the field.
- Under my supervision.
Copy !req
88. - And you believed that he was
valuable because he could
think like a killer?
Copy !req
89. - He could think like anybody.
- Sounds like a super-villain.
Copy !req
90. Five horrendous murders,
over 40 different
Copy !req
91. pieces of forensic
and physical evidence
Copy !req
92. that tell us that will Graham
can think like a killer
because he is one.
Copy !req
93. Rather than feel tormented
by the work he did,
Copy !req
94. will Graham enjoyed the cover
his role at the FBI gave him
Copy !req
95. to commit his terrible crimes.
- I don't believe that
to be true.
Copy !req
96. - Agent Crawford?
Copy !req
97. - Will hated every second
of the work. He hated it.
Copy !req
98. He didn't fake that.
Copy !req
99. He hated it
and I kept making him do it.
Copy !req
100. - Why then is it that when you
offered him an opportunity
to quit, he refused?
Copy !req
101. - Because he was
saving lives.
Copy !req
102. I had been warned
by more than one person
Copy !req
103. that if I pushed will,
I'd break him.
Copy !req
104. I put those checks and balances
in place, then ignored them.
Copy !req
105. And here we are.
Copy !req
106. - What does
Jack Crawford drink?
Copy !req
107. Whatever it is, I need to send
him a very expensive bottle.
Copy !req
108. - He said I'm a killer
because he drove me insane.
Copy !req
109. - No, he paved the road
for your defense.
Copy !req
110. - Well, he didn't say
I'm innocent.
Copy !req
111. - Innocence isn't a verdict,
Mr. Graham, but "not guilty" is.
Copy !req
112. This isn't law;
It's advertising.
Copy !req
113. - Advertising trivializes;
Copy !req
114. it, uh, manipulates;
It's vulgar.
Copy !req
115. - Boo-hoo.
So is the law.
Copy !req
116. We have to create desire
to find you "not guilty,"
Copy !req
117. which is nonexistent
in this courtroom right now.
Copy !req
118. We're manipulating people
into buying something
they don't need.
Copy !req
119. - Mr. brauer?
- They don't want
your innocence. Thank you.
Copy !req
120. Unconsciousness
in a pretty package,
Copy !req
121. that I can sell.
Copy !req
122. If I take the moral high ground
with you, I'll get you killed.
Copy !req
123. I think I opened
your mail.
Copy !req
124. - That was a good and brave
thing you did for will today.
Copy !req
125. - It may have
cost me my job.
Copy !req
126. - The prospect doesn't seem
Copy !req
127. to trouble you as much
as I would have thought.
Copy !req
128. - Haven't felt better
in weeks.
Copy !req
129. - Clarity will do that.
Copy !req
130. - Mm.
Copy !req
131. - Tell me, Jack.
Copy !req
132. Was your testimony meant
to be a resignation?
Copy !req
133. - There is
something appealing
Copy !req
134. about walking away
from all of the noise.
Copy !req
135. I'm...
Copy !req
136. Content to let
the chips fall.
Copy !req
137. - The magic door is
always attractive -
Copy !req
138. step through and leave
all your burdens behind.
Copy !req
139. - I've given my life...
To death.
Copy !req
140. - And now death has
followed you home...
Copy !req
141. come to live
in your house.
Copy !req
142. - Bella has kept our bedroom
from looking too much
like a sickroom.
Copy !req
143. There are flowers,
but not too many.
Copy !req
144. You know.
Copy !req
145. She insists that there are
no pills in sight.
Copy !req
146. So, I've been thinking about
taking her to Italy
where we met.
Copy !req
147. We could...
Copy !req
148. She could die there.
Copy !req
149. - Jack.
Copy !req
150. You're not sick.
Copy !req
151. You don't have to go
into the ground with her.
Copy !req
152. When Bella's lost to you,
the FBI could still be there.
Copy !req
153. - You're telling me not
to commit professional suicide?
Copy !req
154. - As a friend, I'm telling you
not to force an issue
Copy !req
155. for the short-term emotional
satisfaction it can have.
Copy !req
156. - ... shrunken capillaries.
The ear was cut from a corpse
Copy !req
157. no more than 48 hours ago.
Copy !req
158. - Before the trial started.
- We fumed it all -
Copy !req
159. ear's clean, no prints
on either of the envelopes,
Copy !req
160. besides the courier,
paralegal, and lawyer.
Copy !req
161. - We know
will Graham didn't do it.
Copy !req
162. - It wouldn't surprise me.
- The timing's deliberate.
Copy !req
163. It was choreographed to drop
the ear at the beginning
of will's trial.
Copy !req
164. - Such a gift has
great significance.
Copy !req
165. - A gift from who?
- Will claimed
Copy !req
166. someone else committed
the crimes he's accused of.
Copy !req
167. - He said
that person was you.
Copy !req
168. - Perhaps he was
half right.
Copy !req
169. - Oh, you've gotta be
kidding me.
Copy !req
170. - It seems
you have an admirer.
Copy !req
171. - You think someone sent me
an ear because they admire me?
Copy !req
172. - The boundaries
of what's considered normal
Copy !req
173. are getting narrower.
Outside those boundaries,
Copy !req
174. this may be intended
as a helpful gesture.
Copy !req
175. - How far would you go
to help me?
Copy !req
176. - It hadn't occurred to me
to send you an ear.
Copy !req
177. But I'm grateful
someone has.
Copy !req
178. - Gratitude has
a short half-life.
Copy !req
179. - So can doubt.
Copy !req
180. I have new thoughts
about who you are.
Copy !req
181. There may very well be
another killer.
Copy !req
182. - I want there to be.
Copy !req
183. - Some part of you
still suspects me.
Copy !req
184. - I don't know
what anyone is
Copy !req
185. capable of anymore,
least of all myself.
Copy !req
186. But, um...
Copy !req
187. I know there is
no evidence against you.
Copy !req
188. - There never was.
Copy !req
189. - And accusing you
makes me look insane.
Copy !req
190. I'm not insane.
Copy !req
191. Not anymore.
Copy !req
192. - And you may not
be guilty.
Copy !req
193. This ear you were sent
Copy !req
194. is an opportunity.
Copy !req
195. If someone else is responsible
for your crimes,
Copy !req
196. perhaps he now wants
to be seen.
Copy !req
197. - Why would he want
to be seen now?
Copy !req
198. - He cares
what happens to you.
Copy !req
199. - The prosecution calls
Freddie lounds to the stand.
Copy !req
200. - I swear to tell the truth,
the whole truth, nothing
but the truth.
Copy !req
201. - Could you please describe
Copy !req
202. your relationship
with Abigail
Copy !req
203. hobbs?
- We were very close.
Copy !req
204. I was helping her write a book
about surviving her father.
- Did you ever discuss
Copy !req
205. will Graham with Abigail?
- Abigail told me
Copy !req
206. she believed will Graham wanted
to kill her and cannibalize her
Copy !req
207. like her father
wanted to do.
Copy !req
208. She was right.
Copy !req
209. I should've
listened to her.
Copy !req
210. - Do you blame yourself
for her death?
Copy !req
211. - I blame will Graham.
Copy !req
212. - Thank you.
Copy !req
213. Your witness.
Copy !req
214. - Miss lounds.
Copy !req
215. Could you please...
Copy !req
216. Remind me how many times
you've been sued for libel?
Copy !req
217. - Six.
Copy !req
218. - Sorry?
Copy !req
219. - Six.
- Six.
Copy !req
220. And how many times
did you settle?
Copy !req
221. - Six.
Copy !req
222. - Six.
Copy !req
223. Thank you.
Nothing further.
Copy !req
224. - The defense calls
Dr. alana bloom.
Copy !req
225. - I believe will's
empathy disorder...
Copy !req
226. combined with the effects
of viral encephalitis...
Copy !req
227. Do we have to do this
like this?
Copy !req
228. - I don't want the first time
you do this to be in court.
Copy !req
229. Dr. bloom, weren't
Copy !req
230. you and the accused
romantically involved?
Copy !req
231. - How is this relevant
to the case?
Copy !req
232. - It's relevant
to your testimony.
Copy !req
233. In that court, your feelings,
your emotions,
Copy !req
234. your pro-everything-will-Graham
will be on trial.
Copy !req
235. You get all starey
and non-blinky like that,
Copy !req
236. it'll undermine you and me,
but mainly him.
Copy !req
237. - My testimony is based
on my professional—
Copy !req
238. - you are smitten
with the accused, miss bloom,
Copy !req
239. and it is adorable,
but not our brand of defense.
Copy !req
240. And Ms. vega will
smell it on you
Copy !req
241. like you stepped
in young adult and
tracked it into the courtroom.
Copy !req
242. Were you and will Graham
involved romantically?
Copy !req
243. - I have no romantic feelings
for will Graham.
Copy !req
244. I have
a professional curiosity.
Copy !req
245. - I like that.
"Professional curiosity."
Copy !req
246. It seems so...
Copy !req
247. Heh, it seems so indifferent.
Copy !req
248. Unless you look like you're
lying when you say it.
Copy !req
249. But you didn't.
Copy !req
250. - You've
identified the ear?
- We identified
Copy !req
251. the knife that cut it off.
- It's will Graham's.
Copy !req
252. The blade matches the cuts
on Abigail hobbs's ear
and on this one.
Copy !req
253. - It was presented in court
as evidence, then it was sent
Copy !req
254. to the courthouse evidence room
where it was checked out
Copy !req
255. by the bailiff in will's trial,
Andrew Sykes,
Copy !req
256. and it never went back.
- Pretty good, right?
Copy !req
257. - Go.
Copy !req
258. They wanted to give us
a warm welcome
Copy !req
259. and make sure
that we found something.
Copy !req
260. - An arresting piece
of theater.
Copy !req
261. - Our bailiff was mounted
on a stag's head.
Copy !req
262. Glasgow smile. Killer lopped off
his ear and set him on fire.
Copy !req
263. Will Graham's greatest hits.
Copy !req
264. - Could we have been that wrong?
- About will Graham? No.
Copy !req
265. We could not. He practically
takes selfies with his victims.
Copy !req
266. - The evidence we found was
immediate and almost
Copy !req
267. presentational. May as well
have been gift-wrapped.
Copy !req
268. - That's what will said
about Cassie boyle
Copy !req
269. when we found her in that field.
"Field kabuki."
Copy !req
270. - There was no evidence before
will was apprehended and there
hasn't been any since.
Copy !req
271. - He ate a girl's ear!
Copy !req
272. It was in his stomach. God knows
what else of her was in there.
Copy !req
273. - We should've taken
a stool sample.
Copy !req
274. - Yes! We should have.
- Well, why didn't we?
Copy !req
275. I was the one that said
we should have.
- Knock it off.
Copy !req
276. - What impact could
this have on will's trial?
Copy !req
277. - This murder raises
serious doubts about
Copy !req
278. the case against will Graham.
- Your team provided
the evidence.
Copy !req
279. - The overwhelming evidence.
- So you understand
the significance
Copy !req
280. of my questioning it.
- Agent Crawford,
Copy !req
281. we all heard your testimony.
Are you sure you're not
just trying to assuage
Copy !req
282. your own guilt?
- Yes, I'm sure.
Copy !req
283. - I'm not.
- Andrew Sykes was mutilated
Copy !req
284. in the exact same manner
will Graham allegedly
Copy !req
285. mutilated his victims -
ways that have not been
Copy !req
286. made public.
- Will Graham isn't saying
he didn't kill those people.
Copy !req
287. His lawyer is running
an unconsciousness defense.
Copy !req
288. In effect, he's admitting
the acts, but just not
the responsibility.
Copy !req
289. - Will's maintained
his innocence all along,
in spite of memory gaps.
Copy !req
290. Whatever Mr. brauer's strategy
is, this will offer a new
line of defense.
Copy !req
291. - That's for Mr. brauer to tell
me, agent Crawford, not you.
Copy !req
292. - Yes, your honor.
Copy !req
293. - Will Graham
manifests publicly
Copy !req
294. as an introverted personality.
He would like us to believe
Copy !req
295. he places on the spectrum
somewhere
Copy !req
296. near asperger's
and autism.
Copy !req
297. Yet he also claims
an empathy disorder.
Copy !req
298. - You choose your words
very carefully, Dr. chilton.
Copy !req
299. You chose the word
Copy !req
300. "claims."
- Will Graham has
never been diagnosed.
Copy !req
301. He will not allow anyone
to test him.
Copy !req
302. He has carefully
constructed
Copy !req
303. a persona to hide
his real nature from the world.
Copy !req
304. He wears it so well
Copy !req
305. even Jack Crawford could
not see past it.
Copy !req
306. - But you did?
Copy !req
307. - Mr. Graham and I had
no personal relationship
Copy !req
308. for him to manipulate.
I have objectively examined him
Copy !req
309. and the crimes
of which he is
Copy !req
310. accused.
These murders
Copy !req
311. were measured
and controlled.
Copy !req
312. The confused man will Graham
presents to the world
Copy !req
313. could not commit
those crimes,
Copy !req
314. because that man is
a fiction.
Copy !req
315. - So,
Copy !req
316. you discount the encephalitis
he was suffering as a cause?
Copy !req
317. - He managed his illness with
the help of his neurologist,
Copy !req
318. whom he murdered
for his trouble.
Copy !req
319. - Is will Graham
an intelligent psychopath?
Copy !req
320. - There is not yet a name
Copy !req
321. for whatever will Graham is.
Copy !req
322. He kills methodically,
Copy !req
323. and I believe would kill again,
given the opportunity.
Copy !req
324. - Thank you,
Dr. chilton.
Copy !req
325. Your witness.
Copy !req
326. - Dr. chilton,
Copy !req
327. will Graham spent his time
catching murderers for the FBI.
Copy !req
328. You don't see a contradiction
between that
Copy !req
329. and your description
of a coldblooded killer?
Copy !req
330. - No, I do not.
Copy !req
331. Will Graham is driven by vanity
and his own whims.
Copy !req
332. He has a very high opinion
of his intelligence.
Copy !req
333. Ergo, he caught
the other killers
Copy !req
334. simply to prove
Copy !req
335. he was smarter
than all of them too.
Copy !req
336. Saving lives is just as arousing
as ending them.
Copy !req
337. He likes to play God.
Copy !req
338. - My admirer?
- Yes.
Copy !req
339. The forensic report
from the crime scene.
Copy !req
340. What do you see?
Copy !req
341. - I shoot Mr. Sykes once,
Copy !req
342. collapsing lungs,
Copy !req
343. tearing through his heart's
aorta and pulmonary arteries.
Copy !req
344. He will die
believing we were friends.
Copy !req
345. It is his last thought.
Copy !req
346. His death isn't personal.
Copy !req
347. He is merely the ink
from which flows my poem.
Copy !req
348. My tribute.
Copy !req
349. This is my design.
Copy !req
350. It's not the same killer.
Copy !req
351. He murdered his victim first,
and then mutilated him.
Copy !req
352. Cassie boyle's lungs were
removed when she was
still breathing.
Copy !req
353. Georgia madchen was burned
alive. What I...
Copy !req
354. What... what I found
Copy !req
355. of Abigail was cut off
while her heart was beating.
Copy !req
356. - Then this...
Is blunt reproduction?
Copy !req
357. - You knew that already.
Copy !req
358. - Would've liked
to have been wrong.
Copy !req
359. - Occam's broom.
Copy !req
360. You intentionally ignored facts
that refute your argument
Copy !req
361. hoping nobody'd notice.
- You noticed.
Copy !req
362. - Mm-hmm.
Copy !req
363. - I wanted to dispel your doubts
once and for all.
Copy !req
364. - My doubts about what?
Copy !req
365. - Me.
Copy !req
366. I want you to believe
in the best of me,
Copy !req
367. just as I believe
in the best of you.
Copy !req
368. This crime offered us both
reasonable doubt.
Copy !req
369. - It offered us
a distraction.
Copy !req
370. - Maybe this acolyte is giving
you your path to freedom.
Copy !req
371. Even Jack is ready
to believe, will.
Copy !req
372. - It would be a lie.
Copy !req
373. - I don't want you to be here.
- I don't want me to be here
Copy !req
374. either.
- Then you have a choice.
Copy !req
375. This killer wrote you
a poem.
Copy !req
376. Are you going to let his love
go to waste?
Copy !req
377. - I'm confused.
Copy !req
378. You're going to abandon
your defense strategy,
Copy !req
379. the entire case
you've built, mid-trial.
Copy !req
380. - Exciting,
isn't it?
Copy !req
381. - And this seems reasonable
to you?
Copy !req
382. - It's not only
reasonable;
Copy !req
383. it's fashionable.
Copy !req
384. There's a killer
on the loose,
Copy !req
385. demonstrating all the hallmarks
of will Graham's
Copy !req
386. alleged murders.
- Do you think this killer
Copy !req
387. committed the crimes
that you're accused of?
- Don't answer that,
Copy !req
388. not in front of me.
It's inconsequential.
Copy !req
389. - But is it true?
- You're being awfully
high and mighty, Dr. bloom.
Copy !req
390. Very ivory tower,
very reductive.
Copy !req
391. Very far from the point,
which is the exoneration
of your friend
Copy !req
392. will Graham.
- And the point you're trying
Copy !req
393. to make is reasonable doubt.
- That's a win, yes.
Copy !req
394. - The best you can
hope for is mistrial.
- That's also a win.
Copy !req
395. - You won't be able to plead
unconsciousness again.
Copy !req
396. - Your fast,
triumphant diagnosis
Copy !req
397. of unconsciousness was
the best play we had.
Copy !req
398. Now we have a better play.
Needless to say,
Copy !req
399. I won't be calling you
to the witness stand.
Copy !req
400. - Who's taking the stand
in my place?
Copy !req
401. - I swear to tell the truth,
the whole truth,
Copy !req
402. and nothing but the truth,
so help me God.
Copy !req
403. - Good morning, doctor.
Copy !req
404. Please describe
your relationship
with will Graham.
Copy !req
405. - I was asked by Jack Crawford
to monitor will's
Copy !req
406. emotional well-being
while he worked on cases.
Copy !req
407. I was never officially
his psychiatrist.
Copy !req
408. - If you weren't his
psychiatrist, what were you?
Copy !req
409. - I was meant
to be his stability.
Copy !req
410. I failed him in that.
- How did you fail him?
Copy !req
411. - I was unable to determine
if will's condition was due
Copy !req
412. to mental illness or stress
from his work at the FBI.
Copy !req
413. My mistake was
never considering his innocence
Copy !req
414. until the murder of a bailiff
from this courthouse.
Copy !req
415. - And how did you know
about that, Dr. Lecter?
Copy !req
416. - I have been asked to consult
on the case by Jack Crawford.
Copy !req
417. He wanted a profile
of the bailiff's killer.
Copy !req
418. - So, you believe
Copy !req
419. the bailiff's murder was
committed by the same person
Copy !req
420. guilty of will Graham's
alleged crimes, yes?
Copy !req
421. - Profiles aren't evidence;
They're opinion.
This is hearsay.
Copy !req
422. - I will allow it.
Copy !req
423. - Thank you,
your honor.
Copy !req
424. - I believe there are alarming
similarities in the crimes, yes.
Copy !req
425. - Will Graham accused you
Copy !req
426. of the crimes for which
he now stands trial, and yet
Copy !req
427. here you are, testifying
Copy !req
428. on his behalf
for the defense.
Copy !req
429. - Will rightfully couldn't
accept these actions to be his.
Copy !req
430. A mind faced
with the possibility
of committing such deeds
Copy !req
431. will find an alternative reality
to believe in.
Copy !req
432. - You don't blame him
for that?
Copy !req
433. - No.
Copy !req
434. Will Graham is
Copy !req
435. and will always be
my friend.
Copy !req
436. - Your witness.
Copy !req
437. - Dr. Lecter,
what was the cause
Copy !req
438. of death
in the bailiff's murder?
Copy !req
439. - A bullet to the heart.
Copy !req
440. - Mm. And in will Graham's
Copy !req
441. victims, or alleged victims,
what was
Copy !req
442. their cause of death?
Copy !req
443. - Mutilation.
Copy !req
444. - That's very different
from a bullet.
Copy !req
445. - No two crimes of any killer
are going to be exactly
the same.
Copy !req
446. The similarities—
- your honor, the witness's
personal beliefs and biases
Copy !req
447. are driving his conclusions.
There are clearly
Copy !req
448. two different killers
and two different cases.
Copy !req
449. - Your honor, there are
sufficient similarities
to consider this a defense.
Copy !req
450. - I'm ruling this defense
inadmissible, Mr. brauer.
Copy !req
451. - Thank you, your honor.
Copy !req
452. - All previous
testimony on the matter will
be stricken from the record.
Copy !req
453. - So, it appears that
the judge was murdered
in his chambers,
Copy !req
454. and then he was hauled out here
to be put on display.
Copy !req
455. - Not only is justice blind;
It's mindless and heartless.
Copy !req
456. How did the killer get
so close?
Copy !req
457. - No sign of a struggle.
Mutilation was post-mortem.
Copy !req
458. - He was shot in the chest
just like the bailiff.
Copy !req
459. Can't see the, uh, entry wound
because he removed the heart.
Copy !req
460. - But there is an exit wound.
No slug - must have
taken it with him.
Copy !req
461. - A trophy.
Copy !req
462. - Doctor.
Copy !req
463. With this judge's death,
there will be no verdict.
Copy !req
464. No ending.
It'll start again,
Copy !req
465. like the trial
never happened.
Copy !req
466. But why?
Copy !req
467. - Psychopathic violence is
predominantly goal-oriented,
Copy !req
468. a means to a very
particular end.
Copy !req
469. - So, the killer wanted
a mistrial?
Copy !req
470. - It's an elegant,
if rather unorthodox, solution.
Copy !req
471. - He spares will a guilty
verdict and his life
for the moment.
Copy !req
472. - Yes.
- The question is,
Copy !req
473. is it the same killer?
Copy !req
474. Is will still on trial,
in your mind?
Copy !req
475. - The use of a gun;
Copy !req
476. death first,
mutilation last.
Copy !req
477. I feel like St. Peter ready
to deny will for the third time.
Copy !req
478. I'm not sure this is
the same killer, Jack.
Copy !req
479. - Excuse me.
Copy !req
480. The killer exerted careful
control of the environment.
Copy !req
481. He left very little
evidence behind.
Copy !req
482. - Jeez, Jack.
Copy !req
483. The trial was supposed
to put an end to this.
Copy !req
484. Instead, the circus has
just added another ring.
Copy !req
485. - And we're the clowns.
- Who's "we,"
Copy !req
486. Jack?
Copy !req
487. - I got off track.
Copy !req
488. - You have to force yourself
out of this train of thought.
Copy !req
489. The trial was going wrong
Copy !req
490. before this murder.
The trial was going wrong
Copy !req
491. because you wanted
to believe will Graham.
Copy !req
492. Who is he to you that makes you
want to risk everything for him?
Copy !req
493. - A very cogent reminder
of the pitfalls of having faith
in one's fellow man, thank you.
Copy !req
494. - Everyone at one point
or another has to leave
somebody behind.
Copy !req
495. You've got
to cut him loose.
Copy !req
496. Otherwise, the someone
being left behind,
Copy !req
497. today or tomorrow...
Copy !req
498. Is gonna be you.
Copy !req
499. - Will.
Copy !req
500. - I was hoping the verdict would
have helped focus your mind
to get better;
Copy !req
501. make what happened to you
less terrifying and confusing.
Copy !req
502. I can't exactly blame
your lawyer.
Copy !req
503. - Faith in any sort
of legal justice has never been
Copy !req
504. any more comforting
than a nightlight.
Copy !req
505. - There are so many
miscarriages of justice
Copy !req
506. when it comes to
identifying a psychopath.
Copy !req
507. You could easily have been
misdiagnosed.
Copy !req
508. - I've already been
misdiagnosed.
Copy !req
509. - Not by the court.
Copy !req
510. - No. Not yet.
Copy !req
511. I walked out of that courtroom,
and I could hear my blood,
Copy !req
512. like, uh...
Copy !req
513. a hollow drumming
of wings.
Copy !req
514. And I had the...
Copy !req
515. Absurd feeling
Copy !req
516. that whoever
this killer is...
Copy !req
517. he walked out
of that courtroom with me.
Copy !req
518. He's gonna reach out to me.
Copy !req
519. - What does he want?
Copy !req
520. - He wants to know me.
Copy !req
521. What do you want?
Copy !req
522. - I want to save you.
Copy !req
523. Closed captioning by sette inc.
Copy !req